{"_id":"starintel:analysis:wef-columbus-depth-3-network-expansion","assessment":{"confidence":0.96,"gaps":["executed contracts","board minutes","WEF correspondence","complete modification totals"]},"data":{"conclusions":["The strongest deeper mechanism is a public-private implementation network with personnel continuity, repeat vendors, private grant conditions, and replication infrastructure.","No reviewed source establishes WEF command authority, direct WEF funding, fraud, bribery, or unlawful procurement."],"confidence":0.96,"finding_ids":["starintel:relation:corrine-burger-interim-ceo-columbus-partnership","starintel:relation:jordan-davis-chief-of-staff-andhealth","starintel:contract:pillar-accenture-smart-city-chain-2018-2020","starintel:contract:hntb-smart-city-program-management-identified-minimum","starintel:relation:electrification-coalition-advised-smart-columbus","starintel:relation:smart-columbus-board-roster-conflict"],"findings":["The Columbus Partnership leadership transition placed a former JPMorganChase executive over the umbrella organization containing Smart Columbus.","Jordan Davis moved into AndHealth while retaining a Smart Columbus board role, preserving network continuity.","The Pillar/Accenture technology chain has at least $8.1 million in identified authorizations, while HNTB has at least $4.3 million in identified Smart City program-management authorizations.","The Electrification Coalition occupied advisory, implementation, policy, and replication roles around Columbus electrification.","Official Smart Columbus board rosters are inconsistent and require appointment records and minutes."],"limitations":["Contract totals are identified minimums because not every modification has been reconstructed.","Board roster conflicts may reflect stale web pages rather than governance misconduct."],"method":"Recursive expansion from every substantive Depth 2 person, organization, contract and source document, prioritizing official records.","question":"What deeper people, vendor, funding, and document networks emerge from the direct WEF–Columbus relationship?","scope":"Smart Columbus governance, leadership transitions, private financing, Smart City technology and program-management contracts, electrification advisers, and replication materials.","unresolved":["Executed scopes, invoices, deliverables, board appointment records, WEF correspondence, and private-grant approval records remain outstanding."]},"dataset":"starintel-wef-columbus-depth-3-2026-07-25","date_added":"2026-07-25T20:30:00Z","date_updated":"2026-07-25T20:30:00Z","dtype":"analysis","evidence":[],"lineage":{"derived_from":["starintel:research-pass:wef-columbus-depth-2-2026-07-25"],"generation":3},"provenance":{"agent":"GPT-5.6 Thinking","run_id":"wef-columbus-depth-3-2026-07-25","skill":"auto-dig;create-starintel-documents;select-recursive-targets"},"schema_version":"0.9.0","sources":[{"accessed_at":"2026-07-25T20:30:00Z","credibility":0.95,"kind":"official_webpage","publisher":"Smart Columbus","title":"Smart Columbus About","uri":"https://smartcolumbus.com/about","url":"https://smartcolumbus.com/about"},{"accessed_at":"2026-07-25T20:30:00Z","credibility":0.95,"kind":"official_webpage","publisher":"Columbus Partnership","title":"Columbus Partnership leadership transition","uri":"https://columbusregion.com/press-release/columbus-partnership-announces-leadership-transition/","url":"https://columbusregion.com/press-release/columbus-partnership-announces-leadership-transition/"},{"accessed_at":"2026-07-25T20:30:00Z","credibility":0.95,"kind":"government_record","publisher":"City of Columbus","title":"Ordinance 0898-2019","uri":"https://columbus.legistar.com/LegislationDetail.aspx?FullText=1&GUID=25689AF7-E15D-4218-8726-CFE46FC368ED&ID=3910766","url":"https://columbus.legistar.com/LegislationDetail.aspx?FullText=1&GUID=25689AF7-E15D-4218-8726-CFE46FC368ED&ID=3910766"},{"accessed_at":"2026-07-25T20:30:00Z","credibility":0.95,"kind":"official_webpage","publisher":"Electrification Coalition","title":"Electrification Coalition team","uri":"https://electrificationcoalition.org/our-team/","url":"https://electrificationcoalition.org/our-team/"}],"summary":"Depth 3 finds a durable personnel, vendor, and replication apparatus around Smart Columbus. It supports structural influence and continuity, not proof of WEF command or fraud.","tags":["wef-columbus","recursive-research","depth-3"],"title":"WEF–Columbus Depth 3 network analysis","verification":{"status":"source-backed","verified":true},"version":1,"workflow":{"max_depth":6,"recursion_depth":3,"research_status":"completed","root_target_id":"starintel:org:city-of-columbus"}}
{"_id":"starintel:analysis:wef-columbus-depth-4-governance-replication-continuity","assessment":{"caveats":["Association and legal affiliation are not evidence of wrongdoing."],"confidence":0.97,"gaps":["Schedule L details","inter-entity financial flows","executed JobsOhio agreements","staff project assignments"]},"data":{"conclusions":["The deeper structure is not a single WEF funding channel; it is a layered civic-business system combining distinct nonprofits, public contracts, private economic-development support, and reusable program infrastructure.","Current evidence supports institutional continuity and policy diffusion, not WEF command, fraud, bribery, or unlawful contracting."],"confidence":0.97,"finding_ids":["starintel:relation:columbus-partnership-c6-legally-distinct-c3","starintel:observation:columbus-partnership-c6-schedule-l-2024","starintel:event:smart-columbus-three-funding-streams-2021","starintel:observation:smart-columbus-project-continuation-and-replication","starintel:contract:hntb-smart-lighting-phase-4-lifecycle-2022-2026","starintel:relation:jobsohio-supported-andhealth-expansion"],"findings":["The Columbus Partnership name maps to at least two legally distinct tax-exempt entities: a 501(c)(6) business league and a 501(c)(3) charity.","The 501(c)(6) generated most of its 2024 revenue from program services, while the 501(c)(3) relied almost entirely on contributions and reported no salaries.","The 501(c)(6) filing reported Schedule L transactions with interested persons, but the specific details remain unresolved and the disclosure alone does not show misconduct.","The 2021 City program summary explicitly combines City-managed public and philanthropic grants with a Columbus Partnership-coordinated private Acceleration Fund and describes replication through open-source software, technical information, and playbooks.","HNTB's Smart Lighting Phase 4 contract reached an authorized $1,675,811.18 and names EMH&T and Barr Engineering as subconsultants.","AndHealth's 2022 and 2025 expansion records identify JobsOhio, One Columbus, the Ohio Department of Development, and the City of Columbus as support actors; the final 2022 assistance amount remains unpublished in the reviewed records.","The current Smart Columbus page identifies an eleven-person delivery team, creating a new project-assignment and contract-responsibility frontier."],"limitations":["ProPublica reproduces IRS data but is not the filing agency.","Authorized ceilings are not confirmed outlays.","The aggregate funding figure combines grants and private commitments with different accounting status."],"method":"Expand every new Depth 3 entity, contract, source, and unresolved target using official organizational records, municipal legislation, an official City program report, JobsOhio records, and IRS-derived nonprofit filings.","question":"What governance, financing, replication, vendor, and personnel mechanisms appear one layer below the Depth 3 network?","scope":"Columbus Partnership legal structure and filings; Smart Columbus grant-era replication; HNTB Smart Lighting subcontracting; AndHealth public-development support; current Smart Columbus delivery staff.","unresolved":["Schedule L transaction details and inter-entity transfers","complete grant agreement amendments and approval correspondence","HNTB subconsultant scopes and product-evaluation records","JobsOhio final assistance agreements for AndHealth","Smart Columbus staff-to-project and staff-to-contract assignments"]},"dataset":"starintel-wef-columbus-depth-4-2026-07-25","date_added":"2026-07-25T21:15:00Z","date_updated":"2026-07-25T21:15:00Z","dtype":"analysis","evidence":[],"lineage":{"derived_from":["starintel:research-pass:wef-columbus-depth-3-2026-07-25"],"generation":4},"provenance":{"agent":"GPT-5.6 Thinking","run_id":"wef-columbus-depth-4-2026-07-25","skill":"auto-dig;search-starintel-json-db;create-starintel-documents;select-recursive-targets"},"schema_version":"0.9.0","sources":[{"accessed_at":"2026-07-25T21:15:00Z","credibility":0.95,"kind":"government_report","publisher":"City of Columbus","title":"Smart Columbus Program Summary — June 2021","uri":"https://static1.squarespace.com/static/6543abac601e3621dd3fe76d/t/68b832df3dd5017d3a1c12e2/1756902111728/2021-06%2BUSDOT%2BFinal%2BReport%2BExecutive%2BSummary%2B%281%29-compressed-compressed.pdf","url":"https://static1.squarespace.com/static/6543abac601e3621dd3fe76d/t/68b832df3dd5017d3a1c12e2/1756902111728/2021-06%2BUSDOT%2BFinal%2BReport%2BExecutive%2BSummary%2B%281%29-compressed-compressed.pdf"},{"accessed_at":"2026-07-25T21:15:00Z","credibility":0.95,"kind":"irs_derived_filing","publisher":"ProPublica Nonprofit Explorer","title":"Columbus Partnership Form 990 — fiscal year 2024","uri":"https://projects.propublica.org/nonprofits/organizations/352558300","url":"https://projects.propublica.org/nonprofits/organizations/352558300"},{"accessed_at":"2026-07-25T21:15:00Z","credibility":0.95,"kind":"irs_derived_filing","publisher":"ProPublica Nonprofit Explorer","title":"The Columbus Partnership Form 990 — fiscal year 2024","uri":"https://projects.propublica.org/nonprofits/organizations/20580058","url":"https://projects.propublica.org/nonprofits/organizations/20580058"},{"accessed_at":"2026-07-25T21:15:00Z","credibility":0.95,"kind":"government_record","publisher":"City of Columbus","title":"Columbus Ordinance 1424-2026","uri":"https://columbus.legistar.com/LegislationDetail.aspx?FullText=1&GUID=50C99EDC-6138-41FC-A7E1-8672080626A3&ID=8038904","url":"https://columbus.legistar.com/LegislationDetail.aspx?FullText=1&GUID=50C99EDC-6138-41FC-A7E1-8672080626A3&ID=8038904"},{"accessed_at":"2026-07-25T21:15:00Z","credibility":0.95,"kind":"official_project_record","publisher":"JobsOhio","title":"AndHealth Expanding Office Space in Downtown Columbus","uri":"https://www.jobsohio.com/newsroom/news-press/andhealth-expanding-office-space-in-downtown-columbus","url":"https://www.jobsohio.com/newsroom/news-press/andhealth-expanding-office-space-in-downtown-columbus"}],"summary":"Depth 4 resolves legal-entity, financial, contract, replication, staffing, and public-development layers beneath the Smart Columbus network.","tags":["wef-columbus","recursive-research","depth-4"],"title":"WEF–Columbus Depth 4 governance and replication analysis","verification":{"status":"source-backed","verified":true},"version":1,"workflow":{"max_depth":6,"recursion_depth":4,"research_status":"completed","root_target_id":"starintel:org:city-of-columbus"}}
{"_id":"starintel:analysis:wef-columbus-depth-5-policy-contract-implementation","assessment":{"caveats":["Association and participation are not proof of command or misconduct."],"confidence":0.97,"gaps":["executed WEF and JobsOhio agreements","HNTB utilization and workshare records","Living Lab project files","Green IT working-group records","UrbanOS downstream deployment evidence"]},"data":{"conclusions":["The operational layer is a regional public-private implementation system: frameworks and working groups, pilots on existing infrastructure, City procurement, economic-development incentives, and reusable software.","Current evidence supports access, policy diffusion, and implementation capacity. It does not establish that WEF ordered or controlled the Green IT Playbook, Living Lab, HNTB procurement, AndHealth incentives, or UrbanOS publication."],"confidence":0.97,"counterarguments":["Each program can be explained by ordinary local institutional continuity, statutory procurement, economic-development policy, or vendor partnership without centralized external command.","Publicly reusable code and playbooks do not prove actual reuse or adoption by another jurisdiction."],"finding_ids":["starintel:media:columbus-green-it-playbook-2-0-2025","starintel:event:central-ohio-living-lab-launch-2025","starintel:event:hntb-smart-lighting-phase-4-modification-2026","starintel:financial-observation:andhealth-downtown-office-incentive-payment-2024","starintel:product:urbanos-smart-cities-data-platform"],"findings":["Smart Columbus and Rackspace converted a regional working-group process into a 14-practice Green IT Playbook; Bread Financial is a documented implementation case.","Smart Columbus and Honda launched a Living Lab using existing regional smart-city infrastructure, but public material reviewed here does not name the six projects, budgets, vendors, data rules, or evaluation results.","Columbus's HNTB Phase 4 modification funds procurement documents, technical procurement and implementation support, pilots, and new-product evaluation; the identified lifecycle authorization is $1,675,811.18.","Columbus authorized an AndHealth Downtown Office Incentive agreement in 2022 and a $47,727.97 payment for tax year 2024; JobsOhio's 2025 expansion record lists 75 committed jobs, 69 retained jobs, $260,000 capital investment, and four public-development collaborators.","Public UrbanOS repositories demonstrate that Smart City Challenge-era technical infrastructure remains available for reuse; actual deployment by other cities was not established.","The WEF link remains directly documented through the City profile and Jordan Davis's task-force participation. The reviewed Green IT, Living Lab, HNTB, and AndHealth records do not show WEF directing those specific programs or transactions."],"framework":"Separate institutional association, policy diffusion, implementation capacity, public expenditure authorization, and unproven command claims.","input_ids":["starintel:investigation-target:wef-columbus-depth-5-hntb-smart-lighting-subconsultants","starintel:investigation-target:wef-columbus-depth-5-andhealth-public-assistance","starintel:investigation-target:wef-columbus-depth-5-grant-era-replication-lineage","starintel:investigation-target:wef-columbus-depth-5-smart-columbus-team-project-map"],"limitations":["HNTB utilization attachments and detailed subconsultant scopes were not obtained.","Living Lab project charters, vendors, budgets, data governance, and results were not publicly identified in the reviewed material.","Executed JobsOhio assistance agreements and the complete AndHealth incentive payment ledger were not obtained.","Current Columbus Global Shapers hub status was not resolved from the official public directory."],"method":"Recursive expansion of the four queued Depth 5 branches using official municipal legislation, official Smart Columbus publications, official JobsOhio records, WEF project material, and public source repositories.","question":"How do WEF-adjacent urban-policy networks intersect with specific Columbus frameworks, pilots, procurement, incentives, and reusable technical infrastructure?","scope":"Green IT Playbook, Central Ohio Living Lab, HNTB Smart Lighting Phase 4, AndHealth incentives and expansion, UrbanOS code lineage, and unresolved WEF/Global Shapers records.","unresolved":["WEF agreements, dues, invoices, travel, correspondence, profile authorization, and task-force working files.","Green IT Working Group roster, meetings, baseline submissions, and organization-level adoption evidence.","Central Ohio Living Lab project identities and governance.","UrbanOS forks, deployments, licenses, and downstream city reuse.","Smart Columbus staff-to-project, staff-to-contract, and staff-to-vendor assignments."]},"dataset":"wef","date_added":"2026-07-26T04:05:00Z","date_updated":"2026-07-26T04:05:00Z","dtype":"analysis","evidence":[],"lineage":{"derived_from":["starintel:analysis:wef-columbus-depth-4-governance-replication-continuity"],"generation":5},"provenance":{"agent":"GPT-5.6 Thinking","method":"Primary-source recursive OSINT with bounded inference","run_id":"wef-columbus-depth-5-2026-07-26","skill":"auto-dig;web-research;create-starintel-documents;select-recursive-targets"},"schema_version":"0.9.0","sources":[{"accessed_at":"2026-07-26T04:05:00Z","credibility":0.95,"kind":"official_webpage","publisher":"Smart Columbus","title":"A year of impact: 2025 by the numbers","uri":"https://smartcolumbus.com/insights/2025-12-year-of-impact","url":"https://smartcolumbus.com/insights/2025-12-year-of-impact"},{"accessed_at":"2026-07-26T04:05:00Z","credibility":0.95,"kind":"official_webpage","publisher":"Smart Columbus","title":"Columbus leads the way: Evolving our Green IT ambition","uri":"https://smartcolumbus.com/insights/2025-10-cie-vendor-announcement-83p85","url":"https://smartcolumbus.com/insights/2025-10-cie-vendor-announcement-83p85"},{"accessed_at":"2026-07-26T04:05:00Z","credibility":0.99,"kind":"government_record","publisher":"City of Columbus","title":"Columbus Ordinance 1424-2026","uri":"https://columbus.legistar.com/LegislationDetail.aspx?FullText=1&GUID=039FBB6C-BE67-4AC2-9C13-59B8B8EFE96F&ID=8117826&Options=&Search=","url":"https://columbus.legistar.com/LegislationDetail.aspx?FullText=1&GUID=039FBB6C-BE67-4AC2-9C13-59B8B8EFE96F&ID=8117826&Options=&Search="},{"accessed_at":"2026-07-26T04:05:00Z","credibility":0.99,"kind":"government_record","publisher":"City of Columbus","title":"Columbus Ordinance 2014-2022","uri":"https://columbus.legistar.com/LegislationDetail.aspx?GUID=8A04AD26-94FE-4964-BCCC-44203F01D559&ID=5726301&Options=&Search=","url":"https://columbus.legistar.com/LegislationDetail.aspx?GUID=8A04AD26-94FE-4964-BCCC-44203F01D559&ID=5726301&Options=&Search="},{"accessed_at":"2026-07-26T04:05:00Z","credibility":0.99,"kind":"government_record","notes":"The title and background identify the Downtown Office Incentive program; Section 6 uses Jobs Growth Incentive wording.","publisher":"City of Columbus","title":"Columbus Ordinance 1885-2025","uri":"https://columbus.legistar.com/LegislationDetail.aspx?FullText=1&GUID=DE71F085-A673-490A-93D8-BED794B120CB&ID=7489845&Options=&Search=","url":"https://columbus.legistar.com/LegislationDetail.aspx?FullText=1&GUID=DE71F085-A673-490A-93D8-BED794B120CB&ID=7489845&Options=&Search="},{"accessed_at":"2026-07-26T04:05:00Z","credibility":0.97,"kind":"official_project_record","publisher":"JobsOhio","title":"AndHealth Expanding Office Space in Downtown Columbus","uri":"https://www.jobsohio.com/newsroom/news-press/andhealth-expanding-office-space-in-downtown-columbus","url":"https://www.jobsohio.com/newsroom/news-press/andhealth-expanding-office-space-in-downtown-columbus"},{"accessed_at":"2026-07-26T04:05:00Z","credibility":0.99,"kind":"official_project_record","publisher":"World Economic Forum","title":"Implementing a Life-Cycle Approach to Infrastructure: a Policy Roadmap for Cities","uri":"https://centres.weforum.org/centre-for-urban-transformation/infrastructure-lifecycle","url":"https://centres.weforum.org/centre-for-urban-transformation/infrastructure-lifecycle"},{"accessed_at":"2026-07-26T04:05:00Z","credibility":0.98,"kind":"official_organization","publisher":"Global Shapers Community","title":"Global Shapers: About","uri":"https://www.globalshapers.org/about","url":"https://www.globalshapers.org/about"},{"accessed_at":"2026-07-26T04:05:00Z","credibility":0.98,"kind":"source_repository","publisher":"UrbanOS-Public","title":"UrbanOS-Public/smartcitiesdata","uri":"https://github.com/UrbanOS-Public/smartcitiesdata","url":"https://github.com/UrbanOS-Public/smartcitiesdata"},{"accessed_at":"2026-07-26T04:05:00Z","credibility":0.98,"kind":"research_packet","publisher":"StarIntel GPT Auto-Dig","title":"WEF–Columbus Depth 4 governance and replication analysis","uri":"https://github.com/lost-rob0t/starintel-gpt-auto-dig/blob/main/digs/wef-columbus/2026-07-25-depth-4-analysis/starintel-documents.jsonl","url":"https://github.com/lost-rob0t/starintel-gpt-auto-dig/blob/main/digs/wef-columbus/2026-07-25-depth-4-analysis/starintel-documents.jsonl"}],"summary":"Depth 5 resolves concrete implementation mechanisms beneath the existing WEF–Columbus association while preserving the boundary between network influence and specific decision control.","tags":["wef","columbus","recursive-research","depth-5"],"title":"WEF–Columbus Depth 5 policy, contract, and implementation analysis","verification":{"status":"source-backed","verified":true},"version":1,"workflow":{"max_depth":6,"recursion_depth":5,"research_status":"completed","root_target_id":"starintel:org:city-of-columbus"}}
{"_id":"starintel:analysis:wef-columbus-influence","aliases":[],"assessment":{"confidence":0.95},"attachments":[],"data":{"confidence":0.95,"limitations":["Influence is not command.","Corporate overlap is not proof of coordinated control.","The relationship may be bidirectional, with Columbus practices exported through WEF networks."]},"dataset":"starintel-wef-columbus-urban-transformation-2026-07-25","date_added":"2026-07-25T00:00:00Z","date_updated":"2026-07-25T00:00:00Z","description":"","dtype":"analysis","evidence":[],"extensions":{"legacy.v0":{"assessment":{"binding_wef_authority":"not_established","direct_institutional_engagement":"confirmed","direct_wef_funding":"not_found","fraud_or_diversion":"not_established","local_implementation_capacity":"confirmed","overall":"moderate_to_high_structural_influence","wef_linked_corporate_overlap":"confirmed_bounded","wef_policy_project_participation":"confirmed"},"data":{"mechanism":["WEF urban-policy network","Smart Columbus personnel bridge","Columbus Partnership governance","City and regional public-private board","City-funded local implementation"]}}},"geospatial":{},"handling":{"pii":false,"sensitive":false,"visibility":"public"},"identifiers":[],"keywords":[],"labels":[],"language":"en","lineage":{"migration_from":"0.8","migration_notes":["Normalized into the canonical StarIntel v0.9.0 document envelope."]},"notes":[],"provenance":{"original_id":"starintel:analysis:wef-columbus-influence","original_path":"digs/wef-columbus/2026-07-25-urban-transformation-network/starintel-documents.jsonl","original_schema_version":"0.8","software_version":"0.9.0","transform":"starintel_doc.migration.migrate_document"},"quality":{},"related_ids":[],"schema_version":"0.9.0","sources":[{"accessed_at":"2026-07-25T00:00:00Z","metadata":{"source_type":"official_organization"},"title":"City of Columbus | World Economic Forum","uri":"https://www.weforum.org/organizations/city-of-columbus/","url":"https://www.weforum.org/organizations/city-of-columbus/"},{"accessed_at":"2026-07-25T00:00:00Z","metadata":{"source_type":"official_project"},"title":"Implementing a Life-Cycle Approach to Infrastructure","uri":"https://centres.weforum.org/centre-for-urban-transformation/infrastructure-lifecycle","url":"https://centres.weforum.org/centre-for-urban-transformation/infrastructure-lifecycle"},{"accessed_at":"2026-07-25T00:00:00Z","metadata":{"source_type":"official_organization"},"title":"About Smart Columbus","uri":"https://smartcolumbus.com/about","url":"https://smartcolumbus.com/about"},{"accessed_at":"2026-07-25T00:00:00Z","metadata":{"source_type":"official_organization"},"title":"Smart Columbus Board","uri":"https://columbusregion.com/about-us/boards-investors/smart-columbus-board/","url":"https://columbusregion.com/about-us/boards-investors/smart-columbus-board/"},{"accessed_at":"2026-07-25T00:00:00Z","metadata":{"source_type":"official_organization"},"title":"About the Columbus Partnership","uri":"https://columbusregion.com/about-us/","url":"https://columbusregion.com/about-us/"},{"accessed_at":"2026-07-25T00:00:00Z","metadata":{"source_type":"government_record"},"title":"Columbus Ordinance 1663-2025","uri":"https://columbus.legistar.com/LegislationDetail.aspx?FullText=1&GUID=5E02F335-BDF8-4220-B7BB-05FE16CF6CC4&ID=7489830","url":"https://columbus.legistar.com/LegislationDetail.aspx?FullText=1&GUID=5E02F335-BDF8-4220-B7BB-05FE16CF6CC4&ID=7489830"},{"accessed_at":"2026-07-25T00:00:00Z","metadata":{"source_type":"government_record"},"title":"Columbus Ordinance 1850-2026","uri":"https://columbus.legistar.com/LegislationDetail.aspx?FullText=1&GUID=588DBFF9-D9DB-4603-B5D4-776E9F5B5A9E&ID=8117690&Options=&Search=","url":"https://columbus.legistar.com/LegislationDetail.aspx?FullText=1&GUID=588DBFF9-D9DB-4603-B5D4-776E9F5B5A9E&ID=8117690&Options=&Search="},{"accessed_at":"2026-07-25T00:00:00Z","metadata":{"source_type":"official_event"},"title":"World Economic Forum Annual Meeting 2026 Partners","uri":"https://www.weforum.org/meetings/world-economic-forum-annual-meeting-2026/partners/","url":"https://www.weforum.org/meetings/world-economic-forum-annual-meeting-2026/partners/"},{"accessed_at":"2026-07-25T00:00:00Z","metadata":{"source_type":"official_organization"},"title":"One Columbus Investors","uri":"https://columbusregion.com/about-us/boards-investors/one-columbus-investors/","url":"https://columbusregion.com/about-us/boards-investors/one-columbus-investors/"}],"status":"recorded","summary":"The best-supported mechanism is policy-network influence: official institutional association, Smart Columbus participation in a WEF policy task force, and a City-funded local public-private implementation intermediary.","tags":[],"temporal":{},"title":"Assessment of WEF influence in Columbus","verification":{"status":"analytical_synthesis"},"version":1,"workflow":{}}
{"_id":"starintel:contract:andhealth-columbus-downtown-office-incentive-2022","assessment":{"confidence":0.99},"data":{"agency_ids":["starintel:org:city-of-columbus"],"award_type":"tax_incentive_agreement","buyer_id":"starintel:org:city-of-columbus","contract_id":"ORD-2014-2022","currency":"USD","description":"Downtown Office Incentive agreement for AndHealth's headquarters establishment and expansion at 2 Miranova Place.","place_of_performance":"2 Miranova Place, Columbus, Ohio","scope":"Approximately $1.115 million planned project cost; 65 new positions with about $6.155 million estimated annual payroll; retention of 21 positions with about $1.9 million payroll.","seller_id":"starintel:org:andhealth","status":"authorized","vendor_ids":["starintel:org:andhealth"]},"dataset":"wef","date_added":"2026-07-26T04:05:00Z","date_updated":"2026-07-26T04:05:00Z","dtype":"contract","evidence":[],"lineage":{"derived_from":["starintel:analysis:wef-columbus-depth-4-governance-replication-continuity"],"generation":5},"notes":["The reviewed ordinance authorizes the agreement but does not state a fixed total payout ceiling."],"provenance":{"agent":"GPT-5.6 Thinking","method":"Primary-source recursive OSINT with bounded inference","run_id":"wef-columbus-depth-5-2026-07-26","skill":"auto-dig;web-research;create-starintel-documents;select-recursive-targets"},"schema_version":"0.9.0","sources":[{"accessed_at":"2026-07-26T04:05:00Z","credibility":0.99,"kind":"government_record","publisher":"City of Columbus","title":"Columbus Ordinance 2014-2022","uri":"https://columbus.legistar.com/LegislationDetail.aspx?GUID=8A04AD26-94FE-4964-BCCC-44203F01D559&ID=5726301&Options=&Search=","url":"https://columbus.legistar.com/LegislationDetail.aspx?GUID=8A04AD26-94FE-4964-BCCC-44203F01D559&ID=5726301&Options=&Search="}],"summary":"Columbus authorized a Downtown Office Incentive agreement supporting AndHealth's headquarters expansion and 65 planned new jobs.","tags":["wef","columbus","recursive-research","depth-5"],"title":"AndHealth Columbus Downtown Office Incentive agreement","verification":{"status":"source-backed","verified":true},"version":1,"workflow":{"max_depth":6,"recursion_depth":5,"research_status":"completed","root_target_id":"starintel:org:city-of-columbus"}}
{"_id":"starintel:contract:hntb-smart-city-program-management-identified-minimum","assessment":{"caveats":["Identified minimum; intervening modifications remain to be reconstructed."],"confidence":0.96},"data":{"award_type":"professional_services","buyer_id":"starintel:org:city-of-columbus","ceiling_amount":4300000,"currency":"USD","description":"Smart City Challenge program initialization and program management services.","modifications":[{"amount":400000,"ordinance":"1900-2016"},{"amount":1400000,"ordinance":"1056-2018"},{"amount":2500000,"ordinance":"0477-2019"}],"scope":"Program management for USDOT and Vulcan Smart City Challenge work.","seller_id":"starintel:org:hntb-ohio","status":"modified","vendor_ids":["starintel:org:hntb-ohio"]},"dataset":"starintel-wef-columbus-depth-3-2026-07-25","date_added":"2026-07-25T20:30:00Z","date_updated":"2026-07-25T20:30:00Z","dtype":"contract","evidence":[],"lineage":{"derived_from":["starintel:research-pass:wef-columbus-depth-2-2026-07-25"],"generation":3},"provenance":{"agent":"GPT-5.6 Thinking","run_id":"wef-columbus-depth-3-2026-07-25","skill":"auto-dig;create-starintel-documents;select-recursive-targets"},"schema_version":"0.9.0","sources":[{"accessed_at":"2026-07-25T20:30:00Z","credibility":0.95,"kind":"government_record","publisher":"City of Columbus","title":"Columbus Ordinance 1056-2018","uri":"https://columbus.legistar.com/LegislationDetail.aspx?GUID=ACC8B42F-6329-4B0E-9DC0-8AEAED4AF9B6&ID=3477813&Options=&Search=","url":"https://columbus.legistar.com/LegislationDetail.aspx?GUID=ACC8B42F-6329-4B0E-9DC0-8AEAED4AF9B6&ID=3477813&Options=&Search="},{"accessed_at":"2026-07-25T20:30:00Z","credibility":0.95,"kind":"government_record","publisher":"City of Columbus","title":"Columbus Ordinance 0477-2019","uri":"https://columbus.legistar.com/LegislationDetail.aspx?GUID=CCB79A50-08B8-47B1-8EFD-CA2A3EE0E70B&ID=3867981&Options=&Search=","url":"https://columbus.legistar.com/LegislationDetail.aspx?GUID=CCB79A50-08B8-47B1-8EFD-CA2A3EE0E70B&ID=3867981&Options=&Search="}],"summary":"Identified authorizations include an original $400,000 contract, a $1.4 million modification, and a $2.5 million sixth modification; this is a minimum rather than a complete lifecycle total.","tags":["wef-columbus","recursive-research","depth-3"],"title":"HNTB Smart City program-management contract chain","verification":{"status":"source-backed","verified":true},"version":1,"workflow":{"max_depth":6,"recursion_depth":3,"research_status":"completed","root_target_id":"starintel:org:city-of-columbus"}}
{"_id":"starintel:contract:hntb-smart-lighting-phase-4-lifecycle-2022-2026","assessment":{"caveats":["Authorized contract ceiling is not equivalent to confirmed outlay."],"confidence":0.99},"data":{"award_type":"professional_services","buyer_id":"starintel:org:city-of-columbus","ceiling_amount":1675811.18,"contract_id":"PO321125","currency":"USD","description":"Smart Lighting Phase 4 program management, procurement support, implementation assistance, pilot support, and product evaluation.","modifications":[{"amount":676000.0,"ordinance":"0815-2022","type":"original"},{"amount":499883.36,"ordinance":"0217-2024","type":"modification_1"},{"amount":499927.82,"ordinance":"1424-2026","type":"modification_2"}],"scope":"Support conversion of city streetlights to LED fixtures and associated smart-lighting procurement and implementation.","seller_id":"starintel:org:hntb-ohio","status":"modified","subcontractor_ids":["starintel:org:emh-and-t-inc","starintel:org:barr-engineering"],"vendor_ids":["starintel:org:hntb-ohio"]},"dataset":"starintel-wef-columbus-depth-4-2026-07-25","date_added":"2026-07-25T21:15:00Z","date_updated":"2026-07-25T21:15:00Z","dtype":"contract","evidence":[],"lineage":{"derived_from":["starintel:research-pass:wef-columbus-depth-3-2026-07-25"],"generation":4},"provenance":{"agent":"GPT-5.6 Thinking","run_id":"wef-columbus-depth-4-2026-07-25","skill":"auto-dig;search-starintel-json-db;create-starintel-documents;select-recursive-targets"},"schema_version":"0.9.0","sources":[{"accessed_at":"2026-07-25T21:15:00Z","credibility":0.95,"kind":"government_record","publisher":"City of Columbus","title":"Columbus Ordinance 1424-2026","uri":"https://columbus.legistar.com/LegislationDetail.aspx?FullText=1&GUID=50C99EDC-6138-41FC-A7E1-8672080626A3&ID=8038904","url":"https://columbus.legistar.com/LegislationDetail.aspx?FullText=1&GUID=50C99EDC-6138-41FC-A7E1-8672080626A3&ID=8038904"}],"summary":"City records identify an original $676,000 contract and two modifications totaling $1,675,811.18, with EMH&T and Barr Engineering as subconsultants on the 2026 modification.","tags":["wef-columbus","recursive-research","depth-4"],"title":"HNTB Smart Lighting Phase 4 contract lifecycle","verification":{"status":"source-backed","verified":true},"version":1,"workflow":{"max_depth":6,"recursion_depth":4,"research_status":"completed","root_target_id":"starintel:org:city-of-columbus"}}
{"_id":"starintel:contract:pillar-accenture-smart-city-chain-2018-2020","assessment":{"caveats":["Amount is an identified minimum; not every contract modification was reconstructed."],"confidence":0.97},"data":{"award_type":"professional_services","buyer_id":"starintel:org:city-of-columbus","ceiling_amount":8100000,"competition_type":"competitive_rfp","contract_id":"PO116406","currency":"USD","description":"IT professional services and Smart Columbus Operating System design and delivery.","modifications":[{"amount":2500000,"ordinance":"0820-2018"},{"amount":2500000,"ordinance":"2125-2018"},{"amount":2500000,"assignment":"Pillar to Accenture","ordinance":"0898-2019"},{"amount":600000,"ordinance":"2432-2020"}],"scope":"Advanced data and intelligent transportation systems for the Smart City Challenge.","seller_id":"starintel:org:accenture","status":"modified","vendor_ids":["starintel:org:pillar-technology-group","starintel:org:accenture"]},"dataset":"starintel-wef-columbus-depth-3-2026-07-25","date_added":"2026-07-25T20:30:00Z","date_updated":"2026-07-25T20:30:00Z","dtype":"contract","evidence":[],"lineage":{"derived_from":["starintel:research-pass:wef-columbus-depth-2-2026-07-25"],"generation":3},"provenance":{"agent":"GPT-5.6 Thinking","run_id":"wef-columbus-depth-3-2026-07-25","skill":"auto-dig;create-starintel-documents;select-recursive-targets"},"schema_version":"0.9.0","sources":[{"accessed_at":"2026-07-25T20:30:00Z","credibility":0.95,"kind":"government_record","publisher":"City of Columbus","title":"Columbus Ordinance 0820-2018","uri":"https://columbus.legistar.com/LegislationDetail.aspx?FullText=1&GUID=A46BE430-491C-4BFF-BA59-B37B763DF2B6&ID=3476477","url":"https://columbus.legistar.com/LegislationDetail.aspx?FullText=1&GUID=A46BE430-491C-4BFF-BA59-B37B763DF2B6&ID=3476477"},{"accessed_at":"2026-07-25T20:30:00Z","credibility":0.95,"kind":"government_record","publisher":"City of Columbus","title":"Columbus Ordinance 0898-2019","uri":"https://columbus.legistar.com/LegislationDetail.aspx?FullText=1&GUID=25689AF7-E15D-4218-8726-CFE46FC368ED&ID=3910766","url":"https://columbus.legistar.com/LegislationDetail.aspx?FullText=1&GUID=25689AF7-E15D-4218-8726-CFE46FC368ED&ID=3910766"},{"accessed_at":"2026-07-25T20:30:00Z","credibility":0.95,"kind":"government_record","publisher":"City of Columbus","title":"Columbus Ordinance 2432-2020","uri":"https://columbus.legistar.com/LegislationDetail.aspx?G=4F637594-17B0-4E92-8196-37F14328D337&GUID=55EF6D82-37AC-42A8-AC78-9C64E74804A8&ID=4687160&Options=&Search=","url":"https://columbus.legistar.com/LegislationDetail.aspx?G=4F637594-17B0-4E92-8196-37F14328D337&GUID=55EF6D82-37AC-42A8-AC78-9C64E74804A8&ID=4687160&Options=&Search="}],"summary":"Original $2.5 million contract, two identified $2.5 million modifications reaching $7.5 million, assignment to Accenture, and a later $600,000 modification; the documented minimum is $8.1 million and may not include every modification.","tags":["wef-columbus","recursive-research","depth-3"],"title":"Pillar/Accenture Smart City technology contract chain","verification":{"status":"source-backed","verified":true},"version":1,"workflow":{"max_depth":6,"recursion_depth":3,"research_status":"completed","root_target_id":"starintel:org:city-of-columbus"}}
{"_id":"starintel:event:andhealth-expansion-2022-public-support","assessment":{"confidence":0.98,"gaps":["Final JobsOhio agreement and assistance amount were not located in this pass."]},"data":{"description":"AndHealth announced a downtown headquarters expansion with 65 new jobs; JobsOhio assistance was planned but the amount was not published in the announcement.","event_kind":"economic_development_expansion","location_ids":[],"name":"AndHealth downtown Columbus expansion","participant_ids":["starintel:org:andhealth","starintel:org:jobsohio","starintel:org:one-columbus","starintel:org:city-of-columbus"],"start_at":"2022-07-26T00:00:00Z","status":"announced"},"dataset":"starintel-wef-columbus-depth-4-2026-07-25","date_added":"2026-07-25T21:15:00Z","date_updated":"2026-07-25T21:15:00Z","dtype":"event","evidence":[],"lineage":{"derived_from":["starintel:research-pass:wef-columbus-depth-3-2026-07-25"],"generation":4},"provenance":{"agent":"GPT-5.6 Thinking","run_id":"wef-columbus-depth-4-2026-07-25","skill":"auto-dig;search-starintel-json-db;create-starintel-documents;select-recursive-targets"},"schema_version":"0.9.0","sources":[{"accessed_at":"2026-07-25T21:15:00Z","credibility":0.95,"kind":"official_project_record","publisher":"One Columbus","title":"Digital Healthcare Startup AndHealth Brings 65 New Jobs","uri":"https://columbusregion.com/press-release/digital-healthcare-startup-andhealth-brings-65-new-jobs-to-downtown-columbus-for-operations-expansion/","url":"https://columbusregion.com/press-release/digital-healthcare-startup-andhealth-brings-65-new-jobs-to-downtown-columbus-for-operations-expansion/"}],"summary":"One Columbus announced 65 new jobs and stated that JobsOhio planned assistance after a final agreement was executed.","tags":["wef-columbus","recursive-research","depth-4"],"title":"AndHealth 2022 Columbus expansion","verification":{"status":"source-backed","verified":true},"version":1,"workflow":{"max_depth":6,"recursion_depth":4,"research_status":"completed","root_target_id":"starintel:org:city-of-columbus"}}
{"_id":"starintel:event:andhealth-expansion-2025-public-support","assessment":{"confidence":0.99},"data":{"amount":260000.0,"currency":"USD","description":"Project summary lists 75 committed jobs, 69 retained jobs, and $260,000 capital investment.","event_kind":"economic_development_expansion","name":"AndHealth headquarters expansion","participant_ids":["starintel:org:andhealth","starintel:org:jobsohio","starintel:org:ohio-department-of-development","starintel:org:one-columbus","starintel:org:city-of-columbus"],"start_at":"2025-10-27T00:00:00Z","status":"announced"},"dataset":"starintel-wef-columbus-depth-4-2026-07-25","date_added":"2026-07-25T21:15:00Z","date_updated":"2026-07-25T21:15:00Z","dtype":"event","evidence":[],"lineage":{"derived_from":["starintel:research-pass:wef-columbus-depth-3-2026-07-25"],"generation":4},"provenance":{"agent":"GPT-5.6 Thinking","run_id":"wef-columbus-depth-4-2026-07-25","skill":"auto-dig;search-starintel-json-db;create-starintel-documents;select-recursive-targets"},"schema_version":"0.9.0","sources":[{"accessed_at":"2026-07-25T21:15:00Z","credibility":0.95,"kind":"official_project_record","publisher":"JobsOhio","title":"AndHealth Expanding Office Space in Downtown Columbus","uri":"https://www.jobsohio.com/newsroom/news-press/andhealth-expanding-office-space-in-downtown-columbus","url":"https://www.jobsohio.com/newsroom/news-press/andhealth-expanding-office-space-in-downtown-columbus"}],"summary":"JobsOhio documented a later expansion committing 75 new jobs, retaining 69, and investing $260,000, with four public-development collaborators.","tags":["wef-columbus","recursive-research","depth-4"],"title":"AndHealth 2025 Columbus expansion","verification":{"status":"source-backed","verified":true},"version":1,"workflow":{"max_depth":6,"recursion_depth":4,"research_status":"completed","root_target_id":"starintel:org:city-of-columbus"}}
{"_id":"starintel:event:central-ohio-living-lab-launch-2025","assessment":{"confidence":0.98},"data":{"description":"Regional test environment for emerging transportation technology from Honda and other industry participants using Central Ohio smart-city infrastructure.","event_kind":"program_launch","jurisdiction":"Central Ohio","name":"Central Ohio Living Lab","outcome":"Three projects launched in 2025; three additional projects were planned for 2026.","participant_ids":["starintel:org:smart-columbus","starintel:org:honda"],"participants":["Smart Columbus","Honda"],"status":"active"},"dataset":"wef","date_added":"2026-07-26T04:05:00Z","date_updated":"2026-07-26T04:05:00Z","dtype":"event","evidence":[],"lineage":{"derived_from":["starintel:analysis:wef-columbus-depth-4-governance-replication-continuity"],"generation":5},"provenance":{"agent":"GPT-5.6 Thinking","method":"Primary-source recursive OSINT with bounded inference","run_id":"wef-columbus-depth-5-2026-07-26","skill":"auto-dig;web-research;create-starintel-documents;select-recursive-targets"},"schema_version":"0.9.0","sources":[{"accessed_at":"2026-07-26T04:05:00Z","credibility":0.95,"kind":"official_webpage","publisher":"Smart Columbus","title":"A year of impact: 2025 by the numbers","uri":"https://smartcolumbus.com/insights/2025-12-year-of-impact","url":"https://smartcolumbus.com/insights/2025-12-year-of-impact"}],"summary":"Smart Columbus and Honda launched a regional living lab that uses existing smart-city infrastructure to test transportation-safety and emissions-reduction technology.","tags":["wef","columbus","recursive-research","depth-5"],"title":"Central Ohio Living Lab launch","verification":{"status":"source-backed","verified":true},"version":1,"workflow":{"max_depth":6,"recursion_depth":5,"research_status":"completed","root_target_id":"starintel:org:city-of-columbus"}}
{"_id":"starintel:event:hntb-smart-lighting-phase-4-modification-2026","assessment":{"confidence":0.99},"data":{"amount":499927.82,"contract_id":"starintel:contract:hntb-smart-lighting-phase-4-lifecycle-2022-2026","currency":"USD","decisions":["Use planned modification rather than a new procurement process.","Authorize procurement documents and technical support for procurement and implementation.","Continue smart-lighting pilots and new-product evaluations."],"description":"Planned modification of the HNTB Ohio professional-services agreement for citywide LED conversion and smart controls.","event_kind":"contract_modification","jurisdiction":"Columbus, Ohio","name":"Smart Lighting Phase 4 modification #2","outcome":"Authorized up to $499,927.82; identified lifecycle authorization reached $1,675,811.18.","participant_ids":["starintel:org:city-of-columbus","starintel:org:hntb-ohio","starintel:org:emh-and-t-inc","starintel:org:barr-engineering"],"status":"passed"},"dataset":"wef","date_added":"2026-07-26T04:05:00Z","date_updated":"2026-07-26T04:05:00Z","dtype":"event","evidence":[],"lineage":{"derived_from":["starintel:analysis:wef-columbus-depth-4-governance-replication-continuity"],"generation":5},"notes":["The ordinance identifies EMH&T and Barr Engineering as subconsultants, but the reviewed public text does not disclose their workshare or dollar allocation."],"provenance":{"agent":"GPT-5.6 Thinking","method":"Primary-source recursive OSINT with bounded inference","run_id":"wef-columbus-depth-5-2026-07-26","skill":"auto-dig;web-research;create-starintel-documents;select-recursive-targets"},"schema_version":"0.9.0","sources":[{"accessed_at":"2026-07-26T04:05:00Z","credibility":0.99,"kind":"government_record","publisher":"City of Columbus","title":"Columbus Ordinance 1424-2026","uri":"https://columbus.legistar.com/LegislationDetail.aspx?FullText=1&GUID=039FBB6C-BE67-4AC2-9C13-59B8B8EFE96F&ID=8117826&Options=&Search=","url":"https://columbus.legistar.com/LegislationDetail.aspx?FullText=1&GUID=039FBB6C-BE67-4AC2-9C13-59B8B8EFE96F&ID=8117826&Options=&Search="}],"summary":"Columbus approved a $499,927.82 planned modification for procurement documents, procurement and implementation support, pilots, and new product evaluations.","tags":["wef","columbus","recursive-research","depth-5"],"title":"HNTB Smart Lighting Phase 4 modification","verification":{"status":"source-backed","verified":true},"version":1,"workflow":{"max_depth":6,"recursion_depth":5,"research_status":"completed","root_target_id":"starintel:org:city-of-columbus"}}
{"_id":"starintel:event:smart-columbus-three-funding-streams-2021","assessment":{"caveats":["The $750 million sum combines differently structured funding and commitment streams; it is not a single grant or confirmed expenditure total."],"confidence":0.98},"data":{"amount":750000000.0,"currency":"USD","description":"USDOT cooperative agreement and Paul G. Allen grant were managed by the City PMO; the Columbus Partnership coordinated the private-sector Acceleration Fund.","event_kind":"program_funding_structure","name":"Smart Columbus three-stream funding structure","outcome":"The three efforts were described as a springboard for the regional innovation initiative.","participant_ids":["starintel:org:city-of-columbus","starintel:org:columbus-partnership","starintel:org:paul-g-allen-philanthropies-vulcan"]},"dataset":"starintel-wef-columbus-depth-4-2026-07-25","date_added":"2026-07-25T21:15:00Z","date_updated":"2026-07-25T21:15:00Z","dtype":"event","evidence":[],"lineage":{"derived_from":["starintel:research-pass:wef-columbus-depth-3-2026-07-25"],"generation":4},"provenance":{"agent":"GPT-5.6 Thinking","run_id":"wef-columbus-depth-4-2026-07-25","skill":"auto-dig;search-starintel-json-db;create-starintel-documents;select-recursive-targets"},"schema_version":"0.9.0","sources":[{"accessed_at":"2026-07-25T21:15:00Z","credibility":0.95,"kind":"government_report","publisher":"City of Columbus","title":"Smart Columbus Program Summary — June 2021","uri":"https://static1.squarespace.com/static/6543abac601e3621dd3fe76d/t/68b832df3dd5017d3a1c12e2/1756902111728/2021-06%2BUSDOT%2BFinal%2BReport%2BExecutive%2BSummary%2B%281%29-compressed-compressed.pdf","url":"https://static1.squarespace.com/static/6543abac601e3621dd3fe76d/t/68b832df3dd5017d3a1c12e2/1756902111728/2021-06%2BUSDOT%2BFinal%2BReport%2BExecutive%2BSummary%2B%281%29-compressed-compressed.pdf"}],"summary":"The City program summary describes $40 million in USDOT funding, a $10 million foundation grant, and a Columbus Partnership-coordinated Acceleration Fund that grew from $90 million to more than $700 million.","tags":["wef-columbus","recursive-research","depth-4"],"title":"Smart Columbus public, philanthropic, and private funding streams","verification":{"status":"source-backed","verified":true},"version":1,"workflow":{"max_depth":6,"recursion_depth":4,"research_status":"completed","root_target_id":"starintel:org:city-of-columbus"}}
{"_id":"starintel:event:wef-infrastructure-roadmap-2024","aliases":[],"assessment":{"confidence":0.99},"attachments":[],"data":{"participants":["starintel:person:jordan-davis","starintel:org:smart-columbus","starintel:org:world-economic-forum"]},"dataset":"starintel-wef-columbus-urban-transformation-2026-07-25","date_added":"2026-07-25T00:00:00Z","date_updated":"2026-07-25T00:00:00Z","description":"","dtype":"event","evidence":[],"extensions":{"legacy.v0":{"data":{"confidence":0.99,"event_type":"policy_development","year":2024}}},"geospatial":{},"handling":{"pii":false,"sensitive":false,"visibility":"public"},"identifiers":[],"keywords":[],"labels":[],"language":"en","lineage":{"migration_from":"0.8","migration_notes":["Normalized into the canonical StarIntel v0.9.0 document envelope."]},"notes":[],"provenance":{"original_id":"starintel:event:wef-infrastructure-roadmap-2024","original_path":"digs/wef-columbus/2026-07-25-urban-transformation-network/starintel-documents.jsonl","original_schema_version":"0.8","software_version":"0.9.0","transform":"starintel_doc.migration.migrate_document"},"quality":{},"related_ids":[],"schema_version":"0.9.0","sources":[{"accessed_at":"2026-07-25T00:00:00Z","metadata":{"source_type":"official_project"},"title":"Implementing a Life-Cycle Approach to Infrastructure","uri":"https://centres.weforum.org/centre-for-urban-transformation/infrastructure-lifecycle","url":"https://centres.weforum.org/centre-for-urban-transformation/infrastructure-lifecycle"}],"status":"recorded","summary":"WEF's task-force roster included Jordan Davis, Executive Director of Smart Columbus, creating a direct personnel bridge into policy development.","tags":[],"temporal":{},"title":"WEF infrastructure life-cycle policy-roadmap task force","verification":{"status":"confirmed"},"version":1,"workflow":{}}
{"_id":"starintel:financial-observation:andhealth-downtown-office-incentive-payment-2024","assessment":{"confidence":0.99},"data":{"amount":47727.97,"counterparty_ids":["starintel:org:city-of-columbus"],"currency":"USD","entity_id":"starintel:org:andhealth","fiscal_year":2024,"instrument":"Columbus Downtown Office Incentive Program","methodology":"Amount stated in Columbus Ordinance 1885-2025.","observation_type":"municipal_tax_incentive_payment","qualifications":["The ordinance title and background identify the Downtown Office Incentive program; Section 6 uses Jobs Growth Incentive wording."],"value_type":"authorized_payment"},"dataset":"wef","date_added":"2026-07-26T04:05:00Z","date_updated":"2026-07-26T04:05:00Z","dtype":"financial-observation","evidence":[],"lineage":{"derived_from":["starintel:analysis:wef-columbus-depth-4-governance-replication-continuity"],"generation":5},"provenance":{"agent":"GPT-5.6 Thinking","method":"Primary-source recursive OSINT with bounded inference","run_id":"wef-columbus-depth-5-2026-07-26","skill":"auto-dig;web-research;create-starintel-documents;select-recursive-targets"},"schema_version":"0.9.0","sources":[{"accessed_at":"2026-07-26T04:05:00Z","credibility":0.99,"kind":"government_record","notes":"The title and background identify the Downtown Office Incentive program; Section 6 uses Jobs Growth Incentive wording.","publisher":"City of Columbus","title":"Columbus Ordinance 1885-2025","uri":"https://columbus.legistar.com/LegislationDetail.aspx?FullText=1&GUID=DE71F085-A673-490A-93D8-BED794B120CB&ID=7489845&Options=&Search=","url":"https://columbus.legistar.com/LegislationDetail.aspx?FullText=1&GUID=DE71F085-A673-490A-93D8-BED794B120CB&ID=7489845&Options=&Search="}],"summary":"Columbus authorized a $47,727.97 incentive payment to AndHealth for tax year 2024, its first reporting year under the agreement.","tags":["wef","columbus","recursive-research","depth-5"],"title":"AndHealth Downtown Office Incentive payment for tax year 2024","verification":{"status":"source-backed","verified":true},"version":1,"workflow":{"max_depth":6,"recursion_depth":5,"research_status":"completed","root_target_id":"starintel:org:city-of-columbus"}}
{"_id":"starintel:financial-observation:columbus-partnership-c3-expenses-2024","assessment":{"confidence":0.96},"data":{"amount":4353677,"currency":"USD","entity_id":"starintel:org:the-columbus-partnership-c3","fiscal_year":2024,"methodology":"ProPublica extraction from IRS Form 990 data.","observation_type":"expenses","qualifications":["IRS-derived filing data"],"value_type":"reported"},"dataset":"starintel-wef-columbus-depth-4-2026-07-25","date_added":"2026-07-25T21:15:00Z","date_updated":"2026-07-25T21:15:00Z","dtype":"financial-observation","evidence":[],"lineage":{"derived_from":["starintel:research-pass:wef-columbus-depth-3-2026-07-25"],"generation":4},"provenance":{"agent":"GPT-5.6 Thinking","run_id":"wef-columbus-depth-4-2026-07-25","skill":"auto-dig;search-starintel-json-db;create-starintel-documents;select-recursive-targets"},"schema_version":"0.9.0","sources":[{"accessed_at":"2026-07-25T21:15:00Z","credibility":0.95,"kind":"irs_derived_filing","publisher":"ProPublica Nonprofit Explorer","title":"The Columbus Partnership Form 990 — fiscal year 2024","uri":"https://projects.propublica.org/nonprofits/organizations/20580058","url":"https://projects.propublica.org/nonprofits/organizations/20580058"}],"summary":"IRS-derived fiscal-year observation for starintel:org:the-columbus-partnership-c3.","tags":["wef-columbus","recursive-research","depth-4"],"title":"Columbus Partnership expenses — 2024","verification":{"status":"source-backed","verified":true},"version":1,"workflow":{"max_depth":6,"recursion_depth":4,"research_status":"completed","root_target_id":"starintel:org:city-of-columbus"}}
{"_id":"starintel:financial-observation:columbus-partnership-c3-net-assets-2024","assessment":{"confidence":0.96},"data":{"amount":2193475,"currency":"USD","entity_id":"starintel:org:the-columbus-partnership-c3","fiscal_year":2024,"methodology":"ProPublica extraction from IRS Form 990 data.","observation_type":"net_assets","qualifications":["IRS-derived filing data"],"value_type":"reported"},"dataset":"starintel-wef-columbus-depth-4-2026-07-25","date_added":"2026-07-25T21:15:00Z","date_updated":"2026-07-25T21:15:00Z","dtype":"financial-observation","evidence":[],"lineage":{"derived_from":["starintel:research-pass:wef-columbus-depth-3-2026-07-25"],"generation":4},"provenance":{"agent":"GPT-5.6 Thinking","run_id":"wef-columbus-depth-4-2026-07-25","skill":"auto-dig;search-starintel-json-db;create-starintel-documents;select-recursive-targets"},"schema_version":"0.9.0","sources":[{"accessed_at":"2026-07-25T21:15:00Z","credibility":0.95,"kind":"irs_derived_filing","publisher":"ProPublica Nonprofit Explorer","title":"The Columbus Partnership Form 990 — fiscal year 2024","uri":"https://projects.propublica.org/nonprofits/organizations/20580058","url":"https://projects.propublica.org/nonprofits/organizations/20580058"}],"summary":"IRS-derived fiscal-year observation for starintel:org:the-columbus-partnership-c3.","tags":["wef-columbus","recursive-research","depth-4"],"title":"Columbus Partnership net assets — 2024","verification":{"status":"source-backed","verified":true},"version":1,"workflow":{"max_depth":6,"recursion_depth":4,"research_status":"completed","root_target_id":"starintel:org:city-of-columbus"}}
{"_id":"starintel:financial-observation:columbus-partnership-c3-revenue-2024","assessment":{"confidence":0.96},"data":{"amount":2065507,"currency":"USD","entity_id":"starintel:org:the-columbus-partnership-c3","fiscal_year":2024,"methodology":"ProPublica extraction from IRS Form 990 data.","observation_type":"revenue","qualifications":["IRS-derived filing data","98.9 percent contributions"],"value_type":"reported"},"dataset":"starintel-wef-columbus-depth-4-2026-07-25","date_added":"2026-07-25T21:15:00Z","date_updated":"2026-07-25T21:15:00Z","dtype":"financial-observation","evidence":[],"lineage":{"derived_from":["starintel:research-pass:wef-columbus-depth-3-2026-07-25"],"generation":4},"provenance":{"agent":"GPT-5.6 Thinking","run_id":"wef-columbus-depth-4-2026-07-25","skill":"auto-dig;search-starintel-json-db;create-starintel-documents;select-recursive-targets"},"schema_version":"0.9.0","sources":[{"accessed_at":"2026-07-25T21:15:00Z","credibility":0.95,"kind":"irs_derived_filing","publisher":"ProPublica Nonprofit Explorer","title":"The Columbus Partnership Form 990 — fiscal year 2024","uri":"https://projects.propublica.org/nonprofits/organizations/20580058","url":"https://projects.propublica.org/nonprofits/organizations/20580058"}],"summary":"IRS-derived fiscal-year observation for starintel:org:the-columbus-partnership-c3.","tags":["wef-columbus","recursive-research","depth-4"],"title":"Columbus Partnership revenue — 2024","verification":{"status":"source-backed","verified":true},"version":1,"workflow":{"max_depth":6,"recursion_depth":4,"research_status":"completed","root_target_id":"starintel:org:city-of-columbus"}}
{"_id":"starintel:financial-observation:columbus-partnership-c6-expenses-2024","assessment":{"confidence":0.96},"data":{"amount":10340008,"currency":"USD","entity_id":"starintel:org:columbus-partnership-c6","fiscal_year":2024,"methodology":"ProPublica extraction from IRS Form 990 data.","observation_type":"expenses","qualifications":["IRS-derived filing data"],"value_type":"reported"},"dataset":"starintel-wef-columbus-depth-4-2026-07-25","date_added":"2026-07-25T21:15:00Z","date_updated":"2026-07-25T21:15:00Z","dtype":"financial-observation","evidence":[],"lineage":{"derived_from":["starintel:research-pass:wef-columbus-depth-3-2026-07-25"],"generation":4},"provenance":{"agent":"GPT-5.6 Thinking","run_id":"wef-columbus-depth-4-2026-07-25","skill":"auto-dig;search-starintel-json-db;create-starintel-documents;select-recursive-targets"},"schema_version":"0.9.0","sources":[{"accessed_at":"2026-07-25T21:15:00Z","credibility":0.95,"kind":"irs_derived_filing","publisher":"ProPublica Nonprofit Explorer","title":"Columbus Partnership Form 990 — fiscal year 2024","uri":"https://projects.propublica.org/nonprofits/organizations/352558300","url":"https://projects.propublica.org/nonprofits/organizations/352558300"}],"summary":"IRS-derived fiscal-year observation for starintel:org:columbus-partnership-c6.","tags":["wef-columbus","recursive-research","depth-4"],"title":"Columbus Partnership expenses — 2024","verification":{"status":"source-backed","verified":true},"version":1,"workflow":{"max_depth":6,"recursion_depth":4,"research_status":"completed","root_target_id":"starintel:org:city-of-columbus"}}
{"_id":"starintel:financial-observation:columbus-partnership-c6-program-services-2024","assessment":{"confidence":0.96},"data":{"amount":8287785,"currency":"USD","entity_id":"starintel:org:columbus-partnership-c6","fiscal_year":2024,"methodology":"ProPublica extraction from IRS Form 990 data.","observation_type":"program_service_revenue","qualifications":["IRS-derived filing data","76.3 percent of total revenue"],"value_type":"reported"},"dataset":"starintel-wef-columbus-depth-4-2026-07-25","date_added":"2026-07-25T21:15:00Z","date_updated":"2026-07-25T21:15:00Z","dtype":"financial-observation","evidence":[],"lineage":{"derived_from":["starintel:research-pass:wef-columbus-depth-3-2026-07-25"],"generation":4},"provenance":{"agent":"GPT-5.6 Thinking","run_id":"wef-columbus-depth-4-2026-07-25","skill":"auto-dig;search-starintel-json-db;create-starintel-documents;select-recursive-targets"},"schema_version":"0.9.0","sources":[{"accessed_at":"2026-07-25T21:15:00Z","credibility":0.95,"kind":"irs_derived_filing","publisher":"ProPublica Nonprofit Explorer","title":"Columbus Partnership Form 990 — fiscal year 2024","uri":"https://projects.propublica.org/nonprofits/organizations/352558300","url":"https://projects.propublica.org/nonprofits/organizations/352558300"}],"summary":"IRS-derived fiscal-year observation for starintel:org:columbus-partnership-c6.","tags":["wef-columbus","recursive-research","depth-4"],"title":"Columbus Partnership program service revenue — 2024","verification":{"status":"source-backed","verified":true},"version":1,"workflow":{"max_depth":6,"recursion_depth":4,"research_status":"completed","root_target_id":"starintel:org:city-of-columbus"}}
{"_id":"starintel:financial-observation:columbus-partnership-c6-revenue-2024","assessment":{"confidence":0.96},"data":{"amount":10865769,"currency":"USD","entity_id":"starintel:org:columbus-partnership-c6","fiscal_year":2024,"methodology":"ProPublica extraction from IRS Form 990 data.","observation_type":"revenue","qualifications":["IRS-derived filing data","Fiscal-year total"],"value_type":"reported"},"dataset":"starintel-wef-columbus-depth-4-2026-07-25","date_added":"2026-07-25T21:15:00Z","date_updated":"2026-07-25T21:15:00Z","dtype":"financial-observation","evidence":[],"lineage":{"derived_from":["starintel:research-pass:wef-columbus-depth-3-2026-07-25"],"generation":4},"provenance":{"agent":"GPT-5.6 Thinking","run_id":"wef-columbus-depth-4-2026-07-25","skill":"auto-dig;search-starintel-json-db;create-starintel-documents;select-recursive-targets"},"schema_version":"0.9.0","sources":[{"accessed_at":"2026-07-25T21:15:00Z","credibility":0.95,"kind":"irs_derived_filing","publisher":"ProPublica Nonprofit Explorer","title":"Columbus Partnership Form 990 — fiscal year 2024","uri":"https://projects.propublica.org/nonprofits/organizations/352558300","url":"https://projects.propublica.org/nonprofits/organizations/352558300"}],"summary":"IRS-derived fiscal-year observation for starintel:org:columbus-partnership-c6.","tags":["wef-columbus","recursive-research","depth-4"],"title":"Columbus Partnership revenue — 2024","verification":{"status":"source-backed","verified":true},"version":1,"workflow":{"max_depth":6,"recursion_depth":4,"research_status":"completed","root_target_id":"starintel:org:city-of-columbus"}}
{"_id":"starintel:financial-observation:smart-columbus-authorizations-2022-2026","aliases":[],"assessment":{"confidence":0.98},"attachments":[],"data":{"currency":"USD"},"dataset":"starintel-wef-columbus-urban-transformation-2026-07-25","date_added":"2026-07-25T00:00:00Z","date_updated":"2026-07-25T00:00:00Z","description":"","dtype":"financial-observation","evidence":[],"extensions":{"legacy.v0":{"data":{"amount_type":"authorized_ceiling","confidence":0.98,"counterparty":"starintel:org:city-of-columbus","identified_total":2733574.98,"observations":[{"amount":263574.98,"ordinance":"0670-2022"},{"amount":560000,"ordinance":"2657-2022"},{"amount":500000,"ordinance":"1462-2023"},{"amount":610000,"ordinance":"2266-2023"},{"amount":500000,"ordinance":"1663-2025"},{"amount":300000,"ordinance":"1850-2026"}],"subject":"starintel:org:smart-columbus"}}},"geospatial":{},"handling":{"pii":false,"sensitive":false,"visibility":"public"},"identifiers":[],"keywords":[],"labels":[],"language":"en","lineage":{"migration_from":"0.8","migration_notes":["Normalized into the canonical StarIntel v0.9.0 document envelope."]},"notes":[],"provenance":{"original_id":"starintel:financial-observation:smart-columbus-authorizations-2022-2026","original_path":"digs/wef-columbus/2026-07-25-urban-transformation-network/starintel-documents.jsonl","original_schema_version":"0.8","software_version":"0.9.0","transform":"starintel_doc.migration.migrate_document"},"quality":{},"related_ids":[],"schema_version":"0.9.0","sources":[{"accessed_at":"2026-07-25T00:00:00Z","metadata":{"source_type":"government_record"},"title":"Columbus Ordinance 0670-2022","uri":"https://columbus.legistar.com/LegislationDetail.aspx?From=RSS&FullText=1&G=4F637594-17B0-4E92-8196-37F14328D337&GUID=BA6AF40A-7EE9-4728-8409-9030A6B48AED&ID=5528670","url":"https://columbus.legistar.com/LegislationDetail.aspx?From=RSS&FullText=1&G=4F637594-17B0-4E92-8196-37F14328D337&GUID=BA6AF40A-7EE9-4728-8409-9030A6B48AED&ID=5528670"},{"accessed_at":"2026-07-25T00:00:00Z","metadata":{"source_type":"government_record"},"title":"Columbus Ordinance 2657-2022","uri":"https://columbus.legistar.com/LegislationDetail.aspx?FullText=1&GUID=D49DAC76-C0A0-4A0E-BA0E-15A83ACCEFC9&ID=5941583&Options=&Search=","url":"https://columbus.legistar.com/LegislationDetail.aspx?FullText=1&GUID=D49DAC76-C0A0-4A0E-BA0E-15A83ACCEFC9&ID=5941583&Options=&Search="},{"accessed_at":"2026-07-25T00:00:00Z","metadata":{"source_type":"government_record"},"title":"Columbus Ordinance 1462-2023","uri":"https://columbus.legistar.com/LegislationDetail.aspx?FullText=1&GUID=F6518EB6-1806-41C5-A998-B5A0EFB4941B&ID=6245314","url":"https://columbus.legistar.com/LegislationDetail.aspx?FullText=1&GUID=F6518EB6-1806-41C5-A998-B5A0EFB4941B&ID=6245314"},{"accessed_at":"2026-07-25T00:00:00Z","metadata":{"source_type":"government_record"},"title":"Columbus Ordinance 2266-2023","uri":"https://columbus.legistar.com/LegislationDetail.aspx?FullText=1&G=4F637594-17B0-4E92-8196-37F14328D337&GUID=48F6A387-601F-4B3A-9855-A1635EC2910A&ID=6301088&Options=&Search=","url":"https://columbus.legistar.com/LegislationDetail.aspx?FullText=1&G=4F637594-17B0-4E92-8196-37F14328D337&GUID=48F6A387-601F-4B3A-9855-A1635EC2910A&ID=6301088&Options=&Search="},{"accessed_at":"2026-07-25T00:00:00Z","metadata":{"source_type":"government_record"},"title":"Columbus Ordinance 1663-2025","uri":"https://columbus.legistar.com/LegislationDetail.aspx?FullText=1&GUID=5E02F335-BDF8-4220-B7BB-05FE16CF6CC4&ID=7489830","url":"https://columbus.legistar.com/LegislationDetail.aspx?FullText=1&GUID=5E02F335-BDF8-4220-B7BB-05FE16CF6CC4&ID=7489830"},{"accessed_at":"2026-07-25T00:00:00Z","metadata":{"source_type":"government_record"},"title":"Columbus Ordinance 1850-2026","uri":"https://columbus.legistar.com/LegislationDetail.aspx?FullText=1&GUID=588DBFF9-D9DB-4603-B5D4-776E9F5B5A9E&ID=8117690&Options=&Search=","url":"https://columbus.legistar.com/LegislationDetail.aspx?FullText=1&GUID=588DBFF9-D9DB-4603-B5D4-776E9F5B5A9E&ID=8117690&Options=&Search="}],"status":"recorded","summary":"Six ordinances authorized ceilings totaling $2,733,574.98. Authorization is not confirmed outlay, and the records do not show transfer of these funds to WEF.","tags":[],"temporal":{},"title":"Identified Columbus authorizations to Smart Columbus, 2022–2026","verification":{"status":"confirmed_bounded"},"version":1,"workflow":{}}
{"_id":"starintel:grant:columbus-vulcan-smart-city-2016","assessment":{"confidence":0.98},"data":{"buyer_id":"starintel:org:paul-g-allen-philanthropies-vulcan","ceiling_amount":10000000,"currency":"USD","description":"Private matching funding supporting electrification and Smart City deployment.","grantor_id":"starintel:org:paul-g-allen-philanthropies-vulcan","program":"Smart City Challenge","recipient_ids":["starintel:org:city-of-columbus"],"seller_id":"starintel:org:city-of-columbus","status":"awarded"},"dataset":"starintel-wef-columbus-depth-3-2026-07-25","date_added":"2026-07-25T20:30:00Z","date_updated":"2026-07-25T20:30:00Z","dtype":"grant","evidence":[],"lineage":{"derived_from":["starintel:research-pass:wef-columbus-depth-2-2026-07-25"],"generation":3},"provenance":{"agent":"GPT-5.6 Thinking","run_id":"wef-columbus-depth-3-2026-07-25","skill":"auto-dig;create-starintel-documents;select-recursive-targets"},"schema_version":"0.9.0","sources":[{"accessed_at":"2026-07-25T20:30:00Z","credibility":0.95,"kind":"government_record","publisher":"City of Columbus","title":"Columbus Ordinance 0820-2018","uri":"https://columbus.legistar.com/LegislationDetail.aspx?FullText=1&GUID=A46BE430-491C-4BFF-BA59-B37B763DF2B6&ID=3476477","url":"https://columbus.legistar.com/LegislationDetail.aspx?FullText=1&GUID=A46BE430-491C-4BFF-BA59-B37B763DF2B6&ID=3476477"}],"summary":"Private grant of up to $10 million awarded alongside the USDOT Smart City Challenge funding.","tags":["wef-columbus","recursive-research","depth-3"],"title":"Paul G. Allen/Vulcan Smart City Challenge grant","verification":{"status":"source-backed","verified":true},"version":1,"workflow":{"max_depth":6,"recursion_depth":3,"research_status":"completed","root_target_id":"starintel:org:city-of-columbus"}}
{"_id":"starintel:investigation-target:wef-columbus-depth-4-andhealth-public-private-continuity","data":{"breadth":20,"depth":4,"hypotheses":["Documented network continuity may explain policy diffusion without requiring centralized command.","Official records may reveal additional contract, funding, or governance mechanisms."],"in_scope":["JobsOhio records","state incentives","CHC contracts","board memberships","lobbying and grants"],"max_depth":6,"objectives":["JobsOhio records","state incentives","CHC contracts","board memberships","lobbying and grants"],"out_of_scope":["unsupported allegations","private personal data"],"preferred_sources":["government records","contracts","board minutes","official organizational records"],"priority":0.9,"required_dtypes":["person","org","relation","contract","grant","source","research-pass"],"research_question":"What public funding, JobsOhio support, health-center contracts, and Columbus Partnership links connect AndHealth to the regional governance network?","scope_type":"recursive_depth_4","score":0.9,"seed_ids":["starintel:org:andhealth","starintel:person:jordan-davis","starintel:person:matt-scantland","starintel:org:francisco-partners","starintel:org:health2047"],"selection_reason":["new high-connectivity entities","unresolved documentary gaps","direct linkage to prior findings"],"status":"queued","target":"AndHealth and Columbus civic-network continuity","target_id":"starintel:investigation-target:wef-columbus-depth-4-andhealth-public-private-continuity","target_type":"organization_network"},"dataset":"starintel-wef-columbus-depth-3-2026-07-25","date_added":"2026-07-25T20:30:00Z","date_updated":"2026-07-25T20:30:00Z","dtype":"investigation-target","evidence":[],"lineage":{"derived_from":["starintel:research-pass:wef-columbus-depth-2-2026-07-25"],"generation":3},"provenance":{"agent":"GPT-5.6 Thinking","run_id":"wef-columbus-depth-3-2026-07-25","skill":"auto-dig;create-starintel-documents;select-recursive-targets"},"schema_version":"0.9.0","sources":[],"summary":"Depth 4 recursive target selected from the Depth 3 WEF–Columbus expansion.","tags":["wef-columbus","recursive-research","depth-3"],"title":"AndHealth and Columbus civic-network continuity","verification":{"status":"source-backed","verified":true},"version":1,"workflow":{"max_depth":6,"next_action":"collect primary records","priority":0.9,"queue":"wef-columbus-depth-4","recursion_depth":4,"research_status":"queued","root_target_id":"starintel:org:city-of-columbus","selected_from":["starintel:org:andhealth","starintel:person:jordan-davis","starintel:person:matt-scantland","starintel:org:francisco-partners","starintel:org:health2047"],"selection_reason":["recursive expansion from depth 3"]}}
{"_id":"starintel:investigation-target:wef-columbus-depth-4-personnel-board-governance","data":{"breadth":20,"depth":4,"hypotheses":["Documented network continuity may explain policy diffusion without requiring centralized command.","Official records may reveal additional contract, funding, or governance mechanisms."],"in_scope":["board minutes","appointment records","conflict disclosures","archived rosters","resignation letters"],"max_depth":6,"objectives":["board minutes","appointment records","conflict disclosures","archived rosters","resignation letters"],"out_of_scope":["unsupported allegations","private personal data"],"preferred_sources":["government records","contracts","board minutes","official organizational records"],"priority":0.9,"required_dtypes":["person","org","relation","contract","grant","source","research-pass"],"research_question":"Who appointed current Smart Columbus board members, when did roles change, and what voting or conflict rules apply?","scope_type":"recursive_depth_4","score":0.9,"seed_ids":["starintel:person:corrine-burger","starintel:person:jordan-davis","starintel:person:calvin-cooper","starintel:relation:smart-columbus-board-roster-conflict"],"selection_reason":["new high-connectivity entities","unresolved documentary gaps","direct linkage to prior findings"],"status":"queued","target":"Smart Columbus personnel and board governance","target_id":"starintel:investigation-target:wef-columbus-depth-4-personnel-board-governance","target_type":"person_or_governance_network"},"dataset":"starintel-wef-columbus-depth-3-2026-07-25","date_added":"2026-07-25T20:30:00Z","date_updated":"2026-07-25T20:30:00Z","dtype":"investigation-target","evidence":[],"lineage":{"derived_from":["starintel:research-pass:wef-columbus-depth-2-2026-07-25"],"generation":3},"provenance":{"agent":"GPT-5.6 Thinking","run_id":"wef-columbus-depth-3-2026-07-25","skill":"auto-dig;create-starintel-documents;select-recursive-targets"},"schema_version":"0.9.0","sources":[],"summary":"Depth 4 recursive target selected from the Depth 3 WEF–Columbus expansion.","tags":["wef-columbus","recursive-research","depth-3"],"title":"Smart Columbus personnel and board governance","verification":{"status":"source-backed","verified":true},"version":1,"workflow":{"max_depth":6,"next_action":"collect primary records","priority":0.9,"queue":"wef-columbus-depth-4","recursion_depth":4,"research_status":"queued","root_target_id":"starintel:org:city-of-columbus","selected_from":["starintel:person:corrine-burger","starintel:person:jordan-davis","starintel:person:calvin-cooper","starintel:relation:smart-columbus-board-roster-conflict"],"selection_reason":["recursive expansion from depth 3"]}}
{"_id":"starintel:investigation-target:wef-columbus-depth-4-private-grant-replication","data":{"breadth":20,"depth":4,"hypotheses":["Documented network continuity may explain policy diffusion without requiring centralized command.","Official records may reveal additional contract, funding, or governance mechanisms."],"in_scope":["grant agreement","amendments","approval correspondence","playbook drafts","webinar materials","replication agreements"],"max_depth":6,"objectives":["grant agreement","amendments","approval correspondence","playbook drafts","webinar materials","replication agreements"],"out_of_scope":["unsupported allegations","private personal data"],"preferred_sources":["government records","contracts","board minutes","official organizational records"],"priority":0.9,"required_dtypes":["person","org","relation","contract","grant","source","research-pass"],"research_question":"How did private grant approval conditions, schedules, playbooks, advisers, and national replication products shape Columbus implementation?","scope_type":"recursive_depth_4","score":0.9,"seed_ids":["starintel:grant:columbus-vulcan-smart-city-2016","starintel:org:paul-g-allen-philanthropies-vulcan","starintel:org:electrification-coalition","starintel:source:ec-accelerate-your-city"],"selection_reason":["new high-connectivity entities","unresolved documentary gaps","direct linkage to prior findings"],"status":"queued","target":"Vulcan grant conditions and replication system","target_id":"starintel:investigation-target:wef-columbus-depth-4-private-grant-replication","target_type":"grant_and_policy_diffusion"},"dataset":"starintel-wef-columbus-depth-3-2026-07-25","date_added":"2026-07-25T20:30:00Z","date_updated":"2026-07-25T20:30:00Z","dtype":"investigation-target","evidence":[],"lineage":{"derived_from":["starintel:research-pass:wef-columbus-depth-2-2026-07-25"],"generation":3},"provenance":{"agent":"GPT-5.6 Thinking","run_id":"wef-columbus-depth-3-2026-07-25","skill":"auto-dig;create-starintel-documents;select-recursive-targets"},"schema_version":"0.9.0","sources":[],"summary":"Depth 4 recursive target selected from the Depth 3 WEF–Columbus expansion.","tags":["wef-columbus","recursive-research","depth-3"],"title":"Vulcan grant conditions and replication system","verification":{"status":"source-backed","verified":true},"version":1,"workflow":{"max_depth":6,"next_action":"collect primary records","priority":0.9,"queue":"wef-columbus-depth-4","recursion_depth":4,"research_status":"queued","root_target_id":"starintel:org:city-of-columbus","selected_from":["starintel:grant:columbus-vulcan-smart-city-2016","starintel:org:paul-g-allen-philanthropies-vulcan","starintel:org:electrification-coalition","starintel:source:ec-accelerate-your-city"],"selection_reason":["recursive expansion from depth 3"]}}
{"_id":"starintel:investigation-target:wef-columbus-depth-4-vendor-contract-lifecycle","data":{"breadth":20,"depth":4,"hypotheses":["Documented network continuity may explain policy diffusion without requiring centralized command.","Official records may reveal additional contract, funding, or governance mechanisms."],"in_scope":["executed contracts","purchase orders","modification ledgers","deliverables","invoices","IP clauses","post-grant awards"],"max_depth":6,"objectives":["executed contracts","purchase orders","modification ledgers","deliverables","invoices","IP clauses","post-grant awards"],"out_of_scope":["unsupported allegations","private personal data"],"preferred_sources":["government records","contracts","board minutes","official organizational records"],"priority":0.9,"required_dtypes":["person","org","relation","contract","grant","source","research-pass"],"research_question":"What are the complete award, modification, deliverable, IP, and post-grant continuation histories for Accenture/Pillar, HNTB, CivitasNow, Navigant, Fahlgren Mortine, and Electrification Coalition?","scope_type":"recursive_depth_4","score":0.9,"seed_ids":["starintel:contract:pillar-accenture-smart-city-chain-2018-2020","starintel:contract:hntb-smart-city-program-management-identified-minimum","starintel:org:civitasnow","starintel:org:navigant-guidehouse","starintel:org:fahlgren-mortine","starintel:org:electrification-coalition"],"selection_reason":["new high-connectivity entities","unresolved documentary gaps","direct linkage to prior findings"],"status":"queued","target":"Smart Columbus vendor contract lifecycle","target_id":"starintel:investigation-target:wef-columbus-depth-4-vendor-contract-lifecycle","target_type":"contract_network"},"dataset":"starintel-wef-columbus-depth-3-2026-07-25","date_added":"2026-07-25T20:30:00Z","date_updated":"2026-07-25T20:30:00Z","dtype":"investigation-target","evidence":[],"lineage":{"derived_from":["starintel:research-pass:wef-columbus-depth-2-2026-07-25"],"generation":3},"provenance":{"agent":"GPT-5.6 Thinking","run_id":"wef-columbus-depth-3-2026-07-25","skill":"auto-dig;create-starintel-documents;select-recursive-targets"},"schema_version":"0.9.0","sources":[],"summary":"Depth 4 recursive target selected from the Depth 3 WEF–Columbus expansion.","tags":["wef-columbus","recursive-research","depth-3"],"title":"Smart Columbus vendor contract lifecycle","verification":{"status":"source-backed","verified":true},"version":1,"workflow":{"max_depth":6,"next_action":"collect primary records","priority":0.9,"queue":"wef-columbus-depth-4","recursion_depth":4,"research_status":"queued","root_target_id":"starintel:org:city-of-columbus","selected_from":["starintel:contract:pillar-accenture-smart-city-chain-2018-2020","starintel:contract:hntb-smart-city-program-management-identified-minimum","starintel:org:civitasnow","starintel:org:navigant-guidehouse","starintel:org:fahlgren-mortine","starintel:org:electrification-coalition"],"selection_reason":["recursive expansion from depth 3"]}}
{"_id":"starintel:investigation-target:wef-columbus-depth-5-andhealth-public-assistance","assessment":{"confidence":0.92},"data":{"breadth":25,"depth":5,"hypotheses":["Documentary records may reveal additional governance or implementation mechanisms.","Observed network continuity may be explained by institutional design without centralized command."],"in_scope":["JobsOhio agreements","Tax Credit Authority minutes","One Columbus project files","City incentive legislation","payroll and job commitments"],"max_depth":6,"objectives":["JobsOhio agreements","Tax Credit Authority minutes","One Columbus project files","City incentive legislation","payroll and job commitments"],"out_of_scope":["unsupported allegations","private personal data"],"preferred_sources":["primary government records","executed agreements","official filings","board minutes","source repositories"],"priority":0.92,"required_dtypes":["source","person","org","relation","contract","grant","financial-observation","analysis","research-pass"],"research_question":"What grants, tax credits, loans, site-selection services, and performance agreements supported AndHealth's 2022 and 2025 expansions?","scope_type":"recursive_depth_5","score":0.92,"seed_ids":["starintel:event:andhealth-expansion-2022-public-support","starintel:event:andhealth-expansion-2025-public-support","starintel:org:jobsohio","starintel:org:one-columbus"],"selection_reason":["new Depth 4 entity or document","high graph connectivity","unresolved primary-record gap"],"status":"queued","target":"AndHealth public assistance and expansion agreements","target_id":"starintel:investigation-target:wef-columbus-depth-5-andhealth-public-assistance","target_type":"economic_development_support"},"dataset":"starintel-wef-columbus-depth-4-2026-07-25","date_added":"2026-07-25T21:15:00Z","date_updated":"2026-07-25T21:15:00Z","dtype":"investigation-target","evidence":[],"lineage":{"derived_from":["starintel:research-pass:wef-columbus-depth-3-2026-07-25"],"generation":4},"provenance":{"agent":"GPT-5.6 Thinking","run_id":"wef-columbus-depth-4-2026-07-25","skill":"auto-dig;search-starintel-json-db;create-starintel-documents;select-recursive-targets"},"schema_version":"0.9.0","sources":[],"summary":"Depth 5 recursive target selected from new Depth 4 records.","tags":["wef-columbus","recursive-research","depth-4"],"title":"AndHealth public assistance and expansion agreements","verification":{"status":"queued","verified":false},"version":1,"workflow":{"max_depth":6,"next_action":"collect and normalize primary records","priority":0.92,"queue":"wef-columbus-depth-5","recursion_depth":5,"research_status":"queued","root_target_id":"starintel:org:city-of-columbus","selected_from":["starintel:event:andhealth-expansion-2022-public-support","starintel:event:andhealth-expansion-2025-public-support","starintel:org:jobsohio","starintel:org:one-columbus"],"selection_reason":["recursive expansion from Depth 4"]}}
{"_id":"starintel:investigation-target:wef-columbus-depth-5-columbus-partnership-legal-financial-flows","assessment":{"confidence":0.92},"data":{"breadth":25,"depth":5,"hypotheses":["Documentary records may reveal additional governance or implementation mechanisms.","Observed network continuity may be explained by institutional design without centralized command."],"in_scope":["Form 990 Schedule L and R","audited financial statements","intercompany agreements","shared-services agreements","grant schedules","board minutes"],"max_depth":6,"objectives":["Form 990 Schedule L and R","audited financial statements","intercompany agreements","shared-services agreements","grant schedules","board minutes"],"out_of_scope":["unsupported allegations","private personal data"],"preferred_sources":["primary government records","executed agreements","official filings","board minutes","source repositories"],"priority":0.92,"required_dtypes":["source","person","org","relation","contract","grant","financial-observation","analysis","research-pass"],"research_question":"What transactions, shared services, grants, payments, and governance links connect the 501(c)(6), 501(c)(3), Smart Columbus, and One Columbus entities?","scope_type":"recursive_depth_5","score":0.92,"seed_ids":["starintel:org:columbus-partnership-c6","starintel:org:the-columbus-partnership-c3","starintel:observation:columbus-partnership-c6-schedule-l-2024"],"selection_reason":["new Depth 4 entity or document","high graph connectivity","unresolved primary-record gap"],"status":"queued","target":"Columbus Partnership legal entities and financial flows","target_id":"starintel:investigation-target:wef-columbus-depth-5-columbus-partnership-legal-financial-flows","target_type":"legal_and_financial_network"},"dataset":"starintel-wef-columbus-depth-4-2026-07-25","date_added":"2026-07-25T21:15:00Z","date_updated":"2026-07-25T21:15:00Z","dtype":"investigation-target","evidence":[],"lineage":{"derived_from":["starintel:research-pass:wef-columbus-depth-3-2026-07-25"],"generation":4},"provenance":{"agent":"GPT-5.6 Thinking","run_id":"wef-columbus-depth-4-2026-07-25","skill":"auto-dig;search-starintel-json-db;create-starintel-documents;select-recursive-targets"},"schema_version":"0.9.0","sources":[],"summary":"Depth 5 recursive target selected from new Depth 4 records.","tags":["wef-columbus","recursive-research","depth-4"],"title":"Columbus Partnership legal entities and financial flows","verification":{"status":"queued","verified":false},"version":1,"workflow":{"max_depth":6,"next_action":"collect and normalize primary records","priority":0.92,"queue":"wef-columbus-depth-5","recursion_depth":5,"research_status":"queued","root_target_id":"starintel:org:city-of-columbus","selected_from":["starintel:org:columbus-partnership-c6","starintel:org:the-columbus-partnership-c3","starintel:observation:columbus-partnership-c6-schedule-l-2024"],"selection_reason":["recursive expansion from Depth 4"]}}
{"_id":"starintel:investigation-target:wef-columbus-depth-5-grant-era-replication-lineage","assessment":{"confidence":0.92},"data":{"breadth":25,"depth":5,"hypotheses":["Documentary records may reveal additional governance or implementation mechanisms.","Observed network continuity may be explained by institutional design without centralized command."],"in_scope":["all five final reports","source-code repositories","licenses","playbook versions","conference presentations","city-to-city agreements"],"max_depth":6,"objectives":["all five final reports","source-code repositories","licenses","playbook versions","conference presentations","city-to-city agreements"],"out_of_scope":["unsupported allegations","private personal data"],"preferred_sources":["primary government records","executed agreements","official filings","board minutes","source repositories"],"priority":0.92,"required_dtypes":["source","person","org","relation","contract","grant","financial-observation","analysis","research-pass"],"research_question":"Which grant-era code, playbooks, technical documents, and project designs were reused by Columbus, other cities, vendors, or WEF-linked networks?","scope_type":"recursive_depth_5","score":0.92,"seed_ids":["starintel:source:smart-columbus-grant-era-reports-index","starintel:source:smart-columbus-usdot-program-summary-2021","starintel:observation:smart-columbus-project-continuation-and-replication"],"selection_reason":["new Depth 4 entity or document","high graph connectivity","unresolved primary-record gap"],"status":"queued","target":"Smart Columbus grant-era replication lineage","target_id":"starintel:investigation-target:wef-columbus-depth-5-grant-era-replication-lineage","target_type":"document_and_policy_diffusion"},"dataset":"starintel-wef-columbus-depth-4-2026-07-25","date_added":"2026-07-25T21:15:00Z","date_updated":"2026-07-25T21:15:00Z","dtype":"investigation-target","evidence":[],"lineage":{"derived_from":["starintel:research-pass:wef-columbus-depth-3-2026-07-25"],"generation":4},"provenance":{"agent":"GPT-5.6 Thinking","run_id":"wef-columbus-depth-4-2026-07-25","skill":"auto-dig;search-starintel-json-db;create-starintel-documents;select-recursive-targets"},"schema_version":"0.9.0","sources":[],"summary":"Depth 5 recursive target selected from new Depth 4 records.","tags":["wef-columbus","recursive-research","depth-4"],"title":"Smart Columbus grant-era replication lineage","verification":{"status":"queued","verified":false},"version":1,"workflow":{"max_depth":6,"next_action":"collect and normalize primary records","priority":0.92,"queue":"wef-columbus-depth-5","recursion_depth":5,"research_status":"queued","root_target_id":"starintel:org:city-of-columbus","selected_from":["starintel:source:smart-columbus-grant-era-reports-index","starintel:source:smart-columbus-usdot-program-summary-2021","starintel:observation:smart-columbus-project-continuation-and-replication"],"selection_reason":["recursive expansion from Depth 4"]}}
{"_id":"starintel:investigation-target:wef-columbus-depth-5-hntb-smart-lighting-subconsultants","assessment":{"confidence":0.92},"data":{"breadth":25,"depth":5,"hypotheses":["Documentary records may reveal additional governance or implementation mechanisms.","Observed network continuity may be explained by institutional design without centralized command."],"in_scope":["executed contract","subconsultant agreements","product scoring","pilot results","purchase orders","invoices"],"max_depth":6,"objectives":["executed contract","subconsultant agreements","product scoring","pilot results","purchase orders","invoices"],"out_of_scope":["unsupported allegations","private personal data"],"preferred_sources":["primary government records","executed agreements","official filings","board minutes","source repositories"],"priority":0.92,"required_dtypes":["source","person","org","relation","contract","grant","financial-observation","analysis","research-pass"],"research_question":"What work did HNTB, EMH&T, and Barr perform, which products were evaluated, and how were recommendations translated into procurement?","scope_type":"recursive_depth_5","score":0.92,"seed_ids":["starintel:contract:hntb-smart-lighting-phase-4-lifecycle-2022-2026","starintel:org:emh-and-t-inc","starintel:org:barr-engineering"],"selection_reason":["new Depth 4 entity or document","high graph connectivity","unresolved primary-record gap"],"status":"queued","target":"HNTB Smart Lighting subcontract and product-evaluation chain","target_id":"starintel:investigation-target:wef-columbus-depth-5-hntb-smart-lighting-subconsultants","target_type":"contract_network"},"dataset":"starintel-wef-columbus-depth-4-2026-07-25","date_added":"2026-07-25T21:15:00Z","date_updated":"2026-07-25T21:15:00Z","dtype":"investigation-target","evidence":[],"lineage":{"derived_from":["starintel:research-pass:wef-columbus-depth-3-2026-07-25"],"generation":4},"provenance":{"agent":"GPT-5.6 Thinking","run_id":"wef-columbus-depth-4-2026-07-25","skill":"auto-dig;search-starintel-json-db;create-starintel-documents;select-recursive-targets"},"schema_version":"0.9.0","sources":[],"summary":"Depth 5 recursive target selected from new Depth 4 records.","tags":["wef-columbus","recursive-research","depth-4"],"title":"HNTB Smart Lighting subcontract and product-evaluation chain","verification":{"status":"queued","verified":false},"version":1,"workflow":{"max_depth":6,"next_action":"collect and normalize primary records","priority":0.92,"queue":"wef-columbus-depth-5","recursion_depth":5,"research_status":"queued","root_target_id":"starintel:org:city-of-columbus","selected_from":["starintel:contract:hntb-smart-lighting-phase-4-lifecycle-2022-2026","starintel:org:emh-and-t-inc","starintel:org:barr-engineering"],"selection_reason":["recursive expansion from Depth 4"]}}
{"_id":"starintel:investigation-target:wef-columbus-depth-5-smart-columbus-team-project-map","assessment":{"confidence":0.92},"data":{"breadth":25,"depth":5,"hypotheses":["Documentary records may reveal additional governance or implementation mechanisms.","Observed network continuity may be explained by institutional design without centralized command."],"in_scope":["staff bios","project charters","scopes of work","grant applications","board reports","vendor correspondence"],"max_depth":6,"objectives":["staff bios","project charters","scopes of work","grant applications","board reports","vendor correspondence"],"out_of_scope":["unsupported allegations","private personal data"],"preferred_sources":["primary government records","executed agreements","official filings","board minutes","source repositories"],"priority":0.92,"required_dtypes":["source","person","org","relation","contract","grant","financial-observation","analysis","research-pass"],"research_question":"Which current staff members own each Smart Columbus project, grant, vendor relationship, data system, and deliverable?","scope_type":"recursive_depth_5","score":0.92,"seed_ids":["starintel:person:cami-albaugh","starintel:person:hailey-allison","starintel:person:mike-anderson","starintel:person:arash-ghazvini","starintel:person:norah-goldman","starintel:person:tosin-guobadia","starintel:person:brayan-pabon-gomez","starintel:person:ayaz-hyder","starintel:person:karina-sanchez","starintel:person:dylan-sansone","starintel:person:andreya-veintimilla"],"selection_reason":["new Depth 4 entity or document","high graph connectivity","unresolved primary-record gap"],"status":"queued","target":"Smart Columbus staff project and contract map","target_id":"starintel:investigation-target:wef-columbus-depth-5-smart-columbus-team-project-map","target_type":"personnel_and_delivery_network"},"dataset":"starintel-wef-columbus-depth-4-2026-07-25","date_added":"2026-07-25T21:15:00Z","date_updated":"2026-07-25T21:15:00Z","dtype":"investigation-target","evidence":[],"lineage":{"derived_from":["starintel:research-pass:wef-columbus-depth-3-2026-07-25"],"generation":4},"provenance":{"agent":"GPT-5.6 Thinking","run_id":"wef-columbus-depth-4-2026-07-25","skill":"auto-dig;search-starintel-json-db;create-starintel-documents;select-recursive-targets"},"schema_version":"0.9.0","sources":[],"summary":"Depth 5 recursive target selected from new Depth 4 records.","tags":["wef-columbus","recursive-research","depth-4"],"title":"Smart Columbus staff project and contract map","verification":{"status":"queued","verified":false},"version":1,"workflow":{"max_depth":6,"next_action":"collect and normalize primary records","priority":0.92,"queue":"wef-columbus-depth-5","recursion_depth":5,"research_status":"queued","root_target_id":"starintel:org:city-of-columbus","selected_from":["starintel:person:cami-albaugh","starintel:person:hailey-allison","starintel:person:mike-anderson","starintel:person:arash-ghazvini","starintel:person:norah-goldman","starintel:person:tosin-guobadia","starintel:person:brayan-pabon-gomez","starintel:person:ayaz-hyder","starintel:person:karina-sanchez","starintel:person:dylan-sansone","starintel:person:andreya-veintimilla"],"selection_reason":["recursive expansion from Depth 4"]}}
{"_id":"starintel:investigation-target:wef-columbus-records","aliases":[],"assessment":{"confidence":0.99},"attachments":[],"data":{"priority":0.0,"target":"Obtain WEF–Columbus agreements, correspondence and policy traces"},"dataset":"starintel-wef-columbus-urban-transformation-2026-07-25","date_added":"2026-07-25T00:00:00Z","date_updated":"2026-07-25T00:00:00Z","description":"","dtype":"investigation-target","evidence":[],"extensions":{"legacy.v0":{"data":{"confidence":0.99,"current_status":"open","requested_records":["WEF and Centre correspondence","membership, participation or sponsorship agreements","invoices, dues, donations, travel and conference expenses","task-force invitations, minutes, drafts and deliverables","internal use of WEF roadmaps or toolkits","Smart Columbus board minutes and City contract deliverables","records authorizing the WEF City of Columbus profile"],"target_entities":["starintel:org:city-of-columbus","starintel:org:smart-columbus","starintel:org:columbus-partnership","starintel:org:world-economic-forum"]}}},"geospatial":{},"handling":{"pii":false,"sensitive":false,"visibility":"public"},"identifiers":[],"keywords":[],"labels":[],"language":"en","lineage":{"migration_from":"0.8","migration_notes":["Normalized into the canonical StarIntel v0.9.0 document envelope."]},"notes":[],"provenance":{"original_id":"starintel:investigation-target:wef-columbus-records","original_path":"digs/wef-columbus/2026-07-25-urban-transformation-network/starintel-documents.jsonl","original_schema_version":"0.8","software_version":"0.9.0","transform":"starintel_doc.migration.migrate_document"},"quality":{},"related_ids":[],"schema_version":"0.9.0","sources":[{"accessed_at":"2026-07-25T00:00:00Z","metadata":{"source_type":"official_organization"},"title":"City of Columbus | World Economic Forum","uri":"https://www.weforum.org/organizations/city-of-columbus/","url":"https://www.weforum.org/organizations/city-of-columbus/"},{"accessed_at":"2026-07-25T00:00:00Z","metadata":{"source_type":"official_project"},"title":"Implementing a Life-Cycle Approach to Infrastructure","uri":"https://centres.weforum.org/centre-for-urban-transformation/infrastructure-lifecycle","url":"https://centres.weforum.org/centre-for-urban-transformation/infrastructure-lifecycle"},{"accessed_at":"2026-07-25T00:00:00Z","metadata":{"source_type":"government_record"},"title":"Columbus Ordinance 1663-2025","uri":"https://columbus.legistar.com/LegislationDetail.aspx?FullText=1&GUID=5E02F335-BDF8-4220-B7BB-05FE16CF6CC4&ID=7489830","url":"https://columbus.legistar.com/LegislationDetail.aspx?FullText=1&GUID=5E02F335-BDF8-4220-B7BB-05FE16CF6CC4&ID=7489830"},{"accessed_at":"2026-07-25T00:00:00Z","metadata":{"source_type":"government_record"},"title":"Columbus Ordinance 1850-2026","uri":"https://columbus.legistar.com/LegislationDetail.aspx?FullText=1&GUID=588DBFF9-D9DB-4603-B5D4-776E9F5B5A9E&ID=8117690&Options=&Search=","url":"https://columbus.legistar.com/LegislationDetail.aspx?FullText=1&GUID=588DBFF9-D9DB-4603-B5D4-776E9F5B5A9E&ID=8117690&Options=&Search="}],"status":"recorded","summary":"Resolve the terms, money, personnel, deliverables and local policy use behind the documented relationship.","tags":[],"temporal":{},"title":"Obtain WEF–Columbus agreements, correspondence and policy traces","verification":{"status":"open_probe"},"version":1,"workflow":{}}
{"_id":"starintel:investigation-target:wef-depth-6-andhealth-incentive-ledger","assessment":{"confidence":0.94},"data":{"breadth":30,"depth":6,"hypotheses":["Primary records may reveal additional implementation, governance, financial, or diffusion mechanisms.","Observed continuity may be explained by local institutional design without external command."],"in_scope":["executed JobsOhio agreement","state tax-credit records","City incentive agreement","annual reports","payment ledger","job and payroll certifications","clawback terms"],"max_depth":7,"objectives":["executed JobsOhio agreement","state tax-credit records","City incentive agreement","annual reports","payment ledger","job and payroll certifications","clawback terms"],"out_of_scope":["unsupported allegations","private personal data","inference presented as fact"],"preferred_sources":["executed agreements","official correspondence","procurement files","meeting records","source repositories","official filings"],"priority":0.94,"required_dtypes":["source","person","org","relation","contract","financial-observation","event","analysis","research-pass"],"research_question":"What final JobsOhio and state agreements, City incentive terms, annual compliance reports, payments, amendments, payroll commitments, and clawback provisions supported AndHealth's 2022 and 2025 expansions?","scope_type":"recursive_depth_6","score":0.94,"seed_ids":["starintel:contract:andhealth-columbus-downtown-office-incentive-2022","starintel:financial-observation:andhealth-downtown-office-incentive-payment-2024","starintel:event:andhealth-expansion-2025-public-support","starintel:org:jobsohio"],"selection_reason":["unresolved primary-record gap","high implementation relevance","selected from Depth 5 analysis"],"status":"queued","target":"AndHealth Columbus public-development support","target_id":"starintel:investigation-target:wef-depth-6-andhealth-incentive-ledger","target_type":"recursive_documentary_investigation"},"dataset":"wef","date_added":"2026-07-26T04:05:00Z","date_updated":"2026-07-26T04:05:00Z","dtype":"investigation-target","evidence":[],"lineage":{"derived_from":["starintel:analysis:wef-columbus-depth-5-policy-contract-implementation"],"generation":6},"provenance":{"agent":"GPT-5.6 Thinking","method":"Primary-source recursive OSINT with bounded inference","run_id":"wef-columbus-depth-5-2026-07-26","skill":"auto-dig;web-research;create-starintel-documents;select-recursive-targets"},"schema_version":"0.9.0","sources":[{"accessed_at":"2026-07-26T04:05:00Z","credibility":0.98,"kind":"research_packet","publisher":"StarIntel GPT Auto-Dig","title":"WEF–Columbus Depth 4 governance and replication analysis","uri":"https://github.com/lost-rob0t/starintel-gpt-auto-dig/blob/main/digs/wef-columbus/2026-07-25-depth-4-analysis/starintel-documents.jsonl","url":"https://github.com/lost-rob0t/starintel-gpt-auto-dig/blob/main/digs/wef-columbus/2026-07-25-depth-4-analysis/starintel-documents.jsonl"}],"summary":"Depth 6 recursive target emitted from the completed WEF dataset Depth 5 pass.","tags":["wef","columbus","recursive-research","depth-6"],"title":"AndHealth public-assistance and incentive ledger","verification":{"status":"queued","verified":false},"version":1,"workflow":{"max_depth":7,"next_action":"collect and normalize primary records","priority":0.94,"queue":"wef-depth-6","recursion_depth":6,"research_status":"queued","root_target_id":"starintel:org:city-of-columbus","selected_from":["starintel:contract:andhealth-columbus-downtown-office-incentive-2022","starintel:financial-observation:andhealth-downtown-office-incentive-payment-2024","starintel:event:andhealth-expansion-2025-public-support","starintel:org:jobsohio"],"selection_reason":["recursive expansion from completed Depth 5 pass"]}}
{"_id":"starintel:investigation-target:wef-depth-6-central-ohio-living-lab-projects","assessment":{"confidence":0.94},"data":{"breadth":30,"depth":6,"hypotheses":["Primary records may reveal additional implementation, governance, financial, or diffusion mechanisms.","Observed continuity may be explained by local institutional design without external command."],"in_scope":["project charters","partner agreements","budgets","vendor lists","test plans","data-governance agreements","safety reviews","results","follow-on procurement"],"max_depth":7,"objectives":["project charters","partner agreements","budgets","vendor lists","test plans","data-governance agreements","safety reviews","results","follow-on procurement"],"out_of_scope":["unsupported allegations","private personal data","inference presented as fact"],"preferred_sources":["executed agreements","official correspondence","procurement files","meeting records","source repositories","official filings"],"priority":0.94,"required_dtypes":["source","person","org","relation","contract","financial-observation","event","analysis","research-pass"],"research_question":"What are the six Living Lab projects, participating vendors, public and private funding, test locations, data-sharing terms, safety review, evaluation metrics, outcomes, and procurement consequences?","scope_type":"recursive_depth_6","score":0.94,"seed_ids":["starintel:event:central-ohio-living-lab-launch-2025","starintel:org:smart-columbus","starintel:org:honda"],"selection_reason":["unresolved primary-record gap","high implementation relevance","selected from Depth 5 analysis"],"status":"queued","target":"Central Ohio Living Lab","target_id":"starintel:investigation-target:wef-depth-6-central-ohio-living-lab-projects","target_type":"recursive_documentary_investigation"},"dataset":"wef","date_added":"2026-07-26T04:05:00Z","date_updated":"2026-07-26T04:05:00Z","dtype":"investigation-target","evidence":[],"lineage":{"derived_from":["starintel:analysis:wef-columbus-depth-5-policy-contract-implementation"],"generation":6},"provenance":{"agent":"GPT-5.6 Thinking","method":"Primary-source recursive OSINT with bounded inference","run_id":"wef-columbus-depth-5-2026-07-26","skill":"auto-dig;web-research;create-starintel-documents;select-recursive-targets"},"schema_version":"0.9.0","sources":[{"accessed_at":"2026-07-26T04:05:00Z","credibility":0.98,"kind":"research_packet","publisher":"StarIntel GPT Auto-Dig","title":"WEF–Columbus Depth 4 governance and replication analysis","uri":"https://github.com/lost-rob0t/starintel-gpt-auto-dig/blob/main/digs/wef-columbus/2026-07-25-depth-4-analysis/starintel-documents.jsonl","url":"https://github.com/lost-rob0t/starintel-gpt-auto-dig/blob/main/digs/wef-columbus/2026-07-25-depth-4-analysis/starintel-documents.jsonl"}],"summary":"Depth 6 recursive target emitted from the completed WEF dataset Depth 5 pass.","tags":["wef","columbus","recursive-research","depth-6"],"title":"Central Ohio Living Lab project and data-governance files","verification":{"status":"queued","verified":false},"version":1,"workflow":{"max_depth":7,"next_action":"collect and normalize primary records","priority":0.94,"queue":"wef-depth-6","recursion_depth":6,"research_status":"queued","root_target_id":"starintel:org:city-of-columbus","selected_from":["starintel:event:central-ohio-living-lab-launch-2025","starintel:org:smart-columbus","starintel:org:honda"],"selection_reason":["recursive expansion from completed Depth 5 pass"]}}
{"_id":"starintel:investigation-target:wef-depth-6-global-shapers-columbus-status","assessment":{"confidence":0.94},"data":{"breadth":30,"depth":6,"hypotheses":["Primary records may reveal additional implementation, governance, financial, or diffusion mechanisms.","Observed continuity may be explained by local institutional design without external command."],"in_scope":["official hub record","launch records","rosters","project pages","sponsors","partner organizations","cross-hub activity","status history"],"max_depth":7,"objectives":["official hub record","launch records","rosters","project pages","sponsors","partner organizations","cross-hub activity","status history"],"out_of_scope":["unsupported allegations","private personal data","inference presented as fact"],"preferred_sources":["official Global Shapers records","archived official pages","public organizational filings","event programs","official biographies"],"priority":0.94,"required_dtypes":["source","person","org","relation","contract","financial-observation","event","analysis","research-pass"],"research_question":"Was a Columbus Global Shapers hub formally launched, active, paused, or dissolved; who served in it; what projects, sponsors, partner organizations, and cross-hub relationships existed?","scope_type":"recursive_depth_6","score":0.94,"seed_ids":["starintel:org:world-economic-forum","starintel:org:city-of-columbus"],"selection_reason":["unresolved primary-record gap","high implementation relevance","selected from Depth 5 analysis"],"status":"queued","target":"Global Shapers activity in Columbus","target_id":"starintel:investigation-target:wef-depth-6-global-shapers-columbus-status","target_type":"recursive_documentary_investigation"},"dataset":"wef","date_added":"2026-07-26T04:05:00Z","date_updated":"2026-07-26T04:05:00Z","dtype":"investigation-target","evidence":[],"lineage":{"derived_from":["starintel:analysis:wef-columbus-depth-5-policy-contract-implementation"],"generation":6},"provenance":{"agent":"GPT-5.6 Thinking","method":"Primary-source recursive OSINT with bounded inference","run_id":"wef-columbus-depth-5-2026-07-26","skill":"auto-dig;web-research;create-starintel-documents;select-recursive-targets"},"schema_version":"0.9.0","sources":[{"accessed_at":"2026-07-26T04:05:00Z","credibility":0.98,"kind":"research_packet","publisher":"StarIntel GPT Auto-Dig","title":"WEF–Columbus Depth 4 governance and replication analysis","uri":"https://github.com/lost-rob0t/starintel-gpt-auto-dig/blob/main/digs/wef-columbus/2026-07-25-depth-4-analysis/starintel-documents.jsonl","url":"https://github.com/lost-rob0t/starintel-gpt-auto-dig/blob/main/digs/wef-columbus/2026-07-25-depth-4-analysis/starintel-documents.jsonl"}],"summary":"Depth 6 recursive target emitted from the completed WEF dataset Depth 5 pass.","tags":["wef","columbus","recursive-research","depth-6"],"title":"Global Shapers Columbus hub status and network","verification":{"status":"queued","verified":false},"version":1,"workflow":{"max_depth":7,"next_action":"collect and normalize primary records","priority":0.94,"queue":"wef-depth-6","recursion_depth":6,"research_status":"queued","root_target_id":"starintel:org:city-of-columbus","selected_from":["starintel:org:world-economic-forum","starintel:org:city-of-columbus"],"selection_reason":["recursive expansion from completed Depth 5 pass"]}}
{"_id":"starintel:investigation-target:wef-depth-6-green-it-working-group","assessment":{"confidence":0.94},"data":{"breadth":30,"depth":6,"hypotheses":["Primary records may reveal additional implementation, governance, financial, or diffusion mechanisms.","Observed continuity may be explained by local institutional design without external command."],"in_scope":["working-group roster","meeting agendas and minutes","draft history","baseline submissions","adoption attestations","vendor-selection policies","governance changes"],"max_depth":7,"objectives":["working-group roster","meeting agendas and minutes","draft history","baseline submissions","adoption attestations","vendor-selection policies","governance changes"],"out_of_scope":["unsupported allegations","private personal data","inference presented as fact"],"preferred_sources":["executed agreements","official correspondence","procurement files","meeting records","source repositories","official filings"],"priority":0.94,"required_dtypes":["source","person","org","relation","contract","financial-observation","event","analysis","research-pass"],"research_question":"Who participated in the Green IT Working Group, what baseline data and drafts were exchanged, which organizations adopted each practice, and how did the guidance enter vendor selection and technology governance?","scope_type":"recursive_depth_6","score":0.94,"seed_ids":["starintel:media:columbus-green-it-playbook-2-0-2025","starintel:org:smart-columbus","starintel:org:rackspace-technology","starintel:org:bread-financial"],"selection_reason":["unresolved primary-record gap","high implementation relevance","selected from Depth 5 analysis"],"status":"queued","target":"Columbus Green IT Playbook development and adoption","target_id":"starintel:investigation-target:wef-depth-6-green-it-working-group","target_type":"recursive_documentary_investigation"},"dataset":"wef","date_added":"2026-07-26T04:05:00Z","date_updated":"2026-07-26T04:05:00Z","dtype":"investigation-target","evidence":[],"lineage":{"derived_from":["starintel:analysis:wef-columbus-depth-5-policy-contract-implementation"],"generation":6},"provenance":{"agent":"GPT-5.6 Thinking","method":"Primary-source recursive OSINT with bounded inference","run_id":"wef-columbus-depth-5-2026-07-26","skill":"auto-dig;web-research;create-starintel-documents;select-recursive-targets"},"schema_version":"0.9.0","sources":[{"accessed_at":"2026-07-26T04:05:00Z","credibility":0.98,"kind":"research_packet","publisher":"StarIntel GPT Auto-Dig","title":"WEF–Columbus Depth 4 governance and replication analysis","uri":"https://github.com/lost-rob0t/starintel-gpt-auto-dig/blob/main/digs/wef-columbus/2026-07-25-depth-4-analysis/starintel-documents.jsonl","url":"https://github.com/lost-rob0t/starintel-gpt-auto-dig/blob/main/digs/wef-columbus/2026-07-25-depth-4-analysis/starintel-documents.jsonl"}],"summary":"Depth 6 recursive target emitted from the completed WEF dataset Depth 5 pass.","tags":["wef","columbus","recursive-research","depth-6"],"title":"Green IT Working Group roster, process, and adoption","verification":{"status":"queued","verified":false},"version":1,"workflow":{"max_depth":7,"next_action":"collect and normalize primary records","priority":0.94,"queue":"wef-depth-6","recursion_depth":6,"research_status":"queued","root_target_id":"starintel:org:city-of-columbus","selected_from":["starintel:media:columbus-green-it-playbook-2-0-2025","starintel:org:smart-columbus","starintel:org:rackspace-technology","starintel:org:bread-financial"],"selection_reason":["recursive expansion from completed Depth 5 pass"]}}
{"_id":"starintel:investigation-target:wef-depth-6-hntb-smart-lighting-procurement-records","assessment":{"confidence":0.94},"data":{"breadth":30,"depth":6,"hypotheses":["Primary records may reveal additional implementation, governance, financial, or diffusion mechanisms.","Observed continuity may be explained by local institutional design without external command."],"in_scope":["executed modification","statement of work","utilization plan","subconsultant agreements","product scorecards","pilot reports","purchase orders","invoices"],"max_depth":7,"objectives":["executed modification","statement of work","utilization plan","subconsultant agreements","product scorecards","pilot reports","purchase orders","invoices"],"out_of_scope":["unsupported allegations","private personal data","inference presented as fact"],"preferred_sources":["executed agreements","official correspondence","procurement files","meeting records","source repositories","official filings"],"priority":0.94,"required_dtypes":["source","person","org","relation","contract","financial-observation","event","analysis","research-pass"],"research_question":"Which procurement documents, products, pilot evaluations, scores, subconsultant scopes, workshare percentages, invoices, and purchase decisions resulted from HNTB's Phase 4 work?","scope_type":"recursive_depth_6","score":0.94,"seed_ids":["starintel:event:hntb-smart-lighting-phase-4-modification-2026","starintel:contract:hntb-smart-lighting-phase-4-lifecycle-2022-2026","starintel:org:emh-and-t-inc","starintel:org:barr-engineering"],"selection_reason":["unresolved primary-record gap","high implementation relevance","selected from Depth 5 analysis"],"status":"queued","target":"HNTB Smart Lighting Phase 4 procurement chain","target_id":"starintel:investigation-target:wef-depth-6-hntb-smart-lighting-procurement-records","target_type":"recursive_documentary_investigation"},"dataset":"wef","date_added":"2026-07-26T04:05:00Z","date_updated":"2026-07-26T04:05:00Z","dtype":"investigation-target","evidence":[],"lineage":{"derived_from":["starintel:analysis:wef-columbus-depth-5-policy-contract-implementation"],"generation":6},"provenance":{"agent":"GPT-5.6 Thinking","method":"Primary-source recursive OSINT with bounded inference","run_id":"wef-columbus-depth-5-2026-07-26","skill":"auto-dig;web-research;create-starintel-documents;select-recursive-targets"},"schema_version":"0.9.0","sources":[{"accessed_at":"2026-07-26T04:05:00Z","credibility":0.98,"kind":"research_packet","publisher":"StarIntel GPT Auto-Dig","title":"WEF–Columbus Depth 4 governance and replication analysis","uri":"https://github.com/lost-rob0t/starintel-gpt-auto-dig/blob/main/digs/wef-columbus/2026-07-25-depth-4-analysis/starintel-documents.jsonl","url":"https://github.com/lost-rob0t/starintel-gpt-auto-dig/blob/main/digs/wef-columbus/2026-07-25-depth-4-analysis/starintel-documents.jsonl"}],"summary":"Depth 6 recursive target emitted from the completed WEF dataset Depth 5 pass.","tags":["wef","columbus","recursive-research","depth-6"],"title":"HNTB Smart Lighting procurement, product, and subconsultant records","verification":{"status":"queued","verified":false},"version":1,"workflow":{"max_depth":7,"next_action":"collect and normalize primary records","priority":0.94,"queue":"wef-depth-6","recursion_depth":6,"research_status":"queued","root_target_id":"starintel:org:city-of-columbus","selected_from":["starintel:event:hntb-smart-lighting-phase-4-modification-2026","starintel:contract:hntb-smart-lighting-phase-4-lifecycle-2022-2026","starintel:org:emh-and-t-inc","starintel:org:barr-engineering"],"selection_reason":["recursive expansion from completed Depth 5 pass"]}}
{"_id":"starintel:investigation-target:wef-depth-6-smart-columbus-staff-project-map","assessment":{"confidence":0.94},"data":{"breadth":30,"depth":6,"hypotheses":["Primary records may reveal additional implementation, governance, financial, or diffusion mechanisms.","Observed continuity may be explained by local institutional design without external command."],"in_scope":["staff biographies","project charters","scopes of work","grant applications","board reports","vendor correspondence","conference programs","external task-force records"],"max_depth":7,"objectives":["staff biographies","project charters","scopes of work","grant applications","board reports","vendor correspondence","conference programs","external task-force records"],"out_of_scope":["unsupported allegations","private personal data","inference presented as fact"],"preferred_sources":["executed agreements","official correspondence","procurement files","meeting records","source repositories","official filings"],"priority":0.94,"required_dtypes":["source","person","org","relation","contract","financial-observation","event","analysis","research-pass"],"research_question":"Which current and former staff owned each project, grant, contract, vendor relationship, dataset, policy deliverable, board workstream, and external network role?","scope_type":"recursive_depth_6","score":0.94,"seed_ids":["starintel:investigation-target:wef-columbus-depth-5-smart-columbus-team-project-map","starintel:org:smart-columbus"],"selection_reason":["unresolved primary-record gap","high implementation relevance","selected from Depth 5 analysis"],"status":"queued","target":"Smart Columbus delivery responsibility network","target_id":"starintel:investigation-target:wef-depth-6-smart-columbus-staff-project-map","target_type":"recursive_documentary_investigation"},"dataset":"wef","date_added":"2026-07-26T04:05:00Z","date_updated":"2026-07-26T04:05:00Z","dtype":"investigation-target","evidence":[],"lineage":{"derived_from":["starintel:analysis:wef-columbus-depth-5-policy-contract-implementation"],"generation":6},"provenance":{"agent":"GPT-5.6 Thinking","method":"Primary-source recursive OSINT with bounded inference","run_id":"wef-columbus-depth-5-2026-07-26","skill":"auto-dig;web-research;create-starintel-documents;select-recursive-targets"},"schema_version":"0.9.0","sources":[{"accessed_at":"2026-07-26T04:05:00Z","credibility":0.98,"kind":"research_packet","publisher":"StarIntel GPT Auto-Dig","title":"WEF–Columbus Depth 4 governance and replication analysis","uri":"https://github.com/lost-rob0t/starintel-gpt-auto-dig/blob/main/digs/wef-columbus/2026-07-25-depth-4-analysis/starintel-documents.jsonl","url":"https://github.com/lost-rob0t/starintel-gpt-auto-dig/blob/main/digs/wef-columbus/2026-07-25-depth-4-analysis/starintel-documents.jsonl"}],"summary":"Depth 6 recursive target emitted from the completed WEF dataset Depth 5 pass.","tags":["wef","columbus","recursive-research","depth-6"],"title":"Smart Columbus staff-to-project, contract, and vendor map","verification":{"status":"queued","verified":false},"version":1,"workflow":{"max_depth":7,"next_action":"collect and normalize primary records","priority":0.94,"queue":"wef-depth-6","recursion_depth":6,"research_status":"queued","root_target_id":"starintel:org:city-of-columbus","selected_from":["starintel:investigation-target:wef-columbus-depth-5-smart-columbus-team-project-map","starintel:org:smart-columbus"],"selection_reason":["recursive expansion from completed Depth 5 pass"]}}
{"_id":"starintel:investigation-target:wef-depth-6-urbanos-reuse-lineage","assessment":{"confidence":0.94},"data":{"breadth":30,"depth":6,"hypotheses":["Primary records may reveal additional implementation, governance, financial, or diffusion mechanisms.","Observed continuity may be explained by local institutional design without external command."],"in_scope":["repository inventory","commit history","fork graph","license history","deployment manifests","city references","vendor reuse","archived documentation"],"max_depth":7,"objectives":["repository inventory","commit history","fork graph","license history","deployment manifests","city references","vendor reuse","archived documentation"],"out_of_scope":["unsupported allegations","private personal data","inference presented as fact"],"preferred_sources":["executed agreements","official correspondence","procurement files","meeting records","source repositories","official filings"],"priority":0.94,"required_dtypes":["source","person","org","relation","contract","financial-observation","event","analysis","research-pass"],"research_question":"Which UrbanOS and Smart Columbus repositories were transferred, forked, deployed, maintained, licensed, or reused by other cities, vendors, universities, or WEF-linked networks?","scope_type":"recursive_depth_6","score":0.94,"seed_ids":["starintel:product:urbanos-smart-cities-data-platform","starintel:org:urbanos-public","starintel:source:smart-columbus-grant-era-reports-index"],"selection_reason":["unresolved primary-record gap","high implementation relevance","selected from Depth 5 analysis"],"status":"queued","target":"Smart City Challenge open-source technical reuse","target_id":"starintel:investigation-target:wef-depth-6-urbanos-reuse-lineage","target_type":"recursive_documentary_investigation"},"dataset":"wef","date_added":"2026-07-26T04:05:00Z","date_updated":"2026-07-26T04:05:00Z","dtype":"investigation-target","evidence":[],"lineage":{"derived_from":["starintel:analysis:wef-columbus-depth-5-policy-contract-implementation"],"generation":6},"provenance":{"agent":"GPT-5.6 Thinking","method":"Primary-source recursive OSINT with bounded inference","run_id":"wef-columbus-depth-5-2026-07-26","skill":"auto-dig;web-research;create-starintel-documents;select-recursive-targets"},"schema_version":"0.9.0","sources":[{"accessed_at":"2026-07-26T04:05:00Z","credibility":0.98,"kind":"research_packet","publisher":"StarIntel GPT Auto-Dig","title":"WEF–Columbus Depth 4 governance and replication analysis","uri":"https://github.com/lost-rob0t/starintel-gpt-auto-dig/blob/main/digs/wef-columbus/2026-07-25-depth-4-analysis/starintel-documents.jsonl","url":"https://github.com/lost-rob0t/starintel-gpt-auto-dig/blob/main/digs/wef-columbus/2026-07-25-depth-4-analysis/starintel-documents.jsonl"}],"summary":"Depth 6 recursive target emitted from the completed WEF dataset Depth 5 pass.","tags":["wef","columbus","recursive-research","depth-6"],"title":"UrbanOS code, fork, deployment, and reuse lineage","verification":{"status":"queued","verified":false},"version":1,"workflow":{"max_depth":7,"next_action":"collect and normalize primary records","priority":0.94,"queue":"wef-depth-6","recursion_depth":6,"research_status":"queued","root_target_id":"starintel:org:city-of-columbus","selected_from":["starintel:product:urbanos-smart-cities-data-platform","starintel:org:urbanos-public","starintel:source:smart-columbus-grant-era-reports-index"],"selection_reason":["recursive expansion from completed Depth 5 pass"]}}
{"_id":"starintel:investigation-target:wef-depth-6-wef-columbus-agreements","assessment":{"confidence":0.98},"data":{"breadth":30,"depth":6,"hypotheses":["Primary records may reveal additional implementation, governance, financial, or diffusion mechanisms.","Observed continuity may be explained by local institutional design without external command."],"in_scope":["agreements","membership records","dues and sponsorships","invoices","travel expenses","correspondence","task-force drafts","meeting records","deliverables","policy citations"],"max_depth":7,"objectives":["agreements","membership records","dues and sponsorships","invoices","travel expenses","correspondence","task-force drafts","meeting records","deliverables","policy citations"],"out_of_scope":["unsupported allegations","private personal data","inference presented as fact"],"preferred_sources":["executed agreements","official correspondence","procurement files","meeting records","source repositories","official filings"],"priority":0.98,"required_dtypes":["source","person","org","relation","contract","financial-observation","event","analysis","research-pass"],"research_question":"Who authorized the WEF City of Columbus profile and task-force participation, and what agreements, dues, sponsorships, invoices, travel, correspondence, drafts, meetings, deliverables, or policy references exist?","scope_type":"recursive_depth_6","score":0.98,"seed_ids":["starintel:relation:city-of-columbus-wef-urban-transformation","starintel:event:wef-infrastructure-roadmap-2024","starintel:person:jordan-davis","starintel:org:world-economic-forum"],"selection_reason":["unresolved primary-record gap","high implementation relevance","selected from Depth 5 analysis"],"status":"queued","target":"Formal WEF–Columbus relationship records","target_id":"starintel:investigation-target:wef-depth-6-wef-columbus-agreements","target_type":"recursive_documentary_investigation"},"dataset":"wef","date_added":"2026-07-26T04:05:00Z","date_updated":"2026-07-26T04:05:00Z","dtype":"investigation-target","evidence":[],"lineage":{"derived_from":["starintel:analysis:wef-columbus-depth-5-policy-contract-implementation"],"generation":6},"provenance":{"agent":"GPT-5.6 Thinking","method":"Primary-source recursive OSINT with bounded inference","run_id":"wef-columbus-depth-5-2026-07-26","skill":"auto-dig;web-research;create-starintel-documents;select-recursive-targets"},"schema_version":"0.9.0","sources":[{"accessed_at":"2026-07-26T04:05:00Z","credibility":0.98,"kind":"research_packet","publisher":"StarIntel GPT Auto-Dig","title":"WEF–Columbus Depth 4 governance and replication analysis","uri":"https://github.com/lost-rob0t/starintel-gpt-auto-dig/blob/main/digs/wef-columbus/2026-07-25-depth-4-analysis/starintel-documents.jsonl","url":"https://github.com/lost-rob0t/starintel-gpt-auto-dig/blob/main/digs/wef-columbus/2026-07-25-depth-4-analysis/starintel-documents.jsonl"}],"summary":"Depth 6 recursive target emitted from the completed WEF dataset Depth 5 pass.","tags":["wef","columbus","recursive-research","depth-6"],"title":"WEF–Columbus agreements, correspondence, expenses, and deliverables","verification":{"status":"queued","verified":false},"version":1,"workflow":{"max_depth":7,"next_action":"collect and normalize primary records","priority":0.98,"queue":"wef-depth-6","recursion_depth":6,"research_status":"queued","root_target_id":"starintel:org:city-of-columbus","selected_from":["starintel:relation:city-of-columbus-wef-urban-transformation","starintel:event:wef-infrastructure-roadmap-2024","starintel:person:jordan-davis","starintel:org:world-economic-forum"],"selection_reason":["recursive expansion from completed Depth 5 pass"]}}
{"_id":"starintel:media:columbus-green-it-playbook-2-0-2025","assessment":{"confidence":0.99},"data":{"creator_ids":["starintel:org:smart-columbus","starintel:org:rackspace-technology","starintel:person:ben-blanquera","starintel:person:marcus-carano"],"media_type":"policy_playbook","published_at":"2025-12-18T00:00:00Z","publisher_id":"starintel:org:smart-columbus","title":"Columbus Green IT Playbook 2.0","uri":"https://smartcolumbus.com/insights/2025-10-cie-vendor-announcement-83p85"},"dataset":"wef","date_added":"2026-07-26T04:05:00Z","date_updated":"2026-07-26T04:05:00Z","dtype":"media","evidence":[],"lineage":{"derived_from":["starintel:analysis:wef-columbus-depth-4-governance-replication-continuity"],"generation":5},"provenance":{"agent":"GPT-5.6 Thinking","method":"Primary-source recursive OSINT with bounded inference","run_id":"wef-columbus-depth-5-2026-07-26","skill":"auto-dig;web-research;create-starintel-documents;select-recursive-targets"},"schema_version":"0.9.0","sources":[{"accessed_at":"2026-07-26T04:05:00Z","credibility":0.95,"kind":"official_webpage","publisher":"Smart Columbus","title":"Columbus leads the way: Evolving our Green IT ambition","uri":"https://smartcolumbus.com/insights/2025-10-cie-vendor-announcement-83p85","url":"https://smartcolumbus.com/insights/2025-10-cie-vendor-announcement-83p85"},{"accessed_at":"2026-07-26T04:05:00Z","credibility":0.95,"kind":"official_webpage","publisher":"Smart Columbus","title":"A year of impact: 2025 by the numbers","uri":"https://smartcolumbus.com/insights/2025-12-year-of-impact","url":"https://smartcolumbus.com/insights/2025-12-year-of-impact"}],"summary":"A 2025 operational playbook co-authored by Smart Columbus and Rackspace, informed by more than 100 local technology leaders and organized around 14 sustainable-technology practices.","tags":["wef","columbus","recursive-research","depth-5"],"title":"Columbus Green IT Playbook 2.0","verification":{"status":"source-backed","verified":true},"version":1,"workflow":{"max_depth":6,"recursion_depth":5,"research_status":"completed","root_target_id":"starintel:org:city-of-columbus"}}
{"_id":"starintel:observation:columbus-partnership-c6-schedule-l-2024","assessment":{"caveats":["A Schedule L disclosure is not evidence of fraud or an improper transaction.","The detailed Schedule L entries remain an open records target."],"confidence":0.96},"data":{"instrument":"Form 990 Schedule L indicator","method":"Review of IRS-derived Form 990 summary and filing index","observation_type":"form_990_schedule_l_disclosure","observed_at":"2024-12-31T00:00:00Z","observer_id":"starintel:source:columbus-partnership-c6-form990-2024","subject_id":"starintel:org:columbus-partnership-c6","value":{"details_resolved":false,"reported_interested_person_transactions":true}},"dataset":"starintel-wef-columbus-depth-4-2026-07-25","date_added":"2026-07-25T21:15:00Z","date_updated":"2026-07-25T21:15:00Z","dtype":"observation","evidence":[],"lineage":{"derived_from":["starintel:research-pass:wef-columbus-depth-3-2026-07-25"],"generation":4},"provenance":{"agent":"GPT-5.6 Thinking","run_id":"wef-columbus-depth-4-2026-07-25","skill":"auto-dig;search-starintel-json-db;create-starintel-documents;select-recursive-targets"},"schema_version":"0.9.0","sources":[{"accessed_at":"2026-07-25T21:15:00Z","credibility":0.95,"kind":"irs_derived_filing","publisher":"ProPublica Nonprofit Explorer","title":"Columbus Partnership Form 990 — fiscal year 2024","uri":"https://projects.propublica.org/nonprofits/organizations/352558300","url":"https://projects.propublica.org/nonprofits/organizations/352558300"}],"summary":"Nonprofit Explorer flags the 501(c)(6) filing as reporting transactions with interested persons. The specific transaction details were not resolved in the rendered filing during this pass.","tags":["wef-columbus","recursive-research","depth-4"],"title":"Columbus Partnership reported Schedule L transactions in 2024 filing","verification":{"status":"source-backed","verified":true},"version":1,"workflow":{"max_depth":6,"recursion_depth":4,"research_status":"completed","root_target_id":"starintel:org:city-of-columbus"}}
{"_id":"starintel:observation:smart-columbus-project-continuation-and-replication","assessment":{"confidence":0.98},"data":{"instrument":"official final report","method":"Review of June 2021 City program summary","observation_type":"program_continuation_and_replication","observed_at":"2021-06-01T00:00:00Z","observer_id":"starintel:org:city-of-columbus","subject_id":"starintel:org:smart-columbus","value":{"continued_projects":5,"replication_mechanisms":["open-source software","technical documentation","deployment playbooks"],"total_projects":8}},"dataset":"starintel-wef-columbus-depth-4-2026-07-25","date_added":"2026-07-25T21:15:00Z","date_updated":"2026-07-25T21:15:00Z","dtype":"observation","evidence":[],"lineage":{"derived_from":["starintel:research-pass:wef-columbus-depth-3-2026-07-25"],"generation":4},"provenance":{"agent":"GPT-5.6 Thinking","run_id":"wef-columbus-depth-4-2026-07-25","skill":"auto-dig;search-starintel-json-db;create-starintel-documents;select-recursive-targets"},"schema_version":"0.9.0","sources":[{"accessed_at":"2026-07-25T21:15:00Z","credibility":0.95,"kind":"government_report","publisher":"City of Columbus","title":"Smart Columbus Program Summary — June 2021","uri":"https://static1.squarespace.com/static/6543abac601e3621dd3fe76d/t/68b832df3dd5017d3a1c12e2/1756902111728/2021-06%2BUSDOT%2BFinal%2BReport%2BExecutive%2BSummary%2B%281%29-compressed-compressed.pdf","url":"https://static1.squarespace.com/static/6543abac601e3621dd3fe76d/t/68b832df3dd5017d3a1c12e2/1756902111728/2021-06%2BUSDOT%2BFinal%2BReport%2BExecutive%2BSummary%2B%281%29-compressed-compressed.pdf"}],"summary":"The 2021 program summary states that five of eight projects continued after grant funding and that open-source software, technical documentation, and deployment playbooks were intended for reuse by other cities and agencies.","tags":["wef-columbus","recursive-research","depth-4"],"title":"Smart Columbus projects continued and were designed for replication","verification":{"status":"source-backed","verified":true},"version":1,"workflow":{"max_depth":6,"recursion_depth":4,"research_status":"completed","root_target_id":"starintel:org:city-of-columbus"}}
{"_id":"starintel:org:accenture","assessment":{"confidence":0.94},"data":{"name":"Accenture","org_type":"consulting_firm"},"dataset":"starintel-wef-columbus-depth-3-2026-07-25","date_added":"2026-07-25T20:30:00Z","date_updated":"2026-07-25T20:30:00Z","dtype":"org","evidence":[],"lineage":{"derived_from":["starintel:research-pass:wef-columbus-depth-2-2026-07-25"],"generation":3},"provenance":{"agent":"GPT-5.6 Thinking","run_id":"wef-columbus-depth-3-2026-07-25","skill":"auto-dig;create-starintel-documents;select-recursive-targets"},"schema_version":"0.9.0","sources":[{"accessed_at":"2026-07-25T20:30:00Z","credibility":0.95,"kind":"government_record","publisher":"City of Columbus","title":"Accenture","uri":"https://columbus.legistar.com/LegislationDetail.aspx?FullText=1&GUID=25689AF7-E15D-4218-8726-CFE46FC368ED&ID=3910766","url":"https://columbus.legistar.com/LegislationDetail.aspx?FullText=1&GUID=25689AF7-E15D-4218-8726-CFE46FC368ED&ID=3910766"}],"summary":"Acquired Pillar Technology Group and inherited Smart City Challenge contracts.","tags":["wef-columbus","recursive-research","depth-3"],"title":"Accenture","verification":{"status":"source-backed","verified":true},"version":1,"workflow":{"max_depth":6,"recursion_depth":3,"research_status":"completed","root_target_id":"starintel:org:city-of-columbus"}}
{"_id":"starintel:org:barr-engineering","assessment":{"confidence":0.95},"data":{"name":"Barr Engineering","org_type":"engineering_firm"},"dataset":"starintel-wef-columbus-depth-4-2026-07-25","date_added":"2026-07-25T21:15:00Z","date_updated":"2026-07-25T21:15:00Z","dtype":"org","evidence":[],"lineage":{"derived_from":["starintel:research-pass:wef-columbus-depth-3-2026-07-25"],"generation":4},"provenance":{"agent":"GPT-5.6 Thinking","run_id":"wef-columbus-depth-4-2026-07-25","skill":"auto-dig;search-starintel-json-db;create-starintel-documents;select-recursive-targets"},"schema_version":"0.9.0","sources":[{"accessed_at":"2026-07-25T21:15:00Z","credibility":0.95,"kind":"government_record","publisher":"City of Columbus","title":"Columbus Ordinance 1424-2026","uri":"https://columbus.legistar.com/LegislationDetail.aspx?FullText=1&GUID=50C99EDC-6138-41FC-A7E1-8672080626A3&ID=8038904","url":"https://columbus.legistar.com/LegislationDetail.aspx?FullText=1&GUID=50C99EDC-6138-41FC-A7E1-8672080626A3&ID=8038904"}],"summary":"Engineering subconsultant identified on HNTB's 2026 Smart Lighting modification.","tags":["wef-columbus","recursive-research","depth-4"],"title":"Barr Engineering","verification":{"status":"source-backed","verified":true},"version":1,"workflow":{"max_depth":6,"recursion_depth":4,"research_status":"completed","root_target_id":"starintel:org:city-of-columbus"}}
{"_id":"starintel:org:bread-financial","assessment":{"confidence":0.97},"data":{"industry":"consumer financial services","name":"Bread Financial","org_type":"financial_services","website":"https://www.breadfinancial.com/"},"dataset":"wef","date_added":"2026-07-26T04:05:00Z","date_updated":"2026-07-26T04:05:00Z","dtype":"org","evidence":[],"lineage":{"derived_from":["starintel:analysis:wef-columbus-depth-4-governance-replication-continuity"],"generation":5},"provenance":{"agent":"GPT-5.6 Thinking","method":"Primary-source recursive OSINT with bounded inference","run_id":"wef-columbus-depth-5-2026-07-26","skill":"auto-dig;web-research;create-starintel-documents;select-recursive-targets"},"schema_version":"0.9.0","sources":[{"accessed_at":"2026-07-26T04:05:00Z","credibility":0.95,"kind":"official_webpage","publisher":"Smart Columbus","title":"A year of impact: 2025 by the numbers","uri":"https://smartcolumbus.com/insights/2025-12-year-of-impact","url":"https://smartcolumbus.com/insights/2025-12-year-of-impact"}],"summary":"Financial-services company recognized by Smart Columbus for implementing the Green IT Playbook through a Sustainable Technology Framework.","tags":["wef","columbus","recursive-research","depth-5"],"title":"Bread Financial","verification":{"status":"source-backed","verified":true},"version":1,"workflow":{"max_depth":6,"recursion_depth":5,"research_status":"completed","root_target_id":"starintel:org:city-of-columbus"}}
{"_id":"starintel:org:city-of-columbus","aliases":[],"assessment":{"confidence":0.98},"attachments":[],"data":{"jurisdiction":"Columbus, Ohio","name":"City of Columbus"},"dataset":"starintel-wef-columbus-urban-transformation-2026-07-25","date_added":"2026-07-25T00:00:00Z","date_updated":"2026-07-25T00:00:00Z","description":"","dtype":"org","evidence":[],"extensions":{"legacy.v0":{"data":{"confidence":0.98}}},"geospatial":{},"handling":{"pii":false,"sensitive":false,"visibility":"public"},"identifiers":[],"keywords":[],"labels":[],"language":"en","lineage":{"migration_from":"0.8","migration_notes":["Normalized into the canonical StarIntel v0.9.0 document envelope."]},"notes":[],"provenance":{"original_id":"starintel:org:city-of-columbus","original_path":"digs/wef-columbus/2026-07-25-urban-transformation-network/starintel-documents.jsonl","original_schema_version":"0.8","software_version":"0.9.0","transform":"starintel_doc.migration.migrate_document"},"quality":{},"related_ids":[],"schema_version":"0.9.0","sources":[{"accessed_at":"2026-07-25T00:00:00Z","metadata":{"source_type":"official_organization"},"title":"City of Columbus | World Economic Forum","uri":"https://www.weforum.org/organizations/city-of-columbus/","url":"https://www.weforum.org/organizations/city-of-columbus/"},{"accessed_at":"2026-07-25T00:00:00Z","metadata":{"source_type":"government_record"},"title":"Columbus Ordinance 1663-2025","uri":"https://columbus.legistar.com/LegislationDetail.aspx?FullText=1&GUID=5E02F335-BDF8-4220-B7BB-05FE16CF6CC4&ID=7489830","url":"https://columbus.legistar.com/LegislationDetail.aspx?FullText=1&GUID=5E02F335-BDF8-4220-B7BB-05FE16CF6CC4&ID=7489830"},{"accessed_at":"2026-07-25T00:00:00Z","metadata":{"source_type":"government_record"},"title":"Columbus Ordinance 1850-2026","uri":"https://columbus.legistar.com/LegislationDetail.aspx?FullText=1&GUID=588DBFF9-D9DB-4603-B5D4-776E9F5B5A9E&ID=8117690&Options=&Search=","url":"https://columbus.legistar.com/LegislationDetail.aspx?FullText=1&GUID=588DBFF9-D9DB-4603-B5D4-776E9F5B5A9E&ID=8117690&Options=&Search="}],"status":"recorded","summary":"Municipal government with an official WEF organization profile associated with the Centre for Urban Transformation.","tags":[],"temporal":{},"title":"City of Columbus","verification":{"status":"confirmed"},"version":1,"workflow":{}}
{"_id":"starintel:org:columbus-partnership","aliases":[],"assessment":{"confidence":0.99},"attachments":[],"data":{"name":"Columbus Partnership"},"dataset":"starintel-wef-columbus-urban-transformation-2026-07-25","date_added":"2026-07-25T00:00:00Z","date_updated":"2026-07-25T00:00:00Z","description":"","dtype":"org","evidence":[],"extensions":{"legacy.v0":{"data":{"confidence":0.99}}},"geospatial":{},"handling":{"pii":false,"sensitive":false,"visibility":"public"},"identifiers":[],"keywords":[],"labels":[],"language":"en","lineage":{"migration_from":"0.8","migration_notes":["Normalized into the canonical StarIntel v0.9.0 document envelope."]},"notes":[],"provenance":{"original_id":"starintel:org:columbus-partnership","original_path":"digs/wef-columbus/2026-07-25-urban-transformation-network/starintel-documents.jsonl","original_schema_version":"0.8","software_version":"0.9.0","transform":"starintel_doc.migration.migrate_document"},"quality":{},"related_ids":[],"schema_version":"0.9.0","sources":[{"accessed_at":"2026-07-25T00:00:00Z","metadata":{"source_type":"official_organization"},"title":"About the Columbus Partnership","uri":"https://columbusregion.com/about-us/","url":"https://columbusregion.com/about-us/"},{"accessed_at":"2026-07-25T00:00:00Z","metadata":{"source_type":"official_organization"},"title":"About Smart Columbus","uri":"https://smartcolumbus.com/about","url":"https://smartcolumbus.com/about"}],"status":"recorded","summary":"CEO-led regional nonprofit that includes Smart Columbus and coordinates private, public and academic actors.","tags":[],"temporal":{},"title":"Columbus Partnership","verification":{"status":"confirmed"},"version":1,"workflow":{}}
{"_id":"starintel:org:columbus-partnership-c6","assessment":{"confidence":0.95},"data":{"name":"Columbus Partnership — 501(c)(6)","org_type":"business_league","tax_id":"35-2558300"},"dataset":"starintel-wef-columbus-depth-4-2026-07-25","date_added":"2026-07-25T21:15:00Z","date_updated":"2026-07-25T21:15:00Z","dtype":"org","evidence":[],"lineage":{"derived_from":["starintel:research-pass:wef-columbus-depth-3-2026-07-25"],"generation":4},"provenance":{"agent":"GPT-5.6 Thinking","run_id":"wef-columbus-depth-4-2026-07-25","skill":"auto-dig;search-starintel-json-db;create-starintel-documents;select-recursive-targets"},"schema_version":"0.9.0","sources":[{"accessed_at":"2026-07-25T21:15:00Z","credibility":0.95,"kind":"irs_derived_filing","publisher":"ProPublica Nonprofit Explorer","title":"Columbus Partnership Form 990 — fiscal year 2024","uri":"https://projects.propublica.org/nonprofits/organizations/352558300","url":"https://projects.propublica.org/nonprofits/organizations/352558300"}],"summary":"Business-league entity using the Columbus Partnership name; EIN 35-2558300.","tags":["wef-columbus","recursive-research","depth-4"],"title":"Columbus Partnership — 501(c)(6)","verification":{"status":"source-backed","verified":true},"version":1,"workflow":{"max_depth":6,"recursion_depth":4,"research_status":"completed","root_target_id":"starintel:org:city-of-columbus"}}
{"_id":"starintel:org:electrification-coalition","assessment":{"confidence":0.94},"data":{"name":"Electrification Coalition","org_type":"nonprofit"},"dataset":"starintel-wef-columbus-depth-3-2026-07-25","date_added":"2026-07-25T20:30:00Z","date_updated":"2026-07-25T20:30:00Z","dtype":"org","evidence":[],"lineage":{"derived_from":["starintel:research-pass:wef-columbus-depth-2-2026-07-25"],"generation":3},"provenance":{"agent":"GPT-5.6 Thinking","run_id":"wef-columbus-depth-3-2026-07-25","skill":"auto-dig;create-starintel-documents;select-recursive-targets"},"schema_version":"0.9.0","sources":[{"accessed_at":"2026-07-25T20:30:00Z","credibility":0.95,"kind":"official_webpage","publisher":"Official source","title":"Electrification Coalition","uri":"https://electrificationcoalition.org/our-team/","url":"https://electrificationcoalition.org/our-team/"},{"accessed_at":"2026-07-25T20:30:00Z","credibility":0.95,"kind":"official_webpage","publisher":"Official source","title":"Electrification Coalition","uri":"https://electrificationcoalition.org/resource/accelerate-your-city/","url":"https://electrificationcoalition.org/resource/accelerate-your-city/"}],"summary":"Strategic and technical adviser to Smart Columbus electrification and replication work.","tags":["wef-columbus","recursive-research","depth-3"],"title":"Electrification Coalition","verification":{"status":"source-backed","verified":true},"version":1,"workflow":{"max_depth":6,"recursion_depth":3,"research_status":"completed","root_target_id":"starintel:org:city-of-columbus"}}
{"_id":"starintel:org:emh-and-t-inc","assessment":{"confidence":0.95},"data":{"name":"EMH&T Inc.","org_type":"engineering_firm"},"dataset":"starintel-wef-columbus-depth-4-2026-07-25","date_added":"2026-07-25T21:15:00Z","date_updated":"2026-07-25T21:15:00Z","dtype":"org","evidence":[],"lineage":{"derived_from":["starintel:research-pass:wef-columbus-depth-3-2026-07-25"],"generation":4},"provenance":{"agent":"GPT-5.6 Thinking","run_id":"wef-columbus-depth-4-2026-07-25","skill":"auto-dig;search-starintel-json-db;create-starintel-documents;select-recursive-targets"},"schema_version":"0.9.0","sources":[{"accessed_at":"2026-07-25T21:15:00Z","credibility":0.95,"kind":"government_record","publisher":"City of Columbus","title":"Columbus Ordinance 1424-2026","uri":"https://columbus.legistar.com/LegislationDetail.aspx?FullText=1&GUID=50C99EDC-6138-41FC-A7E1-8672080626A3&ID=8038904","url":"https://columbus.legistar.com/LegislationDetail.aspx?FullText=1&GUID=50C99EDC-6138-41FC-A7E1-8672080626A3&ID=8038904"}],"summary":"Engineering subconsultant identified on HNTB's 2026 Smart Lighting modification.","tags":["wef-columbus","recursive-research","depth-4"],"title":"EMH&T Inc.","verification":{"status":"source-backed","verified":true},"version":1,"workflow":{"max_depth":6,"recursion_depth":4,"research_status":"completed","root_target_id":"starintel:org:city-of-columbus"}}
{"_id":"starintel:org:francisco-partners","assessment":{"confidence":0.94},"data":{"name":"Francisco Partners","org_type":"investment_firm"},"dataset":"starintel-wef-columbus-depth-3-2026-07-25","date_added":"2026-07-25T20:30:00Z","date_updated":"2026-07-25T20:30:00Z","dtype":"org","evidence":[],"lineage":{"derived_from":["starintel:research-pass:wef-columbus-depth-2-2026-07-25"],"generation":3},"provenance":{"agent":"GPT-5.6 Thinking","run_id":"wef-columbus-depth-3-2026-07-25","skill":"auto-dig;create-starintel-documents;select-recursive-targets"},"schema_version":"0.9.0","sources":[{"accessed_at":"2026-07-25T20:30:00Z","credibility":0.95,"kind":"official_webpage","publisher":"Official source","title":"Francisco Partners","uri":"https://andhealth.com/andhealth-digital-health-company-reversing-migraine-autoimmune-diseases-raises-57-million/","url":"https://andhealth.com/andhealth-digital-health-company-reversing-migraine-autoimmune-diseases-raises-57-million/"}],"summary":"Technology-focused investor that led AndHealth's financing round.","tags":["wef-columbus","recursive-research","depth-3"],"title":"Francisco Partners","verification":{"status":"source-backed","verified":true},"version":1,"workflow":{"max_depth":6,"recursion_depth":3,"research_status":"completed","root_target_id":"starintel:org:city-of-columbus"}}
{"_id":"starintel:org:gpd-group","assessment":{"confidence":0.94},"data":{"name":"GPD Group","org_type":"engineering_firm"},"dataset":"starintel-wef-columbus-depth-3-2026-07-25","date_added":"2026-07-25T20:30:00Z","date_updated":"2026-07-25T20:30:00Z","dtype":"org","evidence":[],"lineage":{"derived_from":["starintel:research-pass:wef-columbus-depth-2-2026-07-25"],"generation":3},"provenance":{"agent":"GPT-5.6 Thinking","run_id":"wef-columbus-depth-3-2026-07-25","skill":"auto-dig;create-starintel-documents;select-recursive-targets"},"schema_version":"0.9.0","sources":[{"accessed_at":"2026-07-25T20:30:00Z","credibility":0.95,"kind":"official_webpage","publisher":"Official source","title":"GPD Group","uri":"https://electrificationcoalition.org/resource/accelerate-your-city/","url":"https://electrificationcoalition.org/resource/accelerate-your-city/"}],"summary":"Charging-infrastructure engineering participant in Smart Columbus replication programming.","tags":["wef-columbus","recursive-research","depth-3"],"title":"GPD Group","verification":{"status":"source-backed","verified":true},"version":1,"workflow":{"max_depth":6,"recursion_depth":3,"research_status":"completed","root_target_id":"starintel:org:city-of-columbus"}}
{"_id":"starintel:org:health2047","assessment":{"confidence":0.94},"data":{"name":"Health2047 Capital Partners","org_type":"venture_capital"},"dataset":"starintel-wef-columbus-depth-3-2026-07-25","date_added":"2026-07-25T20:30:00Z","date_updated":"2026-07-25T20:30:00Z","dtype":"org","evidence":[],"lineage":{"derived_from":["starintel:research-pass:wef-columbus-depth-2-2026-07-25"],"generation":3},"provenance":{"agent":"GPT-5.6 Thinking","run_id":"wef-columbus-depth-3-2026-07-25","skill":"auto-dig;create-starintel-documents;select-recursive-targets"},"schema_version":"0.9.0","sources":[{"accessed_at":"2026-07-25T20:30:00Z","credibility":0.95,"kind":"official_webpage","publisher":"Official source","title":"Health2047 Capital Partners","uri":"https://andhealth.com/andhealth-digital-health-company-reversing-migraine-autoimmune-diseases-raises-57-million/","url":"https://andhealth.com/andhealth-digital-health-company-reversing-migraine-autoimmune-diseases-raises-57-million/"}],"summary":"American Medical Association venture arm that participated in AndHealth financing.","tags":["wef-columbus","recursive-research","depth-3"],"title":"Health2047 Capital Partners","verification":{"status":"source-backed","verified":true},"version":1,"workflow":{"max_depth":6,"recursion_depth":3,"research_status":"completed","root_target_id":"starintel:org:city-of-columbus"}}
{"_id":"starintel:org:honda","assessment":{"confidence":0.97},"data":{"industry":"automotive and mobility","name":"Honda","org_type":"corporation","website":"https://global.honda/en/"},"dataset":"wef","date_added":"2026-07-26T04:05:00Z","date_updated":"2026-07-26T04:05:00Z","dtype":"org","evidence":[],"lineage":{"derived_from":["starintel:analysis:wef-columbus-depth-4-governance-replication-continuity"],"generation":5},"provenance":{"agent":"GPT-5.6 Thinking","method":"Primary-source recursive OSINT with bounded inference","run_id":"wef-columbus-depth-5-2026-07-26","skill":"auto-dig;web-research;create-starintel-documents;select-recursive-targets"},"schema_version":"0.9.0","sources":[{"accessed_at":"2026-07-26T04:05:00Z","credibility":0.95,"kind":"official_webpage","publisher":"Smart Columbus","title":"A year of impact: 2025 by the numbers","uri":"https://smartcolumbus.com/insights/2025-12-year-of-impact","url":"https://smartcolumbus.com/insights/2025-12-year-of-impact"}],"summary":"Automotive and mobility company identified by Smart Columbus as its partner in launching the Central Ohio Living Lab.","tags":["wef","columbus","recursive-research","depth-5"],"title":"Honda","verification":{"status":"source-backed","verified":true},"version":1,"workflow":{"max_depth":6,"recursion_depth":5,"research_status":"completed","root_target_id":"starintel:org:city-of-columbus"}}
{"_id":"starintel:org:ibm-ix","assessment":{"confidence":0.94},"data":{"name":"IBM iX","org_type":"consulting_unit"},"dataset":"starintel-wef-columbus-depth-3-2026-07-25","date_added":"2026-07-25T20:30:00Z","date_updated":"2026-07-25T20:30:00Z","dtype":"org","evidence":[],"lineage":{"derived_from":["starintel:research-pass:wef-columbus-depth-2-2026-07-25"],"generation":3},"provenance":{"agent":"GPT-5.6 Thinking","run_id":"wef-columbus-depth-3-2026-07-25","skill":"auto-dig;create-starintel-documents;select-recursive-targets"},"schema_version":"0.9.0","sources":[{"accessed_at":"2026-07-25T20:30:00Z","credibility":0.95,"kind":"official_webpage","publisher":"Official source","title":"IBM iX","uri":"https://smartcolumbus.com/about","url":"https://smartcolumbus.com/about"},{"accessed_at":"2026-07-25T20:30:00Z","credibility":0.95,"kind":"official_webpage","publisher":"Official source","title":"IBM iX","uri":"https://columbusregion.com/about-us/boards-investors/smart-columbus-board/","url":"https://columbusregion.com/about-us/boards-investors/smart-columbus-board/"}],"summary":"IBM consulting and experience-design unit represented on the Smart Columbus board.","tags":["wef-columbus","recursive-research","depth-3"],"title":"IBM iX","verification":{"status":"source-backed","verified":true},"version":1,"workflow":{"max_depth":6,"recursion_depth":3,"research_status":"completed","root_target_id":"starintel:org:city-of-columbus"}}
{"_id":"starintel:org:jobsohio","assessment":{"confidence":0.95},"data":{"name":"JobsOhio","org_type":"economic_development_nonprofit"},"dataset":"starintel-wef-columbus-depth-4-2026-07-25","date_added":"2026-07-25T21:15:00Z","date_updated":"2026-07-25T21:15:00Z","dtype":"org","evidence":[],"lineage":{"derived_from":["starintel:research-pass:wef-columbus-depth-3-2026-07-25"],"generation":4},"provenance":{"agent":"GPT-5.6 Thinking","run_id":"wef-columbus-depth-4-2026-07-25","skill":"auto-dig;search-starintel-json-db;create-starintel-documents;select-recursive-targets"},"schema_version":"0.9.0","sources":[{"accessed_at":"2026-07-25T21:15:00Z","credibility":0.95,"kind":"official_project_record","publisher":"JobsOhio","title":"AndHealth Expanding Office Space in Downtown Columbus","uri":"https://www.jobsohio.com/newsroom/news-press/andhealth-expanding-office-space-in-downtown-columbus","url":"https://www.jobsohio.com/newsroom/news-press/andhealth-expanding-office-space-in-downtown-columbus"}],"summary":"Ohio's private nonprofit economic-development corporation and collaborator on AndHealth expansions.","tags":["wef-columbus","recursive-research","depth-4"],"title":"JobsOhio","verification":{"status":"source-backed","verified":true},"version":1,"workflow":{"max_depth":6,"recursion_depth":4,"research_status":"completed","root_target_id":"starintel:org:city-of-columbus"}}
{"_id":"starintel:org:jpmorgan-chase","assessment":{"confidence":0.94},"data":{"name":"JPMorganChase","org_type":"financial_services"},"dataset":"starintel-wef-columbus-depth-3-2026-07-25","date_added":"2026-07-25T20:30:00Z","date_updated":"2026-07-25T20:30:00Z","dtype":"org","evidence":[],"lineage":{"derived_from":["starintel:research-pass:wef-columbus-depth-2-2026-07-25"],"generation":3},"provenance":{"agent":"GPT-5.6 Thinking","run_id":"wef-columbus-depth-3-2026-07-25","skill":"auto-dig;create-starintel-documents;select-recursive-targets"},"schema_version":"0.9.0","sources":[{"accessed_at":"2026-07-25T20:30:00Z","credibility":0.95,"kind":"official_webpage","publisher":"Official source","title":"JPMorganChase","uri":"https://columbusregion.com/press-release/columbus-partnership-announces-leadership-transition/","url":"https://columbusregion.com/press-release/columbus-partnership-announces-leadership-transition/"}],"summary":"Former employer of Corrine Burger, who moved into interim leadership of the Columbus Partnership.","tags":["wef-columbus","recursive-research","depth-3"],"title":"JPMorganChase","verification":{"status":"source-backed","verified":true},"version":1,"workflow":{"max_depth":6,"recursion_depth":3,"research_status":"completed","root_target_id":"starintel:org:city-of-columbus"}}
{"_id":"starintel:org:morpc","assessment":{"confidence":0.94},"data":{"name":"Mid-Ohio Regional Planning Commission","org_type":"regional_planning_agency"},"dataset":"starintel-wef-columbus-depth-3-2026-07-25","date_added":"2026-07-25T20:30:00Z","date_updated":"2026-07-25T20:30:00Z","dtype":"org","evidence":[],"lineage":{"derived_from":["starintel:research-pass:wef-columbus-depth-2-2026-07-25"],"generation":3},"provenance":{"agent":"GPT-5.6 Thinking","run_id":"wef-columbus-depth-3-2026-07-25","skill":"auto-dig;create-starintel-documents;select-recursive-targets"},"schema_version":"0.9.0","sources":[{"accessed_at":"2026-07-25T20:30:00Z","credibility":0.95,"kind":"official_webpage","publisher":"Official source","title":"Mid-Ohio Regional Planning Commission","uri":"https://www.morpc.org/william-murdock/","url":"https://www.morpc.org/william-murdock/"}],"summary":"Regional council represented on the Smart Columbus board.","tags":["wef-columbus","recursive-research","depth-3"],"title":"Mid-Ohio Regional Planning Commission","verification":{"status":"source-backed","verified":true},"version":1,"workflow":{"max_depth":6,"recursion_depth":3,"research_status":"completed","root_target_id":"starintel:org:city-of-columbus"}}
{"_id":"starintel:org:navigant-guidehouse","assessment":{"confidence":0.94},"data":{"name":"Navigant / Guidehouse","org_type":"consulting_firm"},"dataset":"starintel-wef-columbus-depth-3-2026-07-25","date_added":"2026-07-25T20:30:00Z","date_updated":"2026-07-25T20:30:00Z","dtype":"org","evidence":[],"lineage":{"derived_from":["starintel:research-pass:wef-columbus-depth-2-2026-07-25"],"generation":3},"provenance":{"agent":"GPT-5.6 Thinking","run_id":"wef-columbus-depth-3-2026-07-25","skill":"auto-dig;create-starintel-documents;select-recursive-targets"},"schema_version":"0.9.0","sources":[{"accessed_at":"2026-07-25T20:30:00Z","credibility":0.95,"kind":"government_record","publisher":"City of Columbus","title":"Navigant / Guidehouse","uri":"https://columbus.legistar.com/LegislationDetail.aspx?GUID=0AA0D122-320C-4CC0-B0EC-11B78C87F598&ID=3197311&Options=&Search=","url":"https://columbus.legistar.com/LegislationDetail.aspx?GUID=0AA0D122-320C-4CC0-B0EC-11B78C87F598&ID=3197311&Options=&Search="}],"summary":"Research contractor for Smart Columbus consumer-adoption and logic-model work.","tags":["wef-columbus","recursive-research","depth-3"],"title":"Navigant / Guidehouse","verification":{"status":"source-backed","verified":true},"version":1,"workflow":{"max_depth":6,"recursion_depth":3,"research_status":"completed","root_target_id":"starintel:org:city-of-columbus"}}
{"_id":"starintel:org:ohio-department-of-development","assessment":{"confidence":0.95},"data":{"name":"Ohio Department of Development","org_type":"state_agency"},"dataset":"starintel-wef-columbus-depth-4-2026-07-25","date_added":"2026-07-25T21:15:00Z","date_updated":"2026-07-25T21:15:00Z","dtype":"org","evidence":[],"lineage":{"derived_from":["starintel:research-pass:wef-columbus-depth-3-2026-07-25"],"generation":4},"provenance":{"agent":"GPT-5.6 Thinking","run_id":"wef-columbus-depth-4-2026-07-25","skill":"auto-dig;search-starintel-json-db;create-starintel-documents;select-recursive-targets"},"schema_version":"0.9.0","sources":[{"accessed_at":"2026-07-25T21:15:00Z","credibility":0.95,"kind":"official_project_record","publisher":"JobsOhio","title":"AndHealth Expanding Office Space in Downtown Columbus","uri":"https://www.jobsohio.com/newsroom/news-press/andhealth-expanding-office-space-in-downtown-columbus","url":"https://www.jobsohio.com/newsroom/news-press/andhealth-expanding-office-space-in-downtown-columbus"}],"summary":"State economic-development agency listed as an AndHealth expansion collaborator.","tags":["wef-columbus","recursive-research","depth-4"],"title":"Ohio Department of Development","verification":{"status":"source-backed","verified":true},"version":1,"workflow":{"max_depth":6,"recursion_depth":4,"research_status":"completed","root_target_id":"starintel:org:city-of-columbus"}}
{"_id":"starintel:org:one-columbus","assessment":{"confidence":0.95},"data":{"name":"One Columbus","org_type":"economic_development_organization"},"dataset":"starintel-wef-columbus-depth-4-2026-07-25","date_added":"2026-07-25T21:15:00Z","date_updated":"2026-07-25T21:15:00Z","dtype":"org","evidence":[],"lineage":{"derived_from":["starintel:research-pass:wef-columbus-depth-3-2026-07-25"],"generation":4},"provenance":{"agent":"GPT-5.6 Thinking","run_id":"wef-columbus-depth-4-2026-07-25","skill":"auto-dig;search-starintel-json-db;create-starintel-documents;select-recursive-targets"},"schema_version":"0.9.0","sources":[{"accessed_at":"2026-07-25T21:15:00Z","credibility":0.95,"kind":"official_project_record","publisher":"One Columbus","title":"Digital Healthcare Startup AndHealth Brings 65 New Jobs","uri":"https://columbusregion.com/press-release/digital-healthcare-startup-andhealth-brings-65-new-jobs-to-downtown-columbus-for-operations-expansion/","url":"https://columbusregion.com/press-release/digital-healthcare-startup-andhealth-brings-65-new-jobs-to-downtown-columbus-for-operations-expansion/"}],"summary":"Regional economic-development organization within the Columbus Partnership family.","tags":["wef-columbus","recursive-research","depth-4"],"title":"One Columbus","verification":{"status":"source-backed","verified":true},"version":1,"workflow":{"max_depth":6,"recursion_depth":4,"research_status":"completed","root_target_id":"starintel:org:city-of-columbus"}}
{"_id":"starintel:org:paul-g-allen-philanthropies-vulcan","assessment":{"confidence":0.94},"data":{"name":"Paul G. Allen Philanthropies / Vulcan","org_type":"philanthropic_funder"},"dataset":"starintel-wef-columbus-depth-3-2026-07-25","date_added":"2026-07-25T20:30:00Z","date_updated":"2026-07-25T20:30:00Z","dtype":"org","evidence":[],"lineage":{"derived_from":["starintel:research-pass:wef-columbus-depth-2-2026-07-25"],"generation":3},"provenance":{"agent":"GPT-5.6 Thinking","run_id":"wef-columbus-depth-3-2026-07-25","skill":"auto-dig;create-starintel-documents;select-recursive-targets"},"schema_version":"0.9.0","sources":[{"accessed_at":"2026-07-25T20:30:00Z","credibility":0.95,"kind":"government_record","publisher":"City of Columbus","title":"Paul G. Allen Philanthropies / Vulcan","uri":"https://columbus.legistar.com/LegislationDetail.aspx?FullText=1&GUID=A46BE430-491C-4BFF-BA59-B37B763DF2B6&ID=3476477","url":"https://columbus.legistar.com/LegislationDetail.aspx?FullText=1&GUID=A46BE430-491C-4BFF-BA59-B37B763DF2B6&ID=3476477"}],"summary":"Private Smart City Challenge funder that awarded Columbus up to $10 million.","tags":["wef-columbus","recursive-research","depth-3"],"title":"Paul G. Allen Philanthropies / Vulcan","verification":{"status":"source-backed","verified":true},"version":1,"workflow":{"max_depth":6,"recursion_depth":3,"research_status":"completed","root_target_id":"starintel:org:city-of-columbus"}}
{"_id":"starintel:org:rackspace-technology","assessment":{"confidence":0.98},"data":{"industry":"cloud computing and managed services","name":"Rackspace Technology","org_type":"technology_services","website":"https://www.rackspace.com/"},"dataset":"wef","date_added":"2026-07-26T04:05:00Z","date_updated":"2026-07-26T04:05:00Z","dtype":"org","evidence":[],"lineage":{"derived_from":["starintel:analysis:wef-columbus-depth-4-governance-replication-continuity"],"generation":5},"provenance":{"agent":"GPT-5.6 Thinking","method":"Primary-source recursive OSINT with bounded inference","run_id":"wef-columbus-depth-5-2026-07-26","skill":"auto-dig;web-research;create-starintel-documents;select-recursive-targets"},"schema_version":"0.9.0","sources":[{"accessed_at":"2026-07-26T04:05:00Z","credibility":0.95,"kind":"official_webpage","publisher":"Smart Columbus","title":"Columbus leads the way: Evolving our Green IT ambition","uri":"https://smartcolumbus.com/insights/2025-10-cie-vendor-announcement-83p85","url":"https://smartcolumbus.com/insights/2025-10-cie-vendor-announcement-83p85"},{"accessed_at":"2026-07-26T04:05:00Z","credibility":0.95,"kind":"official_webpage","publisher":"Smart Columbus","title":"A year of impact: 2025 by the numbers","uri":"https://smartcolumbus.com/insights/2025-12-year-of-impact","url":"https://smartcolumbus.com/insights/2025-12-year-of-impact"}],"summary":"Technology-services company that co-authored the Columbus Green IT Playbook 2.0 with Smart Columbus.","tags":["wef","columbus","recursive-research","depth-5"],"title":"Rackspace Technology","verification":{"status":"source-backed","verified":true},"version":1,"workflow":{"max_depth":6,"recursion_depth":5,"research_status":"completed","root_target_id":"starintel:org:city-of-columbus"}}
{"_id":"starintel:org:rhove","assessment":{"confidence":0.94},"data":{"name":"Rhove","org_type":"company"},"dataset":"starintel-wef-columbus-depth-3-2026-07-25","date_added":"2026-07-25T20:30:00Z","date_updated":"2026-07-25T20:30:00Z","dtype":"org","evidence":[],"lineage":{"derived_from":["starintel:research-pass:wef-columbus-depth-2-2026-07-25"],"generation":3},"provenance":{"agent":"GPT-5.6 Thinking","run_id":"wef-columbus-depth-3-2026-07-25","skill":"auto-dig;create-starintel-documents;select-recursive-targets"},"schema_version":"0.9.0","sources":[{"accessed_at":"2026-07-25T20:30:00Z","credibility":0.95,"kind":"official_webpage","publisher":"Official source","title":"Rhove","uri":"https://columbusregion.com/about-us/boards-investors/smart-columbus-board/","url":"https://columbusregion.com/about-us/boards-investors/smart-columbus-board/"}],"summary":"Organization formerly associated with Calvin Cooper on a legacy Smart Columbus board roster.","tags":["wef-columbus","recursive-research","depth-3"],"title":"Rhove","verification":{"status":"source-backed","verified":true},"version":1,"workflow":{"max_depth":6,"recursion_depth":3,"research_status":"completed","root_target_id":"starintel:org:city-of-columbus"}}
{"_id":"starintel:org:smart-columbus","aliases":["Smart Columbus LLC","Columbus Partnership dba Smart Columbus LLC"],"assessment":{"confidence":0.99},"attachments":[],"data":{"name":"Smart Columbus"},"dataset":"starintel-wef-columbus-urban-transformation-2026-07-25","date_added":"2026-07-25T00:00:00Z","date_updated":"2026-07-25T00:00:00Z","description":"","dtype":"org","evidence":[],"extensions":{"legacy.v0":{"data":{"confidence":0.99}}},"geospatial":{},"handling":{"pii":false,"sensitive":false,"visibility":"public"},"identifiers":[],"keywords":[],"labels":[],"language":"en","lineage":{"migration_from":"0.8","migration_notes":["Normalized into the canonical StarIntel v0.9.0 document envelope."]},"notes":[],"provenance":{"original_id":"starintel:org:smart-columbus","original_path":"digs/wef-columbus/2026-07-25-urban-transformation-network/starintel-documents.jsonl","original_schema_version":"0.8","software_version":"0.9.0","transform":"starintel_doc.migration.migrate_document"},"quality":{},"related_ids":[],"schema_version":"0.9.0","sources":[{"accessed_at":"2026-07-25T00:00:00Z","metadata":{"source_type":"official_organization"},"title":"About Smart Columbus","uri":"https://smartcolumbus.com/about","url":"https://smartcolumbus.com/about"},{"accessed_at":"2026-07-25T00:00:00Z","metadata":{"source_type":"official_organization"},"title":"About the Columbus Partnership","uri":"https://columbusregion.com/about-us/","url":"https://columbusregion.com/about-us/"},{"accessed_at":"2026-07-25T00:00:00Z","metadata":{"source_type":"government_record"},"title":"Columbus Ordinance 1663-2025","uri":"https://columbus.legistar.com/LegislationDetail.aspx?FullText=1&GUID=5E02F335-BDF8-4220-B7BB-05FE16CF6CC4&ID=7489830","url":"https://columbus.legistar.com/LegislationDetail.aspx?FullText=1&GUID=5E02F335-BDF8-4220-B7BB-05FE16CF6CC4&ID=7489830"},{"accessed_at":"2026-07-25T00:00:00Z","metadata":{"source_type":"government_record"},"title":"Columbus Ordinance 1850-2026","uri":"https://columbus.legistar.com/LegislationDetail.aspx?FullText=1&GUID=588DBFF9-D9DB-4603-B5D4-776E9F5B5A9E&ID=8117690&Options=&Search=","url":"https://columbus.legistar.com/LegislationDetail.aspx?FullText=1&GUID=588DBFF9-D9DB-4603-B5D4-776E9F5B5A9E&ID=8117690&Options=&Search="}],"status":"recorded","summary":"Civic innovation lab within the Columbus Partnership; the City funds it for thought leadership, convening and project delivery.","tags":[],"temporal":{},"title":"Smart Columbus","verification":{"status":"confirmed"},"version":1,"workflow":{}}
{"_id":"starintel:org:the-columbus-partnership-c3","assessment":{"confidence":0.95},"data":{"name":"The Columbus Partnership — 501(c)(3)","org_type":"charitable_nonprofit","tax_id":"02-0580058"},"dataset":"starintel-wef-columbus-depth-4-2026-07-25","date_added":"2026-07-25T21:15:00Z","date_updated":"2026-07-25T21:15:00Z","dtype":"org","evidence":[],"lineage":{"derived_from":["starintel:research-pass:wef-columbus-depth-3-2026-07-25"],"generation":4},"provenance":{"agent":"GPT-5.6 Thinking","run_id":"wef-columbus-depth-4-2026-07-25","skill":"auto-dig;search-starintel-json-db;create-starintel-documents;select-recursive-targets"},"schema_version":"0.9.0","sources":[{"accessed_at":"2026-07-25T21:15:00Z","credibility":0.95,"kind":"irs_derived_filing","publisher":"ProPublica Nonprofit Explorer","title":"The Columbus Partnership Form 990 — fiscal year 2024","uri":"https://projects.propublica.org/nonprofits/organizations/20580058","url":"https://projects.propublica.org/nonprofits/organizations/20580058"}],"summary":"Charitable entity using The Columbus Partnership name; EIN 02-0580058.","tags":["wef-columbus","recursive-research","depth-4"],"title":"The Columbus Partnership — 501(c)(3)","verification":{"status":"source-backed","verified":true},"version":1,"workflow":{"max_depth":6,"recursion_depth":4,"research_status":"completed","root_target_id":"starintel:org:city-of-columbus"}}
{"_id":"starintel:org:urbanos-public","assessment":{"confidence":0.98},"data":{"name":"UrbanOS-Public","org_type":"open_source_organization","products":["Smart Cities Data Platform"],"website":"https://github.com/UrbanOS-Public"},"dataset":"wef","date_added":"2026-07-26T04:05:00Z","date_updated":"2026-07-26T04:05:00Z","dtype":"org","evidence":[],"lineage":{"derived_from":["starintel:analysis:wef-columbus-depth-4-governance-replication-continuity"],"generation":5},"provenance":{"agent":"GPT-5.6 Thinking","method":"Primary-source recursive OSINT with bounded inference","run_id":"wef-columbus-depth-5-2026-07-26","skill":"auto-dig;web-research;create-starintel-documents;select-recursive-targets"},"schema_version":"0.9.0","sources":[{"accessed_at":"2026-07-26T04:05:00Z","credibility":0.98,"kind":"source_repository","publisher":"UrbanOS-Public","title":"UrbanOS-Public/smartcitiesdata","uri":"https://github.com/UrbanOS-Public/smartcitiesdata","url":"https://github.com/UrbanOS-Public/smartcitiesdata"}],"summary":"GitHub organization publishing the Smart Cities Data Platform and related open-source smart-city components.","tags":["wef","columbus","recursive-research","depth-5"],"title":"UrbanOS-Public","verification":{"status":"source-backed","verified":true},"version":1,"workflow":{"max_depth":6,"recursion_depth":5,"research_status":"completed","root_target_id":"starintel:org:city-of-columbus"}}
{"_id":"starintel:org:world-economic-forum","aliases":["WEF"],"assessment":{"confidence":0.99},"attachments":[],"data":{"name":"World Economic Forum"},"dataset":"starintel-wef-columbus-urban-transformation-2026-07-25","date_added":"2026-07-25T00:00:00Z","date_updated":"2026-07-25T00:00:00Z","description":"","dtype":"org","evidence":[],"extensions":{"legacy.v0":{"data":{"confidence":0.99}}},"geospatial":{},"handling":{"pii":false,"sensitive":false,"visibility":"public"},"identifiers":[],"keywords":[],"labels":[],"language":"en","lineage":{"migration_from":"0.8","migration_notes":["Normalized into the canonical StarIntel v0.9.0 document envelope."]},"notes":[],"provenance":{"original_id":"starintel:org:world-economic-forum","original_path":"digs/wef-columbus/2026-07-25-urban-transformation-network/starintel-documents.jsonl","original_schema_version":"0.8","software_version":"0.9.0","transform":"starintel_doc.migration.migrate_document"},"quality":{},"related_ids":[],"schema_version":"0.9.0","sources":[{"accessed_at":"2026-07-25T00:00:00Z","metadata":{"source_type":"official_organization"},"title":"City of Columbus | World Economic Forum","uri":"https://www.weforum.org/organizations/city-of-columbus/","url":"https://www.weforum.org/organizations/city-of-columbus/"},{"accessed_at":"2026-07-25T00:00:00Z","metadata":{"source_type":"official_project"},"title":"Implementing a Life-Cycle Approach to Infrastructure","uri":"https://centres.weforum.org/centre-for-urban-transformation/infrastructure-lifecycle","url":"https://centres.weforum.org/centre-for-urban-transformation/infrastructure-lifecycle"}],"status":"recorded","summary":"International organization operating the Centre for Urban Transformation and maintaining an official City of Columbus profile.","tags":[],"temporal":{},"title":"World Economic Forum","verification":{"status":"confirmed"},"version":1,"workflow":{}}
{"_id":"starintel:person:andreya-veintimilla","assessment":{"confidence":0.93},"data":{"employers":["Smart Columbus"],"full_name":"Andreya Veintimilla","name":"Andreya Veintimilla","positions":["Design Research Lead"]},"dataset":"starintel-wef-columbus-depth-4-2026-07-25","date_added":"2026-07-25T21:15:00Z","date_updated":"2026-07-25T21:15:00Z","dtype":"person","evidence":[],"lineage":{"derived_from":["starintel:research-pass:wef-columbus-depth-3-2026-07-25"],"generation":4},"provenance":{"agent":"GPT-5.6 Thinking","run_id":"wef-columbus-depth-4-2026-07-25","skill":"auto-dig;search-starintel-json-db;create-starintel-documents;select-recursive-targets"},"schema_version":"0.9.0","sources":[{"accessed_at":"2026-07-25T21:15:00Z","credibility":0.95,"kind":"official_webpage","publisher":"Smart Columbus","title":"Smart Columbus — About","uri":"https://smartcolumbus.com/about","url":"https://smartcolumbus.com/about"}],"summary":"Depth 4 person node identified in current governance, staffing, or filing records.","tags":["wef-columbus","recursive-research","depth-4"],"title":"Andreya Veintimilla","verification":{"status":"source-backed","verified":true},"version":1,"workflow":{"max_depth":6,"recursion_depth":4,"research_status":"completed","root_target_id":"starintel:org:city-of-columbus"}}
{"_id":"starintel:person:arash-ghazvini","assessment":{"confidence":0.93},"data":{"employers":["Smart Columbus"],"full_name":"Arash Ghazvini","name":"Arash Ghazvini","positions":["Principal Product Manager"]},"dataset":"starintel-wef-columbus-depth-4-2026-07-25","date_added":"2026-07-25T21:15:00Z","date_updated":"2026-07-25T21:15:00Z","dtype":"person","evidence":[],"lineage":{"derived_from":["starintel:research-pass:wef-columbus-depth-3-2026-07-25"],"generation":4},"provenance":{"agent":"GPT-5.6 Thinking","run_id":"wef-columbus-depth-4-2026-07-25","skill":"auto-dig;search-starintel-json-db;create-starintel-documents;select-recursive-targets"},"schema_version":"0.9.0","sources":[{"accessed_at":"2026-07-25T21:15:00Z","credibility":0.95,"kind":"official_webpage","publisher":"Smart Columbus","title":"Smart Columbus — About","uri":"https://smartcolumbus.com/about","url":"https://smartcolumbus.com/about"}],"summary":"Depth 4 person node identified in current governance, staffing, or filing records.","tags":["wef-columbus","recursive-research","depth-4"],"title":"Arash Ghazvini","verification":{"status":"source-backed","verified":true},"version":1,"workflow":{"max_depth":6,"recursion_depth":4,"research_status":"completed","root_target_id":"starintel:org:city-of-columbus"}}
{"_id":"starintel:person:ayaz-hyder","assessment":{"confidence":0.93},"data":{"employers":["Smart Columbus"],"full_name":"Ayaz Hyder","name":"Ayaz Hyder","positions":["Data & Integrations Lead"]},"dataset":"starintel-wef-columbus-depth-4-2026-07-25","date_added":"2026-07-25T21:15:00Z","date_updated":"2026-07-25T21:15:00Z","dtype":"person","evidence":[],"lineage":{"derived_from":["starintel:research-pass:wef-columbus-depth-3-2026-07-25"],"generation":4},"provenance":{"agent":"GPT-5.6 Thinking","run_id":"wef-columbus-depth-4-2026-07-25","skill":"auto-dig;search-starintel-json-db;create-starintel-documents;select-recursive-targets"},"schema_version":"0.9.0","sources":[{"accessed_at":"2026-07-25T21:15:00Z","credibility":0.95,"kind":"official_webpage","publisher":"Smart Columbus","title":"Smart Columbus — About","uri":"https://smartcolumbus.com/about","url":"https://smartcolumbus.com/about"}],"summary":"Depth 4 person node identified in current governance, staffing, or filing records.","tags":["wef-columbus","recursive-research","depth-4"],"title":"Ayaz Hyder","verification":{"status":"source-backed","verified":true},"version":1,"workflow":{"max_depth":6,"recursion_depth":4,"research_status":"completed","root_target_id":"starintel:org:city-of-columbus"}}
{"_id":"starintel:person:ben-blanquera","assessment":{"confidence":0.92},"data":{"employers":["starintel:org:rackspace-technology"],"full_name":"Ben Blanquera","name":"Ben Blanquera","positions":["Vice President, AI and Sustainability"]},"dataset":"wef","date_added":"2026-07-26T04:05:00Z","date_updated":"2026-07-26T04:05:00Z","dtype":"person","evidence":[],"lineage":{"derived_from":["starintel:analysis:wef-columbus-depth-4-governance-replication-continuity"],"generation":5},"provenance":{"agent":"GPT-5.6 Thinking","method":"Primary-source recursive OSINT with bounded inference","run_id":"wef-columbus-depth-5-2026-07-26","skill":"auto-dig;web-research;create-starintel-documents;select-recursive-targets"},"schema_version":"0.9.0","sources":[{"accessed_at":"2026-07-26T04:05:00Z","credibility":0.95,"kind":"official_webpage","publisher":"Smart Columbus","title":"Columbus leads the way: Evolving our Green IT ambition","uri":"https://smartcolumbus.com/insights/2025-10-cie-vendor-announcement-83p85","url":"https://smartcolumbus.com/insights/2025-10-cie-vendor-announcement-83p85"}],"summary":"Rackspace technology and sustainability executive identified as a Green IT Playbook contributor.","tags":["wef","columbus","recursive-research","depth-5"],"title":"Ben Blanquera","verification":{"status":"source-backed","verified":true},"version":1,"workflow":{"max_depth":6,"recursion_depth":5,"research_status":"completed","root_target_id":"starintel:org:city-of-columbus"}}
{"_id":"starintel:person:ben-prochazka","assessment":{"confidence":0.94},"data":{"employers":["Electrification Coalition"],"full_name":"Ben Prochazka","name":"Ben Prochazka","positions":["Executive Director, Electrification Coalition"]},"dataset":"starintel-wef-columbus-depth-3-2026-07-25","date_added":"2026-07-25T20:30:00Z","date_updated":"2026-07-25T20:30:00Z","dtype":"person","evidence":[],"lineage":{"derived_from":["starintel:research-pass:wef-columbus-depth-2-2026-07-25"],"generation":3},"provenance":{"agent":"GPT-5.6 Thinking","run_id":"wef-columbus-depth-3-2026-07-25","skill":"auto-dig;create-starintel-documents;select-recursive-targets"},"schema_version":"0.9.0","sources":[{"accessed_at":"2026-07-25T20:30:00Z","credibility":0.95,"kind":"official_webpage","publisher":"Official source","title":"Ben Prochazka","uri":"https://electrificationcoalition.org/our-team/","url":"https://electrificationcoalition.org/our-team/"}],"summary":"Executive director of the Electrification Coalition, which advised Smart Columbus.","tags":["wef-columbus","recursive-research","depth-3"],"title":"Ben Prochazka","verification":{"status":"source-backed","verified":true},"version":1,"workflow":{"max_depth":6,"recursion_depth":3,"research_status":"completed","root_target_id":"starintel:org:city-of-columbus"}}
{"_id":"starintel:person:brayan-pabon-gomez","assessment":{"confidence":0.93},"data":{"employers":["Smart Columbus"],"full_name":"Brayan Pabón Gomez","name":"Brayan Pabón Gomez","positions":["Service Designer"]},"dataset":"starintel-wef-columbus-depth-4-2026-07-25","date_added":"2026-07-25T21:15:00Z","date_updated":"2026-07-25T21:15:00Z","dtype":"person","evidence":[],"lineage":{"derived_from":["starintel:research-pass:wef-columbus-depth-3-2026-07-25"],"generation":4},"provenance":{"agent":"GPT-5.6 Thinking","run_id":"wef-columbus-depth-4-2026-07-25","skill":"auto-dig;search-starintel-json-db;create-starintel-documents;select-recursive-targets"},"schema_version":"0.9.0","sources":[{"accessed_at":"2026-07-25T21:15:00Z","credibility":0.95,"kind":"official_webpage","publisher":"Smart Columbus","title":"Smart Columbus — About","uri":"https://smartcolumbus.com/about","url":"https://smartcolumbus.com/about"}],"summary":"Depth 4 person node identified in current governance, staffing, or filing records.","tags":["wef-columbus","recursive-research","depth-4"],"title":"Brayan Pabón Gomez","verification":{"status":"source-backed","verified":true},"version":1,"workflow":{"max_depth":6,"recursion_depth":4,"research_status":"completed","root_target_id":"starintel:org:city-of-columbus"}}
{"_id":"starintel:person:bud-braughton","assessment":{"confidence":0.94},"data":{"employers":["Smart Columbus"],"full_name":"Bud Braughton","name":"Bud Braughton","positions":["Project Manager, Smart Columbus"]},"dataset":"starintel-wef-columbus-depth-3-2026-07-25","date_added":"2026-07-25T20:30:00Z","date_updated":"2026-07-25T20:30:00Z","dtype":"person","evidence":[],"lineage":{"derived_from":["starintel:research-pass:wef-columbus-depth-2-2026-07-25"],"generation":3},"provenance":{"agent":"GPT-5.6 Thinking","run_id":"wef-columbus-depth-3-2026-07-25","skill":"auto-dig;create-starintel-documents;select-recursive-targets"},"schema_version":"0.9.0","sources":[{"accessed_at":"2026-07-25T20:30:00Z","credibility":0.95,"kind":"official_webpage","publisher":"Official source","title":"Bud Braughton","uri":"https://electrificationcoalition.org/resource/accelerate-your-city/","url":"https://electrificationcoalition.org/resource/accelerate-your-city/"}],"summary":"Speaker in Smart Columbus replication programming on regional charging infrastructure.","tags":["wef-columbus","recursive-research","depth-3"],"title":"Bud Braughton","verification":{"status":"source-backed","verified":true},"version":1,"workflow":{"max_depth":6,"recursion_depth":3,"research_status":"completed","root_target_id":"starintel:org:city-of-columbus"}}
{"_id":"starintel:person:cami-albaugh","assessment":{"confidence":0.93},"data":{"employers":["Smart Columbus"],"full_name":"Cami Albaugh","name":"Cami Albaugh","positions":["Operations & Communications Coordinator"]},"dataset":"starintel-wef-columbus-depth-4-2026-07-25","date_added":"2026-07-25T21:15:00Z","date_updated":"2026-07-25T21:15:00Z","dtype":"person","evidence":[],"lineage":{"derived_from":["starintel:research-pass:wef-columbus-depth-3-2026-07-25"],"generation":4},"provenance":{"agent":"GPT-5.6 Thinking","run_id":"wef-columbus-depth-4-2026-07-25","skill":"auto-dig;search-starintel-json-db;create-starintel-documents;select-recursive-targets"},"schema_version":"0.9.0","sources":[{"accessed_at":"2026-07-25T21:15:00Z","credibility":0.95,"kind":"official_webpage","publisher":"Smart Columbus","title":"Smart Columbus — About","uri":"https://smartcolumbus.com/about","url":"https://smartcolumbus.com/about"}],"summary":"Depth 4 person node identified in current governance, staffing, or filing records.","tags":["wef-columbus","recursive-research","depth-4"],"title":"Cami Albaugh","verification":{"status":"source-backed","verified":true},"version":1,"workflow":{"max_depth":6,"recursion_depth":4,"research_status":"completed","root_target_id":"starintel:org:city-of-columbus"}}
{"_id":"starintel:person:dylan-sansone","assessment":{"confidence":0.93},"data":{"employers":["Smart Columbus"],"full_name":"Dylan Sansone","name":"Dylan Sansone","positions":["Senior Project Manager, Digital Equity"]},"dataset":"starintel-wef-columbus-depth-4-2026-07-25","date_added":"2026-07-25T21:15:00Z","date_updated":"2026-07-25T21:15:00Z","dtype":"person","evidence":[],"lineage":{"derived_from":["starintel:research-pass:wef-columbus-depth-3-2026-07-25"],"generation":4},"provenance":{"agent":"GPT-5.6 Thinking","run_id":"wef-columbus-depth-4-2026-07-25","skill":"auto-dig;search-starintel-json-db;create-starintel-documents;select-recursive-targets"},"schema_version":"0.9.0","sources":[{"accessed_at":"2026-07-25T21:15:00Z","credibility":0.95,"kind":"official_webpage","publisher":"Smart Columbus","title":"Smart Columbus — About","uri":"https://smartcolumbus.com/about","url":"https://smartcolumbus.com/about"}],"summary":"Depth 4 person node identified in current governance, staffing, or filing records.","tags":["wef-columbus","recursive-research","depth-4"],"title":"Dylan Sansone","verification":{"status":"source-backed","verified":true},"version":1,"workflow":{"max_depth":6,"recursion_depth":4,"research_status":"completed","root_target_id":"starintel:org:city-of-columbus"}}
{"_id":"starintel:person:frances-henry","assessment":{"confidence":0.93},"data":{"employers":["The Columbus Partnership"],"full_name":"Frances Henry","name":"Frances Henry","positions":["Secretary, The Columbus Partnership"]},"dataset":"starintel-wef-columbus-depth-4-2026-07-25","date_added":"2026-07-25T21:15:00Z","date_updated":"2026-07-25T21:15:00Z","dtype":"person","evidence":[],"lineage":{"derived_from":["starintel:research-pass:wef-columbus-depth-3-2026-07-25"],"generation":4},"provenance":{"agent":"GPT-5.6 Thinking","run_id":"wef-columbus-depth-4-2026-07-25","skill":"auto-dig;search-starintel-json-db;create-starintel-documents;select-recursive-targets"},"schema_version":"0.9.0","sources":[{"accessed_at":"2026-07-25T21:15:00Z","credibility":0.95,"kind":"irs_derived_filing","publisher":"ProPublica Nonprofit Explorer","title":"The Columbus Partnership Form 990 — fiscal year 2024","uri":"https://projects.propublica.org/nonprofits/organizations/20580058","url":"https://projects.propublica.org/nonprofits/organizations/20580058"}],"summary":"Depth 4 person node identified in current governance, staffing, or filing records.","tags":["wef-columbus","recursive-research","depth-4"],"title":"Frances Henry","verification":{"status":"source-backed","verified":true},"version":1,"workflow":{"max_depth":6,"recursion_depth":4,"research_status":"completed","root_target_id":"starintel:org:city-of-columbus"}}
{"_id":"starintel:person:gerard-basalla","assessment":{"confidence":0.93},"data":{"employers":["Columbus Partnership"],"full_name":"Gerard Basalla","name":"Gerard Basalla","positions":["Director of Public Policy, Columbus Partnership"]},"dataset":"starintel-wef-columbus-depth-4-2026-07-25","date_added":"2026-07-25T21:15:00Z","date_updated":"2026-07-25T21:15:00Z","dtype":"person","evidence":[],"lineage":{"derived_from":["starintel:research-pass:wef-columbus-depth-3-2026-07-25"],"generation":4},"provenance":{"agent":"GPT-5.6 Thinking","run_id":"wef-columbus-depth-4-2026-07-25","skill":"auto-dig;search-starintel-json-db;create-starintel-documents;select-recursive-targets"},"schema_version":"0.9.0","sources":[{"accessed_at":"2026-07-25T21:15:00Z","credibility":0.95,"kind":"irs_derived_filing","publisher":"ProPublica Nonprofit Explorer","title":"Columbus Partnership Form 990 — fiscal year 2024","uri":"https://projects.propublica.org/nonprofits/organizations/352558300","url":"https://projects.propublica.org/nonprofits/organizations/352558300"}],"summary":"Depth 4 person node identified in current governance, staffing, or filing records.","tags":["wef-columbus","recursive-research","depth-4"],"title":"Gerard Basalla","verification":{"status":"source-backed","verified":true},"version":1,"workflow":{"max_depth":6,"recursion_depth":4,"research_status":"completed","root_target_id":"starintel:org:city-of-columbus"}}
{"_id":"starintel:person:hailey-allison","assessment":{"confidence":0.93},"data":{"employers":["Smart Columbus"],"full_name":"Hailey Allison","name":"Hailey Allison","positions":["Director of Operations"]},"dataset":"starintel-wef-columbus-depth-4-2026-07-25","date_added":"2026-07-25T21:15:00Z","date_updated":"2026-07-25T21:15:00Z","dtype":"person","evidence":[],"lineage":{"derived_from":["starintel:research-pass:wef-columbus-depth-3-2026-07-25"],"generation":4},"provenance":{"agent":"GPT-5.6 Thinking","run_id":"wef-columbus-depth-4-2026-07-25","skill":"auto-dig;search-starintel-json-db;create-starintel-documents;select-recursive-targets"},"schema_version":"0.9.0","sources":[{"accessed_at":"2026-07-25T21:15:00Z","credibility":0.95,"kind":"official_webpage","publisher":"Smart Columbus","title":"Smart Columbus — About","uri":"https://smartcolumbus.com/about","url":"https://smartcolumbus.com/about"}],"summary":"Depth 4 person node identified in current governance, staffing, or filing records.","tags":["wef-columbus","recursive-research","depth-4"],"title":"Hailey Allison","verification":{"status":"source-backed","verified":true},"version":1,"workflow":{"max_depth":6,"recursion_depth":4,"research_status":"completed","root_target_id":"starintel:org:city-of-columbus"}}
{"_id":"starintel:person:jeff-polesovsky","assessment":{"confidence":0.93},"data":{"employers":["Columbus Partnership"],"full_name":"Jeff Polesovsky","name":"Jeff Polesovsky","positions":["Vice President of Public Policy, Columbus Partnership"]},"dataset":"starintel-wef-columbus-depth-4-2026-07-25","date_added":"2026-07-25T21:15:00Z","date_updated":"2026-07-25T21:15:00Z","dtype":"person","evidence":[],"lineage":{"derived_from":["starintel:research-pass:wef-columbus-depth-3-2026-07-25"],"generation":4},"provenance":{"agent":"GPT-5.6 Thinking","run_id":"wef-columbus-depth-4-2026-07-25","skill":"auto-dig;search-starintel-json-db;create-starintel-documents;select-recursive-targets"},"schema_version":"0.9.0","sources":[{"accessed_at":"2026-07-25T21:15:00Z","credibility":0.95,"kind":"irs_derived_filing","publisher":"ProPublica Nonprofit Explorer","title":"Columbus Partnership Form 990 — fiscal year 2024","uri":"https://projects.propublica.org/nonprofits/organizations/352558300","url":"https://projects.propublica.org/nonprofits/organizations/352558300"}],"summary":"Depth 4 person node identified in current governance, staffing, or filing records.","tags":["wef-columbus","recursive-research","depth-4"],"title":"Jeff Polesovsky","verification":{"status":"source-backed","verified":true},"version":1,"workflow":{"max_depth":6,"recursion_depth":4,"research_status":"completed","root_target_id":"starintel:org:city-of-columbus"}}
{"_id":"starintel:person:jennifer-fennig","assessment":{"confidence":0.94},"data":{"employers":["Smart Columbus"],"full_name":"Jennifer Fennig","name":"Jennifer Fennig","positions":["Director, Marketing Communications, Smart Columbus"]},"dataset":"starintel-wef-columbus-depth-3-2026-07-25","date_added":"2026-07-25T20:30:00Z","date_updated":"2026-07-25T20:30:00Z","dtype":"person","evidence":[],"lineage":{"derived_from":["starintel:research-pass:wef-columbus-depth-2-2026-07-25"],"generation":3},"provenance":{"agent":"GPT-5.6 Thinking","run_id":"wef-columbus-depth-3-2026-07-25","skill":"auto-dig;create-starintel-documents;select-recursive-targets"},"schema_version":"0.9.0","sources":[{"accessed_at":"2026-07-25T20:30:00Z","credibility":0.95,"kind":"official_webpage","publisher":"Official source","title":"Jennifer Fennig","uri":"https://electrificationcoalition.org/resource/accelerate-your-city/","url":"https://electrificationcoalition.org/resource/accelerate-your-city/"}],"summary":"Speaker in Smart Columbus replication programming on regional charging infrastructure.","tags":["wef-columbus","recursive-research","depth-3"],"title":"Jennifer Fennig","verification":{"status":"source-backed","verified":true},"version":1,"workflow":{"max_depth":6,"recursion_depth":3,"research_status":"completed","root_target_id":"starintel:org:city-of-columbus"}}
{"_id":"starintel:person:john-ammendola","assessment":{"confidence":0.93},"data":{"employers":["The Columbus Partnership"],"full_name":"John Ammendola","name":"John Ammendola","positions":["Director, The Columbus Partnership"]},"dataset":"starintel-wef-columbus-depth-4-2026-07-25","date_added":"2026-07-25T21:15:00Z","date_updated":"2026-07-25T21:15:00Z","dtype":"person","evidence":[],"lineage":{"derived_from":["starintel:research-pass:wef-columbus-depth-3-2026-07-25"],"generation":4},"provenance":{"agent":"GPT-5.6 Thinking","run_id":"wef-columbus-depth-4-2026-07-25","skill":"auto-dig;search-starintel-json-db;create-starintel-documents;select-recursive-targets"},"schema_version":"0.9.0","sources":[{"accessed_at":"2026-07-25T21:15:00Z","credibility":0.95,"kind":"irs_derived_filing","publisher":"ProPublica Nonprofit Explorer","title":"The Columbus Partnership Form 990 — fiscal year 2024","uri":"https://projects.propublica.org/nonprofits/organizations/20580058","url":"https://projects.propublica.org/nonprofits/organizations/20580058"}],"summary":"Depth 4 person node identified in current governance, staffing, or filing records.","tags":["wef-columbus","recursive-research","depth-4"],"title":"John Ammendola","verification":{"status":"source-backed","verified":true},"version":1,"workflow":{"max_depth":6,"recursion_depth":4,"research_status":"completed","root_target_id":"starintel:org:city-of-columbus"}}
{"_id":"starintel:person:john-keeling","assessment":{"confidence":0.93},"data":{"employers":["Columbus Partnership"],"full_name":"John Keeling","name":"John Keeling","positions":["Director of Communications, Columbus Partnership"]},"dataset":"starintel-wef-columbus-depth-4-2026-07-25","date_added":"2026-07-25T21:15:00Z","date_updated":"2026-07-25T21:15:00Z","dtype":"person","evidence":[],"lineage":{"derived_from":["starintel:research-pass:wef-columbus-depth-3-2026-07-25"],"generation":4},"provenance":{"agent":"GPT-5.6 Thinking","run_id":"wef-columbus-depth-4-2026-07-25","skill":"auto-dig;search-starintel-json-db;create-starintel-documents;select-recursive-targets"},"schema_version":"0.9.0","sources":[{"accessed_at":"2026-07-25T21:15:00Z","credibility":0.95,"kind":"irs_derived_filing","publisher":"ProPublica Nonprofit Explorer","title":"Columbus Partnership Form 990 — fiscal year 2024","uri":"https://projects.propublica.org/nonprofits/organizations/352558300","url":"https://projects.propublica.org/nonprofits/organizations/352558300"}],"summary":"Depth 4 person node identified in current governance, staffing, or filing records.","tags":["wef-columbus","recursive-research","depth-4"],"title":"John Keeling","verification":{"status":"source-backed","verified":true},"version":1,"workflow":{"max_depth":6,"recursion_depth":4,"research_status":"completed","root_target_id":"starintel:org:city-of-columbus"}}
{"_id":"starintel:person:jordan-davis","aliases":[],"assessment":{"confidence":0.99},"attachments":[],"data":{"name":"Jordan Davis"},"dataset":"starintel-wef-columbus-urban-transformation-2026-07-25","date_added":"2026-07-25T00:00:00Z","date_updated":"2026-07-25T00:00:00Z","description":"","dtype":"person","evidence":[],"extensions":{"legacy.v0":{"data":{"confidence":0.99,"roles":[{"organization":"starintel:org:smart-columbus","title":"Executive Director"},{"organization":"starintel:org:world-economic-forum","title":"Task Force Member"}]}}},"geospatial":{},"handling":{"pii":false,"sensitive":false,"visibility":"public"},"identifiers":[],"keywords":[],"labels":[],"language":"en","lineage":{"migration_from":"0.8","migration_notes":["Normalized into the canonical StarIntel v0.9.0 document envelope."]},"notes":[],"provenance":{"original_id":"starintel:person:jordan-davis","original_path":"digs/wef-columbus/2026-07-25-urban-transformation-network/starintel-documents.jsonl","original_schema_version":"0.8","software_version":"0.9.0","transform":"starintel_doc.migration.migrate_document"},"quality":{},"related_ids":[],"schema_version":"0.9.0","sources":[{"accessed_at":"2026-07-25T00:00:00Z","metadata":{"source_type":"official_project"},"title":"Implementing a Life-Cycle Approach to Infrastructure","uri":"https://centres.weforum.org/centre-for-urban-transformation/infrastructure-lifecycle","url":"https://centres.weforum.org/centre-for-urban-transformation/infrastructure-lifecycle"}],"status":"recorded","summary":"Listed by WEF as Executive Director of Smart Columbus and a member of its city-infrastructure policy-roadmap task force.","tags":[],"temporal":{},"title":"Jordan Davis","verification":{"status":"confirmed"},"version":1,"workflow":{}}
{"_id":"starintel:person:karina-sanchez","assessment":{"confidence":0.93},"data":{"employers":["Smart Columbus"],"full_name":"Karina Sanchez","name":"Karina Sanchez","positions":["Research Assistant"]},"dataset":"starintel-wef-columbus-depth-4-2026-07-25","date_added":"2026-07-25T21:15:00Z","date_updated":"2026-07-25T21:15:00Z","dtype":"person","evidence":[],"lineage":{"derived_from":["starintel:research-pass:wef-columbus-depth-3-2026-07-25"],"generation":4},"provenance":{"agent":"GPT-5.6 Thinking","run_id":"wef-columbus-depth-4-2026-07-25","skill":"auto-dig;search-starintel-json-db;create-starintel-documents;select-recursive-targets"},"schema_version":"0.9.0","sources":[{"accessed_at":"2026-07-25T21:15:00Z","credibility":0.95,"kind":"official_webpage","publisher":"Smart Columbus","title":"Smart Columbus — About","uri":"https://smartcolumbus.com/about","url":"https://smartcolumbus.com/about"}],"summary":"Depth 4 person node identified in current governance, staffing, or filing records.","tags":["wef-columbus","recursive-research","depth-4"],"title":"Karina Sanchez","verification":{"status":"source-backed","verified":true},"version":1,"workflow":{"max_depth":6,"recursion_depth":4,"research_status":"completed","root_target_id":"starintel:org:city-of-columbus"}}
{"_id":"starintel:person:ken-wilson","assessment":{"confidence":0.94},"data":{"employers":["Franklin County","Smart Columbus"],"full_name":"Ken Wilson","name":"Ken Wilson","positions":["County Administrator, Franklin County","Smart Columbus board member"]},"dataset":"starintel-wef-columbus-depth-3-2026-07-25","date_added":"2026-07-25T20:30:00Z","date_updated":"2026-07-25T20:30:00Z","dtype":"person","evidence":[],"lineage":{"derived_from":["starintel:research-pass:wef-columbus-depth-2-2026-07-25"],"generation":3},"provenance":{"agent":"GPT-5.6 Thinking","run_id":"wef-columbus-depth-3-2026-07-25","skill":"auto-dig;create-starintel-documents;select-recursive-targets"},"schema_version":"0.9.0","sources":[{"accessed_at":"2026-07-25T20:30:00Z","credibility":0.95,"kind":"official_webpage","publisher":"Official source","title":"Ken Wilson","uri":"https://smartcolumbus.com/about","url":"https://smartcolumbus.com/about"}],"summary":"Franklin County administrator serving on the Smart Columbus board.","tags":["wef-columbus","recursive-research","depth-3"],"title":"Ken Wilson","verification":{"status":"source-backed","verified":true},"version":1,"workflow":{"max_depth":6,"recursion_depth":3,"research_status":"completed","root_target_id":"starintel:org:city-of-columbus"}}
{"_id":"starintel:person:kenneth-d-mcdonald","assessment":{"confidence":0.93},"data":{"employers":["Columbus Partnership"],"full_name":"Kenneth D. McDonald","name":"Kenneth D. McDonald","positions":["President and CEO, Columbus Partnership"]},"dataset":"starintel-wef-columbus-depth-4-2026-07-25","date_added":"2026-07-25T21:15:00Z","date_updated":"2026-07-25T21:15:00Z","dtype":"person","evidence":[],"lineage":{"derived_from":["starintel:research-pass:wef-columbus-depth-3-2026-07-25"],"generation":4},"provenance":{"agent":"GPT-5.6 Thinking","run_id":"wef-columbus-depth-4-2026-07-25","skill":"auto-dig;search-starintel-json-db;create-starintel-documents;select-recursive-targets"},"schema_version":"0.9.0","sources":[{"accessed_at":"2026-07-25T21:15:00Z","credibility":0.95,"kind":"irs_derived_filing","publisher":"ProPublica Nonprofit Explorer","title":"Columbus Partnership Form 990 — fiscal year 2024","uri":"https://projects.propublica.org/nonprofits/organizations/352558300","url":"https://projects.propublica.org/nonprofits/organizations/352558300"}],"summary":"Depth 4 person node identified in current governance, staffing, or filing records.","tags":["wef-columbus","recursive-research","depth-4"],"title":"Kenneth D. McDonald","verification":{"status":"source-backed","verified":true},"version":1,"workflow":{"max_depth":6,"recursion_depth":4,"research_status":"completed","root_target_id":"starintel:org:city-of-columbus"}}
{"_id":"starintel:person:marcus-carano","assessment":{"confidence":0.92},"data":{"employers":["starintel:org:smart-columbus"],"full_name":"Marcus Carano","name":"Marcus Carano","positions":["Project Manager"]},"dataset":"wef","date_added":"2026-07-26T04:05:00Z","date_updated":"2026-07-26T04:05:00Z","dtype":"person","evidence":[],"lineage":{"derived_from":["starintel:analysis:wef-columbus-depth-4-governance-replication-continuity"],"generation":5},"provenance":{"agent":"GPT-5.6 Thinking","method":"Primary-source recursive OSINT with bounded inference","run_id":"wef-columbus-depth-5-2026-07-26","skill":"auto-dig;web-research;create-starintel-documents;select-recursive-targets"},"schema_version":"0.9.0","sources":[{"accessed_at":"2026-07-26T04:05:00Z","credibility":0.95,"kind":"official_webpage","publisher":"Smart Columbus","title":"Columbus leads the way: Evolving our Green IT ambition","uri":"https://smartcolumbus.com/insights/2025-10-cie-vendor-announcement-83p85","url":"https://smartcolumbus.com/insights/2025-10-cie-vendor-announcement-83p85"}],"summary":"Smart Columbus project manager identified as a Green IT Playbook contributor.","tags":["wef","columbus","recursive-research","depth-5"],"title":"Marcus Carano","verification":{"status":"source-backed","verified":true},"version":1,"workflow":{"max_depth":6,"recursion_depth":5,"research_status":"completed","root_target_id":"starintel:org:city-of-columbus"}}
{"_id":"starintel:person:mark-patton","assessment":{"confidence":0.93},"data":{"employers":["Columbus Partnership","Smart Columbus"],"full_name":"Mark Patton","name":"Mark Patton","positions":["Vice President, New Business","Former Vice President, Smart Columbus"]},"dataset":"starintel-wef-columbus-depth-4-2026-07-25","date_added":"2026-07-25T21:15:00Z","date_updated":"2026-07-25T21:15:00Z","dtype":"person","evidence":[],"lineage":{"derived_from":["starintel:research-pass:wef-columbus-depth-3-2026-07-25"],"generation":4},"provenance":{"agent":"GPT-5.6 Thinking","run_id":"wef-columbus-depth-4-2026-07-25","skill":"auto-dig;search-starintel-json-db;create-starintel-documents;select-recursive-targets"},"schema_version":"0.9.0","sources":[{"accessed_at":"2026-07-25T21:15:00Z","credibility":0.95,"kind":"irs_derived_filing","publisher":"ProPublica Nonprofit Explorer","title":"Columbus Partnership Form 990 — fiscal year 2024","uri":"https://projects.propublica.org/nonprofits/organizations/352558300","url":"https://projects.propublica.org/nonprofits/organizations/352558300"}],"summary":"Depth 4 person node identified in current governance, staffing, or filing records.","tags":["wef-columbus","recursive-research","depth-4"],"title":"Mark Patton","verification":{"status":"source-backed","verified":true},"version":1,"workflow":{"max_depth":6,"recursion_depth":4,"research_status":"completed","root_target_id":"starintel:org:city-of-columbus"}}
{"_id":"starintel:person:matt-stephens-rich","assessment":{"confidence":0.94},"data":{"employers":["Electrification Coalition","Smart Columbus"],"full_name":"Matt Stephens-Rich","name":"Matt Stephens-Rich","positions":["Director of Programs, Electrification Coalition","Former Smart Columbus EV Specialist"]},"dataset":"starintel-wef-columbus-depth-3-2026-07-25","date_added":"2026-07-25T20:30:00Z","date_updated":"2026-07-25T20:30:00Z","dtype":"person","evidence":[],"lineage":{"derived_from":["starintel:research-pass:wef-columbus-depth-2-2026-07-25"],"generation":3},"provenance":{"agent":"GPT-5.6 Thinking","run_id":"wef-columbus-depth-3-2026-07-25","skill":"auto-dig;create-starintel-documents;select-recursive-targets"},"schema_version":"0.9.0","sources":[{"accessed_at":"2026-07-25T20:30:00Z","credibility":0.95,"kind":"official_webpage","publisher":"Official source","title":"Matt Stephens-Rich","uri":"https://electrificationcoalition.org/our-team/","url":"https://electrificationcoalition.org/our-team/"}],"summary":"Worked in Smart Columbus electrification and helped write the Smart City Challenge application.","tags":["wef-columbus","recursive-research","depth-3"],"title":"Matt Stephens-Rich","verification":{"status":"source-backed","verified":true},"version":1,"workflow":{"max_depth":6,"recursion_depth":3,"research_status":"completed","root_target_id":"starintel:org:city-of-columbus"}}
{"_id":"starintel:person:mike-anderson","assessment":{"confidence":0.93},"data":{"employers":["Smart Columbus"],"full_name":"Mike Anderson","name":"Mike Anderson","positions":["CIE Delivery Lead"]},"dataset":"starintel-wef-columbus-depth-4-2026-07-25","date_added":"2026-07-25T21:15:00Z","date_updated":"2026-07-25T21:15:00Z","dtype":"person","evidence":[],"lineage":{"derived_from":["starintel:research-pass:wef-columbus-depth-3-2026-07-25"],"generation":4},"provenance":{"agent":"GPT-5.6 Thinking","run_id":"wef-columbus-depth-4-2026-07-25","skill":"auto-dig;search-starintel-json-db;create-starintel-documents;select-recursive-targets"},"schema_version":"0.9.0","sources":[{"accessed_at":"2026-07-25T21:15:00Z","credibility":0.95,"kind":"official_webpage","publisher":"Smart Columbus","title":"Smart Columbus — About","uri":"https://smartcolumbus.com/about","url":"https://smartcolumbus.com/about"}],"summary":"Depth 4 person node identified in current governance, staffing, or filing records.","tags":["wef-columbus","recursive-research","depth-4"],"title":"Mike Anderson","verification":{"status":"source-backed","verified":true},"version":1,"workflow":{"max_depth":6,"recursion_depth":4,"research_status":"completed","root_target_id":"starintel:org:city-of-columbus"}}
{"_id":"starintel:person:natalia-swalnick","assessment":{"confidence":0.94},"data":{"employers":["Electrification Coalition"],"full_name":"Natalia Swalnick","name":"Natalia Swalnick","positions":["Former Senior Director of EV Programs, Electrification Coalition"]},"dataset":"starintel-wef-columbus-depth-3-2026-07-25","date_added":"2026-07-25T20:30:00Z","date_updated":"2026-07-25T20:30:00Z","dtype":"person","evidence":[],"lineage":{"derived_from":["starintel:research-pass:wef-columbus-depth-2-2026-07-25"],"generation":3},"provenance":{"agent":"GPT-5.6 Thinking","run_id":"wef-columbus-depth-3-2026-07-25","skill":"auto-dig;create-starintel-documents;select-recursive-targets"},"schema_version":"0.9.0","sources":[{"accessed_at":"2026-07-25T20:30:00Z","credibility":0.95,"kind":"official_webpage","publisher":"Official source","title":"Natalia Swalnick","uri":"https://electrificationcoalition.org/resource/accelerate-your-city/","url":"https://electrificationcoalition.org/resource/accelerate-your-city/"}],"summary":"Electrification Coalition speaker in Smart Columbus replication programming.","tags":["wef-columbus","recursive-research","depth-3"],"title":"Natalia Swalnick","verification":{"status":"source-backed","verified":true},"version":1,"workflow":{"max_depth":6,"recursion_depth":3,"research_status":"completed","root_target_id":"starintel:org:city-of-columbus"}}
{"_id":"starintel:person:norah-goldman","assessment":{"confidence":0.93},"data":{"employers":["Smart Columbus"],"full_name":"Norah Goldman","name":"Norah Goldman","positions":["Communications Lead"]},"dataset":"starintel-wef-columbus-depth-4-2026-07-25","date_added":"2026-07-25T21:15:00Z","date_updated":"2026-07-25T21:15:00Z","dtype":"person","evidence":[],"lineage":{"derived_from":["starintel:research-pass:wef-columbus-depth-3-2026-07-25"],"generation":4},"provenance":{"agent":"GPT-5.6 Thinking","run_id":"wef-columbus-depth-4-2026-07-25","skill":"auto-dig;search-starintel-json-db;create-starintel-documents;select-recursive-targets"},"schema_version":"0.9.0","sources":[{"accessed_at":"2026-07-25T21:15:00Z","credibility":0.95,"kind":"official_webpage","publisher":"Smart Columbus","title":"Smart Columbus — About","uri":"https://smartcolumbus.com/about","url":"https://smartcolumbus.com/about"}],"summary":"Depth 4 person node identified in current governance, staffing, or filing records.","tags":["wef-columbus","recursive-research","depth-4"],"title":"Norah Goldman","verification":{"status":"source-backed","verified":true},"version":1,"workflow":{"max_depth":6,"recursion_depth":4,"research_status":"completed","root_target_id":"starintel:org:city-of-columbus"}}
{"_id":"starintel:person:paige-hollowell","assessment":{"confidence":0.93},"data":{"employers":["Smart Columbus"],"full_name":"Paige Hollowell","name":"Paige Hollowell","positions":["Author, Smart City Grant Era Reports index"]},"dataset":"starintel-wef-columbus-depth-4-2026-07-25","date_added":"2026-07-25T21:15:00Z","date_updated":"2026-07-25T21:15:00Z","dtype":"person","evidence":[],"lineage":{"derived_from":["starintel:research-pass:wef-columbus-depth-3-2026-07-25"],"generation":4},"provenance":{"agent":"GPT-5.6 Thinking","run_id":"wef-columbus-depth-4-2026-07-25","skill":"auto-dig;search-starintel-json-db;create-starintel-documents;select-recursive-targets"},"schema_version":"0.9.0","sources":[{"accessed_at":"2026-07-25T21:15:00Z","credibility":0.95,"kind":"official_webpage","publisher":"Smart Columbus","title":"Smart City Grant Era Reports","uri":"https://smartcolumbus.com/insights/smart-city-grant-era-reports","url":"https://smartcolumbus.com/insights/smart-city-grant-era-reports"}],"summary":"Depth 4 person node identified in current governance, staffing, or filing records.","tags":["wef-columbus","recursive-research","depth-4"],"title":"Paige Hollowell","verification":{"status":"source-backed","verified":true},"version":1,"workflow":{"max_depth":6,"recursion_depth":4,"research_status":"completed","root_target_id":"starintel:org:city-of-columbus"}}
{"_id":"starintel:person:scott-jaffee","assessment":{"confidence":0.94},"data":{"employers":["GPD Group"],"full_name":"Scott Jaffee","name":"Scott Jaffee","positions":["Project Engineer, GPD Group"]},"dataset":"starintel-wef-columbus-depth-3-2026-07-25","date_added":"2026-07-25T20:30:00Z","date_updated":"2026-07-25T20:30:00Z","dtype":"person","evidence":[],"lineage":{"derived_from":["starintel:research-pass:wef-columbus-depth-2-2026-07-25"],"generation":3},"provenance":{"agent":"GPT-5.6 Thinking","run_id":"wef-columbus-depth-3-2026-07-25","skill":"auto-dig;create-starintel-documents;select-recursive-targets"},"schema_version":"0.9.0","sources":[{"accessed_at":"2026-07-25T20:30:00Z","credibility":0.95,"kind":"official_webpage","publisher":"Official source","title":"Scott Jaffee","uri":"https://electrificationcoalition.org/resource/accelerate-your-city/","url":"https://electrificationcoalition.org/resource/accelerate-your-city/"}],"summary":"GPD Group engineer appearing in Smart Columbus replication programming.","tags":["wef-columbus","recursive-research","depth-3"],"title":"Scott Jaffee","verification":{"status":"source-backed","verified":true},"version":1,"workflow":{"max_depth":6,"recursion_depth":3,"research_status":"completed","root_target_id":"starintel:org:city-of-columbus"}}
{"_id":"starintel:person:sean-grant","assessment":{"confidence":0.93},"data":{"employers":["Columbus Partnership"],"full_name":"Sean Grant","name":"Sean Grant","positions":["Chief Administrative Officer, Columbus Partnership"]},"dataset":"starintel-wef-columbus-depth-4-2026-07-25","date_added":"2026-07-25T21:15:00Z","date_updated":"2026-07-25T21:15:00Z","dtype":"person","evidence":[],"lineage":{"derived_from":["starintel:research-pass:wef-columbus-depth-3-2026-07-25"],"generation":4},"provenance":{"agent":"GPT-5.6 Thinking","run_id":"wef-columbus-depth-4-2026-07-25","skill":"auto-dig;search-starintel-json-db;create-starintel-documents;select-recursive-targets"},"schema_version":"0.9.0","sources":[{"accessed_at":"2026-07-25T21:15:00Z","credibility":0.95,"kind":"irs_derived_filing","publisher":"ProPublica Nonprofit Explorer","title":"Columbus Partnership Form 990 — fiscal year 2024","uri":"https://projects.propublica.org/nonprofits/organizations/352558300","url":"https://projects.propublica.org/nonprofits/organizations/352558300"}],"summary":"Depth 4 person node identified in current governance, staffing, or filing records.","tags":["wef-columbus","recursive-research","depth-4"],"title":"Sean Grant","verification":{"status":"source-backed","verified":true},"version":1,"workflow":{"max_depth":6,"recursion_depth":4,"research_status":"completed","root_target_id":"starintel:org:city-of-columbus"}}
{"_id":"starintel:person:steve-steinour","assessment":{"confidence":0.93},"data":{"employers":["The Columbus Partnership"],"full_name":"Steve Steinour","name":"Steve Steinour","positions":["Co-Chair, The Columbus Partnership"]},"dataset":"starintel-wef-columbus-depth-4-2026-07-25","date_added":"2026-07-25T21:15:00Z","date_updated":"2026-07-25T21:15:00Z","dtype":"person","evidence":[],"lineage":{"derived_from":["starintel:research-pass:wef-columbus-depth-3-2026-07-25"],"generation":4},"provenance":{"agent":"GPT-5.6 Thinking","run_id":"wef-columbus-depth-4-2026-07-25","skill":"auto-dig;search-starintel-json-db;create-starintel-documents;select-recursive-targets"},"schema_version":"0.9.0","sources":[{"accessed_at":"2026-07-25T21:15:00Z","credibility":0.95,"kind":"irs_derived_filing","publisher":"ProPublica Nonprofit Explorer","title":"The Columbus Partnership Form 990 — fiscal year 2024","uri":"https://projects.propublica.org/nonprofits/organizations/20580058","url":"https://projects.propublica.org/nonprofits/organizations/20580058"}],"summary":"Depth 4 person node identified in current governance, staffing, or filing records.","tags":["wef-columbus","recursive-research","depth-4"],"title":"Steve Steinour","verification":{"status":"source-backed","verified":true},"version":1,"workflow":{"max_depth":6,"recursion_depth":4,"research_status":"completed","root_target_id":"starintel:org:city-of-columbus"}}
{"_id":"starintel:person:tosin-guobadia","assessment":{"confidence":0.93},"data":{"employers":["Smart Columbus"],"full_name":"Tosin Guobadia","name":"Tosin Guobadia","positions":["Project and Change Management Consultant"]},"dataset":"starintel-wef-columbus-depth-4-2026-07-25","date_added":"2026-07-25T21:15:00Z","date_updated":"2026-07-25T21:15:00Z","dtype":"person","evidence":[],"lineage":{"derived_from":["starintel:research-pass:wef-columbus-depth-3-2026-07-25"],"generation":4},"provenance":{"agent":"GPT-5.6 Thinking","run_id":"wef-columbus-depth-4-2026-07-25","skill":"auto-dig;search-starintel-json-db;create-starintel-documents;select-recursive-targets"},"schema_version":"0.9.0","sources":[{"accessed_at":"2026-07-25T21:15:00Z","credibility":0.95,"kind":"official_webpage","publisher":"Smart Columbus","title":"Smart Columbus — About","uri":"https://smartcolumbus.com/about","url":"https://smartcolumbus.com/about"}],"summary":"Depth 4 person node identified in current governance, staffing, or filing records.","tags":["wef-columbus","recursive-research","depth-4"],"title":"Tosin Guobadia","verification":{"status":"source-backed","verified":true},"version":1,"workflow":{"max_depth":6,"recursion_depth":4,"research_status":"completed","root_target_id":"starintel:org:city-of-columbus"}}
{"_id":"starintel:product:urbanos-smart-cities-data-platform","assessment":{"confidence":0.98},"data":{"capabilities":["distributed smart-city data processing","REST API","websocket streams","SQL analytics"],"features":["data ingestion","normalization","transformation","persistence","streaming","data discovery"],"integrations":["Kafka","Kubernetes","S3-compatible object storage","PrestoDB","React"],"manufacturer_id":"starintel:org:urbanos-public","name":"Smart Cities Data Platform","product_type":"open_source_data_platform","technical":{"architecture":"microservices","languages":["Elixir","JavaScript"],"repository":"UrbanOS-Public/smartcitiesdata"},"website":"https://github.com/UrbanOS-Public/smartcitiesdata"},"dataset":"wef","date_added":"2026-07-26T04:05:00Z","date_updated":"2026-07-26T04:05:00Z","dtype":"product","evidence":[],"lineage":{"derived_from":["starintel:analysis:wef-columbus-depth-4-governance-replication-continuity"],"generation":5},"notes":["Public availability is established; downstream adoption by other cities is not established in this pass."],"provenance":{"agent":"GPT-5.6 Thinking","method":"Primary-source recursive OSINT with bounded inference","run_id":"wef-columbus-depth-5-2026-07-26","skill":"auto-dig;web-research;create-starintel-documents;select-recursive-targets"},"schema_version":"0.9.0","sources":[{"accessed_at":"2026-07-26T04:05:00Z","credibility":0.98,"kind":"source_repository","publisher":"UrbanOS-Public","title":"UrbanOS-Public/smartcitiesdata","uri":"https://github.com/UrbanOS-Public/smartcitiesdata","url":"https://github.com/UrbanOS-Public/smartcitiesdata"}],"summary":"Public smart-city data platform built as distributed Elixir services using Kafka, Kubernetes, object storage, PrestoDB, APIs, and a web interface.","tags":["wef","columbus","recursive-research","depth-5"],"title":"UrbanOS Smart Cities Data Platform","verification":{"status":"source-backed","verified":true},"version":1,"workflow":{"max_depth":6,"recursion_depth":5,"research_status":"completed","root_target_id":"starintel:org:city-of-columbus"}}
{"_id":"starintel:relation:andhealth-financing-francisco-health2047","assessment":{"confidence":0.99},"data":{"confidence":0.99,"directed":true,"object":["starintel:org:francisco-partners","starintel:org:health2047"],"predicate":"financed_by","qualifiers":{"announced_amount_usd":57000000},"subject":"starintel:org:andhealth"},"dataset":"starintel-wef-columbus-depth-3-2026-07-25","date_added":"2026-07-25T20:30:00Z","date_updated":"2026-07-25T20:30:00Z","dtype":"relation","evidence":[],"lineage":{"derived_from":["starintel:research-pass:wef-columbus-depth-2-2026-07-25"],"generation":3},"provenance":{"agent":"GPT-5.6 Thinking","run_id":"wef-columbus-depth-3-2026-07-25","skill":"auto-dig;create-starintel-documents;select-recursive-targets"},"schema_version":"0.9.0","sources":[{"accessed_at":"2026-07-25T20:30:00Z","credibility":0.95,"kind":"official_webpage","publisher":"Official source","title":"AndHealth received financing from Francisco Partners and Health2047","uri":"https://andhealth.com/andhealth-digital-health-company-reversing-migraine-autoimmune-diseases-raises-57-million/","url":"https://andhealth.com/andhealth-digital-health-company-reversing-migraine-autoimmune-diseases-raises-57-million/"}],"summary":"AndHealth announced more than $57 million led by Francisco Partners with Health2047 participation.","tags":["wef-columbus","recursive-research","depth-3"],"title":"AndHealth received financing from Francisco Partners and Health2047","verification":{"status":"source-backed","verified":true},"version":1,"workflow":{"max_depth":6,"recursion_depth":3,"research_status":"completed","root_target_id":"starintel:org:city-of-columbus"}}
{"_id":"starintel:relation:andreya-veintimilla-smart-columbus-team","assessment":{"confidence":0.99},"data":{"confidence":0.99,"directed":true,"object":"starintel:org:smart-columbus","predicate":"team_member_of","qualifiers":{"position":"Design Research Lead"},"subject":"starintel:person:andreya-veintimilla"},"dataset":"starintel-wef-columbus-depth-4-2026-07-25","date_added":"2026-07-25T21:15:00Z","date_updated":"2026-07-25T21:15:00Z","dtype":"relation","evidence":[],"lineage":{"derived_from":["starintel:research-pass:wef-columbus-depth-3-2026-07-25"],"generation":4},"provenance":{"agent":"GPT-5.6 Thinking","run_id":"wef-columbus-depth-4-2026-07-25","skill":"auto-dig;search-starintel-json-db;create-starintel-documents;select-recursive-targets"},"schema_version":"0.9.0","sources":[{"accessed_at":"2026-07-25T21:15:00Z","credibility":0.95,"kind":"official_webpage","publisher":"Smart Columbus","title":"Smart Columbus — About","uri":"https://smartcolumbus.com/about","url":"https://smartcolumbus.com/about"}],"summary":"Smart Columbus lists Andreya Veintimilla as Design Research Lead.","tags":["wef-columbus","recursive-research","depth-4"],"title":"Andreya Veintimilla is listed on the Smart Columbus team","verification":{"status":"source-backed","verified":true},"version":1,"workflow":{"max_depth":6,"recursion_depth":4,"research_status":"completed","root_target_id":"starintel:org:city-of-columbus"}}
{"_id":"starintel:relation:arash-ghazvini-smart-columbus-team","assessment":{"confidence":0.99},"data":{"confidence":0.99,"directed":true,"object":"starintel:org:smart-columbus","predicate":"team_member_of","qualifiers":{"position":"Principal Product Manager"},"subject":"starintel:person:arash-ghazvini"},"dataset":"starintel-wef-columbus-depth-4-2026-07-25","date_added":"2026-07-25T21:15:00Z","date_updated":"2026-07-25T21:15:00Z","dtype":"relation","evidence":[],"lineage":{"derived_from":["starintel:research-pass:wef-columbus-depth-3-2026-07-25"],"generation":4},"provenance":{"agent":"GPT-5.6 Thinking","run_id":"wef-columbus-depth-4-2026-07-25","skill":"auto-dig;search-starintel-json-db;create-starintel-documents;select-recursive-targets"},"schema_version":"0.9.0","sources":[{"accessed_at":"2026-07-25T21:15:00Z","credibility":0.95,"kind":"official_webpage","publisher":"Smart Columbus","title":"Smart Columbus — About","uri":"https://smartcolumbus.com/about","url":"https://smartcolumbus.com/about"}],"summary":"Smart Columbus lists Arash Ghazvini as Principal Product Manager.","tags":["wef-columbus","recursive-research","depth-4"],"title":"Arash Ghazvini is listed on the Smart Columbus team","verification":{"status":"source-backed","verified":true},"version":1,"workflow":{"max_depth":6,"recursion_depth":4,"research_status":"completed","root_target_id":"starintel:org:city-of-columbus"}}
{"_id":"starintel:relation:ayaz-hyder-smart-columbus-team","assessment":{"confidence":0.99},"data":{"confidence":0.99,"directed":true,"object":"starintel:org:smart-columbus","predicate":"team_member_of","qualifiers":{"position":"Data & Integrations Lead"},"subject":"starintel:person:ayaz-hyder"},"dataset":"starintel-wef-columbus-depth-4-2026-07-25","date_added":"2026-07-25T21:15:00Z","date_updated":"2026-07-25T21:15:00Z","dtype":"relation","evidence":[],"lineage":{"derived_from":["starintel:research-pass:wef-columbus-depth-3-2026-07-25"],"generation":4},"provenance":{"agent":"GPT-5.6 Thinking","run_id":"wef-columbus-depth-4-2026-07-25","skill":"auto-dig;search-starintel-json-db;create-starintel-documents;select-recursive-targets"},"schema_version":"0.9.0","sources":[{"accessed_at":"2026-07-25T21:15:00Z","credibility":0.95,"kind":"official_webpage","publisher":"Smart Columbus","title":"Smart Columbus — About","uri":"https://smartcolumbus.com/about","url":"https://smartcolumbus.com/about"}],"summary":"Smart Columbus lists Ayaz Hyder as Data & Integrations Lead.","tags":["wef-columbus","recursive-research","depth-4"],"title":"Ayaz Hyder is listed on the Smart Columbus team","verification":{"status":"source-backed","verified":true},"version":1,"workflow":{"max_depth":6,"recursion_depth":4,"research_status":"completed","root_target_id":"starintel:org:city-of-columbus"}}
{"_id":"starintel:relation:ben-blanquera-employed-by-rackspace","assessment":{"confidence":0.92},"data":{"confidence":0.92,"directed":true,"object":"starintel:org:rackspace-technology","predicate":"employed_by","subject":"starintel:person:ben-blanquera"},"dataset":"wef","date_added":"2026-07-26T04:05:00Z","date_updated":"2026-07-26T04:05:00Z","dtype":"relation","evidence":[],"lineage":{"derived_from":["starintel:analysis:wef-columbus-depth-4-governance-replication-continuity"],"generation":5},"provenance":{"agent":"GPT-5.6 Thinking","method":"Primary-source recursive OSINT with bounded inference","run_id":"wef-columbus-depth-5-2026-07-26","skill":"auto-dig;web-research;create-starintel-documents;select-recursive-targets"},"schema_version":"0.9.0","sources":[{"accessed_at":"2026-07-26T04:05:00Z","credibility":0.95,"kind":"official_webpage","publisher":"Smart Columbus","title":"Columbus leads the way: Evolving our Green IT ambition","uri":"https://smartcolumbus.com/insights/2025-10-cie-vendor-announcement-83p85","url":"https://smartcolumbus.com/insights/2025-10-cie-vendor-announcement-83p85"}],"summary":"The Green IT publication identifies Ben Blanquera as a Rackspace AI and sustainability executive.","tags":["wef","columbus","recursive-research","depth-5"],"title":"Ben Blanquera employed by Rackspace Technology","verification":{"status":"source-backed","verified":true},"version":1,"workflow":{"max_depth":6,"recursion_depth":5,"research_status":"completed","root_target_id":"starintel:org:city-of-columbus"}}
{"_id":"starintel:relation:brayan-pabon-gomez-smart-columbus-team","assessment":{"confidence":0.99},"data":{"confidence":0.99,"directed":true,"object":"starintel:org:smart-columbus","predicate":"team_member_of","qualifiers":{"position":"Service Designer"},"subject":"starintel:person:brayan-pabon-gomez"},"dataset":"starintel-wef-columbus-depth-4-2026-07-25","date_added":"2026-07-25T21:15:00Z","date_updated":"2026-07-25T21:15:00Z","dtype":"relation","evidence":[],"lineage":{"derived_from":["starintel:research-pass:wef-columbus-depth-3-2026-07-25"],"generation":4},"provenance":{"agent":"GPT-5.6 Thinking","run_id":"wef-columbus-depth-4-2026-07-25","skill":"auto-dig;search-starintel-json-db;create-starintel-documents;select-recursive-targets"},"schema_version":"0.9.0","sources":[{"accessed_at":"2026-07-25T21:15:00Z","credibility":0.95,"kind":"official_webpage","publisher":"Smart Columbus","title":"Smart Columbus — About","uri":"https://smartcolumbus.com/about","url":"https://smartcolumbus.com/about"}],"summary":"Smart Columbus lists Brayan Pabón Gomez as Service Designer.","tags":["wef-columbus","recursive-research","depth-4"],"title":"Brayan Pabón Gomez is listed on the Smart Columbus team","verification":{"status":"source-backed","verified":true},"version":1,"workflow":{"max_depth":6,"recursion_depth":4,"research_status":"completed","root_target_id":"starintel:org:city-of-columbus"}}
{"_id":"starintel:relation:bread-financial-implemented-green-it-playbook","assessment":{"confidence":0.97},"data":{"confidence":0.97,"directed":true,"object":"starintel:media:columbus-green-it-playbook-2-0-2025","predicate":"implemented_framework_from","subject":"starintel:org:bread-financial"},"dataset":"wef","date_added":"2026-07-26T04:05:00Z","date_updated":"2026-07-26T04:05:00Z","dtype":"relation","evidence":[],"lineage":{"derived_from":["starintel:analysis:wef-columbus-depth-4-governance-replication-continuity"],"generation":5},"provenance":{"agent":"GPT-5.6 Thinking","method":"Primary-source recursive OSINT with bounded inference","run_id":"wef-columbus-depth-5-2026-07-26","skill":"auto-dig;web-research;create-starintel-documents;select-recursive-targets"},"schema_version":"0.9.0","sources":[{"accessed_at":"2026-07-26T04:05:00Z","credibility":0.95,"kind":"official_webpage","publisher":"Smart Columbus","title":"A year of impact: 2025 by the numbers","uri":"https://smartcolumbus.com/insights/2025-12-year-of-impact","url":"https://smartcolumbus.com/insights/2025-12-year-of-impact"}],"summary":"Smart Columbus states Bread Financial used the playbook to develop a Sustainable Technology Framework embedding sustainability criteria into capabilities and vendor selection.","tags":["wef","columbus","recursive-research","depth-5"],"title":"Bread Financial implemented the Green IT Playbook","verification":{"status":"source-backed","verified":true},"version":1,"workflow":{"max_depth":6,"recursion_depth":5,"research_status":"completed","root_target_id":"starintel:org:city-of-columbus"}}
{"_id":"starintel:relation:calvin-cooper-board-roster-identity-change","assessment":{"confidence":0.98},"data":{"confidence":0.98,"directed":true,"object":["starintel:org:rhove","starintel:org:vend3tta"],"predicate":"represented_organization_changed_on_roster","qualifiers":{},"subject":"starintel:person:calvin-cooper"},"dataset":"starintel-wef-columbus-depth-3-2026-07-25","date_added":"2026-07-25T20:30:00Z","date_updated":"2026-07-25T20:30:00Z","dtype":"relation","evidence":[],"lineage":{"derived_from":["starintel:research-pass:wef-columbus-depth-2-2026-07-25"],"generation":3},"provenance":{"agent":"GPT-5.6 Thinking","run_id":"wef-columbus-depth-3-2026-07-25","skill":"auto-dig;create-starintel-documents;select-recursive-targets"},"schema_version":"0.9.0","sources":[{"accessed_at":"2026-07-25T20:30:00Z","credibility":0.95,"kind":"official_webpage","publisher":"Official source","title":"Calvin Cooper board affiliation changed across official rosters","uri":"https://smartcolumbus.com/about","url":"https://smartcolumbus.com/about"},{"accessed_at":"2026-07-25T20:30:00Z","credibility":0.95,"kind":"official_webpage","publisher":"Official source","title":"Calvin Cooper board affiliation changed across official rosters","uri":"https://columbusregion.com/about-us/boards-investors/smart-columbus-board/","url":"https://columbusregion.com/about-us/boards-investors/smart-columbus-board/"}],"summary":"Current roster says Vend3tta; legacy Columbus Region roster says Rhove.","tags":["wef-columbus","recursive-research","depth-3"],"title":"Calvin Cooper board affiliation changed across official rosters","verification":{"status":"source-backed","verified":true},"version":1,"workflow":{"max_depth":6,"recursion_depth":3,"research_status":"completed","root_target_id":"starintel:org:city-of-columbus"}}
{"_id":"starintel:relation:cami-albaugh-smart-columbus-team","assessment":{"confidence":0.99},"data":{"confidence":0.99,"directed":true,"object":"starintel:org:smart-columbus","predicate":"team_member_of","qualifiers":{"position":"Operations & Communications Coordinator"},"subject":"starintel:person:cami-albaugh"},"dataset":"starintel-wef-columbus-depth-4-2026-07-25","date_added":"2026-07-25T21:15:00Z","date_updated":"2026-07-25T21:15:00Z","dtype":"relation","evidence":[],"lineage":{"derived_from":["starintel:research-pass:wef-columbus-depth-3-2026-07-25"],"generation":4},"provenance":{"agent":"GPT-5.6 Thinking","run_id":"wef-columbus-depth-4-2026-07-25","skill":"auto-dig;search-starintel-json-db;create-starintel-documents;select-recursive-targets"},"schema_version":"0.9.0","sources":[{"accessed_at":"2026-07-25T21:15:00Z","credibility":0.95,"kind":"official_webpage","publisher":"Smart Columbus","title":"Smart Columbus — About","uri":"https://smartcolumbus.com/about","url":"https://smartcolumbus.com/about"}],"summary":"Smart Columbus lists Cami Albaugh as Operations & Communications Coordinator.","tags":["wef-columbus","recursive-research","depth-4"],"title":"Cami Albaugh is listed on the Smart Columbus team","verification":{"status":"source-backed","verified":true},"version":1,"workflow":{"max_depth":6,"recursion_depth":4,"research_status":"completed","root_target_id":"starintel:org:city-of-columbus"}}
{"_id":"starintel:relation:city-authorized-andhealth-downtown-office-incentive","assessment":{"confidence":0.99},"data":{"confidence":0.99,"directed":true,"object":"starintel:org:andhealth","predicate":"authorized_incentive_agreement_with","qualifiers":{"contract_id":"starintel:contract:andhealth-columbus-downtown-office-incentive-2022"},"subject":"starintel:org:city-of-columbus"},"dataset":"wef","date_added":"2026-07-26T04:05:00Z","date_updated":"2026-07-26T04:05:00Z","dtype":"relation","evidence":[],"lineage":{"derived_from":["starintel:analysis:wef-columbus-depth-4-governance-replication-continuity"],"generation":5},"provenance":{"agent":"GPT-5.6 Thinking","method":"Primary-source recursive OSINT with bounded inference","run_id":"wef-columbus-depth-5-2026-07-26","skill":"auto-dig;web-research;create-starintel-documents;select-recursive-targets"},"schema_version":"0.9.0","sources":[{"accessed_at":"2026-07-26T04:05:00Z","credibility":0.99,"kind":"government_record","publisher":"City of Columbus","title":"Columbus Ordinance 2014-2022","uri":"https://columbus.legistar.com/LegislationDetail.aspx?GUID=8A04AD26-94FE-4964-BCCC-44203F01D559&ID=5726301&Options=&Search=","url":"https://columbus.legistar.com/LegislationDetail.aspx?GUID=8A04AD26-94FE-4964-BCCC-44203F01D559&ID=5726301&Options=&Search="}],"summary":"Ordinance 2014-2022 authorized the City development director to enter the agreement.","tags":["wef","columbus","recursive-research","depth-5"],"title":"Columbus authorized an AndHealth Downtown Office Incentive agreement","verification":{"status":"source-backed","verified":true},"version":1,"workflow":{"max_depth":6,"recursion_depth":5,"research_status":"completed","root_target_id":"starintel:org:city-of-columbus"}}
{"_id":"starintel:relation:city-authorized-andhealth-incentive-payment-2024","assessment":{"confidence":0.99},"data":{"confidence":0.99,"directed":true,"object":"starintel:org:andhealth","predicate":"authorized_payment_to","qualifiers":{"amount":47727.97,"currency":"USD","fiscal_year":2024},"subject":"starintel:org:city-of-columbus"},"dataset":"wef","date_added":"2026-07-26T04:05:00Z","date_updated":"2026-07-26T04:05:00Z","dtype":"relation","evidence":[],"lineage":{"derived_from":["starintel:analysis:wef-columbus-depth-4-governance-replication-continuity"],"generation":5},"provenance":{"agent":"GPT-5.6 Thinking","method":"Primary-source recursive OSINT with bounded inference","run_id":"wef-columbus-depth-5-2026-07-26","skill":"auto-dig;web-research;create-starintel-documents;select-recursive-targets"},"schema_version":"0.9.0","sources":[{"accessed_at":"2026-07-26T04:05:00Z","credibility":0.99,"kind":"government_record","notes":"The title and background identify the Downtown Office Incentive program; Section 6 uses Jobs Growth Incentive wording.","publisher":"City of Columbus","title":"Columbus Ordinance 1885-2025","uri":"https://columbus.legistar.com/LegislationDetail.aspx?FullText=1&GUID=DE71F085-A673-490A-93D8-BED794B120CB&ID=7489845&Options=&Search=","url":"https://columbus.legistar.com/LegislationDetail.aspx?FullText=1&GUID=DE71F085-A673-490A-93D8-BED794B120CB&ID=7489845&Options=&Search="}],"summary":"Ordinance 1885-2025 authorized a $47,727.97 payment.","tags":["wef","columbus","recursive-research","depth-5"],"title":"Columbus authorized AndHealth's tax-year 2024 incentive payment","verification":{"status":"source-backed","verified":true},"version":1,"workflow":{"max_depth":6,"recursion_depth":5,"research_status":"completed","root_target_id":"starintel:org:city-of-columbus"}}
{"_id":"starintel:relation:city-columbus-contracted-hntb-smart-lighting","assessment":{"confidence":0.99},"data":{"confidence":0.99,"directed":true,"object":"starintel:org:hntb-ohio","predicate":"contracted","qualifiers":{"authorized_ceiling_usd":1675811.18,"contract_id":"PO321125"},"subject":"starintel:org:city-of-columbus"},"dataset":"starintel-wef-columbus-depth-4-2026-07-25","date_added":"2026-07-25T21:15:00Z","date_updated":"2026-07-25T21:15:00Z","dtype":"relation","evidence":[],"lineage":{"derived_from":["starintel:research-pass:wef-columbus-depth-3-2026-07-25"],"generation":4},"provenance":{"agent":"GPT-5.6 Thinking","run_id":"wef-columbus-depth-4-2026-07-25","skill":"auto-dig;search-starintel-json-db;create-starintel-documents;select-recursive-targets"},"schema_version":"0.9.0","sources":[{"accessed_at":"2026-07-25T21:15:00Z","credibility":0.95,"kind":"government_record","publisher":"City of Columbus","title":"Columbus Ordinance 1424-2026","uri":"https://columbus.legistar.com/LegislationDetail.aspx?FullText=1&GUID=50C99EDC-6138-41FC-A7E1-8672080626A3&ID=8038904","url":"https://columbus.legistar.com/LegislationDetail.aspx?FullText=1&GUID=50C99EDC-6138-41FC-A7E1-8672080626A3&ID=8038904"}],"summary":"The contract lifecycle reached an authorized ceiling of $1,675,811.18 after two modifications.","tags":["wef-columbus","recursive-research","depth-4"],"title":"City of Columbus contracted HNTB for Smart Lighting Phase 4","verification":{"status":"source-backed","verified":true},"version":1,"workflow":{"max_depth":6,"recursion_depth":4,"research_status":"completed","root_target_id":"starintel:org:city-of-columbus"}}
{"_id":"starintel:relation:city-columbus-supported-andhealth-expansion","assessment":{"confidence":0.99},"data":{"confidence":0.99,"directed":true,"object":"starintel:org:andhealth","predicate":"supported_expansion_of","qualifiers":{},"subject":"starintel:org:city-of-columbus"},"dataset":"starintel-wef-columbus-depth-4-2026-07-25","date_added":"2026-07-25T21:15:00Z","date_updated":"2026-07-25T21:15:00Z","dtype":"relation","evidence":[],"lineage":{"derived_from":["starintel:research-pass:wef-columbus-depth-3-2026-07-25"],"generation":4},"provenance":{"agent":"GPT-5.6 Thinking","run_id":"wef-columbus-depth-4-2026-07-25","skill":"auto-dig;search-starintel-json-db;create-starintel-documents;select-recursive-targets"},"schema_version":"0.9.0","sources":[{"accessed_at":"2026-07-25T21:15:00Z","credibility":0.95,"kind":"official_project_record","publisher":"One Columbus","title":"Digital Healthcare Startup AndHealth Brings 65 New Jobs","uri":"https://columbusregion.com/press-release/digital-healthcare-startup-andhealth-brings-65-new-jobs-to-downtown-columbus-for-operations-expansion/","url":"https://columbusregion.com/press-release/digital-healthcare-startup-andhealth-brings-65-new-jobs-to-downtown-columbus-for-operations-expansion/"},{"accessed_at":"2026-07-25T21:15:00Z","credibility":0.95,"kind":"official_project_record","publisher":"JobsOhio","title":"AndHealth Expanding Office Space in Downtown Columbus","uri":"https://www.jobsohio.com/newsroom/news-press/andhealth-expanding-office-space-in-downtown-columbus","url":"https://www.jobsohio.com/newsroom/news-press/andhealth-expanding-office-space-in-downtown-columbus"}],"summary":"The City is named as a collaborator in the JobsOhio project record and in the 2022 regional announcement.","tags":["wef-columbus","recursive-research","depth-4"],"title":"City of Columbus supported AndHealth expansion","verification":{"status":"source-backed","verified":true},"version":1,"workflow":{"max_depth":6,"recursion_depth":4,"research_status":"completed","root_target_id":"starintel:org:city-of-columbus"}}
{"_id":"starintel:relation:city-of-columbus-wef-urban-transformation","aliases":[],"assessment":{"confidence":0.97},"attachments":[],"data":{"confidence":0.97,"object":"starintel:org:world-economic-forum","predicate":"associated_with","subject":"starintel:org:city-of-columbus"},"dataset":"starintel-wef-columbus-urban-transformation-2026-07-25","date_added":"2026-07-25T00:00:00Z","date_updated":"2026-07-25T00:00:00Z","description":"","dtype":"relation","evidence":[],"extensions":{"legacy.v0":{"data":{"limitations":["No terms, payments, dates or binding commitments are published on the profile."]}}},"geospatial":{},"handling":{"pii":false,"sensitive":false,"visibility":"public"},"identifiers":[],"keywords":[],"labels":[],"language":"en","lineage":{"migration_from":"0.8","migration_notes":["Normalized into the canonical StarIntel v0.9.0 document envelope."]},"notes":[],"provenance":{"original_id":"starintel:relation:city-of-columbus-wef-urban-transformation","original_path":"digs/wef-columbus/2026-07-25-urban-transformation-network/starintel-documents.jsonl","original_schema_version":"0.8","software_version":"0.9.0","transform":"starintel_doc.migration.migrate_document"},"quality":{},"related_ids":[],"schema_version":"0.9.0","sources":[{"accessed_at":"2026-07-25T00:00:00Z","metadata":{"source_type":"official_organization"},"title":"City of Columbus | World Economic Forum","uri":"https://www.weforum.org/organizations/city-of-columbus/","url":"https://www.weforum.org/organizations/city-of-columbus/"}],"status":"recorded","summary":"WEF's City of Columbus profile establishes direct institutional association, but does not establish funding, command authority or policy control.","tags":[],"temporal":{},"title":"City of Columbus associated with WEF urban-transformation centre","verification":{"status":"confirmed_bounded"},"version":1,"workflow":{}}
{"_id":"starintel:relation:city-pmo-managed-usdot-allen-efforts","assessment":{"confidence":0.97},"data":{"confidence":0.97,"directed":true,"object":["starintel:org:paul-g-allen-philanthropies-vulcan"],"predicate":"managed_programs_for","qualifiers":{"additional_program":"USDOT Smart City Challenge"},"subject":"starintel:org:city-of-columbus"},"dataset":"starintel-wef-columbus-depth-4-2026-07-25","date_added":"2026-07-25T21:15:00Z","date_updated":"2026-07-25T21:15:00Z","dtype":"relation","evidence":[],"lineage":{"derived_from":["starintel:research-pass:wef-columbus-depth-3-2026-07-25"],"generation":4},"provenance":{"agent":"GPT-5.6 Thinking","run_id":"wef-columbus-depth-4-2026-07-25","skill":"auto-dig;search-starintel-json-db;create-starintel-documents;select-recursive-targets"},"schema_version":"0.9.0","sources":[{"accessed_at":"2026-07-25T21:15:00Z","credibility":0.95,"kind":"government_report","publisher":"City of Columbus","title":"Smart Columbus Program Summary — June 2021","uri":"https://static1.squarespace.com/static/6543abac601e3621dd3fe76d/t/68b832df3dd5017d3a1c12e2/1756902111728/2021-06%2BUSDOT%2BFinal%2BReport%2BExecutive%2BSummary%2B%281%29-compressed-compressed.pdf","url":"https://static1.squarespace.com/static/6543abac601e3621dd3fe76d/t/68b832df3dd5017d3a1c12e2/1756902111728/2021-06%2BUSDOT%2BFinal%2BReport%2BExecutive%2BSummary%2B%281%29-compressed-compressed.pdf"}],"summary":"The final program summary assigns management of the two grant-backed efforts to the City program management office.","tags":["wef-columbus","recursive-research","depth-4"],"title":"City PMO managed USDOT and Allen foundation efforts","verification":{"status":"source-backed","verified":true},"version":1,"workflow":{"max_depth":6,"recursion_depth":4,"research_status":"completed","root_target_id":"starintel:org:city-of-columbus"}}
{"_id":"starintel:relation:columbus-partnership-c3-associated-with-brand","assessment":{"confidence":0.98},"data":{"confidence":0.98,"directed":true,"object":"starintel:org:columbus-partnership","predicate":"associated_with","qualifiers":{},"subject":"starintel:org:the-columbus-partnership-c3"},"dataset":"starintel-wef-columbus-depth-4-2026-07-25","date_added":"2026-07-25T21:15:00Z","date_updated":"2026-07-25T21:15:00Z","dtype":"relation","evidence":[],"lineage":{"derived_from":["starintel:research-pass:wef-columbus-depth-3-2026-07-25"],"generation":4},"provenance":{"agent":"GPT-5.6 Thinking","run_id":"wef-columbus-depth-4-2026-07-25","skill":"auto-dig;search-starintel-json-db;create-starintel-documents;select-recursive-targets"},"schema_version":"0.9.0","sources":[{"accessed_at":"2026-07-25T21:15:00Z","credibility":0.95,"kind":"irs_derived_filing","publisher":"ProPublica Nonprofit Explorer","title":"The Columbus Partnership Form 990 — fiscal year 2024","uri":"https://projects.propublica.org/nonprofits/organizations/20580058","url":"https://projects.propublica.org/nonprofits/organizations/20580058"}],"summary":"The filing identifies a separate charitable entity using The Columbus Partnership name.","tags":["wef-columbus","recursive-research","depth-4"],"title":"501(c)(3) entity associated with Columbus Partnership brand","verification":{"status":"source-backed","verified":true},"version":1,"workflow":{"max_depth":6,"recursion_depth":4,"research_status":"completed","root_target_id":"starintel:org:city-of-columbus"}}
{"_id":"starintel:relation:columbus-partnership-c6-associated-with-brand","assessment":{"confidence":0.98},"data":{"confidence":0.98,"directed":true,"object":"starintel:org:columbus-partnership","predicate":"associated_with","qualifiers":{},"subject":"starintel:org:columbus-partnership-c6"},"dataset":"starintel-wef-columbus-depth-4-2026-07-25","date_added":"2026-07-25T21:15:00Z","date_updated":"2026-07-25T21:15:00Z","dtype":"relation","evidence":[],"lineage":{"derived_from":["starintel:research-pass:wef-columbus-depth-3-2026-07-25"],"generation":4},"provenance":{"agent":"GPT-5.6 Thinking","run_id":"wef-columbus-depth-4-2026-07-25","skill":"auto-dig;search-starintel-json-db;create-starintel-documents;select-recursive-targets"},"schema_version":"0.9.0","sources":[{"accessed_at":"2026-07-25T21:15:00Z","credibility":0.95,"kind":"irs_derived_filing","publisher":"ProPublica Nonprofit Explorer","title":"Columbus Partnership Form 990 — fiscal year 2024","uri":"https://projects.propublica.org/nonprofits/organizations/352558300","url":"https://projects.propublica.org/nonprofits/organizations/352558300"}],"summary":"The filing and public organizational materials associate the business-league entity with Columbus Partnership operations.","tags":["wef-columbus","recursive-research","depth-4"],"title":"501(c)(6) entity associated with Columbus Partnership brand","verification":{"status":"source-backed","verified":true},"version":1,"workflow":{"max_depth":6,"recursion_depth":4,"research_status":"completed","root_target_id":"starintel:org:city-of-columbus"}}
{"_id":"starintel:relation:columbus-partnership-c6-legally-distinct-c3","assessment":{"caveats":["Shared branding or governance does not by itself establish improper inter-entity transfers."],"confidence":0.99},"data":{"confidence":0.99,"directed":true,"object":"starintel:org:the-columbus-partnership-c3","predicate":"legally_distinct_from","qualifiers":{"c3_ein":"02-0580058","c6_ein":"35-2558300"},"subject":"starintel:org:columbus-partnership-c6"},"dataset":"starintel-wef-columbus-depth-4-2026-07-25","date_added":"2026-07-25T21:15:00Z","date_updated":"2026-07-25T21:15:00Z","dtype":"relation","evidence":[],"lineage":{"derived_from":["starintel:research-pass:wef-columbus-depth-3-2026-07-25"],"generation":4},"provenance":{"agent":"GPT-5.6 Thinking","run_id":"wef-columbus-depth-4-2026-07-25","skill":"auto-dig;search-starintel-json-db;create-starintel-documents;select-recursive-targets"},"schema_version":"0.9.0","sources":[{"accessed_at":"2026-07-25T21:15:00Z","credibility":0.95,"kind":"irs_derived_filing","publisher":"ProPublica Nonprofit Explorer","title":"Columbus Partnership Form 990 — fiscal year 2024","uri":"https://projects.propublica.org/nonprofits/organizations/352558300","url":"https://projects.propublica.org/nonprofits/organizations/352558300"},{"accessed_at":"2026-07-25T21:15:00Z","credibility":0.95,"kind":"irs_derived_filing","publisher":"ProPublica Nonprofit Explorer","title":"The Columbus Partnership Form 990 — fiscal year 2024","uri":"https://projects.propublica.org/nonprofits/organizations/20580058","url":"https://projects.propublica.org/nonprofits/organizations/20580058"}],"summary":"IRS-derived filings identify a 501(c)(6) business league and a separate 501(c)(3) charity with different EINs and financial profiles.","tags":["wef-columbus","recursive-research","depth-4"],"title":"Columbus Partnership uses two legally distinct nonprofit entities","verification":{"status":"source-backed","verified":true},"version":1,"workflow":{"max_depth":6,"recursion_depth":4,"research_status":"completed","root_target_id":"starintel:org:city-of-columbus"}}
{"_id":"starintel:relation:columbus-partnership-contracted-civitasnow","assessment":{"confidence":0.99},"data":{"confidence":0.99,"directed":true,"object":"starintel:org:civitasnow","predicate":"contracted","qualifiers":{},"subject":"starintel:org:columbus-partnership"},"dataset":"starintel-wef-columbus-depth-3-2026-07-25","date_added":"2026-07-25T20:30:00Z","date_updated":"2026-07-25T20:30:00Z","dtype":"relation","evidence":[],"lineage":{"derived_from":["starintel:research-pass:wef-columbus-depth-2-2026-07-25"],"generation":3},"provenance":{"agent":"GPT-5.6 Thinking","run_id":"wef-columbus-depth-3-2026-07-25","skill":"auto-dig;create-starintel-documents;select-recursive-targets"},"schema_version":"0.9.0","sources":[{"accessed_at":"2026-07-25T20:30:00Z","credibility":0.95,"kind":"government_record","publisher":"Official source","title":"Columbus Partnership engaged CivitasNow","uri":"https://columbus.legistar.com/LegislationDetail.aspx?GUID=ACFD8601-81BC-4387-A69C-219EE1A8431B&ID=3889855&Options=&Search=","url":"https://columbus.legistar.com/LegislationDetail.aspx?GUID=ACFD8601-81BC-4387-A69C-219EE1A8431B&ID=3889855&Options=&Search="}],"summary":"CivitasNow implemented a 120-event Smart Columbus Ride and Drive roadshow.","tags":["wef-columbus","recursive-research","depth-3"],"title":"Columbus Partnership engaged CivitasNow","verification":{"status":"source-backed","verified":true},"version":1,"workflow":{"max_depth":6,"recursion_depth":3,"research_status":"completed","root_target_id":"starintel:org:city-of-columbus"}}
{"_id":"starintel:relation:columbus-partnership-contracted-fahlgren","assessment":{"confidence":0.99},"data":{"confidence":0.99,"directed":true,"object":"starintel:org:fahlgren-mortine","predicate":"contracted","qualifiers":{},"subject":"starintel:org:columbus-partnership"},"dataset":"starintel-wef-columbus-depth-3-2026-07-25","date_added":"2026-07-25T20:30:00Z","date_updated":"2026-07-25T20:30:00Z","dtype":"relation","evidence":[],"lineage":{"derived_from":["starintel:research-pass:wef-columbus-depth-2-2026-07-25"],"generation":3},"provenance":{"agent":"GPT-5.6 Thinking","run_id":"wef-columbus-depth-3-2026-07-25","skill":"auto-dig;create-starintel-documents;select-recursive-targets"},"schema_version":"0.9.0","sources":[{"accessed_at":"2026-07-25T20:30:00Z","credibility":0.95,"kind":"government_record","publisher":"Official source","title":"Columbus Partnership engaged Fahlgren Mortine","uri":"https://columbus.legistar.com/LegislationDetail.aspx?GUID=2DDDFCD7-0346-4F0A-A7AD-4D59B8695E1D&ID=3889858&Options=&Search=","url":"https://columbus.legistar.com/LegislationDetail.aspx?GUID=2DDDFCD7-0346-4F0A-A7AD-4D59B8695E1D&ID=3889858&Options=&Search="}],"summary":"Fahlgren Mortine provided consumer education, communications, event coordination and creative services.","tags":["wef-columbus","recursive-research","depth-3"],"title":"Columbus Partnership engaged Fahlgren Mortine","verification":{"status":"source-backed","verified":true},"version":1,"workflow":{"max_depth":6,"recursion_depth":3,"research_status":"completed","root_target_id":"starintel:org:city-of-columbus"}}
{"_id":"starintel:relation:columbus-partnership-contracted-navigant","assessment":{"confidence":0.99},"data":{"confidence":0.99,"directed":true,"object":"starintel:org:navigant-guidehouse","predicate":"contracted","qualifiers":{},"subject":"starintel:org:columbus-partnership"},"dataset":"starintel-wef-columbus-depth-3-2026-07-25","date_added":"2026-07-25T20:30:00Z","date_updated":"2026-07-25T20:30:00Z","dtype":"relation","evidence":[],"lineage":{"derived_from":["starintel:research-pass:wef-columbus-depth-2-2026-07-25"],"generation":3},"provenance":{"agent":"GPT-5.6 Thinking","run_id":"wef-columbus-depth-3-2026-07-25","skill":"auto-dig;create-starintel-documents;select-recursive-targets"},"schema_version":"0.9.0","sources":[{"accessed_at":"2026-07-25T20:30:00Z","credibility":0.95,"kind":"government_record","publisher":"Official source","title":"Columbus Partnership engaged Navigant","uri":"https://columbus.legistar.com/LegislationDetail.aspx?GUID=0AA0D122-320C-4CC0-B0EC-11B78C87F598&ID=3197311&Options=&Search=","url":"https://columbus.legistar.com/LegislationDetail.aspx?GUID=0AA0D122-320C-4CC0-B0EC-11B78C87F598&ID=3197311&Options=&Search="}],"summary":"Navigant conducted consumer-adoption and logic-model research.","tags":["wef-columbus","recursive-research","depth-3"],"title":"Columbus Partnership engaged Navigant","verification":{"status":"source-backed","verified":true},"version":1,"workflow":{"max_depth":6,"recursion_depth":3,"research_status":"completed","root_target_id":"starintel:org:city-of-columbus"}}
{"_id":"starintel:relation:columbus-partnership-coordinated-acceleration-fund","assessment":{"confidence":0.99},"data":{"confidence":0.99,"directed":true,"object":"starintel:event:smart-columbus-three-funding-streams-2021","predicate":"coordinated","qualifiers":{"fund_initial_usd":90000000,"fund_reported_over_usd":700000000},"subject":"starintel:org:columbus-partnership"},"dataset":"starintel-wef-columbus-depth-4-2026-07-25","date_added":"2026-07-25T21:15:00Z","date_updated":"2026-07-25T21:15:00Z","dtype":"relation","evidence":[],"lineage":{"derived_from":["starintel:research-pass:wef-columbus-depth-3-2026-07-25"],"generation":4},"provenance":{"agent":"GPT-5.6 Thinking","run_id":"wef-columbus-depth-4-2026-07-25","skill":"auto-dig;search-starintel-json-db;create-starintel-documents;select-recursive-targets"},"schema_version":"0.9.0","sources":[{"accessed_at":"2026-07-25T21:15:00Z","credibility":0.95,"kind":"government_report","publisher":"City of Columbus","title":"Smart Columbus Program Summary — June 2021","uri":"https://static1.squarespace.com/static/6543abac601e3621dd3fe76d/t/68b832df3dd5017d3a1c12e2/1756902111728/2021-06%2BUSDOT%2BFinal%2BReport%2BExecutive%2BSummary%2B%281%29-compressed-compressed.pdf","url":"https://static1.squarespace.com/static/6543abac601e3621dd3fe76d/t/68b832df3dd5017d3a1c12e2/1756902111728/2021-06%2BUSDOT%2BFinal%2BReport%2BExecutive%2BSummary%2B%281%29-compressed-compressed.pdf"}],"summary":"The City program summary says the private-sector fund began at $90 million and grew to more than $700 million.","tags":["wef-columbus","recursive-research","depth-4"],"title":"Columbus Partnership coordinated the Acceleration Fund","verification":{"status":"source-backed","verified":true},"version":1,"workflow":{"max_depth":6,"recursion_depth":4,"research_status":"completed","root_target_id":"starintel:org:city-of-columbus"}}
{"_id":"starintel:relation:corrine-burger-former-jpmorgan-chase","assessment":{"confidence":0.99},"data":{"confidence":0.99,"directed":true,"object":"starintel:org:jpmorgan-chase","predicate":"former_executive_of","qualifiers":{},"subject":"starintel:person:corrine-burger"},"dataset":"starintel-wef-columbus-depth-3-2026-07-25","date_added":"2026-07-25T20:30:00Z","date_updated":"2026-07-25T20:30:00Z","dtype":"relation","evidence":[],"lineage":{"derived_from":["starintel:research-pass:wef-columbus-depth-2-2026-07-25"],"generation":3},"provenance":{"agent":"GPT-5.6 Thinking","run_id":"wef-columbus-depth-3-2026-07-25","skill":"auto-dig;create-starintel-documents;select-recursive-targets"},"schema_version":"0.9.0","sources":[{"accessed_at":"2026-07-25T20:30:00Z","credibility":0.95,"kind":"official_webpage","publisher":"Official source","title":"Corrine Burger formerly worked at JPMorganChase","uri":"https://columbusregion.com/press-release/columbus-partnership-announces-leadership-transition/","url":"https://columbusregion.com/press-release/columbus-partnership-announces-leadership-transition/"}],"summary":"The Partnership says Burger completed a 34-year career at JPMorganChase and Bank One.","tags":["wef-columbus","recursive-research","depth-3"],"title":"Corrine Burger formerly worked at JPMorganChase","verification":{"status":"source-backed","verified":true},"version":1,"workflow":{"max_depth":6,"recursion_depth":3,"research_status":"completed","root_target_id":"starintel:org:city-of-columbus"}}
{"_id":"starintel:relation:dylan-sansone-smart-columbus-team","assessment":{"confidence":0.99},"data":{"confidence":0.99,"directed":true,"object":"starintel:org:smart-columbus","predicate":"team_member_of","qualifiers":{"position":"Senior Project Manager, Digital Equity"},"subject":"starintel:person:dylan-sansone"},"dataset":"starintel-wef-columbus-depth-4-2026-07-25","date_added":"2026-07-25T21:15:00Z","date_updated":"2026-07-25T21:15:00Z","dtype":"relation","evidence":[],"lineage":{"derived_from":["starintel:research-pass:wef-columbus-depth-3-2026-07-25"],"generation":4},"provenance":{"agent":"GPT-5.6 Thinking","run_id":"wef-columbus-depth-4-2026-07-25","skill":"auto-dig;search-starintel-json-db;create-starintel-documents;select-recursive-targets"},"schema_version":"0.9.0","sources":[{"accessed_at":"2026-07-25T21:15:00Z","credibility":0.95,"kind":"official_webpage","publisher":"Smart Columbus","title":"Smart Columbus — About","uri":"https://smartcolumbus.com/about","url":"https://smartcolumbus.com/about"}],"summary":"Smart Columbus lists Dylan Sansone as Senior Project Manager, Digital Equity.","tags":["wef-columbus","recursive-research","depth-4"],"title":"Dylan Sansone is listed on the Smart Columbus team","verification":{"status":"source-backed","verified":true},"version":1,"workflow":{"max_depth":6,"recursion_depth":4,"research_status":"completed","root_target_id":"starintel:org:city-of-columbus"}}
{"_id":"starintel:relation:electrification-coalition-advised-smart-columbus","assessment":{"confidence":0.99},"data":{"confidence":0.99,"directed":true,"object":"starintel:org:smart-columbus","predicate":"strategic_and_technical_advisor_to","qualifiers":{},"subject":"starintel:org:electrification-coalition"},"dataset":"starintel-wef-columbus-depth-3-2026-07-25","date_added":"2026-07-25T20:30:00Z","date_updated":"2026-07-25T20:30:00Z","dtype":"relation","evidence":[],"lineage":{"derived_from":["starintel:research-pass:wef-columbus-depth-2-2026-07-25"],"generation":3},"provenance":{"agent":"GPT-5.6 Thinking","run_id":"wef-columbus-depth-3-2026-07-25","skill":"auto-dig;create-starintel-documents;select-recursive-targets"},"schema_version":"0.9.0","sources":[{"accessed_at":"2026-07-25T20:30:00Z","credibility":0.95,"kind":"official_webpage","publisher":"Official source","title":"Electrification Coalition advised Smart Columbus","uri":"https://electrificationcoalition.org/electrification-coalition-praises-smart-columbus-for-exceeding-electric-vehicle-adoption-goal/","url":"https://electrificationcoalition.org/electrification-coalition-praises-smart-columbus-for-exceeding-electric-vehicle-adoption-goal/"}],"summary":"EC describes itself as strategic and technical adviser to the Smart Columbus Electrification Program.","tags":["wef-columbus","recursive-research","depth-3"],"title":"Electrification Coalition advised Smart Columbus","verification":{"status":"source-backed","verified":true},"version":1,"workflow":{"max_depth":6,"recursion_depth":3,"research_status":"completed","root_target_id":"starintel:org:city-of-columbus"}}
{"_id":"starintel:relation:elon-simms-smart-columbus-cochair","assessment":{"confidence":0.99},"data":{"confidence":0.99,"directed":true,"object":"starintel:org:smart-columbus","predicate":"cochair_of","qualifiers":{},"subject":"starintel:person:elon-simms"},"dataset":"starintel-wef-columbus-depth-3-2026-07-25","date_added":"2026-07-25T20:30:00Z","date_updated":"2026-07-25T20:30:00Z","dtype":"relation","evidence":[],"lineage":{"derived_from":["starintel:research-pass:wef-columbus-depth-2-2026-07-25"],"generation":3},"provenance":{"agent":"GPT-5.6 Thinking","run_id":"wef-columbus-depth-3-2026-07-25","skill":"auto-dig;create-starintel-documents;select-recursive-targets"},"schema_version":"0.9.0","sources":[{"accessed_at":"2026-07-25T20:30:00Z","credibility":0.95,"kind":"official_webpage","publisher":"Official source","title":"Elon Simms co-chairs Smart Columbus","uri":"https://smartcolumbus.com/about","url":"https://smartcolumbus.com/about"}],"summary":"Smart Columbus lists the Mayor's Office chief of staff as co-chair.","tags":["wef-columbus","recursive-research","depth-3"],"title":"Elon Simms co-chairs Smart Columbus","verification":{"status":"source-backed","verified":true},"version":1,"workflow":{"max_depth":6,"recursion_depth":3,"research_status":"completed","root_target_id":"starintel:org:city-of-columbus"}}
{"_id":"starintel:relation:frances-henry-columbus-partnership-c3","assessment":{"confidence":0.97},"data":{"confidence":0.97,"directed":true,"object":"starintel:org:the-columbus-partnership-c3","predicate":"secretary_of","qualifiers":{"fiscal_year":2024},"subject":"starintel:person:frances-henry"},"dataset":"starintel-wef-columbus-depth-4-2026-07-25","date_added":"2026-07-25T21:15:00Z","date_updated":"2026-07-25T21:15:00Z","dtype":"relation","evidence":[],"lineage":{"derived_from":["starintel:research-pass:wef-columbus-depth-3-2026-07-25"],"generation":4},"provenance":{"agent":"GPT-5.6 Thinking","run_id":"wef-columbus-depth-4-2026-07-25","skill":"auto-dig;search-starintel-json-db;create-starintel-documents;select-recursive-targets"},"schema_version":"0.9.0","sources":[{"accessed_at":"2026-07-25T21:15:00Z","credibility":0.95,"kind":"irs_derived_filing","publisher":"ProPublica Nonprofit Explorer","title":"The Columbus Partnership Form 990 — fiscal year 2024","uri":"https://projects.propublica.org/nonprofits/organizations/20580058","url":"https://projects.propublica.org/nonprofits/organizations/20580058"}],"summary":"The 2024 501(c)(3) filing identifies Frances Henry as an officer or director.","tags":["wef-columbus","recursive-research","depth-4"],"title":"Frances Henry held a 2024 The Columbus Partnership role","verification":{"status":"source-backed","verified":true},"version":1,"workflow":{"max_depth":6,"recursion_depth":4,"research_status":"completed","root_target_id":"starintel:org:city-of-columbus"}}
{"_id":"starintel:relation:gerard-basalla-columbus-partnership-c6","assessment":{"confidence":0.97},"data":{"confidence":0.97,"directed":true,"object":"starintel:org:columbus-partnership-c6","predicate":"director_of","qualifiers":{"fiscal_year":2024},"subject":"starintel:person:gerard-basalla"},"dataset":"starintel-wef-columbus-depth-4-2026-07-25","date_added":"2026-07-25T21:15:00Z","date_updated":"2026-07-25T21:15:00Z","dtype":"relation","evidence":[],"lineage":{"derived_from":["starintel:research-pass:wef-columbus-depth-3-2026-07-25"],"generation":4},"provenance":{"agent":"GPT-5.6 Thinking","run_id":"wef-columbus-depth-4-2026-07-25","skill":"auto-dig;search-starintel-json-db;create-starintel-documents;select-recursive-targets"},"schema_version":"0.9.0","sources":[{"accessed_at":"2026-07-25T21:15:00Z","credibility":0.95,"kind":"irs_derived_filing","publisher":"ProPublica Nonprofit Explorer","title":"Columbus Partnership Form 990 — fiscal year 2024","uri":"https://projects.propublica.org/nonprofits/organizations/352558300","url":"https://projects.propublica.org/nonprofits/organizations/352558300"}],"summary":"The 2024 501(c)(6) filing identifies Gerard Basalla as an officer or key employee.","tags":["wef-columbus","recursive-research","depth-4"],"title":"Gerard Basalla held a 2024 Columbus Partnership role","verification":{"status":"source-backed","verified":true},"version":1,"workflow":{"max_depth":6,"recursion_depth":4,"research_status":"completed","root_target_id":"starintel:org:city-of-columbus"}}
{"_id":"starintel:relation:green-it-playbook-authored-by-smart-columbus-rackspace","assessment":{"confidence":0.99},"data":{"confidence":0.99,"directed":true,"object":["starintel:org:smart-columbus","starintel:org:rackspace-technology"],"predicate":"authored_by","subject":"starintel:media:columbus-green-it-playbook-2-0-2025"},"dataset":"wef","date_added":"2026-07-26T04:05:00Z","date_updated":"2026-07-26T04:05:00Z","dtype":"relation","evidence":[],"lineage":{"derived_from":["starintel:analysis:wef-columbus-depth-4-governance-replication-continuity"],"generation":5},"provenance":{"agent":"GPT-5.6 Thinking","method":"Primary-source recursive OSINT with bounded inference","run_id":"wef-columbus-depth-5-2026-07-26","skill":"auto-dig;web-research;create-starintel-documents;select-recursive-targets"},"schema_version":"0.9.0","sources":[{"accessed_at":"2026-07-26T04:05:00Z","credibility":0.95,"kind":"official_webpage","publisher":"Smart Columbus","title":"Columbus leads the way: Evolving our Green IT ambition","uri":"https://smartcolumbus.com/insights/2025-10-cie-vendor-announcement-83p85","url":"https://smartcolumbus.com/insights/2025-10-cie-vendor-announcement-83p85"},{"accessed_at":"2026-07-26T04:05:00Z","credibility":0.95,"kind":"official_webpage","publisher":"Smart Columbus","title":"A year of impact: 2025 by the numbers","uri":"https://smartcolumbus.com/insights/2025-12-year-of-impact","url":"https://smartcolumbus.com/insights/2025-12-year-of-impact"}],"summary":"The official Smart Columbus publication identifies Smart Columbus and Rackspace Technology as co-authors.","tags":["wef","columbus","recursive-research","depth-5"],"title":"Green IT Playbook 2.0 authored by Smart Columbus and Rackspace","verification":{"status":"source-backed","verified":true},"version":1,"workflow":{"max_depth":6,"recursion_depth":5,"research_status":"completed","root_target_id":"starintel:org:city-of-columbus"}}
{"_id":"starintel:relation:hailey-allison-smart-columbus-team","assessment":{"confidence":0.99},"data":{"confidence":0.99,"directed":true,"object":"starintel:org:smart-columbus","predicate":"team_member_of","qualifiers":{"position":"Director of Operations"},"subject":"starintel:person:hailey-allison"},"dataset":"starintel-wef-columbus-depth-4-2026-07-25","date_added":"2026-07-25T21:15:00Z","date_updated":"2026-07-25T21:15:00Z","dtype":"relation","evidence":[],"lineage":{"derived_from":["starintel:research-pass:wef-columbus-depth-3-2026-07-25"],"generation":4},"provenance":{"agent":"GPT-5.6 Thinking","run_id":"wef-columbus-depth-4-2026-07-25","skill":"auto-dig;search-starintel-json-db;create-starintel-documents;select-recursive-targets"},"schema_version":"0.9.0","sources":[{"accessed_at":"2026-07-25T21:15:00Z","credibility":0.95,"kind":"official_webpage","publisher":"Smart Columbus","title":"Smart Columbus — About","uri":"https://smartcolumbus.com/about","url":"https://smartcolumbus.com/about"}],"summary":"Smart Columbus lists Hailey Allison as Director of Operations.","tags":["wef-columbus","recursive-research","depth-4"],"title":"Hailey Allison is listed on the Smart Columbus team","verification":{"status":"source-backed","verified":true},"version":1,"workflow":{"max_depth":6,"recursion_depth":4,"research_status":"completed","root_target_id":"starintel:org:city-of-columbus"}}
{"_id":"starintel:relation:hntb-phase-4-uses-emht-barr-subconsultants","assessment":{"confidence":0.99},"data":{"confidence":0.99,"directed":true,"note":"Do not infer scope or payment allocation from listing alone.","object":["starintel:org:emh-and-t-inc","starintel:org:barr-engineering"],"predicate":"uses_subconsultants","qualifiers":{"contract_id":"starintel:contract:hntb-smart-lighting-phase-4-lifecycle-2022-2026"},"subject":"starintel:org:hntb-ohio"},"dataset":"wef","date_added":"2026-07-26T04:05:00Z","date_updated":"2026-07-26T04:05:00Z","dtype":"relation","evidence":[],"lineage":{"derived_from":["starintel:analysis:wef-columbus-depth-4-governance-replication-continuity"],"generation":5},"provenance":{"agent":"GPT-5.6 Thinking","method":"Primary-source recursive OSINT with bounded inference","run_id":"wef-columbus-depth-5-2026-07-26","skill":"auto-dig;web-research;create-starintel-documents;select-recursive-targets"},"schema_version":"0.9.0","sources":[{"accessed_at":"2026-07-26T04:05:00Z","credibility":0.99,"kind":"government_record","publisher":"City of Columbus","title":"Columbus Ordinance 1424-2026","uri":"https://columbus.legistar.com/LegislationDetail.aspx?FullText=1&GUID=039FBB6C-BE67-4AC2-9C13-59B8B8EFE96F&ID=8117826&Options=&Search=","url":"https://columbus.legistar.com/LegislationDetail.aspx?FullText=1&GUID=039FBB6C-BE67-4AC2-9C13-59B8B8EFE96F&ID=8117826&Options=&Search="}],"summary":"The 2026 Smart Lighting modification identifies both firms, while workshare and dollar allocations remain unresolved.","tags":["wef","columbus","recursive-research","depth-5"],"title":"HNTB Phase 4 identifies EMH&T and Barr as subconsultants","verification":{"status":"source-backed","verified":true},"version":1,"workflow":{"max_depth":6,"recursion_depth":5,"research_status":"completed","root_target_id":"starintel:org:city-of-columbus"}}
{"_id":"starintel:relation:hntb-subcontracted-barr-smart-lighting","assessment":{"confidence":0.99},"data":{"confidence":0.99,"directed":true,"object":"starintel:org:barr-engineering","predicate":"subcontracted","qualifiers":{"program":"Smart Lighting Phase 4"},"subject":"starintel:org:hntb-ohio"},"dataset":"starintel-wef-columbus-depth-4-2026-07-25","date_added":"2026-07-25T21:15:00Z","date_updated":"2026-07-25T21:15:00Z","dtype":"relation","evidence":[],"lineage":{"derived_from":["starintel:research-pass:wef-columbus-depth-3-2026-07-25"],"generation":4},"provenance":{"agent":"GPT-5.6 Thinking","run_id":"wef-columbus-depth-4-2026-07-25","skill":"auto-dig;search-starintel-json-db;create-starintel-documents;select-recursive-targets"},"schema_version":"0.9.0","sources":[{"accessed_at":"2026-07-25T21:15:00Z","credibility":0.95,"kind":"government_record","publisher":"City of Columbus","title":"Columbus Ordinance 1424-2026","uri":"https://columbus.legistar.com/LegislationDetail.aspx?FullText=1&GUID=50C99EDC-6138-41FC-A7E1-8672080626A3&ID=8038904","url":"https://columbus.legistar.com/LegislationDetail.aspx?FullText=1&GUID=50C99EDC-6138-41FC-A7E1-8672080626A3&ID=8038904"}],"summary":"The 2026 modification lists Barr Engineering among HNTB's subconsultants.","tags":["wef-columbus","recursive-research","depth-4"],"title":"HNTB identified Barr Engineering as Smart Lighting subconsultant","verification":{"status":"source-backed","verified":true},"version":1,"workflow":{"max_depth":6,"recursion_depth":4,"research_status":"completed","root_target_id":"starintel:org:city-of-columbus"}}
{"_id":"starintel:relation:hntb-subcontracted-emh-and-t-smart-lighting","assessment":{"confidence":0.99},"data":{"confidence":0.99,"directed":true,"object":"starintel:org:emh-and-t-inc","predicate":"subcontracted","qualifiers":{"program":"Smart Lighting Phase 4"},"subject":"starintel:org:hntb-ohio"},"dataset":"starintel-wef-columbus-depth-4-2026-07-25","date_added":"2026-07-25T21:15:00Z","date_updated":"2026-07-25T21:15:00Z","dtype":"relation","evidence":[],"lineage":{"derived_from":["starintel:research-pass:wef-columbus-depth-3-2026-07-25"],"generation":4},"provenance":{"agent":"GPT-5.6 Thinking","run_id":"wef-columbus-depth-4-2026-07-25","skill":"auto-dig;search-starintel-json-db;create-starintel-documents;select-recursive-targets"},"schema_version":"0.9.0","sources":[{"accessed_at":"2026-07-25T21:15:00Z","credibility":0.95,"kind":"government_record","publisher":"City of Columbus","title":"Columbus Ordinance 1424-2026","uri":"https://columbus.legistar.com/LegislationDetail.aspx?FullText=1&GUID=50C99EDC-6138-41FC-A7E1-8672080626A3&ID=8038904","url":"https://columbus.legistar.com/LegislationDetail.aspx?FullText=1&GUID=50C99EDC-6138-41FC-A7E1-8672080626A3&ID=8038904"}],"summary":"The 2026 modification lists EMH&T among HNTB's subconsultants.","tags":["wef-columbus","recursive-research","depth-4"],"title":"HNTB identified EMH&T as Smart Lighting subconsultant","verification":{"status":"source-backed","verified":true},"version":1,"workflow":{"max_depth":6,"recursion_depth":4,"research_status":"completed","root_target_id":"starintel:org:city-of-columbus"}}
{"_id":"starintel:relation:jason-hall-former-ceo-columbus-partnership","assessment":{"confidence":0.99},"data":{"confidence":0.99,"directed":true,"object":"starintel:org:columbus-partnership","predicate":"former_ceo_of","qualifiers":{},"subject":"starintel:person:jason-hall"},"dataset":"starintel-wef-columbus-depth-3-2026-07-25","date_added":"2026-07-25T20:30:00Z","date_updated":"2026-07-25T20:30:00Z","dtype":"relation","evidence":[],"lineage":{"derived_from":["starintel:research-pass:wef-columbus-depth-2-2026-07-25"],"generation":3},"provenance":{"agent":"GPT-5.6 Thinking","run_id":"wef-columbus-depth-3-2026-07-25","skill":"auto-dig;create-starintel-documents;select-recursive-targets"},"schema_version":"0.9.0","sources":[{"accessed_at":"2026-07-25T20:30:00Z","credibility":0.95,"kind":"official_webpage","publisher":"Official source","title":"Jason Hall departed Columbus Partnership leadership","uri":"https://columbusregion.com/press-release/columbus-partnership-announces-leadership-transition/","url":"https://columbusregion.com/press-release/columbus-partnership-announces-leadership-transition/"}],"summary":"Hall stepped down effective June 30, 2026.","tags":["wef-columbus","recursive-research","depth-3"],"title":"Jason Hall departed Columbus Partnership leadership","verification":{"status":"source-backed","verified":true},"version":1,"workflow":{"max_depth":6,"recursion_depth":3,"research_status":"completed","root_target_id":"starintel:org:city-of-columbus"}}
{"_id":"starintel:relation:jeff-polesovsky-columbus-partnership-c6","assessment":{"confidence":0.97},"data":{"confidence":0.97,"directed":true,"object":"starintel:org:columbus-partnership-c6","predicate":"vice_president_of","qualifiers":{"fiscal_year":2024},"subject":"starintel:person:jeff-polesovsky"},"dataset":"starintel-wef-columbus-depth-4-2026-07-25","date_added":"2026-07-25T21:15:00Z","date_updated":"2026-07-25T21:15:00Z","dtype":"relation","evidence":[],"lineage":{"derived_from":["starintel:research-pass:wef-columbus-depth-3-2026-07-25"],"generation":4},"provenance":{"agent":"GPT-5.6 Thinking","run_id":"wef-columbus-depth-4-2026-07-25","skill":"auto-dig;search-starintel-json-db;create-starintel-documents;select-recursive-targets"},"schema_version":"0.9.0","sources":[{"accessed_at":"2026-07-25T21:15:00Z","credibility":0.95,"kind":"irs_derived_filing","publisher":"ProPublica Nonprofit Explorer","title":"Columbus Partnership Form 990 — fiscal year 2024","uri":"https://projects.propublica.org/nonprofits/organizations/352558300","url":"https://projects.propublica.org/nonprofits/organizations/352558300"}],"summary":"The 2024 501(c)(6) filing identifies Jeff Polesovsky as an officer or key employee.","tags":["wef-columbus","recursive-research","depth-4"],"title":"Jeff Polesovsky held a 2024 Columbus Partnership role","verification":{"status":"source-backed","verified":true},"version":1,"workflow":{"max_depth":6,"recursion_depth":4,"research_status":"completed","root_target_id":"starintel:org:city-of-columbus"}}
{"_id":"starintel:relation:jobsohio-supported-andhealth-expansion","assessment":{"caveats":["The final 2022 assistance agreement and amount were not found in this pass."],"confidence":0.99},"data":{"confidence":0.99,"directed":true,"object":"starintel:org:andhealth","predicate":"supported_expansion_of","qualifiers":{},"subject":"starintel:org:jobsohio"},"dataset":"starintel-wef-columbus-depth-4-2026-07-25","date_added":"2026-07-25T21:15:00Z","date_updated":"2026-07-25T21:15:00Z","dtype":"relation","evidence":[],"lineage":{"derived_from":["starintel:research-pass:wef-columbus-depth-3-2026-07-25"],"generation":4},"provenance":{"agent":"GPT-5.6 Thinking","run_id":"wef-columbus-depth-4-2026-07-25","skill":"auto-dig;search-starintel-json-db;create-starintel-documents;select-recursive-targets"},"schema_version":"0.9.0","sources":[{"accessed_at":"2026-07-25T21:15:00Z","credibility":0.95,"kind":"official_project_record","publisher":"One Columbus","title":"Digital Healthcare Startup AndHealth Brings 65 New Jobs","uri":"https://columbusregion.com/press-release/digital-healthcare-startup-andhealth-brings-65-new-jobs-to-downtown-columbus-for-operations-expansion/","url":"https://columbusregion.com/press-release/digital-healthcare-startup-andhealth-brings-65-new-jobs-to-downtown-columbus-for-operations-expansion/"},{"accessed_at":"2026-07-25T21:15:00Z","credibility":0.95,"kind":"official_project_record","publisher":"JobsOhio","title":"AndHealth Expanding Office Space in Downtown Columbus","uri":"https://www.jobsohio.com/newsroom/news-press/andhealth-expanding-office-space-in-downtown-columbus","url":"https://www.jobsohio.com/newsroom/news-press/andhealth-expanding-office-space-in-downtown-columbus"}],"summary":"JobsOhio appears as a collaborator in 2025 and planned assistance in 2022 after a final agreement.","tags":["wef-columbus","recursive-research","depth-4"],"title":"JobsOhio supported AndHealth expansion projects","verification":{"status":"source-backed","verified":true},"version":1,"workflow":{"max_depth":6,"recursion_depth":4,"research_status":"completed","root_target_id":"starintel:org:city-of-columbus"}}
{"_id":"starintel:relation:john-ammendola-columbus-partnership-c3","assessment":{"confidence":0.97},"data":{"confidence":0.97,"directed":true,"object":"starintel:org:the-columbus-partnership-c3","predicate":"director_of","qualifiers":{"fiscal_year":2024},"subject":"starintel:person:john-ammendola"},"dataset":"starintel-wef-columbus-depth-4-2026-07-25","date_added":"2026-07-25T21:15:00Z","date_updated":"2026-07-25T21:15:00Z","dtype":"relation","evidence":[],"lineage":{"derived_from":["starintel:research-pass:wef-columbus-depth-3-2026-07-25"],"generation":4},"provenance":{"agent":"GPT-5.6 Thinking","run_id":"wef-columbus-depth-4-2026-07-25","skill":"auto-dig;search-starintel-json-db;create-starintel-documents;select-recursive-targets"},"schema_version":"0.9.0","sources":[{"accessed_at":"2026-07-25T21:15:00Z","credibility":0.95,"kind":"irs_derived_filing","publisher":"ProPublica Nonprofit Explorer","title":"The Columbus Partnership Form 990 — fiscal year 2024","uri":"https://projects.propublica.org/nonprofits/organizations/20580058","url":"https://projects.propublica.org/nonprofits/organizations/20580058"}],"summary":"The 2024 501(c)(3) filing identifies John Ammendola as an officer or director.","tags":["wef-columbus","recursive-research","depth-4"],"title":"John Ammendola held a 2024 The Columbus Partnership role","verification":{"status":"source-backed","verified":true},"version":1,"workflow":{"max_depth":6,"recursion_depth":4,"research_status":"completed","root_target_id":"starintel:org:city-of-columbus"}}
{"_id":"starintel:relation:john-keeling-columbus-partnership-c6","assessment":{"confidence":0.97},"data":{"confidence":0.97,"directed":true,"object":"starintel:org:columbus-partnership-c6","predicate":"director_of","qualifiers":{"fiscal_year":2024},"subject":"starintel:person:john-keeling"},"dataset":"starintel-wef-columbus-depth-4-2026-07-25","date_added":"2026-07-25T21:15:00Z","date_updated":"2026-07-25T21:15:00Z","dtype":"relation","evidence":[],"lineage":{"derived_from":["starintel:research-pass:wef-columbus-depth-3-2026-07-25"],"generation":4},"provenance":{"agent":"GPT-5.6 Thinking","run_id":"wef-columbus-depth-4-2026-07-25","skill":"auto-dig;search-starintel-json-db;create-starintel-documents;select-recursive-targets"},"schema_version":"0.9.0","sources":[{"accessed_at":"2026-07-25T21:15:00Z","credibility":0.95,"kind":"irs_derived_filing","publisher":"ProPublica Nonprofit Explorer","title":"Columbus Partnership Form 990 — fiscal year 2024","uri":"https://projects.propublica.org/nonprofits/organizations/352558300","url":"https://projects.propublica.org/nonprofits/organizations/352558300"}],"summary":"The 2024 501(c)(6) filing identifies John Keeling as an officer or key employee.","tags":["wef-columbus","recursive-research","depth-4"],"title":"John Keeling held a 2024 Columbus Partnership role","verification":{"status":"source-backed","verified":true},"version":1,"workflow":{"max_depth":6,"recursion_depth":4,"research_status":"completed","root_target_id":"starintel:org:city-of-columbus"}}
{"_id":"starintel:relation:jordan-davis-smart-columbus-board","assessment":{"confidence":0.99},"data":{"confidence":0.99,"directed":true,"object":"starintel:org:smart-columbus","predicate":"board_member_of","qualifiers":{},"subject":"starintel:person:jordan-davis"},"dataset":"starintel-wef-columbus-depth-3-2026-07-25","date_added":"2026-07-25T20:30:00Z","date_updated":"2026-07-25T20:30:00Z","dtype":"relation","evidence":[],"lineage":{"derived_from":["starintel:research-pass:wef-columbus-depth-2-2026-07-25"],"generation":3},"provenance":{"agent":"GPT-5.6 Thinking","run_id":"wef-columbus-depth-3-2026-07-25","skill":"auto-dig;create-starintel-documents;select-recursive-targets"},"schema_version":"0.9.0","sources":[{"accessed_at":"2026-07-25T20:30:00Z","credibility":0.95,"kind":"official_webpage","publisher":"Official source","title":"Jordan Davis remains on Smart Columbus board","uri":"https://smartcolumbus.com/about","url":"https://smartcolumbus.com/about"}],"summary":"Smart Columbus lists Davis as an AndHealth executive and board member.","tags":["wef-columbus","recursive-research","depth-3"],"title":"Jordan Davis remains on Smart Columbus board","verification":{"status":"source-backed","verified":true},"version":1,"workflow":{"max_depth":6,"recursion_depth":3,"research_status":"completed","root_target_id":"starintel:org:city-of-columbus"}}
{"_id":"starintel:relation:karina-sanchez-smart-columbus-team","assessment":{"confidence":0.99},"data":{"confidence":0.99,"directed":true,"object":"starintel:org:smart-columbus","predicate":"team_member_of","qualifiers":{"position":"Research Assistant"},"subject":"starintel:person:karina-sanchez"},"dataset":"starintel-wef-columbus-depth-4-2026-07-25","date_added":"2026-07-25T21:15:00Z","date_updated":"2026-07-25T21:15:00Z","dtype":"relation","evidence":[],"lineage":{"derived_from":["starintel:research-pass:wef-columbus-depth-3-2026-07-25"],"generation":4},"provenance":{"agent":"GPT-5.6 Thinking","run_id":"wef-columbus-depth-4-2026-07-25","skill":"auto-dig;search-starintel-json-db;create-starintel-documents;select-recursive-targets"},"schema_version":"0.9.0","sources":[{"accessed_at":"2026-07-25T21:15:00Z","credibility":0.95,"kind":"official_webpage","publisher":"Smart Columbus","title":"Smart Columbus — About","uri":"https://smartcolumbus.com/about","url":"https://smartcolumbus.com/about"}],"summary":"Smart Columbus lists Karina Sanchez as Research Assistant.","tags":["wef-columbus","recursive-research","depth-4"],"title":"Karina Sanchez is listed on the Smart Columbus team","verification":{"status":"source-backed","verified":true},"version":1,"workflow":{"max_depth":6,"recursion_depth":4,"research_status":"completed","root_target_id":"starintel:org:city-of-columbus"}}
{"_id":"starintel:relation:ken-wilson-smart-columbus-board","assessment":{"confidence":0.99},"data":{"confidence":0.99,"directed":true,"object":"starintel:org:smart-columbus","predicate":"board_member_of","qualifiers":{},"subject":"starintel:person:ken-wilson"},"dataset":"starintel-wef-columbus-depth-3-2026-07-25","date_added":"2026-07-25T20:30:00Z","date_updated":"2026-07-25T20:30:00Z","dtype":"relation","evidence":[],"lineage":{"derived_from":["starintel:research-pass:wef-columbus-depth-2-2026-07-25"],"generation":3},"provenance":{"agent":"GPT-5.6 Thinking","run_id":"wef-columbus-depth-3-2026-07-25","skill":"auto-dig;create-starintel-documents;select-recursive-targets"},"schema_version":"0.9.0","sources":[{"accessed_at":"2026-07-25T20:30:00Z","credibility":0.95,"kind":"official_webpage","publisher":"Official source","title":"Ken Wilson serves on Smart Columbus board","uri":"https://smartcolumbus.com/about","url":"https://smartcolumbus.com/about"}],"summary":"Franklin County administrator is a board member.","tags":["wef-columbus","recursive-research","depth-3"],"title":"Ken Wilson serves on Smart Columbus board","verification":{"status":"source-backed","verified":true},"version":1,"workflow":{"max_depth":6,"recursion_depth":3,"research_status":"completed","root_target_id":"starintel:org:city-of-columbus"}}
{"_id":"starintel:relation:kenneth-d-mcdonald-columbus-partnership-c6","assessment":{"confidence":0.97},"data":{"confidence":0.97,"directed":true,"object":"starintel:org:columbus-partnership-c6","predicate":"president_and_ceo_of","qualifiers":{"fiscal_year":2024},"subject":"starintel:person:kenneth-d-mcdonald"},"dataset":"starintel-wef-columbus-depth-4-2026-07-25","date_added":"2026-07-25T21:15:00Z","date_updated":"2026-07-25T21:15:00Z","dtype":"relation","evidence":[],"lineage":{"derived_from":["starintel:research-pass:wef-columbus-depth-3-2026-07-25"],"generation":4},"provenance":{"agent":"GPT-5.6 Thinking","run_id":"wef-columbus-depth-4-2026-07-25","skill":"auto-dig;search-starintel-json-db;create-starintel-documents;select-recursive-targets"},"schema_version":"0.9.0","sources":[{"accessed_at":"2026-07-25T21:15:00Z","credibility":0.95,"kind":"irs_derived_filing","publisher":"ProPublica Nonprofit Explorer","title":"Columbus Partnership Form 990 — fiscal year 2024","uri":"https://projects.propublica.org/nonprofits/organizations/352558300","url":"https://projects.propublica.org/nonprofits/organizations/352558300"}],"summary":"The 2024 501(c)(6) filing identifies Kenneth D. McDonald as an officer or key employee.","tags":["wef-columbus","recursive-research","depth-4"],"title":"Kenneth D. McDonald held a 2024 Columbus Partnership role","verification":{"status":"source-backed","verified":true},"version":1,"workflow":{"max_depth":6,"recursion_depth":4,"research_status":"completed","root_target_id":"starintel:org:city-of-columbus"}}
{"_id":"starintel:relation:marcus-carano-employed-by-smart-columbus","assessment":{"confidence":0.92},"data":{"confidence":0.92,"directed":true,"object":"starintel:org:smart-columbus","predicate":"employed_by","subject":"starintel:person:marcus-carano"},"dataset":"wef","date_added":"2026-07-26T04:05:00Z","date_updated":"2026-07-26T04:05:00Z","dtype":"relation","evidence":[],"lineage":{"derived_from":["starintel:analysis:wef-columbus-depth-4-governance-replication-continuity"],"generation":5},"provenance":{"agent":"GPT-5.6 Thinking","method":"Primary-source recursive OSINT with bounded inference","run_id":"wef-columbus-depth-5-2026-07-26","skill":"auto-dig;web-research;create-starintel-documents;select-recursive-targets"},"schema_version":"0.9.0","sources":[{"accessed_at":"2026-07-26T04:05:00Z","credibility":0.95,"kind":"official_webpage","publisher":"Smart Columbus","title":"Columbus leads the way: Evolving our Green IT ambition","uri":"https://smartcolumbus.com/insights/2025-10-cie-vendor-announcement-83p85","url":"https://smartcolumbus.com/insights/2025-10-cie-vendor-announcement-83p85"}],"summary":"The Green IT publication identifies Marcus Carano as a Smart Columbus project manager.","tags":["wef","columbus","recursive-research","depth-5"],"title":"Marcus Carano employed by Smart Columbus","verification":{"status":"source-backed","verified":true},"version":1,"workflow":{"max_depth":6,"recursion_depth":5,"research_status":"completed","root_target_id":"starintel:org:city-of-columbus"}}
{"_id":"starintel:relation:mark-patton-columbus-partnership-c6","assessment":{"confidence":0.97},"data":{"confidence":0.97,"directed":true,"object":"starintel:org:columbus-partnership-c6","predicate":"vice_president_of","qualifiers":{"fiscal_year":2024},"subject":"starintel:person:mark-patton"},"dataset":"starintel-wef-columbus-depth-4-2026-07-25","date_added":"2026-07-25T21:15:00Z","date_updated":"2026-07-25T21:15:00Z","dtype":"relation","evidence":[],"lineage":{"derived_from":["starintel:research-pass:wef-columbus-depth-3-2026-07-25"],"generation":4},"provenance":{"agent":"GPT-5.6 Thinking","run_id":"wef-columbus-depth-4-2026-07-25","skill":"auto-dig;search-starintel-json-db;create-starintel-documents;select-recursive-targets"},"schema_version":"0.9.0","sources":[{"accessed_at":"2026-07-25T21:15:00Z","credibility":0.95,"kind":"irs_derived_filing","publisher":"ProPublica Nonprofit Explorer","title":"Columbus Partnership Form 990 — fiscal year 2024","uri":"https://projects.propublica.org/nonprofits/organizations/352558300","url":"https://projects.propublica.org/nonprofits/organizations/352558300"}],"summary":"The 2024 501(c)(6) filing identifies Mark Patton as an officer or key employee.","tags":["wef-columbus","recursive-research","depth-4"],"title":"Mark Patton held a 2024 Columbus Partnership role","verification":{"status":"source-backed","verified":true},"version":1,"workflow":{"max_depth":6,"recursion_depth":4,"research_status":"completed","root_target_id":"starintel:org:city-of-columbus"}}
{"_id":"starintel:relation:matt-scantland-founder-andhealth","assessment":{"confidence":0.98},"data":{"confidence":0.98,"directed":true,"object":"starintel:org:andhealth","predicate":"founder_and_ceo_of","qualifiers":{},"subject":"starintel:person:matt-scantland"},"dataset":"starintel-wef-columbus-depth-3-2026-07-25","date_added":"2026-07-25T20:30:00Z","date_updated":"2026-07-25T20:30:00Z","dtype":"relation","evidence":[],"lineage":{"derived_from":["starintel:research-pass:wef-columbus-depth-2-2026-07-25"],"generation":3},"provenance":{"agent":"GPT-5.6 Thinking","run_id":"wef-columbus-depth-3-2026-07-25","skill":"auto-dig;create-starintel-documents;select-recursive-targets"},"schema_version":"0.9.0","sources":[{"accessed_at":"2026-07-25T20:30:00Z","credibility":0.95,"kind":"official_webpage","publisher":"Official source","title":"Matt Scantland founded AndHealth","uri":"https://andhealth.com/about/","url":"https://andhealth.com/about/"}],"summary":"AndHealth identifies Scantland as founder and CEO.","tags":["wef-columbus","recursive-research","depth-3"],"title":"Matt Scantland founded AndHealth","verification":{"status":"source-backed","verified":true},"version":1,"workflow":{"max_depth":6,"recursion_depth":3,"research_status":"completed","root_target_id":"starintel:org:city-of-columbus"}}
{"_id":"starintel:relation:matt-stephens-rich-smart-columbus-ec","assessment":{"confidence":0.99},"data":{"confidence":0.99,"directed":true,"object":["starintel:org:smart-columbus","starintel:org:electrification-coalition"],"predicate":"worked_for_or_with","qualifiers":{},"subject":"starintel:person:matt-stephens-rich"},"dataset":"starintel-wef-columbus-depth-3-2026-07-25","date_added":"2026-07-25T20:30:00Z","date_updated":"2026-07-25T20:30:00Z","dtype":"relation","evidence":[],"lineage":{"derived_from":["starintel:research-pass:wef-columbus-depth-2-2026-07-25"],"generation":3},"provenance":{"agent":"GPT-5.6 Thinking","run_id":"wef-columbus-depth-3-2026-07-25","skill":"auto-dig;create-starintel-documents;select-recursive-targets"},"schema_version":"0.9.0","sources":[{"accessed_at":"2026-07-25T20:30:00Z","credibility":0.95,"kind":"official_webpage","publisher":"Official source","title":"Matt Stephens-Rich links Smart Columbus and Electrification Coalition","uri":"https://electrificationcoalition.org/our-team/","url":"https://electrificationcoalition.org/our-team/"}],"summary":"EC says he worked as Smart Columbus EV specialist and helped write the grant application.","tags":["wef-columbus","recursive-research","depth-3"],"title":"Matt Stephens-Rich links Smart Columbus and Electrification Coalition","verification":{"status":"source-backed","verified":true},"version":1,"workflow":{"max_depth":6,"recursion_depth":3,"research_status":"completed","root_target_id":"starintel:org:city-of-columbus"}}
{"_id":"starintel:relation:michael-stevens-former-chief-innovation-officer","assessment":{"confidence":0.99},"data":{"confidence":0.99,"directed":true,"object":"starintel:org:smart-columbus","predicate":"formerly_responsible_for","qualifiers":{},"subject":"starintel:person:michael-stevens"},"dataset":"starintel-wef-columbus-depth-3-2026-07-25","date_added":"2026-07-25T20:30:00Z","date_updated":"2026-07-25T20:30:00Z","dtype":"relation","evidence":[],"lineage":{"derived_from":["starintel:research-pass:wef-columbus-depth-2-2026-07-25"],"generation":3},"provenance":{"agent":"GPT-5.6 Thinking","run_id":"wef-columbus-depth-3-2026-07-25","skill":"auto-dig;create-starintel-documents;select-recursive-targets"},"schema_version":"0.9.0","sources":[{"accessed_at":"2026-07-25T20:30:00Z","credibility":0.95,"kind":"official_webpage","publisher":"Official source","title":"Michael Stevens formerly led Smart Columbus","uri":"https://www.columbus.gov/Government/Departments/Development/Directors-Bio","url":"https://www.columbus.gov/Government/Departments/Development/Directors-Bio"}],"summary":"The City identifies Stevens as its first Chief Innovation Officer responsible for Smart Columbus.","tags":["wef-columbus","recursive-research","depth-3"],"title":"Michael Stevens formerly led Smart Columbus","verification":{"status":"source-backed","verified":true},"version":1,"workflow":{"max_depth":6,"recursion_depth":3,"research_status":"completed","root_target_id":"starintel:org:city-of-columbus"}}
{"_id":"starintel:relation:mike-anderson-smart-columbus-team","assessment":{"confidence":0.99},"data":{"confidence":0.99,"directed":true,"object":"starintel:org:smart-columbus","predicate":"team_member_of","qualifiers":{"position":"CIE Delivery Lead"},"subject":"starintel:person:mike-anderson"},"dataset":"starintel-wef-columbus-depth-4-2026-07-25","date_added":"2026-07-25T21:15:00Z","date_updated":"2026-07-25T21:15:00Z","dtype":"relation","evidence":[],"lineage":{"derived_from":["starintel:research-pass:wef-columbus-depth-3-2026-07-25"],"generation":4},"provenance":{"agent":"GPT-5.6 Thinking","run_id":"wef-columbus-depth-4-2026-07-25","skill":"auto-dig;search-starintel-json-db;create-starintel-documents;select-recursive-targets"},"schema_version":"0.9.0","sources":[{"accessed_at":"2026-07-25T21:15:00Z","credibility":0.95,"kind":"official_webpage","publisher":"Smart Columbus","title":"Smart Columbus — About","uri":"https://smartcolumbus.com/about","url":"https://smartcolumbus.com/about"}],"summary":"Smart Columbus lists Mike Anderson as CIE Delivery Lead.","tags":["wef-columbus","recursive-research","depth-4"],"title":"Mike Anderson is listed on the Smart Columbus team","verification":{"status":"source-backed","verified":true},"version":1,"workflow":{"max_depth":6,"recursion_depth":4,"research_status":"completed","root_target_id":"starintel:org:city-of-columbus"}}
{"_id":"starintel:relation:norah-goldman-smart-columbus-team","assessment":{"confidence":0.99},"data":{"confidence":0.99,"directed":true,"object":"starintel:org:smart-columbus","predicate":"team_member_of","qualifiers":{"position":"Communications Lead"},"subject":"starintel:person:norah-goldman"},"dataset":"starintel-wef-columbus-depth-4-2026-07-25","date_added":"2026-07-25T21:15:00Z","date_updated":"2026-07-25T21:15:00Z","dtype":"relation","evidence":[],"lineage":{"derived_from":["starintel:research-pass:wef-columbus-depth-3-2026-07-25"],"generation":4},"provenance":{"agent":"GPT-5.6 Thinking","run_id":"wef-columbus-depth-4-2026-07-25","skill":"auto-dig;search-starintel-json-db;create-starintel-documents;select-recursive-targets"},"schema_version":"0.9.0","sources":[{"accessed_at":"2026-07-25T21:15:00Z","credibility":0.95,"kind":"official_webpage","publisher":"Smart Columbus","title":"Smart Columbus — About","uri":"https://smartcolumbus.com/about","url":"https://smartcolumbus.com/about"}],"summary":"Smart Columbus lists Norah Goldman as Communications Lead.","tags":["wef-columbus","recursive-research","depth-4"],"title":"Norah Goldman is listed on the Smart Columbus team","verification":{"status":"source-backed","verified":true},"version":1,"workflow":{"max_depth":6,"recursion_depth":4,"research_status":"completed","root_target_id":"starintel:org:city-of-columbus"}}
{"_id":"starintel:relation:ohio-development-supported-andhealth-expansion","assessment":{"confidence":0.99},"data":{"confidence":0.99,"directed":true,"object":"starintel:org:andhealth","predicate":"supported_expansion_of","qualifiers":{},"subject":"starintel:org:ohio-department-of-development"},"dataset":"starintel-wef-columbus-depth-4-2026-07-25","date_added":"2026-07-25T21:15:00Z","date_updated":"2026-07-25T21:15:00Z","dtype":"relation","evidence":[],"lineage":{"derived_from":["starintel:research-pass:wef-columbus-depth-3-2026-07-25"],"generation":4},"provenance":{"agent":"GPT-5.6 Thinking","run_id":"wef-columbus-depth-4-2026-07-25","skill":"auto-dig;search-starintel-json-db;create-starintel-documents;select-recursive-targets"},"schema_version":"0.9.0","sources":[{"accessed_at":"2026-07-25T21:15:00Z","credibility":0.95,"kind":"official_project_record","publisher":"JobsOhio","title":"AndHealth Expanding Office Space in Downtown Columbus","uri":"https://www.jobsohio.com/newsroom/news-press/andhealth-expanding-office-space-in-downtown-columbus","url":"https://www.jobsohio.com/newsroom/news-press/andhealth-expanding-office-space-in-downtown-columbus"}],"summary":"The state agency is listed among the 2025 project collaborators.","tags":["wef-columbus","recursive-research","depth-4"],"title":"Ohio Department of Development supported AndHealth expansion","verification":{"status":"source-backed","verified":true},"version":1,"workflow":{"max_depth":6,"recursion_depth":4,"research_status":"completed","root_target_id":"starintel:org:city-of-columbus"}}
{"_id":"starintel:relation:one-columbus-supported-andhealth-expansion","assessment":{"confidence":0.99},"data":{"confidence":0.99,"directed":true,"object":"starintel:org:andhealth","predicate":"supported_expansion_of","qualifiers":{},"subject":"starintel:org:one-columbus"},"dataset":"starintel-wef-columbus-depth-4-2026-07-25","date_added":"2026-07-25T21:15:00Z","date_updated":"2026-07-25T21:15:00Z","dtype":"relation","evidence":[],"lineage":{"derived_from":["starintel:research-pass:wef-columbus-depth-3-2026-07-25"],"generation":4},"provenance":{"agent":"GPT-5.6 Thinking","run_id":"wef-columbus-depth-4-2026-07-25","skill":"auto-dig;search-starintel-json-db;create-starintel-documents;select-recursive-targets"},"schema_version":"0.9.0","sources":[{"accessed_at":"2026-07-25T21:15:00Z","credibility":0.95,"kind":"official_project_record","publisher":"One Columbus","title":"Digital Healthcare Startup AndHealth Brings 65 New Jobs","uri":"https://columbusregion.com/press-release/digital-healthcare-startup-andhealth-brings-65-new-jobs-to-downtown-columbus-for-operations-expansion/","url":"https://columbusregion.com/press-release/digital-healthcare-startup-andhealth-brings-65-new-jobs-to-downtown-columbus-for-operations-expansion/"},{"accessed_at":"2026-07-25T21:15:00Z","credibility":0.95,"kind":"official_project_record","publisher":"JobsOhio","title":"AndHealth Expanding Office Space in Downtown Columbus","uri":"https://www.jobsohio.com/newsroom/news-press/andhealth-expanding-office-space-in-downtown-columbus","url":"https://www.jobsohio.com/newsroom/news-press/andhealth-expanding-office-space-in-downtown-columbus"}],"summary":"One Columbus announced the 2022 project and is listed as a collaborator in the 2025 JobsOhio project record.","tags":["wef-columbus","recursive-research","depth-4"],"title":"One Columbus supported AndHealth expansion","verification":{"status":"source-backed","verified":true},"version":1,"workflow":{"max_depth":6,"recursion_depth":4,"research_status":"completed","root_target_id":"starintel:org:city-of-columbus"}}
{"_id":"starintel:relation:paige-hollowell-authored-grant-era-index","assessment":{"confidence":0.99},"data":{"confidence":0.99,"directed":true,"object":"starintel:source:smart-columbus-grant-era-reports-index","predicate":"authored","qualifiers":{},"subject":"starintel:person:paige-hollowell"},"dataset":"starintel-wef-columbus-depth-4-2026-07-25","date_added":"2026-07-25T21:15:00Z","date_updated":"2026-07-25T21:15:00Z","dtype":"relation","evidence":[],"lineage":{"derived_from":["starintel:research-pass:wef-columbus-depth-3-2026-07-25"],"generation":4},"provenance":{"agent":"GPT-5.6 Thinking","run_id":"wef-columbus-depth-4-2026-07-25","skill":"auto-dig;search-starintel-json-db;create-starintel-documents;select-recursive-targets"},"schema_version":"0.9.0","sources":[{"accessed_at":"2026-07-25T21:15:00Z","credibility":0.95,"kind":"official_webpage","publisher":"Smart Columbus","title":"Smart City Grant Era Reports","uri":"https://smartcolumbus.com/insights/smart-city-grant-era-reports","url":"https://smartcolumbus.com/insights/smart-city-grant-era-reports"}],"summary":"The Smart Columbus index identifies Paige Hollowell as the author.","tags":["wef-columbus","recursive-research","depth-4"],"title":"Paige Hollowell authored the Smart City grant-era report index","verification":{"status":"source-backed","verified":true},"version":1,"workflow":{"max_depth":6,"recursion_depth":4,"research_status":"completed","root_target_id":"starintel:org:city-of-columbus"}}
{"_id":"starintel:relation:pillar-acquired-by-accenture","assessment":{"confidence":0.99},"data":{"confidence":0.99,"directed":true,"object":"starintel:org:accenture","predicate":"acquired_by","qualifiers":{},"subject":"starintel:org:pillar-technology-group"},"dataset":"starintel-wef-columbus-depth-3-2026-07-25","date_added":"2026-07-25T20:30:00Z","date_updated":"2026-07-25T20:30:00Z","dtype":"relation","evidence":[],"lineage":{"derived_from":["starintel:research-pass:wef-columbus-depth-2-2026-07-25"],"generation":3},"provenance":{"agent":"GPT-5.6 Thinking","run_id":"wef-columbus-depth-3-2026-07-25","skill":"auto-dig;create-starintel-documents;select-recursive-targets"},"schema_version":"0.9.0","sources":[{"accessed_at":"2026-07-25T20:30:00Z","credibility":0.95,"kind":"government_record","publisher":"Official source","title":"Accenture acquired Pillar Technology Group","uri":"https://columbus.legistar.com/LegislationDetail.aspx?FullText=1&GUID=25689AF7-E15D-4218-8726-CFE46FC368ED&ID=3910766","url":"https://columbus.legistar.com/LegislationDetail.aspx?FullText=1&GUID=25689AF7-E15D-4218-8726-CFE46FC368ED&ID=3910766"}],"summary":"City ordinance assigned Pillar's Smart City contracts to Accenture after acquisition.","tags":["wef-columbus","recursive-research","depth-3"],"title":"Accenture acquired Pillar Technology Group","verification":{"status":"source-backed","verified":true},"version":1,"workflow":{"max_depth":6,"recursion_depth":3,"research_status":"completed","root_target_id":"starintel:org:city-of-columbus"}}
{"_id":"starintel:relation:sean-grant-columbus-partnership-c6","assessment":{"confidence":0.97},"data":{"confidence":0.97,"directed":true,"object":"starintel:org:columbus-partnership-c6","predicate":"chief_administrative_officer_of","qualifiers":{"fiscal_year":2024},"subject":"starintel:person:sean-grant"},"dataset":"starintel-wef-columbus-depth-4-2026-07-25","date_added":"2026-07-25T21:15:00Z","date_updated":"2026-07-25T21:15:00Z","dtype":"relation","evidence":[],"lineage":{"derived_from":["starintel:research-pass:wef-columbus-depth-3-2026-07-25"],"generation":4},"provenance":{"agent":"GPT-5.6 Thinking","run_id":"wef-columbus-depth-4-2026-07-25","skill":"auto-dig;search-starintel-json-db;create-starintel-documents;select-recursive-targets"},"schema_version":"0.9.0","sources":[{"accessed_at":"2026-07-25T21:15:00Z","credibility":0.95,"kind":"irs_derived_filing","publisher":"ProPublica Nonprofit Explorer","title":"Columbus Partnership Form 990 — fiscal year 2024","uri":"https://projects.propublica.org/nonprofits/organizations/352558300","url":"https://projects.propublica.org/nonprofits/organizations/352558300"}],"summary":"The 2024 501(c)(6) filing identifies Sean Grant as an officer or key employee.","tags":["wef-columbus","recursive-research","depth-4"],"title":"Sean Grant held a 2024 Columbus Partnership role","verification":{"status":"source-backed","verified":true},"version":1,"workflow":{"max_depth":6,"recursion_depth":4,"research_status":"completed","root_target_id":"starintel:org:city-of-columbus"}}
{"_id":"starintel:relation:smart-columbus-board-roster-conflict","assessment":{"confidence":0.99},"data":{"confidence":0.99,"directed":true,"object":["starintel:source:smart-columbus-about","starintel:source:smart-columbus-board-legacy"],"predicate":"has_conflicting_public_board_rosters","qualifiers":{},"subject":"starintel:org:smart-columbus"},"dataset":"starintel-wef-columbus-depth-3-2026-07-25","date_added":"2026-07-25T20:30:00Z","date_updated":"2026-07-25T20:30:00Z","dtype":"relation","evidence":[],"lineage":{"derived_from":["starintel:research-pass:wef-columbus-depth-2-2026-07-25"],"generation":3},"provenance":{"agent":"GPT-5.6 Thinking","run_id":"wef-columbus-depth-3-2026-07-25","skill":"auto-dig;create-starintel-documents;select-recursive-targets"},"schema_version":"0.9.0","sources":[{"accessed_at":"2026-07-25T20:30:00Z","credibility":0.95,"kind":"official_webpage","publisher":"Official source","title":"Official Smart Columbus board rosters conflict","uri":"https://smartcolumbus.com/about","url":"https://smartcolumbus.com/about"},{"accessed_at":"2026-07-25T20:30:00Z","credibility":0.95,"kind":"official_webpage","publisher":"Official source","title":"Official Smart Columbus board rosters conflict","uri":"https://columbusregion.com/about-us/boards-investors/smart-columbus-board/","url":"https://columbusregion.com/about-us/boards-investors/smart-columbus-board/"}],"summary":"The current Smart Columbus page and legacy Columbus Region page list different leadership and affiliations.","tags":["wef-columbus","recursive-research","depth-3"],"title":"Official Smart Columbus board rosters conflict","verification":{"status":"source-backed","verified":true},"version":1,"workflow":{"max_depth":6,"recursion_depth":3,"research_status":"completed","root_target_id":"starintel:org:city-of-columbus"}}
{"_id":"starintel:relation:smart-columbus-exported-playbooks","assessment":{"confidence":0.98},"data":{"confidence":0.98,"directed":true,"object":{"dtype":"org","label":"other cities and agencies","unresolved":true},"predicate":"exported_knowledge_to","qualifiers":{"mechanisms":["open-source software","technical documentation","deployment playbooks"]},"subject":"starintel:org:smart-columbus"},"dataset":"starintel-wef-columbus-depth-4-2026-07-25","date_added":"2026-07-25T21:15:00Z","date_updated":"2026-07-25T21:15:00Z","dtype":"relation","evidence":[],"lineage":{"derived_from":["starintel:research-pass:wef-columbus-depth-3-2026-07-25"],"generation":4},"provenance":{"agent":"GPT-5.6 Thinking","run_id":"wef-columbus-depth-4-2026-07-25","skill":"auto-dig;search-starintel-json-db;create-starintel-documents;select-recursive-targets"},"schema_version":"0.9.0","sources":[{"accessed_at":"2026-07-25T21:15:00Z","credibility":0.95,"kind":"government_report","publisher":"City of Columbus","title":"Smart Columbus Program Summary — June 2021","uri":"https://static1.squarespace.com/static/6543abac601e3621dd3fe76d/t/68b832df3dd5017d3a1c12e2/1756902111728/2021-06%2BUSDOT%2BFinal%2BReport%2BExecutive%2BSummary%2B%281%29-compressed-compressed.pdf","url":"https://static1.squarespace.com/static/6543abac601e3621dd3fe76d/t/68b832df3dd5017d3a1c12e2/1756902111728/2021-06%2BUSDOT%2BFinal%2BReport%2BExecutive%2BSummary%2B%281%29-compressed-compressed.pdf"}],"summary":"Program outputs included open-source components, technical information, and deployment playbooks intended for other cities and agencies.","tags":["wef-columbus","recursive-research","depth-4"],"title":"Smart Columbus exported technical lessons and playbooks","verification":{"status":"source-backed","verified":true},"version":1,"workflow":{"max_depth":6,"recursion_depth":4,"research_status":"completed","root_target_id":"starintel:org:city-of-columbus"}}
{"_id":"starintel:relation:smart-columbus-local-implementation","aliases":[],"assessment":{"confidence":0.98},"attachments":[],"data":{"confidence":0.98,"object":"starintel:org:city-of-columbus","predicate":"provides_policy_and_project_capacity_to","subject":"starintel:org:smart-columbus"},"dataset":"starintel-wef-columbus-urban-transformation-2026-07-25","date_added":"2026-07-25T00:00:00Z","date_updated":"2026-07-25T00:00:00Z","description":"","dtype":"relation","evidence":[],"extensions":{"legacy.v0":{"data":{"board_sectors":["City of Columbus","Franklin County","MORPC","Columbus Partnership","IBM iX"],"service_areas":["thought leadership","partner convening","project delivery","climate action","electrification","broadband","digital equity"]}}},"geospatial":{},"handling":{"pii":false,"sensitive":false,"visibility":"public"},"identifiers":[],"keywords":[],"labels":[],"language":"en","lineage":{"migration_from":"0.8","migration_notes":["Normalized into the canonical StarIntel v0.9.0 document envelope."]},"notes":[],"provenance":{"original_id":"starintel:relation:smart-columbus-local-implementation","original_path":"digs/wef-columbus/2026-07-25-urban-transformation-network/starintel-documents.jsonl","original_schema_version":"0.8","software_version":"0.9.0","transform":"starintel_doc.migration.migrate_document"},"quality":{},"related_ids":[],"schema_version":"0.9.0","sources":[{"accessed_at":"2026-07-25T00:00:00Z","metadata":{"source_type":"official_organization"},"title":"About Smart Columbus","uri":"https://smartcolumbus.com/about","url":"https://smartcolumbus.com/about"},{"accessed_at":"2026-07-25T00:00:00Z","metadata":{"source_type":"official_organization"},"title":"Smart Columbus Board","uri":"https://columbusregion.com/about-us/boards-investors/smart-columbus-board/","url":"https://columbusregion.com/about-us/boards-investors/smart-columbus-board/"},{"accessed_at":"2026-07-25T00:00:00Z","metadata":{"source_type":"official_organization"},"title":"About the Columbus Partnership","uri":"https://columbusregion.com/about-us/","url":"https://columbusregion.com/about-us/"},{"accessed_at":"2026-07-25T00:00:00Z","metadata":{"source_type":"government_record"},"title":"Columbus Ordinance 1663-2025","uri":"https://columbus.legistar.com/LegislationDetail.aspx?FullText=1&GUID=5E02F335-BDF8-4220-B7BB-05FE16CF6CC4&ID=7489830","url":"https://columbus.legistar.com/LegislationDetail.aspx?FullText=1&GUID=5E02F335-BDF8-4220-B7BB-05FE16CF6CC4&ID=7489830"},{"accessed_at":"2026-07-25T00:00:00Z","metadata":{"source_type":"government_record"},"title":"Columbus Ordinance 1850-2026","uri":"https://columbus.legistar.com/LegislationDetail.aspx?FullText=1&GUID=588DBFF9-D9DB-4603-B5D4-776E9F5B5A9E&ID=8117690&Options=&Search=","url":"https://columbus.legistar.com/LegislationDetail.aspx?FullText=1&GUID=588DBFF9-D9DB-4603-B5D4-776E9F5B5A9E&ID=8117690&Options=&Search="}],"status":"recorded","summary":"Smart Columbus operates within the Columbus Partnership, has a public-private board and receives City assignments covering climate, electrification, broadband and digital equity.","tags":[],"temporal":{},"title":"Smart Columbus links global policy participation to local implementation capacity","verification":{"status":"confirmed"},"version":1,"workflow":{}}
{"_id":"starintel:relation:smart-columbus-partnered-honda-living-lab","assessment":{"confidence":0.98},"data":{"confidence":0.98,"directed":true,"object":"starintel:org:honda","predicate":"partnered_with","qualifiers":{"program_id":"starintel:event:central-ohio-living-lab-launch-2025"},"subject":"starintel:org:smart-columbus"},"dataset":"wef","date_added":"2026-07-26T04:05:00Z","date_updated":"2026-07-26T04:05:00Z","dtype":"relation","evidence":[],"lineage":{"derived_from":["starintel:analysis:wef-columbus-depth-4-governance-replication-continuity"],"generation":5},"provenance":{"agent":"GPT-5.6 Thinking","method":"Primary-source recursive OSINT with bounded inference","run_id":"wef-columbus-depth-5-2026-07-26","skill":"auto-dig;web-research;create-starintel-documents;select-recursive-targets"},"schema_version":"0.9.0","sources":[{"accessed_at":"2026-07-26T04:05:00Z","credibility":0.95,"kind":"official_webpage","publisher":"Smart Columbus","title":"A year of impact: 2025 by the numbers","uri":"https://smartcolumbus.com/insights/2025-12-year-of-impact","url":"https://smartcolumbus.com/insights/2025-12-year-of-impact"}],"summary":"Smart Columbus identifies Honda as its partner in launching the Living Lab.","tags":["wef","columbus","recursive-research","depth-5"],"title":"Smart Columbus partnered with Honda on the Central Ohio Living Lab","verification":{"status":"source-backed","verified":true},"version":1,"workflow":{"max_depth":6,"recursion_depth":5,"research_status":"completed","root_target_id":"starintel:org:city-of-columbus"}}
{"_id":"starintel:relation:steve-steinour-columbus-partnership-c3","assessment":{"confidence":0.97},"data":{"confidence":0.97,"directed":true,"object":"starintel:org:the-columbus-partnership-c3","predicate":"cochair_of","qualifiers":{"fiscal_year":2024},"subject":"starintel:person:steve-steinour"},"dataset":"starintel-wef-columbus-depth-4-2026-07-25","date_added":"2026-07-25T21:15:00Z","date_updated":"2026-07-25T21:15:00Z","dtype":"relation","evidence":[],"lineage":{"derived_from":["starintel:research-pass:wef-columbus-depth-3-2026-07-25"],"generation":4},"provenance":{"agent":"GPT-5.6 Thinking","run_id":"wef-columbus-depth-4-2026-07-25","skill":"auto-dig;search-starintel-json-db;create-starintel-documents;select-recursive-targets"},"schema_version":"0.9.0","sources":[{"accessed_at":"2026-07-25T21:15:00Z","credibility":0.95,"kind":"irs_derived_filing","publisher":"ProPublica Nonprofit Explorer","title":"The Columbus Partnership Form 990 — fiscal year 2024","uri":"https://projects.propublica.org/nonprofits/organizations/20580058","url":"https://projects.propublica.org/nonprofits/organizations/20580058"}],"summary":"The 2024 501(c)(3) filing identifies Steve Steinour as an officer or director.","tags":["wef-columbus","recursive-research","depth-4"],"title":"Steve Steinour held a 2024 The Columbus Partnership role","verification":{"status":"source-backed","verified":true},"version":1,"workflow":{"max_depth":6,"recursion_depth":4,"research_status":"completed","root_target_id":"starintel:org:city-of-columbus"}}
{"_id":"starintel:relation:tosin-guobadia-smart-columbus-team","assessment":{"confidence":0.99},"data":{"confidence":0.99,"directed":true,"object":"starintel:org:smart-columbus","predicate":"team_member_of","qualifiers":{"position":"Project and Change Management Consultant"},"subject":"starintel:person:tosin-guobadia"},"dataset":"starintel-wef-columbus-depth-4-2026-07-25","date_added":"2026-07-25T21:15:00Z","date_updated":"2026-07-25T21:15:00Z","dtype":"relation","evidence":[],"lineage":{"derived_from":["starintel:research-pass:wef-columbus-depth-3-2026-07-25"],"generation":4},"provenance":{"agent":"GPT-5.6 Thinking","run_id":"wef-columbus-depth-4-2026-07-25","skill":"auto-dig;search-starintel-json-db;create-starintel-documents;select-recursive-targets"},"schema_version":"0.9.0","sources":[{"accessed_at":"2026-07-25T21:15:00Z","credibility":0.95,"kind":"official_webpage","publisher":"Smart Columbus","title":"Smart Columbus — About","uri":"https://smartcolumbus.com/about","url":"https://smartcolumbus.com/about"}],"summary":"Smart Columbus lists Tosin Guobadia as Project and Change Management Consultant.","tags":["wef-columbus","recursive-research","depth-4"],"title":"Tosin Guobadia is listed on the Smart Columbus team","verification":{"status":"source-backed","verified":true},"version":1,"workflow":{"max_depth":6,"recursion_depth":4,"research_status":"completed","root_target_id":"starintel:org:city-of-columbus"}}
{"_id":"starintel:relation:urbanos-public-publishes-smart-cities-data-platform","assessment":{"confidence":0.98},"data":{"confidence":0.98,"directed":true,"object":"starintel:product:urbanos-smart-cities-data-platform","predicate":"publishes","subject":"starintel:org:urbanos-public"},"dataset":"wef","date_added":"2026-07-26T04:05:00Z","date_updated":"2026-07-26T04:05:00Z","dtype":"relation","evidence":[],"lineage":{"derived_from":["starintel:analysis:wef-columbus-depth-4-governance-replication-continuity"],"generation":5},"provenance":{"agent":"GPT-5.6 Thinking","method":"Primary-source recursive OSINT with bounded inference","run_id":"wef-columbus-depth-5-2026-07-26","skill":"auto-dig;web-research;create-starintel-documents;select-recursive-targets"},"schema_version":"0.9.0","sources":[{"accessed_at":"2026-07-26T04:05:00Z","credibility":0.98,"kind":"source_repository","publisher":"UrbanOS-Public","title":"UrbanOS-Public/smartcitiesdata","uri":"https://github.com/UrbanOS-Public/smartcitiesdata","url":"https://github.com/UrbanOS-Public/smartcitiesdata"}],"summary":"The public repository documents a distributed smart-city ingestion, storage, streaming, and analytics platform.","tags":["wef","columbus","recursive-research","depth-5"],"title":"UrbanOS-Public publishes the Smart Cities Data Platform","verification":{"status":"source-backed","verified":true},"version":1,"workflow":{"max_depth":6,"recursion_depth":5,"research_status":"completed","root_target_id":"starintel:org:city-of-columbus"}}
{"_id":"starintel:research-pass:wef-columbus-2026-07-25","aliases":[],"assessment":{"confidence":0.95},"attachments":[],"data":{"findings":[{"confidence":0.97,"finding":"WEF maintains a City of Columbus organization profile.","support_ids":["starintel:relation:city-of-columbus-wef-urban-transformation"]},{"confidence":0.99,"finding":"Smart Columbus leadership participated in a WEF infrastructure-policy task force.","support_ids":["starintel:event:wef-infrastructure-roadmap-2024"]},{"confidence":0.98,"finding":"Smart Columbus provides City-funded policy and project capacity inside a formal public-private network.","support_ids":["starintel:relation:smart-columbus-local-implementation","starintel:financial-observation:smart-columbus-authorizations-2022-2026"]},{"confidence":0.92,"finding":"No direct WEF funding, binding authority, fraud or diversion was identified.","support_ids":["starintel:analysis:wef-columbus-influence"]}],"method":"['Use official records.', 'Separate relationship, funding and inference.', 'Treat authorizations as ceilings.', 'Record unproven claims.']","research_question":"What documented mechanisms connect WEF to Columbus institutions capable of shaping or implementing policy?"},"dataset":"starintel-wef-columbus-urban-transformation-2026-07-25","date_added":"2026-07-25T00:00:00Z","date_updated":"2026-07-25T00:00:00Z","description":"","dtype":"research-pass","evidence":[],"extensions":{"legacy.v0":{"data":{"author":{"name":"GPT auto-dig research agent","type":"agent"},"confidence":0.95,"open_targets":["starintel:investigation-target:wef-columbus-records"],"subject":{"entity_id":"starintel:org:city-of-columbus","name":"City of Columbus"}},"metadata":{"verification":{"method":"official-record triangulation"}}}},"geospatial":{},"handling":{"pii":false,"sensitive":false,"visibility":"public"},"identifiers":[],"keywords":[],"labels":[],"language":"en","lineage":{"migration_from":"0.8","migration_notes":["Normalized into the canonical StarIntel v0.9.0 document envelope."]},"notes":[],"provenance":{"original_id":"starintel:research-pass:wef-columbus-2026-07-25","original_path":"digs/wef-columbus/2026-07-25-urban-transformation-network/starintel-documents.jsonl","original_schema_version":"0.8","software_version":"0.9.0","transform":"starintel_doc.migration.migrate_document"},"quality":{},"related_ids":[],"schema_version":"0.9.0","sources":[{"accessed_at":"2026-07-25T00:00:00Z","metadata":{"source_type":"official_organization"},"title":"City of Columbus | World Economic Forum","uri":"https://www.weforum.org/organizations/city-of-columbus/","url":"https://www.weforum.org/organizations/city-of-columbus/"},{"accessed_at":"2026-07-25T00:00:00Z","metadata":{"source_type":"official_project"},"title":"Implementing a Life-Cycle Approach to Infrastructure","uri":"https://centres.weforum.org/centre-for-urban-transformation/infrastructure-lifecycle","url":"https://centres.weforum.org/centre-for-urban-transformation/infrastructure-lifecycle"},{"accessed_at":"2026-07-25T00:00:00Z","metadata":{"source_type":"official_organization"},"title":"About Smart Columbus","uri":"https://smartcolumbus.com/about","url":"https://smartcolumbus.com/about"},{"accessed_at":"2026-07-25T00:00:00Z","metadata":{"source_type":"official_organization"},"title":"Smart Columbus Board","uri":"https://columbusregion.com/about-us/boards-investors/smart-columbus-board/","url":"https://columbusregion.com/about-us/boards-investors/smart-columbus-board/"},{"accessed_at":"2026-07-25T00:00:00Z","metadata":{"source_type":"official_organization"},"title":"About the Columbus Partnership","uri":"https://columbusregion.com/about-us/","url":"https://columbusregion.com/about-us/"},{"accessed_at":"2026-07-25T00:00:00Z","metadata":{"source_type":"government_record"},"title":"Columbus Ordinance 1663-2025","uri":"https://columbus.legistar.com/LegislationDetail.aspx?FullText=1&GUID=5E02F335-BDF8-4220-B7BB-05FE16CF6CC4&ID=7489830","url":"https://columbus.legistar.com/LegislationDetail.aspx?FullText=1&GUID=5E02F335-BDF8-4220-B7BB-05FE16CF6CC4&ID=7489830"},{"accessed_at":"2026-07-25T00:00:00Z","metadata":{"source_type":"government_record"},"title":"Columbus Ordinance 1850-2026","uri":"https://columbus.legistar.com/LegislationDetail.aspx?FullText=1&GUID=588DBFF9-D9DB-4603-B5D4-776E9F5B5A9E&ID=8117690&Options=&Search=","url":"https://columbus.legistar.com/LegislationDetail.aspx?FullText=1&GUID=588DBFF9-D9DB-4603-B5D4-776E9F5B5A9E&ID=8117690&Options=&Search="}],"status":"recorded","summary":"The record supports a direct WEF–Columbus policy-network relationship centered on the Centre for Urban Transformation and Smart Columbus; it does not support claims of command, fraud or direct WEF funding.","tags":[],"temporal":{},"title":"Agent research pass: WEF influence in Columbus, Ohio","verification":{"status":"analytical_synthesis"},"version":1,"workflow":{}}
{"_id":"starintel:research-pass:wef-columbus-depth-3-2026-07-25","assessment":{"confidence":0.97},"data":{"agent_identity":"GPT-5.6 Thinking auto-dig agent","classification_rules":["Separate documented relationship from inference.","Use identified-minimum labels when contract modification history is incomplete.","Do not infer WEF command, fraud, or corruption from association or repeat contracting.","Create source documents and recursive targets so every new finding can seed the next depth."],"completed_at":"2026-07-25T20:30:00Z","counterevidence_ids":[],"finding_ids":["starintel:analysis:wef-columbus-depth-3-network-expansion","starintel:relation:corrine-burger-interim-ceo-columbus-partnership","starintel:relation:jordan-davis-chief-of-staff-andhealth","starintel:contract:pillar-accenture-smart-city-chain-2018-2020","starintel:contract:hntb-smart-city-program-management-identified-minimum","starintel:relation:electrification-coalition-advised-smart-columbus","starintel:relation:smart-columbus-board-roster-conflict"],"findings":[{"confidence":0.99,"finding":"Corrine Burger moved from JPMorganChase leadership into interim control of the Columbus Partnership umbrella.","support_ids":["starintel:person:corrine-burger","starintel:relation:corrine-burger-interim-ceo-columbus-partnership","starintel:relation:corrine-burger-former-jpmorgan-chase"]},{"confidence":0.99,"finding":"Jordan Davis moved to AndHealth while remaining on the Smart Columbus board.","support_ids":["starintel:relation:jordan-davis-chief-of-staff-andhealth","starintel:relation:jordan-davis-smart-columbus-board"]},{"confidence":0.97,"finding":"Pillar/Accenture and HNTB occupied large, repeatedly modified technology and program-management roles.","support_ids":["starintel:contract:pillar-accenture-smart-city-chain-2018-2020","starintel:contract:hntb-smart-city-program-management-identified-minimum"]},{"confidence":0.98,"finding":"The Electrification Coalition linked grant application, local implementation, policy advice, and national replication.","support_ids":["starintel:org:electrification-coalition","starintel:person:matt-stephens-rich","starintel:relation:electrification-coalition-advised-smart-columbus"]},{"confidence":0.99,"finding":"Official public board rosters conflict, creating a governance-records target.","support_ids":["starintel:relation:smart-columbus-board-roster-conflict"]}],"iteration":3,"method":"Breadth-first recursive expansion using official organizational pages, municipal legislation, contract histories, and primary program materials.","narrative_role":"recursive network expansion","research_question":"What new institutional pathways appear when every substantive Depth 2 person, organization, contract, and document is recursively expanded?","source_ids":["starintel:source:smart-columbus-about","starintel:source:columbus-partnership-transition-2026","starintel:source:michael-stevens-bio","starintel:source:andhealth-about","starintel:source:andhealth-financing-2022","starintel:source:smart-columbus-board-legacy","starintel:source:morpc-william-murdock","starintel:source:ec-team","starintel:source:ec-accelerate-your-city","starintel:source:ord-0820-2018","starintel:source:ord-0898-2019","starintel:source:ord-2432-2020","starintel:source:ord-1056-2018","starintel:source:ord-0477-2019","starintel:source:council-2019-03-18-vendor-cluster","starintel:source:ord-0551-2019","starintel:source:ord-0554-2019","starintel:source:ord-2608-2017","starintel:source:smart-columbus-work","starintel:source:ord-1850-2026"],"started_at":"2026-07-25T19:55:00Z","supporting_record_ids":["starintel:analysis:wef-columbus-depth-3-network-expansion","starintel:relation:corrine-burger-interim-ceo-columbus-partnership","starintel:relation:jordan-davis-chief-of-staff-andhealth","starintel:contract:pillar-accenture-smart-city-chain-2018-2020","starintel:contract:hntb-smart-city-program-management-identified-minimum","starintel:relation:electrification-coalition-advised-smart-columbus","starintel:relation:smart-columbus-board-roster-conflict"],"unresolved_target_ids":["starintel:investigation-target:wef-columbus-depth-4-personnel-board-governance","starintel:investigation-target:wef-columbus-depth-4-vendor-contract-lifecycle","starintel:investigation-target:wef-columbus-depth-4-private-grant-replication","starintel:investigation-target:wef-columbus-depth-4-andhealth-public-private-continuity"]},"dataset":"starintel-wef-columbus-depth-3-2026-07-25","date_added":"2026-07-25T20:30:00Z","date_updated":"2026-07-25T20:30:00Z","dtype":"research-pass","evidence":[],"lineage":{"derived_from":["starintel:research-pass:wef-columbus-depth-2-2026-07-25"],"generation":3},"provenance":{"agent":"GPT-5.6 Thinking","run_id":"wef-columbus-depth-3-2026-07-25","skill":"auto-dig;create-starintel-documents;select-recursive-targets"},"schema_version":"0.9.0","sources":[{"accessed_at":"2026-07-25T20:30:00Z","credibility":0.95,"kind":"official_webpage","publisher":"Smart Columbus","title":"Smart Columbus About","uri":"https://smartcolumbus.com/about","url":"https://smartcolumbus.com/about"},{"accessed_at":"2026-07-25T20:30:00Z","credibility":0.95,"kind":"official_webpage","publisher":"Columbus Partnership","title":"Columbus Partnership leadership transition","uri":"https://columbusregion.com/press-release/columbus-partnership-announces-leadership-transition/","url":"https://columbusregion.com/press-release/columbus-partnership-announces-leadership-transition/"},{"accessed_at":"2026-07-25T20:30:00Z","credibility":0.95,"kind":"government_database","publisher":"City of Columbus","title":"City of Columbus Legistar","uri":"https://columbus.legistar.com/","url":"https://columbus.legistar.com/"},{"accessed_at":"2026-07-25T20:30:00Z","credibility":0.95,"kind":"official_webpage","publisher":"Electrification Coalition","title":"Electrification Coalition resources","uri":"https://electrificationcoalition.org/resource/","url":"https://electrificationcoalition.org/resource/"}],"summary":"Recursive expansion of all substantive people, organizations, vendors, contracts, and source documents identified at Depth 2.","tags":["wef-columbus","recursive-research","depth-3"],"title":"WEF–Columbus recursive research pass — Depth 3","verification":{"status":"source-backed","verified":true},"version":1,"workflow":{"completed_at":"2026-07-25T20:30:00Z","max_depth":6,"priority":0.95,"queue":"wef-columbus","recursion_depth":3,"research_status":"completed","root_target_id":"starintel:org:city-of-columbus","selected_from":["starintel:research-pass:wef-columbus-depth-2-2026-07-25"],"selection_reason":["operator-directed breadth-first recursion"]}}
{"_id":"starintel:research-pass:wef-columbus-depth-4-2026-07-25","assessment":{"confidence":0.98},"data":{"agent_identity":"GPT-5.6 Thinking auto-dig agent","classification_rules":["Separate facts, inference, and unresolved questions.","Treat authorized contract ceilings as distinct from outlays.","Treat Schedule L reporting as a disclosure requiring details, not proof of misconduct.","Treat economic-development collaboration as support, not proof of a specific incentive amount.","Create each new document, person, organization, contract, relation, and source as a Depth 5 seed."],"completed_at":"2026-07-25T21:15:00Z","counterevidence_ids":[],"finding_ids":["starintel:relation:columbus-partnership-c6-legally-distinct-c3","starintel:observation:columbus-partnership-c6-schedule-l-2024","starintel:event:smart-columbus-three-funding-streams-2021","starintel:observation:smart-columbus-project-continuation-and-replication","starintel:contract:hntb-smart-lighting-phase-4-lifecycle-2022-2026","starintel:relation:jobsohio-supported-andhealth-expansion","starintel:relation:columbus-partnership-c6-legally-distinct-c3","starintel:contract:hntb-smart-lighting-phase-4-lifecycle-2022-2026","starintel:event:andhealth-expansion-2022-public-support","starintel:event:andhealth-expansion-2025-public-support"],"findings":[{"confidence":0.99,"finding":"Two legally distinct Columbus Partnership nonprofit entities are documented.","support_ids":["starintel:org:columbus-partnership-c6","starintel:org:the-columbus-partnership-c3","starintel:relation:columbus-partnership-c6-legally-distinct-c3"]},{"confidence":0.98,"finding":"Grant-era outputs were built for continuation and replication through open-source components and playbooks.","support_ids":["starintel:source:smart-columbus-usdot-program-summary-2021","starintel:observation:smart-columbus-project-continuation-and-replication"]},{"confidence":0.99,"finding":"HNTB's Smart Lighting lifecycle and two subconsultants are documented.","support_ids":["starintel:contract:hntb-smart-lighting-phase-4-lifecycle-2022-2026","starintel:relation:hntb-subcontracted-emh-and-t-smart-lighting","starintel:relation:hntb-subcontracted-barr-smart-lighting"]},{"confidence":0.99,"finding":"AndHealth expansion support connects JobsOhio, One Columbus, Ohio Development, and Columbus.","support_ids":["starintel:event:andhealth-expansion-2022-public-support","starintel:event:andhealth-expansion-2025-public-support"]},{"confidence":0.99,"finding":"Eleven current Smart Columbus staff roles create a new delivery-network frontier.","support_ids":["starintel:person:cami-albaugh","starintel:person:hailey-allison","starintel:person:mike-anderson","starintel:person:arash-ghazvini","starintel:person:norah-goldman","starintel:person:tosin-guobadia","starintel:person:brayan-pabon-gomez","starintel:person:ayaz-hyder","starintel:person:karina-sanchez","starintel:person:dylan-sansone","starintel:person:andreya-veintimilla"]}],"iteration":4,"method":"Breadth-first recursive expansion using corpus-first identity checks and primary or filing-derived sources.","narrative_role":"recursive governance, finance, contract, and replication expansion","research_question":"What new people, organizations, contracts, legal entities, financial observations, and source documents appear when all Depth 3 seeds are expanded?","source_ids":["starintel:source:smart-columbus-grant-era-reports-index","starintel:source:smart-columbus-usdot-program-summary-2021","starintel:source:columbus-partnership-c6-form990-2024","starintel:source:columbus-partnership-c3-form990-2024","starintel:source:columbus-ordinance-1424-2026","starintel:source:jobsohio-andhealth-expansion-2025","starintel:source:one-columbus-andhealth-expansion-2022"],"started_at":"2026-07-25T20:35:00Z","supporting_record_ids":["starintel:relation:columbus-partnership-c6-legally-distinct-c3","starintel:observation:columbus-partnership-c6-schedule-l-2024","starintel:event:smart-columbus-three-funding-streams-2021","starintel:observation:smart-columbus-project-continuation-and-replication","starintel:contract:hntb-smart-lighting-phase-4-lifecycle-2022-2026","starintel:relation:jobsohio-supported-andhealth-expansion"],"unresolved_target_ids":["starintel:investigation-target:wef-columbus-depth-5-columbus-partnership-legal-financial-flows","starintel:investigation-target:wef-columbus-depth-5-grant-era-replication-lineage","starintel:investigation-target:wef-columbus-depth-5-hntb-smart-lighting-subconsultants","starintel:investigation-target:wef-columbus-depth-5-andhealth-public-assistance","starintel:investigation-target:wef-columbus-depth-5-smart-columbus-team-project-map"]},"dataset":"starintel-wef-columbus-depth-4-2026-07-25","date_added":"2026-07-25T21:15:00Z","date_updated":"2026-07-25T21:15:00Z","dtype":"research-pass","evidence":[],"lineage":{"derived_from":["starintel:research-pass:wef-columbus-depth-3-2026-07-25"],"generation":4},"provenance":{"agent":"GPT-5.6 Thinking","run_id":"wef-columbus-depth-4-2026-07-25","skill":"auto-dig;search-starintel-json-db;create-starintel-documents;select-recursive-targets"},"schema_version":"0.9.0","sources":[{"accessed_at":"2026-07-25T21:15:00Z","credibility":0.95,"kind":"government_report","publisher":"City of Columbus","title":"Smart Columbus Program Summary — June 2021","uri":"https://static1.squarespace.com/static/6543abac601e3621dd3fe76d/t/68b832df3dd5017d3a1c12e2/1756902111728/2021-06%2BUSDOT%2BFinal%2BReport%2BExecutive%2BSummary%2B%281%29-compressed-compressed.pdf","url":"https://static1.squarespace.com/static/6543abac601e3621dd3fe76d/t/68b832df3dd5017d3a1c12e2/1756902111728/2021-06%2BUSDOT%2BFinal%2BReport%2BExecutive%2BSummary%2B%281%29-compressed-compressed.pdf"},{"accessed_at":"2026-07-25T21:15:00Z","credibility":0.95,"kind":"irs_derived_filing","publisher":"ProPublica Nonprofit Explorer","title":"Columbus Partnership Form 990 — fiscal year 2024","uri":"https://projects.propublica.org/nonprofits/organizations/352558300","url":"https://projects.propublica.org/nonprofits/organizations/352558300"},{"accessed_at":"2026-07-25T21:15:00Z","credibility":0.95,"kind":"irs_derived_filing","publisher":"ProPublica Nonprofit Explorer","title":"The Columbus Partnership Form 990 — fiscal year 2024","uri":"https://projects.propublica.org/nonprofits/organizations/20580058","url":"https://projects.propublica.org/nonprofits/organizations/20580058"},{"accessed_at":"2026-07-25T21:15:00Z","credibility":0.95,"kind":"government_record","publisher":"City of Columbus","title":"Columbus Ordinance 1424-2026","uri":"https://columbus.legistar.com/LegislationDetail.aspx?FullText=1&GUID=50C99EDC-6138-41FC-A7E1-8672080626A3&ID=8038904","url":"https://columbus.legistar.com/LegislationDetail.aspx?FullText=1&GUID=50C99EDC-6138-41FC-A7E1-8672080626A3&ID=8038904"},{"accessed_at":"2026-07-25T21:15:00Z","credibility":0.95,"kind":"official_project_record","publisher":"JobsOhio","title":"AndHealth Expanding Office Space in Downtown Columbus","uri":"https://www.jobsohio.com/newsroom/news-press/andhealth-expanding-office-space-in-downtown-columbus","url":"https://www.jobsohio.com/newsroom/news-press/andhealth-expanding-office-space-in-downtown-columbus"}],"summary":"Recursive expansion of Depth 3 governance, contract, grant, document, personnel, and public-development targets.","tags":["wef-columbus","recursive-research","depth-4"],"title":"WEF–Columbus recursive research pass — Depth 4","verification":{"status":"source-backed","verified":true},"version":1,"workflow":{"completed_at":"2026-07-25T21:15:00Z","max_depth":6,"priority":0.96,"queue":"wef-columbus","recursion_depth":4,"research_status":"completed","root_target_id":"starintel:org:city-of-columbus","selected_from":["starintel:investigation-target:wef-columbus-depth-4-personnel-board-governance","starintel:investigation-target:wef-columbus-depth-4-vendor-contract-lifecycle","starintel:investigation-target:wef-columbus-depth-4-private-grant-replication","starintel:investigation-target:wef-columbus-depth-4-andhealth-public-private-continuity"],"selection_reason":["operator-directed breadth-first recursion"]}}
{"_id":"starintel:research-pass:wef-columbus-depth-5-2026-07-26","assessment":{"confidence":0.97},"data":{"agent_identity":"GPT-5.6 Thinking","classification_rules":["Separate authorized ceilings from confirmed outlays.","Separate organization listing from verified workshare or payment.","Separate public availability of code from proven downstream deployment.","Separate WEF association and task-force participation from control over specific local decisions.","Represent missing primary records as queued targets rather than claims."],"completed_at":"2026-07-26T04:05:00Z","finding_ids":["starintel:media:columbus-green-it-playbook-2-0-2025","starintel:event:central-ohio-living-lab-launch-2025","starintel:event:hntb-smart-lighting-phase-4-modification-2026","starintel:financial-observation:andhealth-downtown-office-incentive-payment-2024","starintel:product:urbanos-smart-cities-data-platform","starintel:analysis:wef-columbus-depth-5-policy-contract-implementation"],"findings":[{"confidence":0.97,"finding":"Green IT guidance reached documented organizational implementation at Bread Financial."},{"confidence":0.98,"finding":"The Central Ohio Living Lab launched three projects in 2025 and planned three more in 2026; project-level records remain unresolved."},{"confidence":0.99,"finding":"HNTB Phase 4 supports procurement and product evaluation; identified lifecycle authorization reached $1,675,811.18."},{"confidence":0.99,"finding":"AndHealth received a documented $47,727.97 City incentive payment for tax year 2024."},{"confidence":0.95,"finding":"UrbanOS code is publicly available, but external adoption was not established."},{"confidence":0.97,"finding":"No reviewed record establishes WEF control over these specific local programs or transactions."}],"iteration":5,"method":"Primary-source recursive OSINT across municipal legislation, official organizational publications, economic-development records, WEF materials, and public code repositories.","narrative_role":"recursive evidence expansion","research_question":"What concrete programs, contracts, incentives, technical artifacts, and unresolved network records sit below the documented WEF–Columbus association?","started_at":"2026-07-26T02:30:00Z","supporting_record_ids":["starintel:org:rackspace-technology","starintel:org:bread-financial","starintel:org:honda","starintel:org:urbanos-public","starintel:person:ben-blanquera","starintel:person:marcus-carano","starintel:media:columbus-green-it-playbook-2-0-2025","starintel:event:central-ohio-living-lab-launch-2025","starintel:contract:andhealth-columbus-downtown-office-incentive-2022","starintel:financial-observation:andhealth-downtown-office-incentive-payment-2024","starintel:event:hntb-smart-lighting-phase-4-modification-2026","starintel:product:urbanos-smart-cities-data-platform","starintel:relation:green-it-playbook-authored-by-smart-columbus-rackspace","starintel:relation:ben-blanquera-employed-by-rackspace","starintel:relation:marcus-carano-employed-by-smart-columbus","starintel:relation:bread-financial-implemented-green-it-playbook","starintel:relation:smart-columbus-partnered-honda-living-lab","starintel:relation:city-authorized-andhealth-downtown-office-incentive","starintel:relation:city-authorized-andhealth-incentive-payment-2024","starintel:relation:hntb-phase-4-uses-emht-barr-subconsultants","starintel:relation:urbanos-public-publishes-smart-cities-data-platform","starintel:analysis:wef-columbus-depth-5-policy-contract-implementation"],"unresolved_target_ids":["starintel:investigation-target:wef-depth-6-hntb-smart-lighting-procurement-records","starintel:investigation-target:wef-depth-6-andhealth-incentive-ledger","starintel:investigation-target:wef-depth-6-green-it-working-group","starintel:investigation-target:wef-depth-6-central-ohio-living-lab-projects","starintel:investigation-target:wef-depth-6-urbanos-reuse-lineage","starintel:investigation-target:wef-depth-6-wef-columbus-agreements","starintel:investigation-target:wef-depth-6-global-shapers-columbus-status","starintel:investigation-target:wef-depth-6-smart-columbus-staff-project-map"]},"dataset":"wef","date_added":"2026-07-26T04:05:00Z","date_updated":"2026-07-26T04:05:00Z","dtype":"research-pass","evidence":[],"lineage":{"derived_from":["starintel:research-pass:wef-columbus-depth-4-2026-07-25"],"generation":5},"provenance":{"agent":"GPT-5.6 Thinking","method":"Primary-source recursive OSINT with bounded inference","run_id":"wef-columbus-depth-5-2026-07-26","skill":"auto-dig;web-research;create-starintel-documents;select-recursive-targets"},"schema_version":"0.9.0","sources":[{"accessed_at":"2026-07-26T04:05:00Z","credibility":0.95,"kind":"official_webpage","publisher":"Smart Columbus","title":"A year of impact: 2025 by the numbers","uri":"https://smartcolumbus.com/insights/2025-12-year-of-impact","url":"https://smartcolumbus.com/insights/2025-12-year-of-impact"},{"accessed_at":"2026-07-26T04:05:00Z","credibility":0.95,"kind":"official_webpage","publisher":"Smart Columbus","title":"Columbus leads the way: Evolving our Green IT ambition","uri":"https://smartcolumbus.com/insights/2025-10-cie-vendor-announcement-83p85","url":"https://smartcolumbus.com/insights/2025-10-cie-vendor-announcement-83p85"},{"accessed_at":"2026-07-26T04:05:00Z","credibility":0.99,"kind":"government_record","publisher":"City of Columbus","title":"Columbus Ordinance 1424-2026","uri":"https://columbus.legistar.com/LegislationDetail.aspx?FullText=1&GUID=039FBB6C-BE67-4AC2-9C13-59B8B8EFE96F&ID=8117826&Options=&Search=","url":"https://columbus.legistar.com/LegislationDetail.aspx?FullText=1&GUID=039FBB6C-BE67-4AC2-9C13-59B8B8EFE96F&ID=8117826&Options=&Search="},{"accessed_at":"2026-07-26T04:05:00Z","credibility":0.99,"kind":"government_record","publisher":"City of Columbus","title":"Columbus Ordinance 2014-2022","uri":"https://columbus.legistar.com/LegislationDetail.aspx?GUID=8A04AD26-94FE-4964-BCCC-44203F01D559&ID=5726301&Options=&Search=","url":"https://columbus.legistar.com/LegislationDetail.aspx?GUID=8A04AD26-94FE-4964-BCCC-44203F01D559&ID=5726301&Options=&Search="},{"accessed_at":"2026-07-26T04:05:00Z","credibility":0.99,"kind":"government_record","notes":"The title and background identify the Downtown Office Incentive program; Section 6 uses Jobs Growth Incentive wording.","publisher":"City of Columbus","title":"Columbus Ordinance 1885-2025","uri":"https://columbus.legistar.com/LegislationDetail.aspx?FullText=1&GUID=DE71F085-A673-490A-93D8-BED794B120CB&ID=7489845&Options=&Search=","url":"https://columbus.legistar.com/LegislationDetail.aspx?FullText=1&GUID=DE71F085-A673-490A-93D8-BED794B120CB&ID=7489845&Options=&Search="},{"accessed_at":"2026-07-26T04:05:00Z","credibility":0.97,"kind":"official_project_record","publisher":"JobsOhio","title":"AndHealth Expanding Office Space in Downtown Columbus","uri":"https://www.jobsohio.com/newsroom/news-press/andhealth-expanding-office-space-in-downtown-columbus","url":"https://www.jobsohio.com/newsroom/news-press/andhealth-expanding-office-space-in-downtown-columbus"},{"accessed_at":"2026-07-26T04:05:00Z","credibility":0.99,"kind":"official_project_record","publisher":"World Economic Forum","title":"Implementing a Life-Cycle Approach to Infrastructure: a Policy Roadmap for Cities","uri":"https://centres.weforum.org/centre-for-urban-transformation/infrastructure-lifecycle","url":"https://centres.weforum.org/centre-for-urban-transformation/infrastructure-lifecycle"},{"accessed_at":"2026-07-26T04:05:00Z","credibility":0.98,"kind":"official_organization","publisher":"Global Shapers Community","title":"Global Shapers: About","uri":"https://www.globalshapers.org/about","url":"https://www.globalshapers.org/about"},{"accessed_at":"2026-07-26T04:05:00Z","credibility":0.98,"kind":"source_repository","publisher":"UrbanOS-Public","title":"UrbanOS-Public/smartcitiesdata","uri":"https://github.com/UrbanOS-Public/smartcitiesdata","url":"https://github.com/UrbanOS-Public/smartcitiesdata"}],"summary":"Completed the queued Depth 5 implementation branches and emitted eight documentary Depth 6 targets.","tags":["wef","columbus","recursive-research","depth-5"],"title":"WEF–Columbus recursive research pass — Depth 5","verification":{"status":"source-backed","verified":true},"version":1,"workflow":{"max_depth":6,"recursion_depth":5,"research_status":"completed","root_target_id":"starintel:org:city-of-columbus"}}
{"_id":"starintel:source:andhealth-about","data":{"accessed_at":"2026-07-25T20:30:00Z","credibility":0.97,"kind":"official_webpage","publisher":"AndHealth","title":"AndHealth — About","uri":"https://andhealth.com/about/","url":"https://andhealth.com/about/"},"dataset":"starintel-wef-columbus-depth-3-2026-07-25","date_added":"2026-07-25T20:30:00Z","date_updated":"2026-07-25T20:30:00Z","dtype":"source","evidence":[],"lineage":{"derived_from":["starintel:research-pass:wef-columbus-depth-2-2026-07-25"],"generation":3},"provenance":{"agent":"GPT-5.6 Thinking","run_id":"wef-columbus-depth-3-2026-07-25","skill":"auto-dig;create-starintel-documents;select-recursive-targets"},"schema_version":"0.9.0","sources":[{"accessed_at":"2026-07-25T20:30:00Z","credibility":0.95,"kind":"official_webpage","publisher":"AndHealth","title":"AndHealth — About","uri":"https://andhealth.com/about/","url":"https://andhealth.com/about/"}],"summary":"Primary source used in the WEF–Columbus recursive investigation.","tags":["source-document","wef-columbus","depth-3"],"title":"AndHealth — About","verification":{"status":"source-backed","verified":true},"version":1,"workflow":{"max_depth":6,"recursion_depth":3,"research_status":"completed","root_target_id":"starintel:org:city-of-columbus"}}
{"_id":"starintel:source:andhealth-financing-2022","data":{"accessed_at":"2026-07-25T20:30:00Z","credibility":0.97,"kind":"official_webpage","publisher":"AndHealth","title":"AndHealth Raises $57 Million in Financing","uri":"https://andhealth.com/andhealth-digital-health-company-reversing-migraine-autoimmune-diseases-raises-57-million/","url":"https://andhealth.com/andhealth-digital-health-company-reversing-migraine-autoimmune-diseases-raises-57-million/"},"dataset":"starintel-wef-columbus-depth-3-2026-07-25","date_added":"2026-07-25T20:30:00Z","date_updated":"2026-07-25T20:30:00Z","dtype":"source","evidence":[],"lineage":{"derived_from":["starintel:research-pass:wef-columbus-depth-2-2026-07-25"],"generation":3},"provenance":{"agent":"GPT-5.6 Thinking","run_id":"wef-columbus-depth-3-2026-07-25","skill":"auto-dig;create-starintel-documents;select-recursive-targets"},"schema_version":"0.9.0","sources":[{"accessed_at":"2026-07-25T20:30:00Z","credibility":0.95,"kind":"official_webpage","publisher":"AndHealth","title":"AndHealth Raises $57 Million in Financing","uri":"https://andhealth.com/andhealth-digital-health-company-reversing-migraine-autoimmune-diseases-raises-57-million/","url":"https://andhealth.com/andhealth-digital-health-company-reversing-migraine-autoimmune-diseases-raises-57-million/"}],"summary":"Primary source used in the WEF–Columbus recursive investigation.","tags":["source-document","wef-columbus","depth-3"],"title":"AndHealth Raises $57 Million in Financing","verification":{"status":"source-backed","verified":true},"version":1,"workflow":{"max_depth":6,"recursion_depth":3,"research_status":"completed","root_target_id":"starintel:org:city-of-columbus"}}
{"_id":"starintel:source:columbus-ordinance-1424-2026","assessment":{"confidence":0.95},"data":{"accessed_at":"2026-07-25T21:15:00Z","credibility":0.95,"kind":"government_record","publisher":"City of Columbus","title":"Columbus Ordinance 1424-2026","uri":"https://columbus.legistar.com/LegislationDetail.aspx?FullText=1&GUID=50C99EDC-6138-41FC-A7E1-8672080626A3&ID=8038904","url":"https://columbus.legistar.com/LegislationDetail.aspx?FullText=1&GUID=50C99EDC-6138-41FC-A7E1-8672080626A3&ID=8038904"},"dataset":"starintel-wef-columbus-depth-4-2026-07-25","date_added":"2026-07-25T21:15:00Z","date_updated":"2026-07-25T21:15:00Z","dtype":"source","evidence":[],"lineage":{"derived_from":["starintel:research-pass:wef-columbus-depth-3-2026-07-25"],"generation":4},"provenance":{"agent":"GPT-5.6 Thinking","run_id":"wef-columbus-depth-4-2026-07-25","skill":"auto-dig;search-starintel-json-db;create-starintel-documents;select-recursive-targets"},"schema_version":"0.9.0","sources":[{"accessed_at":"2026-07-25T21:15:00Z","credibility":0.95,"kind":"government_record","publisher":"City of Columbus","title":"Columbus Ordinance 1424-2026","uri":"https://columbus.legistar.com/LegislationDetail.aspx?FullText=1&GUID=50C99EDC-6138-41FC-A7E1-8672080626A3&ID=8038904","url":"https://columbus.legistar.com/LegislationDetail.aspx?FullText=1&GUID=50C99EDC-6138-41FC-A7E1-8672080626A3&ID=8038904"}],"summary":"City legislation authorizing the second HNTB Smart Lighting modification and identifying EMH&T and Barr Engineering as subconsultants.","tags":["wef-columbus","recursive-research","depth-4"],"title":"Columbus Ordinance 1424-2026","verification":{"status":"source-backed","verified":true},"version":1,"workflow":{"max_depth":6,"recursion_depth":4,"research_status":"completed","root_target_id":"starintel:org:city-of-columbus"}}
{"_id":"starintel:source:columbus-partnership-c3-form990-2024","assessment":{"confidence":0.95},"data":{"accessed_at":"2026-07-25T21:15:00Z","credibility":0.95,"kind":"irs_derived_filing","publisher":"ProPublica Nonprofit Explorer","title":"The Columbus Partnership Form 990 — fiscal year 2024","uri":"https://projects.propublica.org/nonprofits/organizations/20580058","url":"https://projects.propublica.org/nonprofits/organizations/20580058"},"dataset":"starintel-wef-columbus-depth-4-2026-07-25","date_added":"2026-07-25T21:15:00Z","date_updated":"2026-07-25T21:15:00Z","dtype":"source","evidence":[],"lineage":{"derived_from":["starintel:research-pass:wef-columbus-depth-3-2026-07-25"],"generation":4},"provenance":{"agent":"GPT-5.6 Thinking","run_id":"wef-columbus-depth-4-2026-07-25","skill":"auto-dig;search-starintel-json-db;create-starintel-documents;select-recursive-targets"},"schema_version":"0.9.0","sources":[{"accessed_at":"2026-07-25T21:15:00Z","credibility":0.95,"kind":"irs_derived_filing","publisher":"ProPublica Nonprofit Explorer","title":"The Columbus Partnership Form 990 — fiscal year 2024","uri":"https://projects.propublica.org/nonprofits/organizations/20580058","url":"https://projects.propublica.org/nonprofits/organizations/20580058"}],"summary":"IRS-derived filing record for The Columbus Partnership, EIN 02-0580058, a 501(c)(3) entity.","tags":["wef-columbus","recursive-research","depth-4"],"title":"The Columbus Partnership Form 990 — fiscal year 2024","verification":{"status":"source-backed","verified":true},"version":1,"workflow":{"max_depth":6,"recursion_depth":4,"research_status":"completed","root_target_id":"starintel:org:city-of-columbus"}}
{"_id":"starintel:source:columbus-partnership-c6-form990-2024","assessment":{"confidence":0.95},"data":{"accessed_at":"2026-07-25T21:15:00Z","credibility":0.95,"kind":"irs_derived_filing","publisher":"ProPublica Nonprofit Explorer","title":"Columbus Partnership Form 990 — fiscal year 2024","uri":"https://projects.propublica.org/nonprofits/organizations/352558300","url":"https://projects.propublica.org/nonprofits/organizations/352558300"},"dataset":"starintel-wef-columbus-depth-4-2026-07-25","date_added":"2026-07-25T21:15:00Z","date_updated":"2026-07-25T21:15:00Z","dtype":"source","evidence":[],"lineage":{"derived_from":["starintel:research-pass:wef-columbus-depth-3-2026-07-25"],"generation":4},"provenance":{"agent":"GPT-5.6 Thinking","run_id":"wef-columbus-depth-4-2026-07-25","skill":"auto-dig;search-starintel-json-db;create-starintel-documents;select-recursive-targets"},"schema_version":"0.9.0","sources":[{"accessed_at":"2026-07-25T21:15:00Z","credibility":0.95,"kind":"irs_derived_filing","publisher":"ProPublica Nonprofit Explorer","title":"Columbus Partnership Form 990 — fiscal year 2024","uri":"https://projects.propublica.org/nonprofits/organizations/352558300","url":"https://projects.propublica.org/nonprofits/organizations/352558300"}],"summary":"IRS-derived filing record for Columbus Partnership, EIN 35-2558300, a 501(c)(6) entity.","tags":["wef-columbus","recursive-research","depth-4"],"title":"Columbus Partnership Form 990 — fiscal year 2024","verification":{"status":"source-backed","verified":true},"version":1,"workflow":{"max_depth":6,"recursion_depth":4,"research_status":"completed","root_target_id":"starintel:org:city-of-columbus"}}
{"_id":"starintel:source:council-2019-03-18-vendor-cluster","data":{"accessed_at":"2026-07-25T20:30:00Z","credibility":0.97,"kind":"government_record","publisher":"City of Columbus","title":"Columbus City Council Meeting — March 18, 2019","uri":"https://columbus.legistar.com/MeetingDetail.aspx?From=RSS&GUID=25F614FE-6E54-4D38-B2D9-ED4F3962DDEE&ID=683461","url":"https://columbus.legistar.com/MeetingDetail.aspx?From=RSS&GUID=25F614FE-6E54-4D38-B2D9-ED4F3962DDEE&ID=683461"},"dataset":"starintel-wef-columbus-depth-3-2026-07-25","date_added":"2026-07-25T20:30:00Z","date_updated":"2026-07-25T20:30:00Z","dtype":"source","evidence":[],"lineage":{"derived_from":["starintel:research-pass:wef-columbus-depth-2-2026-07-25"],"generation":3},"provenance":{"agent":"GPT-5.6 Thinking","run_id":"wef-columbus-depth-3-2026-07-25","skill":"auto-dig;create-starintel-documents;select-recursive-targets"},"schema_version":"0.9.0","sources":[{"accessed_at":"2026-07-25T20:30:00Z","credibility":0.95,"kind":"government_record","publisher":"City of Columbus","title":"Columbus City Council Meeting — March 18, 2019","uri":"https://columbus.legistar.com/MeetingDetail.aspx?From=RSS&GUID=25F614FE-6E54-4D38-B2D9-ED4F3962DDEE&ID=683461","url":"https://columbus.legistar.com/MeetingDetail.aspx?From=RSS&GUID=25F614FE-6E54-4D38-B2D9-ED4F3962DDEE&ID=683461"}],"summary":"Primary source used in the WEF–Columbus recursive investigation.","tags":["source-document","wef-columbus","depth-3"],"title":"Columbus City Council Meeting — March 18, 2019","verification":{"status":"source-backed","verified":true},"version":1,"workflow":{"max_depth":6,"recursion_depth":3,"research_status":"completed","root_target_id":"starintel:org:city-of-columbus"}}
{"_id":"starintel:source:ec-accelerate-your-city","data":{"accessed_at":"2026-07-25T20:30:00Z","credibility":0.97,"kind":"official_webpage","publisher":"Electrification Coalition","title":"Accelerate Your City","uri":"https://electrificationcoalition.org/resource/accelerate-your-city/","url":"https://electrificationcoalition.org/resource/accelerate-your-city/"},"dataset":"starintel-wef-columbus-depth-3-2026-07-25","date_added":"2026-07-25T20:30:00Z","date_updated":"2026-07-25T20:30:00Z","dtype":"source","evidence":[],"lineage":{"derived_from":["starintel:research-pass:wef-columbus-depth-2-2026-07-25"],"generation":3},"provenance":{"agent":"GPT-5.6 Thinking","run_id":"wef-columbus-depth-3-2026-07-25","skill":"auto-dig;create-starintel-documents;select-recursive-targets"},"schema_version":"0.9.0","sources":[{"accessed_at":"2026-07-25T20:30:00Z","credibility":0.95,"kind":"official_webpage","publisher":"Electrification Coalition","title":"Accelerate Your City","uri":"https://electrificationcoalition.org/resource/accelerate-your-city/","url":"https://electrificationcoalition.org/resource/accelerate-your-city/"}],"summary":"Primary source used in the WEF–Columbus recursive investigation.","tags":["source-document","wef-columbus","depth-3"],"title":"Accelerate Your City","verification":{"status":"source-backed","verified":true},"version":1,"workflow":{"max_depth":6,"recursion_depth":3,"research_status":"completed","root_target_id":"starintel:org:city-of-columbus"}}
{"_id":"starintel:source:ec-team","data":{"accessed_at":"2026-07-25T20:30:00Z","credibility":0.97,"kind":"official_webpage","publisher":"Electrification Coalition","title":"Electrification Coalition — Our Team","uri":"https://electrificationcoalition.org/our-team/","url":"https://electrificationcoalition.org/our-team/"},"dataset":"starintel-wef-columbus-depth-3-2026-07-25","date_added":"2026-07-25T20:30:00Z","date_updated":"2026-07-25T20:30:00Z","dtype":"source","evidence":[],"lineage":{"derived_from":["starintel:research-pass:wef-columbus-depth-2-2026-07-25"],"generation":3},"provenance":{"agent":"GPT-5.6 Thinking","run_id":"wef-columbus-depth-3-2026-07-25","skill":"auto-dig;create-starintel-documents;select-recursive-targets"},"schema_version":"0.9.0","sources":[{"accessed_at":"2026-07-25T20:30:00Z","credibility":0.95,"kind":"official_webpage","publisher":"Electrification Coalition","title":"Electrification Coalition — Our Team","uri":"https://electrificationcoalition.org/our-team/","url":"https://electrificationcoalition.org/our-team/"}],"summary":"Primary source used in the WEF–Columbus recursive investigation.","tags":["source-document","wef-columbus","depth-3"],"title":"Electrification Coalition — Our Team","verification":{"status":"source-backed","verified":true},"version":1,"workflow":{"max_depth":6,"recursion_depth":3,"research_status":"completed","root_target_id":"starintel:org:city-of-columbus"}}
{"_id":"starintel:source:jobsohio-andhealth-expansion-2025","assessment":{"confidence":0.95},"data":{"accessed_at":"2026-07-25T21:15:00Z","credibility":0.95,"kind":"official_project_record","publisher":"JobsOhio","title":"AndHealth Expanding Office Space in Downtown Columbus","uri":"https://www.jobsohio.com/newsroom/news-press/andhealth-expanding-office-space-in-downtown-columbus","url":"https://www.jobsohio.com/newsroom/news-press/andhealth-expanding-office-space-in-downtown-columbus"},"dataset":"starintel-wef-columbus-depth-4-2026-07-25","date_added":"2026-07-25T21:15:00Z","date_updated":"2026-07-25T21:15:00Z","dtype":"source","evidence":[],"lineage":{"derived_from":["starintel:research-pass:wef-columbus-depth-3-2026-07-25"],"generation":4},"provenance":{"agent":"GPT-5.6 Thinking","run_id":"wef-columbus-depth-4-2026-07-25","skill":"auto-dig;search-starintel-json-db;create-starintel-documents;select-recursive-targets"},"schema_version":"0.9.0","sources":[{"accessed_at":"2026-07-25T21:15:00Z","credibility":0.95,"kind":"official_project_record","publisher":"JobsOhio","title":"AndHealth Expanding Office Space in Downtown Columbus","uri":"https://www.jobsohio.com/newsroom/news-press/andhealth-expanding-office-space-in-downtown-columbus","url":"https://www.jobsohio.com/newsroom/news-press/andhealth-expanding-office-space-in-downtown-columbus"}],"summary":"JobsOhio project record documenting 75 committed jobs, 69 retained jobs, $260,000 capital investment, and four public-development collaborators.","tags":["wef-columbus","recursive-research","depth-4"],"title":"AndHealth Expanding Office Space in Downtown Columbus","verification":{"status":"source-backed","verified":true},"version":1,"workflow":{"max_depth":6,"recursion_depth":4,"research_status":"completed","root_target_id":"starintel:org:city-of-columbus"}}
{"_id":"starintel:source:michael-stevens-bio","data":{"accessed_at":"2026-07-25T20:30:00Z","credibility":0.97,"kind":"official_webpage","publisher":"City of Columbus","title":"Michael Stevens — Director's Bio","uri":"https://www.columbus.gov/Government/Departments/Development/Directors-Bio","url":"https://www.columbus.gov/Government/Departments/Development/Directors-Bio"},"dataset":"starintel-wef-columbus-depth-3-2026-07-25","date_added":"2026-07-25T20:30:00Z","date_updated":"2026-07-25T20:30:00Z","dtype":"source","evidence":[],"lineage":{"derived_from":["starintel:research-pass:wef-columbus-depth-2-2026-07-25"],"generation":3},"provenance":{"agent":"GPT-5.6 Thinking","run_id":"wef-columbus-depth-3-2026-07-25","skill":"auto-dig;create-starintel-documents;select-recursive-targets"},"schema_version":"0.9.0","sources":[{"accessed_at":"2026-07-25T20:30:00Z","credibility":0.95,"kind":"official_webpage","publisher":"City of Columbus","title":"Michael Stevens — Director's Bio","uri":"https://www.columbus.gov/Government/Departments/Development/Directors-Bio","url":"https://www.columbus.gov/Government/Departments/Development/Directors-Bio"}],"summary":"Primary source used in the WEF–Columbus recursive investigation.","tags":["source-document","wef-columbus","depth-3"],"title":"Michael Stevens — Director's Bio","verification":{"status":"source-backed","verified":true},"version":1,"workflow":{"max_depth":6,"recursion_depth":3,"research_status":"completed","root_target_id":"starintel:org:city-of-columbus"}}
{"_id":"starintel:source:morpc-william-murdock","data":{"accessed_at":"2026-07-25T20:30:00Z","credibility":0.97,"kind":"official_webpage","publisher":"MORPC","title":"William Murdock","uri":"https://www.morpc.org/william-murdock/","url":"https://www.morpc.org/william-murdock/"},"dataset":"starintel-wef-columbus-depth-3-2026-07-25","date_added":"2026-07-25T20:30:00Z","date_updated":"2026-07-25T20:30:00Z","dtype":"source","evidence":[],"lineage":{"derived_from":["starintel:research-pass:wef-columbus-depth-2-2026-07-25"],"generation":3},"provenance":{"agent":"GPT-5.6 Thinking","run_id":"wef-columbus-depth-3-2026-07-25","skill":"auto-dig;create-starintel-documents;select-recursive-targets"},"schema_version":"0.9.0","sources":[{"accessed_at":"2026-07-25T20:30:00Z","credibility":0.95,"kind":"official_webpage","publisher":"MORPC","title":"William Murdock","uri":"https://www.morpc.org/william-murdock/","url":"https://www.morpc.org/william-murdock/"}],"summary":"Primary source used in the WEF–Columbus recursive investigation.","tags":["source-document","wef-columbus","depth-3"],"title":"William Murdock","verification":{"status":"source-backed","verified":true},"version":1,"workflow":{"max_depth":6,"recursion_depth":3,"research_status":"completed","root_target_id":"starintel:org:city-of-columbus"}}
{"_id":"starintel:source:one-columbus-andhealth-expansion-2022","assessment":{"confidence":0.95},"data":{"accessed_at":"2026-07-25T21:15:00Z","credibility":0.95,"kind":"official_project_record","publisher":"One Columbus","title":"Digital Healthcare Startup AndHealth Brings 65 New Jobs","uri":"https://columbusregion.com/press-release/digital-healthcare-startup-andhealth-brings-65-new-jobs-to-downtown-columbus-for-operations-expansion/","url":"https://columbusregion.com/press-release/digital-healthcare-startup-andhealth-brings-65-new-jobs-to-downtown-columbus-for-operations-expansion/"},"dataset":"starintel-wef-columbus-depth-4-2026-07-25","date_added":"2026-07-25T21:15:00Z","date_updated":"2026-07-25T21:15:00Z","dtype":"source","evidence":[],"lineage":{"derived_from":["starintel:research-pass:wef-columbus-depth-3-2026-07-25"],"generation":4},"provenance":{"agent":"GPT-5.6 Thinking","run_id":"wef-columbus-depth-4-2026-07-25","skill":"auto-dig;search-starintel-json-db;create-starintel-documents;select-recursive-targets"},"schema_version":"0.9.0","sources":[{"accessed_at":"2026-07-25T21:15:00Z","credibility":0.95,"kind":"official_project_record","publisher":"One Columbus","title":"Digital Healthcare Startup AndHealth Brings 65 New Jobs","uri":"https://columbusregion.com/press-release/digital-healthcare-startup-andhealth-brings-65-new-jobs-to-downtown-columbus-for-operations-expansion/","url":"https://columbusregion.com/press-release/digital-healthcare-startup-andhealth-brings-65-new-jobs-to-downtown-columbus-for-operations-expansion/"}],"summary":"One Columbus/Columbus Region announcement documenting the 2022 expansion and planned JobsOhio assistance after final agreement.","tags":["wef-columbus","recursive-research","depth-4"],"title":"Digital Healthcare Startup AndHealth Brings 65 New Jobs","verification":{"status":"source-backed","verified":true},"version":1,"workflow":{"max_depth":6,"recursion_depth":4,"research_status":"completed","root_target_id":"starintel:org:city-of-columbus"}}
{"_id":"starintel:source:ord-0477-2019","data":{"accessed_at":"2026-07-25T20:30:00Z","credibility":0.97,"kind":"government_record","publisher":"City of Columbus","title":"Columbus Ordinance 0477-2019","uri":"https://columbus.legistar.com/LegislationDetail.aspx?GUID=CCB79A50-08B8-47B1-8EFD-CA2A3EE0E70B&ID=3867981&Options=&Search=","url":"https://columbus.legistar.com/LegislationDetail.aspx?GUID=CCB79A50-08B8-47B1-8EFD-CA2A3EE0E70B&ID=3867981&Options=&Search="},"dataset":"starintel-wef-columbus-depth-3-2026-07-25","date_added":"2026-07-25T20:30:00Z","date_updated":"2026-07-25T20:30:00Z","dtype":"source","evidence":[],"lineage":{"derived_from":["starintel:research-pass:wef-columbus-depth-2-2026-07-25"],"generation":3},"provenance":{"agent":"GPT-5.6 Thinking","run_id":"wef-columbus-depth-3-2026-07-25","skill":"auto-dig;create-starintel-documents;select-recursive-targets"},"schema_version":"0.9.0","sources":[{"accessed_at":"2026-07-25T20:30:00Z","credibility":0.95,"kind":"government_record","publisher":"City of Columbus","title":"Columbus Ordinance 0477-2019","uri":"https://columbus.legistar.com/LegislationDetail.aspx?GUID=CCB79A50-08B8-47B1-8EFD-CA2A3EE0E70B&ID=3867981&Options=&Search=","url":"https://columbus.legistar.com/LegislationDetail.aspx?GUID=CCB79A50-08B8-47B1-8EFD-CA2A3EE0E70B&ID=3867981&Options=&Search="}],"summary":"Primary source used in the WEF–Columbus recursive investigation.","tags":["source-document","wef-columbus","depth-3"],"title":"Columbus Ordinance 0477-2019","verification":{"status":"source-backed","verified":true},"version":1,"workflow":{"max_depth":6,"recursion_depth":3,"research_status":"completed","root_target_id":"starintel:org:city-of-columbus"}}
{"_id":"starintel:source:ord-0551-2019","data":{"accessed_at":"2026-07-25T20:30:00Z","credibility":0.97,"kind":"government_record","publisher":"City of Columbus","title":"Columbus Ordinance 0551-2019","uri":"https://columbus.legistar.com/LegislationDetail.aspx?GUID=ACFD8601-81BC-4387-A69C-219EE1A8431B&ID=3889855&Options=&Search=","url":"https://columbus.legistar.com/LegislationDetail.aspx?GUID=ACFD8601-81BC-4387-A69C-219EE1A8431B&ID=3889855&Options=&Search="},"dataset":"starintel-wef-columbus-depth-3-2026-07-25","date_added":"2026-07-25T20:30:00Z","date_updated":"2026-07-25T20:30:00Z","dtype":"source","evidence":[],"lineage":{"derived_from":["starintel:research-pass:wef-columbus-depth-2-2026-07-25"],"generation":3},"provenance":{"agent":"GPT-5.6 Thinking","run_id":"wef-columbus-depth-3-2026-07-25","skill":"auto-dig;create-starintel-documents;select-recursive-targets"},"schema_version":"0.9.0","sources":[{"accessed_at":"2026-07-25T20:30:00Z","credibility":0.95,"kind":"government_record","publisher":"City of Columbus","title":"Columbus Ordinance 0551-2019","uri":"https://columbus.legistar.com/LegislationDetail.aspx?GUID=ACFD8601-81BC-4387-A69C-219EE1A8431B&ID=3889855&Options=&Search=","url":"https://columbus.legistar.com/LegislationDetail.aspx?GUID=ACFD8601-81BC-4387-A69C-219EE1A8431B&ID=3889855&Options=&Search="}],"summary":"Primary source used in the WEF–Columbus recursive investigation.","tags":["source-document","wef-columbus","depth-3"],"title":"Columbus Ordinance 0551-2019","verification":{"status":"source-backed","verified":true},"version":1,"workflow":{"max_depth":6,"recursion_depth":3,"research_status":"completed","root_target_id":"starintel:org:city-of-columbus"}}
{"_id":"starintel:source:ord-0554-2019","data":{"accessed_at":"2026-07-25T20:30:00Z","credibility":0.97,"kind":"government_record","publisher":"City of Columbus","title":"Columbus Ordinance 0554-2019","uri":"https://columbus.legistar.com/LegislationDetail.aspx?GUID=2DDDFCD7-0346-4F0A-A7AD-4D59B8695E1D&ID=3889858&Options=&Search=","url":"https://columbus.legistar.com/LegislationDetail.aspx?GUID=2DDDFCD7-0346-4F0A-A7AD-4D59B8695E1D&ID=3889858&Options=&Search="},"dataset":"starintel-wef-columbus-depth-3-2026-07-25","date_added":"2026-07-25T20:30:00Z","date_updated":"2026-07-25T20:30:00Z","dtype":"source","evidence":[],"lineage":{"derived_from":["starintel:research-pass:wef-columbus-depth-2-2026-07-25"],"generation":3},"provenance":{"agent":"GPT-5.6 Thinking","run_id":"wef-columbus-depth-3-2026-07-25","skill":"auto-dig;create-starintel-documents;select-recursive-targets"},"schema_version":"0.9.0","sources":[{"accessed_at":"2026-07-25T20:30:00Z","credibility":0.95,"kind":"government_record","publisher":"City of Columbus","title":"Columbus Ordinance 0554-2019","uri":"https://columbus.legistar.com/LegislationDetail.aspx?GUID=2DDDFCD7-0346-4F0A-A7AD-4D59B8695E1D&ID=3889858&Options=&Search=","url":"https://columbus.legistar.com/LegislationDetail.aspx?GUID=2DDDFCD7-0346-4F0A-A7AD-4D59B8695E1D&ID=3889858&Options=&Search="}],"summary":"Primary source used in the WEF–Columbus recursive investigation.","tags":["source-document","wef-columbus","depth-3"],"title":"Columbus Ordinance 0554-2019","verification":{"status":"source-backed","verified":true},"version":1,"workflow":{"max_depth":6,"recursion_depth":3,"research_status":"completed","root_target_id":"starintel:org:city-of-columbus"}}
{"_id":"starintel:source:ord-0820-2018","data":{"accessed_at":"2026-07-25T20:30:00Z","credibility":0.97,"kind":"government_record","publisher":"City of Columbus","title":"Columbus Ordinance 0820-2018","uri":"https://columbus.legistar.com/LegislationDetail.aspx?FullText=1&GUID=A46BE430-491C-4BFF-BA59-B37B763DF2B6&ID=3476477","url":"https://columbus.legistar.com/LegislationDetail.aspx?FullText=1&GUID=A46BE430-491C-4BFF-BA59-B37B763DF2B6&ID=3476477"},"dataset":"starintel-wef-columbus-depth-3-2026-07-25","date_added":"2026-07-25T20:30:00Z","date_updated":"2026-07-25T20:30:00Z","dtype":"source","evidence":[],"lineage":{"derived_from":["starintel:research-pass:wef-columbus-depth-2-2026-07-25"],"generation":3},"provenance":{"agent":"GPT-5.6 Thinking","run_id":"wef-columbus-depth-3-2026-07-25","skill":"auto-dig;create-starintel-documents;select-recursive-targets"},"schema_version":"0.9.0","sources":[{"accessed_at":"2026-07-25T20:30:00Z","credibility":0.95,"kind":"government_record","publisher":"City of Columbus","title":"Columbus Ordinance 0820-2018","uri":"https://columbus.legistar.com/LegislationDetail.aspx?FullText=1&GUID=A46BE430-491C-4BFF-BA59-B37B763DF2B6&ID=3476477","url":"https://columbus.legistar.com/LegislationDetail.aspx?FullText=1&GUID=A46BE430-491C-4BFF-BA59-B37B763DF2B6&ID=3476477"}],"summary":"Primary source used in the WEF–Columbus recursive investigation.","tags":["source-document","wef-columbus","depth-3"],"title":"Columbus Ordinance 0820-2018","verification":{"status":"source-backed","verified":true},"version":1,"workflow":{"max_depth":6,"recursion_depth":3,"research_status":"completed","root_target_id":"starintel:org:city-of-columbus"}}
{"_id":"starintel:source:ord-0898-2019","data":{"accessed_at":"2026-07-25T20:30:00Z","credibility":0.97,"kind":"government_record","publisher":"City of Columbus","title":"Columbus Ordinance 0898-2019","uri":"https://columbus.legistar.com/LegislationDetail.aspx?FullText=1&GUID=25689AF7-E15D-4218-8726-CFE46FC368ED&ID=3910766","url":"https://columbus.legistar.com/LegislationDetail.aspx?FullText=1&GUID=25689AF7-E15D-4218-8726-CFE46FC368ED&ID=3910766"},"dataset":"starintel-wef-columbus-depth-3-2026-07-25","date_added":"2026-07-25T20:30:00Z","date_updated":"2026-07-25T20:30:00Z","dtype":"source","evidence":[],"lineage":{"derived_from":["starintel:research-pass:wef-columbus-depth-2-2026-07-25"],"generation":3},"provenance":{"agent":"GPT-5.6 Thinking","run_id":"wef-columbus-depth-3-2026-07-25","skill":"auto-dig;create-starintel-documents;select-recursive-targets"},"schema_version":"0.9.0","sources":[{"accessed_at":"2026-07-25T20:30:00Z","credibility":0.95,"kind":"government_record","publisher":"City of Columbus","title":"Columbus Ordinance 0898-2019","uri":"https://columbus.legistar.com/LegislationDetail.aspx?FullText=1&GUID=25689AF7-E15D-4218-8726-CFE46FC368ED&ID=3910766","url":"https://columbus.legistar.com/LegislationDetail.aspx?FullText=1&GUID=25689AF7-E15D-4218-8726-CFE46FC368ED&ID=3910766"}],"summary":"Primary source used in the WEF–Columbus recursive investigation.","tags":["source-document","wef-columbus","depth-3"],"title":"Columbus Ordinance 0898-2019","verification":{"status":"source-backed","verified":true},"version":1,"workflow":{"max_depth":6,"recursion_depth":3,"research_status":"completed","root_target_id":"starintel:org:city-of-columbus"}}
{"_id":"starintel:source:ord-1056-2018","data":{"accessed_at":"2026-07-25T20:30:00Z","credibility":0.97,"kind":"government_record","publisher":"City of Columbus","title":"Columbus Ordinance 1056-2018","uri":"https://columbus.legistar.com/LegislationDetail.aspx?GUID=ACC8B42F-6329-4B0E-9DC0-8AEAED4AF9B6&ID=3477813&Options=&Search=","url":"https://columbus.legistar.com/LegislationDetail.aspx?GUID=ACC8B42F-6329-4B0E-9DC0-8AEAED4AF9B6&ID=3477813&Options=&Search="},"dataset":"starintel-wef-columbus-depth-3-2026-07-25","date_added":"2026-07-25T20:30:00Z","date_updated":"2026-07-25T20:30:00Z","dtype":"source","evidence":[],"lineage":{"derived_from":["starintel:research-pass:wef-columbus-depth-2-2026-07-25"],"generation":3},"provenance":{"agent":"GPT-5.6 Thinking","run_id":"wef-columbus-depth-3-2026-07-25","skill":"auto-dig;create-starintel-documents;select-recursive-targets"},"schema_version":"0.9.0","sources":[{"accessed_at":"2026-07-25T20:30:00Z","credibility":0.95,"kind":"government_record","publisher":"City of Columbus","title":"Columbus Ordinance 1056-2018","uri":"https://columbus.legistar.com/LegislationDetail.aspx?GUID=ACC8B42F-6329-4B0E-9DC0-8AEAED4AF9B6&ID=3477813&Options=&Search=","url":"https://columbus.legistar.com/LegislationDetail.aspx?GUID=ACC8B42F-6329-4B0E-9DC0-8AEAED4AF9B6&ID=3477813&Options=&Search="}],"summary":"Primary source used in the WEF–Columbus recursive investigation.","tags":["source-document","wef-columbus","depth-3"],"title":"Columbus Ordinance 1056-2018","verification":{"status":"source-backed","verified":true},"version":1,"workflow":{"max_depth":6,"recursion_depth":3,"research_status":"completed","root_target_id":"starintel:org:city-of-columbus"}}
{"_id":"starintel:source:ord-1850-2026","data":{"accessed_at":"2026-07-25T20:30:00Z","credibility":0.97,"kind":"government_record","publisher":"City of Columbus","title":"Columbus Ordinance 1850-2026","uri":"https://columbus.legistar.com/LegislationDetail.aspx?FullText=1&GUID=588DBFF9-D9DB-4603-B5D4-776E9F5B5A9E&ID=8117690&Options=&Search=","url":"https://columbus.legistar.com/LegislationDetail.aspx?FullText=1&GUID=588DBFF9-D9DB-4603-B5D4-776E9F5B5A9E&ID=8117690&Options=&Search="},"dataset":"starintel-wef-columbus-depth-3-2026-07-25","date_added":"2026-07-25T20:30:00Z","date_updated":"2026-07-25T20:30:00Z","dtype":"source","evidence":[],"lineage":{"derived_from":["starintel:research-pass:wef-columbus-depth-2-2026-07-25"],"generation":3},"provenance":{"agent":"GPT-5.6 Thinking","run_id":"wef-columbus-depth-3-2026-07-25","skill":"auto-dig;create-starintel-documents;select-recursive-targets"},"schema_version":"0.9.0","sources":[{"accessed_at":"2026-07-25T20:30:00Z","credibility":0.95,"kind":"government_record","publisher":"City of Columbus","title":"Columbus Ordinance 1850-2026","uri":"https://columbus.legistar.com/LegislationDetail.aspx?FullText=1&GUID=588DBFF9-D9DB-4603-B5D4-776E9F5B5A9E&ID=8117690&Options=&Search=","url":"https://columbus.legistar.com/LegislationDetail.aspx?FullText=1&GUID=588DBFF9-D9DB-4603-B5D4-776E9F5B5A9E&ID=8117690&Options=&Search="}],"summary":"Primary source used in the WEF–Columbus recursive investigation.","tags":["source-document","wef-columbus","depth-3"],"title":"Columbus Ordinance 1850-2026","verification":{"status":"source-backed","verified":true},"version":1,"workflow":{"max_depth":6,"recursion_depth":3,"research_status":"completed","root_target_id":"starintel:org:city-of-columbus"}}
{"_id":"starintel:source:ord-2432-2020","data":{"accessed_at":"2026-07-25T20:30:00Z","credibility":0.97,"kind":"government_record","publisher":"City of Columbus","title":"Columbus Ordinance 2432-2020","uri":"https://columbus.legistar.com/LegislationDetail.aspx?G=4F637594-17B0-4E92-8196-37F14328D337&GUID=55EF6D82-37AC-42A8-AC78-9C64E74804A8&ID=4687160&Options=&Search=","url":"https://columbus.legistar.com/LegislationDetail.aspx?G=4F637594-17B0-4E92-8196-37F14328D337&GUID=55EF6D82-37AC-42A8-AC78-9C64E74804A8&ID=4687160&Options=&Search="},"dataset":"starintel-wef-columbus-depth-3-2026-07-25","date_added":"2026-07-25T20:30:00Z","date_updated":"2026-07-25T20:30:00Z","dtype":"source","evidence":[],"lineage":{"derived_from":["starintel:research-pass:wef-columbus-depth-2-2026-07-25"],"generation":3},"provenance":{"agent":"GPT-5.6 Thinking","run_id":"wef-columbus-depth-3-2026-07-25","skill":"auto-dig;create-starintel-documents;select-recursive-targets"},"schema_version":"0.9.0","sources":[{"accessed_at":"2026-07-25T20:30:00Z","credibility":0.95,"kind":"government_record","publisher":"City of Columbus","title":"Columbus Ordinance 2432-2020","uri":"https://columbus.legistar.com/LegislationDetail.aspx?G=4F637594-17B0-4E92-8196-37F14328D337&GUID=55EF6D82-37AC-42A8-AC78-9C64E74804A8&ID=4687160&Options=&Search=","url":"https://columbus.legistar.com/LegislationDetail.aspx?G=4F637594-17B0-4E92-8196-37F14328D337&GUID=55EF6D82-37AC-42A8-AC78-9C64E74804A8&ID=4687160&Options=&Search="}],"summary":"Primary source used in the WEF–Columbus recursive investigation.","tags":["source-document","wef-columbus","depth-3"],"title":"Columbus Ordinance 2432-2020","verification":{"status":"source-backed","verified":true},"version":1,"workflow":{"max_depth":6,"recursion_depth":3,"research_status":"completed","root_target_id":"starintel:org:city-of-columbus"}}
{"_id":"starintel:source:ord-2608-2017","data":{"accessed_at":"2026-07-25T20:30:00Z","credibility":0.97,"kind":"government_record","publisher":"City of Columbus","title":"Columbus Ordinance 2608-2017","uri":"https://columbus.legistar.com/LegislationDetail.aspx?GUID=0AA0D122-320C-4CC0-B0EC-11B78C87F598&ID=3197311&Options=&Search=","url":"https://columbus.legistar.com/LegislationDetail.aspx?GUID=0AA0D122-320C-4CC0-B0EC-11B78C87F598&ID=3197311&Options=&Search="},"dataset":"starintel-wef-columbus-depth-3-2026-07-25","date_added":"2026-07-25T20:30:00Z","date_updated":"2026-07-25T20:30:00Z","dtype":"source","evidence":[],"lineage":{"derived_from":["starintel:research-pass:wef-columbus-depth-2-2026-07-25"],"generation":3},"provenance":{"agent":"GPT-5.6 Thinking","run_id":"wef-columbus-depth-3-2026-07-25","skill":"auto-dig;create-starintel-documents;select-recursive-targets"},"schema_version":"0.9.0","sources":[{"accessed_at":"2026-07-25T20:30:00Z","credibility":0.95,"kind":"government_record","publisher":"City of Columbus","title":"Columbus Ordinance 2608-2017","uri":"https://columbus.legistar.com/LegislationDetail.aspx?GUID=0AA0D122-320C-4CC0-B0EC-11B78C87F598&ID=3197311&Options=&Search=","url":"https://columbus.legistar.com/LegislationDetail.aspx?GUID=0AA0D122-320C-4CC0-B0EC-11B78C87F598&ID=3197311&Options=&Search="}],"summary":"Primary source used in the WEF–Columbus recursive investigation.","tags":["source-document","wef-columbus","depth-3"],"title":"Columbus Ordinance 2608-2017","verification":{"status":"source-backed","verified":true},"version":1,"workflow":{"max_depth":6,"recursion_depth":3,"research_status":"completed","root_target_id":"starintel:org:city-of-columbus"}}
{"_id":"starintel:source:smart-columbus-about","data":{"accessed_at":"2026-07-25T20:30:00Z","credibility":0.97,"kind":"official_webpage","publisher":"Smart Columbus","title":"Smart Columbus — About","uri":"https://smartcolumbus.com/about","url":"https://smartcolumbus.com/about"},"dataset":"starintel-wef-columbus-depth-3-2026-07-25","date_added":"2026-07-25T20:30:00Z","date_updated":"2026-07-25T20:30:00Z","dtype":"source","evidence":[],"lineage":{"derived_from":["starintel:research-pass:wef-columbus-depth-2-2026-07-25"],"generation":3},"provenance":{"agent":"GPT-5.6 Thinking","run_id":"wef-columbus-depth-3-2026-07-25","skill":"auto-dig;create-starintel-documents;select-recursive-targets"},"schema_version":"0.9.0","sources":[{"accessed_at":"2026-07-25T20:30:00Z","credibility":0.95,"kind":"official_webpage","publisher":"Smart Columbus","title":"Smart Columbus — About","uri":"https://smartcolumbus.com/about","url":"https://smartcolumbus.com/about"}],"summary":"Primary source used in the WEF–Columbus recursive investigation.","tags":["source-document","wef-columbus","depth-3"],"title":"Smart Columbus — About","verification":{"status":"source-backed","verified":true},"version":1,"workflow":{"max_depth":6,"recursion_depth":3,"research_status":"completed","root_target_id":"starintel:org:city-of-columbus"}}
{"_id":"starintel:source:smart-columbus-board-legacy","data":{"accessed_at":"2026-07-25T20:30:00Z","credibility":0.97,"kind":"official_webpage","publisher":"Columbus Partnership","title":"Smart Columbus Board","uri":"https://columbusregion.com/about-us/boards-investors/smart-columbus-board/","url":"https://columbusregion.com/about-us/boards-investors/smart-columbus-board/"},"dataset":"starintel-wef-columbus-depth-3-2026-07-25","date_added":"2026-07-25T20:30:00Z","date_updated":"2026-07-25T20:30:00Z","dtype":"source","evidence":[],"lineage":{"derived_from":["starintel:research-pass:wef-columbus-depth-2-2026-07-25"],"generation":3},"provenance":{"agent":"GPT-5.6 Thinking","run_id":"wef-columbus-depth-3-2026-07-25","skill":"auto-dig;create-starintel-documents;select-recursive-targets"},"schema_version":"0.9.0","sources":[{"accessed_at":"2026-07-25T20:30:00Z","credibility":0.95,"kind":"official_webpage","publisher":"Columbus Partnership","title":"Smart Columbus Board","uri":"https://columbusregion.com/about-us/boards-investors/smart-columbus-board/","url":"https://columbusregion.com/about-us/boards-investors/smart-columbus-board/"}],"summary":"Primary source used in the WEF–Columbus recursive investigation.","tags":["source-document","wef-columbus","depth-3"],"title":"Smart Columbus Board","verification":{"status":"source-backed","verified":true},"version":1,"workflow":{"max_depth":6,"recursion_depth":3,"research_status":"completed","root_target_id":"starintel:org:city-of-columbus"}}
{"_id":"starintel:source:smart-columbus-grant-era-reports-index","assessment":{"confidence":0.95},"data":{"accessed_at":"2026-07-25T21:15:00Z","credibility":0.95,"kind":"official_webpage","publisher":"Smart Columbus","title":"Smart City Grant Era Reports","uri":"https://smartcolumbus.com/insights/smart-city-grant-era-reports","url":"https://smartcolumbus.com/insights/smart-city-grant-era-reports"},"dataset":"starintel-wef-columbus-depth-4-2026-07-25","date_added":"2026-07-25T21:15:00Z","date_updated":"2026-07-25T21:15:00Z","dtype":"source","evidence":[],"lineage":{"derived_from":["starintel:research-pass:wef-columbus-depth-3-2026-07-25"],"generation":4},"provenance":{"agent":"GPT-5.6 Thinking","run_id":"wef-columbus-depth-4-2026-07-25","skill":"auto-dig;search-starintel-json-db;create-starintel-documents;select-recursive-targets"},"schema_version":"0.9.0","sources":[{"accessed_at":"2026-07-25T21:15:00Z","credibility":0.95,"kind":"official_webpage","publisher":"Smart Columbus","title":"Smart City Grant Era Reports","uri":"https://smartcolumbus.com/insights/smart-city-grant-era-reports","url":"https://smartcolumbus.com/insights/smart-city-grant-era-reports"}],"summary":"Index page for five grant-era reports documenting Smart Columbus's original funding, tests, lessons, and continuing legacy.","tags":["wef-columbus","recursive-research","depth-4"],"title":"Smart City Grant Era Reports","verification":{"status":"source-backed","verified":true},"version":1,"workflow":{"max_depth":6,"recursion_depth":4,"research_status":"completed","root_target_id":"starintel:org:city-of-columbus"}}
{"_id":"starintel:source:smart-columbus-usdot-program-summary-2021","assessment":{"confidence":0.95},"data":{"accessed_at":"2026-07-25T21:15:00Z","credibility":0.95,"kind":"government_report","publisher":"City of Columbus","title":"Smart Columbus Program Summary — June 2021","uri":"https://static1.squarespace.com/static/6543abac601e3621dd3fe76d/t/68b832df3dd5017d3a1c12e2/1756902111728/2021-06%2BUSDOT%2BFinal%2BReport%2BExecutive%2BSummary%2B%281%29-compressed-compressed.pdf","url":"https://static1.squarespace.com/static/6543abac601e3621dd3fe76d/t/68b832df3dd5017d3a1c12e2/1756902111728/2021-06%2BUSDOT%2BFinal%2BReport%2BExecutive%2BSummary%2B%281%29-compressed-compressed.pdf"},"dataset":"starintel-wef-columbus-depth-4-2026-07-25","date_added":"2026-07-25T21:15:00Z","date_updated":"2026-07-25T21:15:00Z","dtype":"source","evidence":[],"lineage":{"derived_from":["starintel:research-pass:wef-columbus-depth-3-2026-07-25"],"generation":4},"provenance":{"agent":"GPT-5.6 Thinking","run_id":"wef-columbus-depth-4-2026-07-25","skill":"auto-dig;search-starintel-json-db;create-starintel-documents;select-recursive-targets"},"schema_version":"0.9.0","sources":[{"accessed_at":"2026-07-25T21:15:00Z","credibility":0.95,"kind":"government_report","publisher":"City of Columbus","title":"Smart Columbus Program Summary — June 2021","uri":"https://static1.squarespace.com/static/6543abac601e3621dd3fe76d/t/68b832df3dd5017d3a1c12e2/1756902111728/2021-06%2BUSDOT%2BFinal%2BReport%2BExecutive%2BSummary%2B%281%29-compressed-compressed.pdf","url":"https://static1.squarespace.com/static/6543abac601e3621dd3fe76d/t/68b832df3dd5017d3a1c12e2/1756902111728/2021-06%2BUSDOT%2BFinal%2BReport%2BExecutive%2BSummary%2B%281%29-compressed-compressed.pdf"}],"summary":"City-produced USDOT grant summary documenting funding streams, program governance, open-source replication, continuation, and lessons learned.","tags":["wef-columbus","recursive-research","depth-4"],"title":"Smart Columbus Program Summary — June 2021","verification":{"status":"source-backed","verified":true},"version":1,"workflow":{"max_depth":6,"recursion_depth":4,"research_status":"completed","root_target_id":"starintel:org:city-of-columbus"}}
{"_id":"starintel:source:smart-columbus-work","data":{"accessed_at":"2026-07-25T20:30:00Z","credibility":0.97,"kind":"official_webpage","publisher":"Smart Columbus","title":"Smart Columbus — Work","uri":"https://smartcolumbus.com/work","url":"https://smartcolumbus.com/work"},"dataset":"starintel-wef-columbus-depth-3-2026-07-25","date_added":"2026-07-25T20:30:00Z","date_updated":"2026-07-25T20:30:00Z","dtype":"source","evidence":[],"lineage":{"derived_from":["starintel:research-pass:wef-columbus-depth-2-2026-07-25"],"generation":3},"provenance":{"agent":"GPT-5.6 Thinking","run_id":"wef-columbus-depth-3-2026-07-25","skill":"auto-dig;create-starintel-documents;select-recursive-targets"},"schema_version":"0.9.0","sources":[{"accessed_at":"2026-07-25T20:30:00Z","credibility":0.95,"kind":"official_webpage","publisher":"Smart Columbus","title":"Smart Columbus — Work","uri":"https://smartcolumbus.com/work","url":"https://smartcolumbus.com/work"}],"summary":"Primary source used in the WEF–Columbus recursive investigation.","tags":["source-document","wef-columbus","depth-3"],"title":"Smart Columbus — Work","verification":{"status":"source-backed","verified":true},"version":1,"workflow":{"max_depth":6,"recursion_depth":3,"research_status":"completed","root_target_id":"starintel:org:city-of-columbus"}}